Obama and Spanish
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 | |
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by mrswask Posted by Erica Posted by Slightly-Taller sorry if this has been posted already: Im feeling saucy so lets get our opinions out there... and lets play nice.. Obama states that ALL American children should be mandated to learn Spanish. what do you all think of this?? this is what drives me crazy...people twist words: "I don't understand when people are going around saying, 'We need to have English only.' They want to pass a law 'We want English only.' Now I agree that immigrants should learn English. I agree with that. But understand this. Instead of worrying about whether immigrants can learn English. They'll learn English. You need to make sure your child can speak Spanish. You should be thinking about how can your child become bilingual. We should have every child speaking more than one language. It's embarrassing when Europeans come over here, they all speak English, they speak French, they speak German. And then we go over to Europe and all we can say is merci beaucoup, right?" (crowd applauds.) Watch for yourself He just used the Spanish example, it doesn't equate to "ALL American children should be mandated to learn Spanish." His idea is a great one. Our children should be bilingual like most Europeans. Like Janice mentioned, being bilingual brings great advantages. Posts like these, should always have a link to back them up. heres a link |
|
Posted 7/12/08 11:12 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Obama and Spanish hmmm... people complain that Americans are behind the rest of the world |
|
Posted 7/12/08 11:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by HelenZ honestly there's far too many people in the US who don't know english, to me that should have more focus before making it a requirement to learn spanish. ETA- and this is from a first generation American whose mom knew english before coming here! i totally agree. my FIL came here with 20 bucks in his pocket, didn't speak a WORD and worked THREE jobs while going to school at night to learn english -- he worked his ARSE off to learn this language and he has more love and pride for this country than anyone i know. he learned it - everyone else can too. |
|
Posted 7/12/08 11:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish We need to catch up the rest of the world and put more importance to learning foreign languages. It doesn't have to be Spanish but something. The internet has opened up international business even more. |
|
Posted 7/12/08 11:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by DaniRella Posted by HelenZ honestly there's far too many people in the US who don't know english, to me that should have more focus before making it a requirement to learn spanish. ETA- and this is from a first generation American whose mom knew english before coming here! i totally agree. my FIL came here with 20 bucks in his pocket, didn't speak a WORD and worked THREE jobs while going to school at night to learn english -- he worked his ARSE off to learn this language and he has more love and pride for this country than anyone i know. he learned it - everyone else can too. this is exactly how i feel about it. as an educator i feel that there are way too many students that come to this country (not just from spanish speaking countries) that have a hard enough time learning english and keeping up with state exams. it would be way too difficult for these students to learn english for the first time and and learn spanish too. i totally agree that we are behind the times, compared to european education, and i have even done research and papers on how extremely beneficial it is for children to learn a foreign language at a young age .in fact, the younger the better. (such children prove to perform better in math and science) but i do not agree with the push on spanish. and more emphasis should be put on people in this country learning english. |
|
Posted 7/12/08 11:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by LaPetiteSirène Ugh, don't get me started on this. 1. Yes. I agree that all students should be mandated to take a second language from the time they are in KINDERGARTEN. That is the BEST time to start learning a second language. We start way too late. 2. Spanish? Don't agree. I believe the family and student should have a choice. There are MANY languages spoken around the world today that are important for international commerce and business. I see what you are saying. But don't we have foreign language classes from the time of around sixth grade?? There are plenty of opportunities to learn another language, if one wishes, during school - I don't know if making it from Kindergarten is the way to go though -- it is hard enough (it seems) for children to master english and writing well along w/ spelling correctly. I feel like we need to focus more on english and mastering that before going onto something else -- my sister, a reading teacher, sees WAY too many kids who are reading/writing on a second grade level in 8th grade. The choice to take another language, and there are many different kinds to choose from, is out there -- I don't feel it should be mandatory though. The other problem is: my sister has many students who barely speak english b/c their parents are immigrants (some legal, some not) who came here and had the child but did not teach them (b/c they don't know english themselves) how to speak english -- then, the children attend our schools and cannot read or write. Teachers try to call the parents and they can't communicate with them. It is very hard - so, if there was more of a focus on people who come to this country learning english there wouldn't be a need to try and "help" them by making everything bilingual and making the general population learn spanish. Message edited 2008-07-12 23:33:10.877000. |
|
Posted 7/12/08 11:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by Erica Posted by Slightly-Taller sorry if this has been posted already: Im feeling saucy so lets get our opinions out there... and lets play nice.. Obama states that ALL American children should be mandated to learn Spanish. what do you all think of this?? this is what drives me crazy...people twist words: "I don't understand when people are going around saying, 'We need to have English only.' They want to pass a law 'We want English only.' Now I agree that immigrants should learn English. I agree with that. But understand this. Instead of worrying about whether immigrants can learn English. They'll learn English. You need to make sure your child can speak Spanish. You should be thinking about how can your child become bilingual. We should have every child speaking more than one language. It's embarrassing when Europeans come over here, they all speak English, they speak French, they speak German. And then we go over to Europe and all we can say is merci beaucoup, right?" (crowd applauds.) Watch for yourself He just used the Spanish example, it doesn't equate to "ALL American children should be mandated to learn Spanish." His idea is a great one. Our children should be bilingual like most Europeans. Like Janice mentioned, being bilingual brings great advantages. Posts like these, should always have a link to back them up. I heard what he said and what he seems to support is a well-rounded educational system. I do agree that people here should know more than one language. I happen to know conversational Spanish because I learned it on school over 20 years ago. If I can do it THEN, anyone can NOW. Besides, there are languages other than Spanish that would be more advantageous for our children to learn. I would encourage my child to learn Chinese if I had to pick one. I think THAT would be a lot more useful in the future in regard to big business and trade. NOT in terms of what our largest minority speaks. I also think that if posts like this are going to be started, people need to be a bit more thorough. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 12:07 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish This link describes the speech that Erica posted. The article makes it sound like he misspoke when he said all children should learn Spanish. But when I watched the speech, it's clear his message is that children should be bi-lingual - not that every child should learn Spanish. I think the more kids learn earlier on the better it is for them in the future. It's a valuable skill to have in today's world. I didn't have to take a foreign language until I was in the 9th grade. I had a difficult time picking it up and only learned enough to pass the course. Message edited 2008-07-13 00:38:24.847000. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 12:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish it's a fact that kids learn languages much better when they are younger Message edited 2008-07-13 01:34:00.253000. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 1:21 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish don't agree. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 2:42 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by DaniRella Posted by HelenZ honestly there's far too many people in the US who don't know english, to me that should have more focus before making it a requirement to learn spanish. ETA- and this is from a first generation American whose mom knew english before coming here! i totally agree. my FIL came here with 20 bucks in his pocket, didn't speak a WORD and worked THREE jobs while going to school at night to learn english -- he worked his ARSE off to learn this language and he has more love and pride for this country than anyone i know. he learned it - everyone else can too. ITA All children should learn two languages? I don't agree with that. If they know two languages, sure, that is great. But I certainly think the primary focus should be on the teaching/knowledge of the English language in regards to children (and adults, for that matter). It's bad enough American children are barely being taught proper grammar in school like schools used to teach back in the day. I know there is little to no emphasis/teaching on this within the NYC public school system (esp in schools with a high proportion of ESL students). And this effects all children, esp those whose primary language is ENGLISH. To me, this is a huge problem in our country. Not a fan of Obama, his concepts or his words at all. Message edited 2008-07-13 10:47:07.460000. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 7:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by Goldi0218 Posted by Erica Posted by Slightly-Taller sorry if this has been posted already: Im feeling saucy so lets get our opinions out there... and lets play nice.. Obama states that ALL American children should be mandated to learn Spanish. what do you all think of this?? this is what drives me crazy...people twist words: "I don't understand when people are going around saying, 'We need to have English only.' They want to pass a law 'We want English only.' Now I agree that immigrants should learn English. I agree with that. But understand this. Instead of worrying about whether immigrants can learn English. They'll learn English. You need to make sure your child can speak Spanish. You should be thinking about how can your child become bilingual. We should have every child speaking more than one language. It's embarrassing when Europeans come over here, they all speak English, they speak French, they speak German. And then we go over to Europe and all we can say is merci beaucoup, right?" (crowd applauds.) Watch for yourself He just used the Spanish example, it doesn't equate to "ALL American children should be mandated to learn Spanish." His idea is a great one. Our children should be bilingual like most Europeans. Like Janice mentioned, being bilingual brings great advantages. Posts like these, should always have a link to back them up. I heard what he said and what he seems to support is a well-rounded educational system. I do agree that people here should know more than one language. I happen to know conversational Spanish because I learned it on school over 20 years ago. If I can do it THEN, anyone can NOW. Besides, there are languages other than Spanish that would be more advantageous for our children to learn. I would encourage my child to learn Chinese if I had to pick one. I think THAT would be a lot more useful in the future in regard to big business and trade. NOT in terms of what our largest minority speaks. I also think that if posts like this are going to be started, people need to be a bit more thorough. ITA - in many businesses the most beneficial language to learn right now is Chinese and they are (I believe) the largest immigrant group to the US (I could be wrong there) so I'm not sure why the argument is being made that the second language students learn should be Spanish. I think a second language of parent/student choice should be taught as early as kindergarten! |
|
Posted 7/13/08 8:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish I think that is ridiculous |
|
Posted 7/13/08 8:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish I agree with some on here who said we need to make it a priority for immigrants to learn English first. when you move to a new country, you conform to them, not the other way around. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 10:35 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish I think people have to look at the big picture here....yes, it would be great if everyone spoke English. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 10:48 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish don't agree at all. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 10:53 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by Janice I think people have to look at the big picture here....yes, it would be great if everyone spoke English. I have inlaws who have lived in the continental US since the 60's who still can't speak English....and not an immigrant. They should learn English, but they don't. They live among other Spanish speakers, build a community that doesn't need to speak English. It drives me insane. I don't care what language my kid learns to speak, but this is a melting pot and if they aren't speaking another language, they will be left behind. By not teaching another language based on the idea that "they" should speak English is very limiting. In Charlotte, we have charter schools. From kindergarden, your child can be taught solely in Chinese if you wish. or french, or spanish. all based on a lottery. there is absolutely nothing wrong with American kids learning a new language. but I think it is wrong that people who live here don't learn English. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 11:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by DaniRella I see what you are saying. But don't we have foreign language classes from the time of around sixth grade?? There are plenty of opportunities to learn another language, if one wishes, during school - I don't know if making it from Kindergarten is the way to go though -- it is hard enough (it seems) for children to master english and writing well along w/ spelling correctly. I feel like we need to focus more on english and mastering that before going onto something else -- my sister, a reading teacher, sees WAY too many kids who are reading/writing on a second grade level in 8th grade. The choice to take another language, and there are many different kinds to choose from, is out there -- I don't feel it should be mandatory though. The other problem is: my sister has many students who barely speak english b/c their parents are immigrants (some legal, some not) who came here and had the child but did not teach them (b/c they don't know english themselves) how to speak english -- then, the children attend our schools and cannot read or write. Teachers try to call the parents and they can't communicate with them. It is very hard - so, if there was more of a focus on people who come to this country learning english there wouldn't be a need to try and "help" them by making everything bilingual and making the general population learn spanish. i too am a reading teacher and see this problem all to often so i agree we really need to focus on english for our esl students of course without them losing their main language, however i also agree that learning a second language of the parents choice is an excellent idea, i just didn't agree with it being mandated spanish |
|
Posted 7/13/08 11:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish The best time to teach children a second language is as young as possible. I totally agree with children learning a second language. I have had quite a few kids at my job who spoke zero English and with in a month or two can speak it perfectly. I tell parents at my job all the time if one parent speaks another language they should only speak that language to the child, while the other speaks in English. I had one child who spoke English, French, Spanish and a little bit of Russian all by the time she was three. This was all because of her parents and grandparents. Message edited 2008-07-13 11:19:41.960000. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 11:14 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish I agree with another poster that said that all children should be bi-lingual. Many of the elementary schools in my county are teaching students second languages (Spanish being one of them). I think it's an excellent idea. I wish I had been exposed to a second language before I was 12. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 11:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by Christine This link describes the speech that Erica posted. The article makes it sound like he misspoke when he said all children should learn Spanish. But when I watched the speech, it's clear his message is that children should be bi-lingual - not that every child should learn Spanish. I think the more kids learn earlier on the better it is for them in the future. It's a valuable skill to have in today's world. I didn't have to take a foreign language until I was in the 9th grade. I had a difficult time picking it up and only learned enough to pass the course. Yeah that article is obviously written by someone who is not a fan of Obama, and it was just analyzing his speech in a typical media spin. he was making an excellent point in that it is true that when you go to european nations, most people out there do speak 2 if not 3 languages. when americans go out there, we stand around talking loud to them and sayign "CAAAAN YOUUU FIIIND MEEE A TAAAXIII??" should a second language be MANDATED? no, i don't think it should have to be mandated. but i do think that learning a second language should be encouraged from the time when children are young...when kids learn from a young age 2 languages, it is easier to learn. i know some people think that its too "confusing" for children, but from my own experience as well as knowing others especially in my family, learning a second language young is much easier than trying to learn it when you are older. but as far as this whole article and such---i don't think that was what Obama was saying at all, and this is just another example of the media twisting his words. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 11:45 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by DaniRella Posted by LaPetiteSirène Ugh, don't get me started on this. 1. Yes. I agree that all students should be mandated to take a second language from the time they are in KINDERGARTEN. That is the BEST time to start learning a second language. We start way too late. 2. Spanish? Don't agree. I believe the family and student should have a choice. There are MANY languages spoken around the world today that are important for international commerce and business. I see what you are saying. But don't we have foreign language classes from the time of around sixth grade?? There are plenty of opportunities to learn another language, if one wishes, during school - I don't know if making it from Kindergarten is the way to go though -- it is hard enough (it seems) for children to master english and writing well along w/ spelling correctly. I am a firm believer that children who are capable should learn a second language from the time they are very young. While living in Europe I taught English to middle school aged students. They were way more proficient in Englisht than most of our students will ever be due to their exposure as a young child. I also wrote my graduate thesis on this subject. Language is best learned while young because of the way your brain develops as a young child. A second language can also strenghten your first language and broaden your vocabulary and grammar. I am currently teaching a 5 year old Spanish and she is like a sponge. Anything we do she gets. Quickly. When I have children they will also be brought up learning Spanish and French from the time they are young. The benefits are endless. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 11:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by pmpkn087 I don't agree. I dont either |
|
Posted 7/13/08 3:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish I think it's ridiculous that Obama's speech was twisted around like that. HE DID NOT SAY SPANISH SHOULD BE MANDATED. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 5:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Obama and Spanish Posted by DandN I think it's ridiculous that Obama's speech was twisted around like that. HE DID NOT SAY SPANISH SHOULD BE MANDATED. That was pretty disgusting. But then again a lot of these pundits have been twisting Obama's words (or those within a 10 mile radius of him like Rev. Wright or Wes Clark) since he started to run for POTUS. Maybe THEY should learn English and stop mangling Obama's words like that. Honestly, McCain and his advisors have said more damaging things about Americans (how economic troubles are just "whining"). Bilingualism is nothing to be scared of. It doesn't matter what language one learns (did you know, English/Arabic binlinguals are in high demand?), but learning another language opens up new doors that we'll need to enter in a world economy. If first-generation immigrants don't want to learn English, let them be. It only limits their possibilities. And besides, their kids and any subsequent generations usually end up learning the language anyways. |
|
Posted 7/13/08 7:17 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| XPOST Pets: Help Zootoo get Obama, McCain, and Clinton to stand up for pet shelters in America! | Wendy | 4/24/08 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| On the eve of the Pennsylvania Primary - Obama, Hilary and McCain will try to reach an important voting population.... | QuoteTheRaven424 | 4/21/08 | 17 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Touchy subject on Politics... do I dare do it? YES Obama vs Clinton | smdl | 1/3/08 | 68 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| can I get an spanish to english translation please? TIA | Janice | 8/30/07 | 8 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| GOT IT THANKS!!! Can someone FM me who can translate english into spanish? | AnthonysWife | 6/21/07 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Go Spain!! Spanish fashion show rejects too-skinny models | Eva Luna | 9/9/06 | 3 | Fashion & Beauty! |

















