ok would you fight it or pay it?- update
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 | |
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? I would fight it! Actually I would probably only fight it if I could do it by mail. I wouldn't want to spend the day in court over it. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 1:10 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by my3boys Posted by Kara Posted by MrsQ-in2007 Here's my question - how did the cop know you didn't have it on speaker? That's not illegal and just because he saw you hanging up doesn't mean you were talking with the phone on your ear, you know? I'd say try to fight it and worst case you still pay the full fine, but otherwise you might get it tossed or reduced. I'm pretty sure the cell phone law states that you must be using HANDS FREE devices while driving. Having your phone on speaker, while holding it in your hand wouldn't be hands free, would it? (Honestly asking because I can't imagine that it would be.) To the OP, honestly I (me personally) would just pay the fine. You broke the law and you know you broke the law. Also, honestly, I think it was incredibly irresponsible to do that with children in the car, especially other people's children. If you were babysitting my child and were talking on your cell phone while driving him or her, I'd be livid. So many accidents occur in traffic because people think it's okay to get distracted. I'm really curious as to why you feel you don't "deserve" this ticket. Why shouldn't the law apply to you in this situation? That said, if you want to fight the ticket, go ahead and fight it. Just know that if you do get it reduced or thrown out (unlikely) it won't be because what you did was legal. you might feel it was "incredibly irresponsible" however the mother of the child feels different. She much rather of had me call then not know why her son wasn't home especailly because we were at the beach and i also mentioned i dropped her call before getting in the car (lost service) and as a parent if my 5yr old was suppose to be home by a certain time and was unreachable I would be extremely nervous and would want my friend to call and just let me know whats going on. I'm not saying i'm i didn't brake the law but i do feel that i was only trying to reasure the mom that her child was ok and on his way home. $200 i feel is a lot for that. It's not like i was doing 60miles perhr chatting up a storm with a friend while drving other kids around. The mother of the child feels horriable that this has happened to me but like I said she is thankful that I called as well.l as a mom, i would be thankful too - i just don't understand why you couldn't pull over to make the call. if you were in bumper-to-bumper traffic, shouldn't it have been easy for you to pull over? |
|
Posted 5/28/09 1:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by CAH127 Posted by headoverheels Posted by HeatherRose pay it! do the crime, gotta do the time, sorry. No matter what the case was, you were on the phone. You can try and fight it, but its the cops word against yours, and a day in court. I highly doubt you will get very far, and I'm sure the judge will not be happy your wasting his time, when you know what you did was illegal. i agree. the law is the law for a reason. i am sure plenty of accidents have occurred when someone was on the phone in bumper to bumper traffic and got distracted. I agree with this, as well. As long as your key was in the ignition, you considered driving by law. That is incorrect when it comes to the cell phone law. I asked a police officer about this and he said the car must be in motion to be breaking the law. So, you can be on your cell, in the driver's seat, stopped at a red light and that is legal. If the car is not moving, you are not breaking the law. So, to the OP - was your car moving at all while you were on the phone? If you were at a dead stop, you have a case. Not saying you'd win, but you have a case. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 1:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by mrsej I can only speak for myself but I think if you break the law, you should pay the fine and not take up court time to try to fight it Then why do we have courts?!?! My court would be empty! I just think she should pay the price for breaking the law.... you DO raise a good point though but I thought that courts are there to uphold the law and ensure that the punishment fits the crime, based in the available facts, no?
Message edited 2009-05-28 13:30:37.930000. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 1:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by MommaG Posted by CAH127 Posted by headoverheels Posted by HeatherRose pay it! do the crime, gotta do the time, sorry. No matter what the case was, you were on the phone. You can try and fight it, but its the cops word against yours, and a day in court. I highly doubt you will get very far, and I'm sure the judge will not be happy your wasting his time, when you know what you did was illegal. i agree. the law is the law for a reason. i am sure plenty of accidents have occurred when someone was on the phone in bumper to bumper traffic and got distracted. I agree with this, as well. As long as your key was in the ignition, you considered driving by law. That is incorrect when it comes to the cell phone law. I asked a police officer about this and he said the car must be in motion to be breaking the law. So, you can be on your cell, in the driver's seat, stopped at a red light and that is legal. If the car is not moving, you are not breaking the law. So, to the OP - was your car moving at all while you were on the phone? If you were at a dead stop, you have a case. Not saying you'd win, but you have a case. This advice is not necessarily correct. While the law does state that you cannot use a hand held cell phone while a motor vehicle is in motion, NYS courts have not defined what "in motion" means. In many states, a vehicle is in motion unless it is legally parked... so I wouldn't bank on being able to use your phone while stopped at a red light. The fact of the matter is that the law is unclear on that point. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 2:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by Kara Posted by MommaG Posted by CAH127 Posted by headoverheels Posted by HeatherRose pay it! do the crime, gotta do the time, sorry. No matter what the case was, you were on the phone. You can try and fight it, but its the cops word against yours, and a day in court. I highly doubt you will get very far, and I'm sure the judge will not be happy your wasting his time, when you know what you did was illegal. i agree. the law is the law for a reason. i am sure plenty of accidents have occurred when someone was on the phone in bumper to bumper traffic and got distracted. I agree with this, as well. As long as your key was in the ignition, you considered driving by law. That is incorrect when it comes to the cell phone law. I asked a police officer about this and he said the car must be in motion to be breaking the law. So, you can be on your cell, in the driver's seat, stopped at a red light and that is legal. If the car is not moving, you are not breaking the law. So, to the OP - was your car moving at all while you were on the phone? If you were at a dead stop, you have a case. Not saying you'd win, but you have a case. This advice is not necessarily correct. While the law does state that you cannot use a hand held cell phone while a motor vehicle is in motion, NYS courts have not defined what "in motion" means. In many states, a vehicle is in motion unless it is legally parked... so I wouldn't bank on being able to use your phone while stopped at a red light. The fact of the matter is that the law is unclear on that point. exactly. I actually spoke to a NY state trooper and a nassau cop about this. Both have said that they were trained that if the car is off on the side of the road, but running, or in a parking spot it is ok to use. Both said that in this case, and in the case of a red light, you are going to be ticketed. (when you are a red right, more then likely your car is in drive, so your not going to win on that one) At the end of the day though, no matter what the issue was, it is still the law. Silly law or not, you can't break it and expect because you have a reason, that its ok. Its no different then rolling through a red light for the first second it red, or parking in a fire lane. Its still the law, and it was broken. Pay the ticket, and be done |
|
Posted 5/28/09 2:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by headoverheels Posted by my3boys Posted by Kara Posted by MrsQ-in2007 Here's my question - how did the cop know you didn't have it on speaker? That's not illegal and just because he saw you hanging up doesn't mean you were talking with the phone on your ear, you know? I'd say try to fight it and worst case you still pay the full fine, but otherwise you might get it tossed or reduced. I'm pretty sure the cell phone law states that you must be using HANDS FREE devices while driving. Having your phone on speaker, while holding it in your hand wouldn't be hands free, would it? (Honestly asking because I can't imagine that it would be.) To the OP, honestly I (me personally) would just pay the fine. You broke the law and you know you broke the law. Also, honestly, I think it was incredibly irresponsible to do that with children in the car, especially other people's children. If you were babysitting my child and were talking on your cell phone while driving him or her, I'd be livid. So many accidents occur in traffic because people think it's okay to get distracted. I'm really curious as to why you feel you don't "deserve" this ticket. Why shouldn't the law apply to you in this situation? That said, if you want to fight the ticket, go ahead and fight it. Just know that if you do get it reduced or thrown out (unlikely) it won't be because what you did was legal. you might feel it was "incredibly irresponsible" however the mother of the child feels different. She much rather of had me call then not know why her son wasn't home especailly because we were at the beach and i also mentioned i dropped her call before getting in the car (lost service) and as a parent if my 5yr old was suppose to be home by a certain time and was unreachable I would be extremely nervous and would want my friend to call and just let me know whats going on. I'm not saying i'm i didn't brake the law but i do feel that i was only trying to reasure the mom that her child was ok and on his way home. $200 i feel is a lot for that. It's not like i was doing 60miles perhr chatting up a storm with a friend while drving other kids around. The mother of the child feels horriable that this has happened to me but like I said she is thankful that I called as well.l as a mom, i would be thankful too - i just don't understand why you couldn't pull over to make the call. if you were in bumper-to-bumper traffic, shouldn't it have been easy for you to pull over? not at all that's how close all the cars were. i couldn't even pull to the side when the police pointed for me to pull over. i had to wait until all the cars inched uped a little. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 2:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by MommaG Posted by CAH127 Posted by headoverheels Posted by HeatherRose pay it! do the crime, gotta do the time, sorry. No matter what the case was, you were on the phone. You can try and fight it, but its the cops word against yours, and a day in court. I highly doubt you will get very far, and I'm sure the judge will not be happy your wasting his time, when you know what you did was illegal. i agree. the law is the law for a reason. i am sure plenty of accidents have occurred when someone was on the phone in bumper to bumper traffic and got distracted. I agree with this, as well. As long as your key was in the ignition, you considered driving by law. That is incorrect when it comes to the cell phone law. I asked a police officer about this and he said the car must be in motion to be breaking the law. So, you can be on your cell, in the driver's seat, stopped at a red light and that is legal. If the car is not moving, you are not breaking the law. So, to the OP - was your car moving at all while you were on the phone? If you were at a dead stop, you have a case. Not saying you'd win, but you have a case. dead stop |
|
Posted 5/28/09 2:12 PM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? I am wondering how to interpret the law regarding what true hands free really means. (e) "Hands-free mobile telephone" shall mean a mobile telephone that has an internal feature or function, or that is equipped with an attachment or addition, whether or not permanently part of such mobile telephone, by which a user engages in a call without the use of either hand, whether or not the use of either hand is necessary to activate, deactivate or initiate a function of such telephone. |
Posted 5/28/09 2:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by ave1024 I am wondering how to interpret the law regarding what true hands free really means. Is a wired headset is still breaking the law if you need a hand to dial the call, answer, or hang it up? This eliminates practically all "hands free" technologies with the exception of voice activated wireless calling (bluetooth). §1225-c. Use of mobile telephones (e) "Hands-free mobile telephone" shall mean a mobile telephone that has an internal feature or function, or that is equipped with an attachment or addition, whether or not permanently part of such mobile telephone, by which a user engages in a call without the use of either hand, whether or not the use of either hand is necessary to activate, deactivate or initiate a function of such telephone. Read the rest of the statute because it goes on to discuss the phone having to be at or near one's ear... then the law defines what that exactly means... |
|
Posted 5/28/09 2:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by ave1024 I am wondering how to interpret the law regarding what true hands free really means. Is a wired headset is still breaking the law if you need a hand to dial the call, answer, or hang it up? This eliminates practically all "hands free" technologies with the exception of voice activated wireless calling (bluetooth). §1225-c. Use of mobile telephones (e) "Hands-free mobile telephone" shall mean a mobile telephone that has an internal feature or function, or that is equipped with an attachment or addition, whether or not permanently part of such mobile telephone, by which a user engages in a call without the use of either hand, whether or not the use of either hand is necessary to activate, deactivate or initiate a function of such telephone. that publication is as of APRIL 2002 I *believe* they have updated it since then, I will see if I can find it Either way, is it that hard to dial your call while parked then begin driving? And when your caller hangs up it drops the call, so I don't see why you would need to be dialing while driving. If texting isn't allowed, I don't see how dialing is any different, your still typing on the keys without looking at the road, or your hands on the wheel |
|
Posted 5/28/09 2:42 PM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Where can I find the rest of it? I checked a couple of sites and I only found the four sections for 1225-c. |
Posted 5/28/09 2:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? 4. A violation of subdivision two of this section shall be a traffic infraction and shall be punishable by a fine of not more than one hundred dollars. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 2:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by my3boys 4. A violation of subdivision two of this section shall be a traffic infraction and shall be punishable by a fine of not more than one hundred dollars. ok so why is my ticket $200, i can see $100 is reasonable What portion of the $200 is court and administrative fees and what portion is the fine? Message edited 2009-05-28 14:55:21.370000. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 2:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by ave1024 Where can I find the rest of it? I checked a couple of sites and I only found the four sections for 1225-c. http://law.justia.com/newyork/codes/vehicle-traffic/vat01225-c_1225-c.html That's the whole thing, I believe. And the sections I discussed relating to proximity to one's ear are in there. ETA - It's still not crystal clear. I'm not sure how the courts interpret it. Message edited 2009-05-28 14:53:34.733000. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 2:52 PM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by Kara Posted by ave1024 Where can I find the rest of it? I checked a couple of sites and I only found the four sections for 1225-c. http://law.justia.com/newyork/codes/vehicle-traffic/vat01225-c_1225-c.html That's the whole thing, I believe. And the sections I discussed relating to proximity to one's ear are in there. ETA - It's still not crystal clear. I'm not sure how the courts interpret it. Hmmm... ok then. With that said, I would change my stance on this and probably fight it. You can question the wording on the law as to what the law means by "in motion". You can also question the fine. Why does it have to be $100 (well in your case $200 with fees). So you may be able to have it reduced. If you show up prepared with the copy of the actual law in hand, printed out, you may impress the judge and show him/her that you actually researched this. |
Posted 5/28/09 2:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by PennyCat I would DEFINITELY fight it, that's ridiculous!!!! Why is this ridiculous? A law is a law for a reason, doesn't matter if she was in traffic or not. I was in a car accident years ago in STOPPED bumper to bumper traffic. I was hit by behind by someone who was on the phone and was distracted. He claimed he thought he saw the cars moving, so he stepped on the gas and rear-ended me TOTALLING my car. She got a ticket for being on the phone without a hands-free device... against the law in NY, why fight the ticket, she was in the wrong. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 4:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? pay it. if you break the law, you should pay the fine, regardless of the reason. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 5:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? While I would have done exactly the same thing if I didn't have my bluetooth, I still think you broke the law and should just pay the ticket. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 6:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Cellphone issue aside, you took 6 kids to the beach by yourself??? Are you Wonder Woman? I have 3 here if you want to try for 9 next time LOL |
|
Posted 5/28/09 6:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? if you have the time to go to court to fight it then give it a shot. i'd probably just pay it. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 6:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by Kara Posted by my3boys 4. A violation of subdivision two of this section shall be a traffic infraction and shall be punishable by a fine of not more than one hundred dollars. ok so why is my ticket $200, i can see $100 is reasonable What portion of the $200 is court and administrative fees and what portion is the fine? $120 for the ticket $60 for surcharge and $20 for tax |
|
Posted 5/28/09 7:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? Posted by Elizabeth Cellphone issue aside, you took 6 kids to the beach by yourself??? Are you Wonder Woman? I have 3 here if you want to try for 9 next time LOL Not wonder woman but maybe crazy LOL two of the children are 11yrs old and the other ones are 2,3,4, & 5 but (3 are mine) but we stay at the play ground the majority of the time we only went by the water for 10mins but the little ones dont go near the water. But hey if you want me to pick up your 3 next time why not, but if i'm not back in time it's because of traffic LOL |
|
Posted 5/28/09 7:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? my Dh is a cop and says to always fight a ticket. no matter what. what can you lose? |
|
Posted 5/28/09 9:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: ok would you fight it or pay it? I would fight it. The last traffic ticket I got I needed to go to the village court. The judge told everyone to plead not guilty. If you fight it you may get less points on your license. |
|
Posted 5/28/09 9:55 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| pay-per-view fight- where to watch? | sagapo | 12/8/07 | 0 | Sports |
| I would pay any amount of money right now for... | BaroqueMama | 3/18/06 | 32 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Self Pay IVF Ladies....Study at SIRM, You may be interested | redstar | 3/13/06 | 0 | Infertility |
| what do you pay for daycare, and for how many hours/days? | raken40 | 3/7/06 | 9 | Parenting |
| How Much Did They Have To Pay Bush.... | LadyMaravilla | 3/3/06 | 11 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Do you save pay stubs? | 04bride | 2/28/06 | 38 | Families Helping Families ™ |







but I thought that courts are there to uphold the law and ensure that the punishment fits the crime, based in the available facts, no?






I only go when I KNOW I am right and the charges will be dropped. (ex. got a ticket for parking in a legit parking spot... complete with white lines... becuase it was 'in front of a hydrant'. well, due to construction, I was instructed by the town to park in that row, and the hydrant was subsequently moved there the day before and was covered by stuff so it wasn't fully visable... and probably wasn't even hooked-up yet!)
