Re: ok would you fight it or pay it?
Posted 5/28/2009 2:10:48 PM by HeatherRose
Posted by Kara
Posted by MommaG
Posted by CAH127
Posted by headoverheels
Posted by HeatherRose
pay it! do the crime, gotta do the time, sorry. No matter what the case was, you were on the phone. You can try and fight it, but its the cops word against yours, and a day in court. I highly doubt you will get very far, and I'm sure the judge will not be happy your wasting his time, when you know what you did was illegal.
i agree. the law is the law for a reason. i am sure plenty of accidents have occurred when someone was on the phone in bumper to bumper traffic and got distracted.
I agree with this, as well. As long as your key was in the ignition, you considered driving by law.
That is incorrect when it comes to the cell phone law. I asked a police officer about this and he said the car must be in motion to be breaking the law. So, you can be on your cell, in the driver's seat, stopped at a red light and that is legal. If the car is not moving, you are not breaking the law.
So, to the OP - was your car moving at all while you were on the phone? If you were at a dead stop, you have a case. Not saying you'd win, but you have a case.
This advice is not necessarily correct. While the law does state that you cannot use a hand held cell phone while a motor vehicle is in motion, NYS courts have not defined what "in motion" means. In many states, a vehicle is in motion unless it is legally parked... so I wouldn't bank on being able to use your phone while stopped at a red light. The fact of the matter is that the law is unclear on that point.
exactly. I actually spoke to a NY state trooper and a nassau cop about this. Both have said that they were trained that if the car is off on the side of the road, but running, or in a parking spot it is ok to use. Both said that in this case, and in the case of a red light, you are going to be ticketed. (when you are a red right, more then likely your car is in drive, so your not going to win on that one)
At the end of the day though, no matter what the issue was, it is still the law. Silly law or not, you can't break it and expect because you have a reason, that its ok. Its no different then rolling through a red light for the first second it red, or parking in a fire lane. Its still the law, and it was broken. Pay the ticket, and be done
|