NY Post Cartoon
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon I don't really see that as offensive, it's in poor taste to the poor woman who had her face ripped off by a chimp but I'm not offended by it. I guess as a political cartoon it worked it got people talking. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 10:11 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: NY Post Cartoon I think the reality is, it is a tad bit of a stretch to say the chimp is "Obama". He didn't even write the stimulus, he was waiting for Congress to write it up so he could sign it. |
Posted 2/19/09 10:16 AM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Im outraged and disgusted that something like this was even able to be circulated. Its racist on all levels no question or doubt about it. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 10:18 AM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by vegalady Im outraged and disgusted that something like this was even able to be circulated. Its racist on all levels no question or doubt about it. It really ISN'T. if you look at the above, they compared Bush to a chimp all the time. and again, the President does NOT write legislation. it's not cool, but it's also not racist. if we keep looking for "racism" against this administration, we will go NO WHERE. |
Posted 2/19/09 10:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon People in the 19th century published articles that blacks in america were direct descendants of chimps - and this was not in the spirit of Darwin's evolutionary theories. It was a way to explain why blacks in this country shouldnt be treated equally. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 10:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by Ophelia Posted by vegalady Im outraged and disgusted that something like this was even able to be circulated. Its racist on all levels no question or doubt about it. It really ISN'T. if you look at the above, they compared Bush to a chimp all the time. and again, the President does NOT write legislation. it's not cool, but it's also not racist. if we keep looking for "racism" against this administration, we will go NO WHERE. I agree. I guess seeing this Bush comparison so many times before did not lead me to believe that this was racist. But perhaps the Post and artist should have known that it could have been miscontrued. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 10:58 AM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by MrsA714 But perhaps the Post and artist should have known that it could have been miscontrued. I agree. I am not arguing that it couldn't be construed as racist..all I am saying is that in reality, I don't believe it wasn't intended to be a racist piece. it is 100% in poor taste for a few reasons, but I think it's more of a reflection of our sensitivity that we immediately placed OBAMA, and not say, Barney Frank or all of Washington, D.C. in the place of the chimpanzee. |
Posted 2/19/09 11:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon I wish everyone would stop talking about this cartoon cause the artist who drew it--he has to be LOVING this. He's known for having some distasteful cartoons thru the years and this one doesn't surprise me at all. Message edited 2009-02-19 11:24:36.410000. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 11:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by MrsPJB2007 I wish everyone would stop talking about this cartoon cause the artist who drew it--he has to be LOVING this. He's known for having some distasteful cartoons thru the years and this one doesn't surprise me at all. as does the Post.... I bet if there was no controversy, most people woudln't even know about this dumb cartoon and it woudl have faded into oblivion. But because the publicity, it (the author and the post) are getting tons of free publicity. Posted by DandN People in the 19th century published articles that blacks in america were direct descendants of chimps - and this was not in the spirit of Darwin's evolutionary theories. It was a way to explain why blacks in this country shouldnt be treated equally. There has been racist cartoons depicting african americans as chimps (or having altered physical characteristics to depict them as looking like chimps) all through the 19th century and into the 20th century. In the 19th century a b*tch was a female dog, a faggot was a bundle of sticks, blacks were slaves, women didn't have the right to vote... etc... I don't think we should be relying on (for lack of a better word) "pop culture" of the 19th century. Many things have changed- and while the racists of the world may still think monkey/chimp equals blacks, and some may construe this as a jab at Obama, I don't see chimp/monkey and equal that with blacks. In this context (especially in light of the chimp attack THIS WEEK), this is just a derogatory comment about the stupidity of the bill/writers of the bill. Message edited 2009-02-19 11:47:17.393000. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 11:41 AM
|
|
|
MetsGirl07
Member since 12/07 16202 total posts Name: |
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by SIBride06 Wow.. Wrong in SOOOO many ways. Insulting to cops, insulting to the president, insulting to monkeys! And I dont get offended easily. This cartoon or whatever this POS is should have never even made the press. i agree 100%... it's very insulting
|
Posted 2/19/09 11:45 AM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon that is awful |
|
Posted 2/19/09 12:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by Ophelia Posted by MrsA714 But perhaps the Post and artist should have known that it could have been miscontrued. I agree. I am not arguing that it couldn't be construed as racist..all I am saying is that in reality, I don't believe it wasn't intended to be a racist piece. it is 100% in poor taste for a few reasons, but I think it's more of a reflection of our sensitivity that we immediately placed OBAMA, and not say, Barney Frank or all of Washington, D.C. in the place of the chimpanzee. I agree 100%. In fact, when I first saw it, I thought of the chimp killing recently, and NOTHING to do w/Obama. Some people really need to get a a life ( cough cough, Al sharpton). |
|
Posted 2/19/09 12:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by photoshopbabe Posted by Ophelia Posted by MrsA714 But perhaps the Post and artist should have known that it could have been miscontrued. I agree. I am not arguing that it couldn't be construed as racist..all I am saying is that in reality, I don't believe it wasn't intended to be a racist piece. it is 100% in poor taste for a few reasons, but I think it's more of a reflection of our sensitivity that we immediately placed OBAMA, and not say, Barney Frank or all of Washington, D.C. in the place of the chimpanzee. I agree 100%. In fact, when I first saw it, I thought of the chimp killing recently, and NOTHING to do w/Obama. Some people really need to get a a life ( cough cough, Al sharpton). ITA! on all counts! |
|
Posted 2/19/09 12:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by Shelly I don't think its in good taste- but I don't think its offensive. I believe the chimp was used in light of the recent chimp mauling this week where the cops killed the attacking chimp. In THAT CONTEXT, I believe that this cartoon is an attack on those who wrote the stimulus bill -Democrats and not just Obama- as "chimps" who wrote a crappy bill. Honestly, it didn't even occur to me that people would interpret the chimp as Obama until I saw the controversy on this. I agree. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 12:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by Lisa Posted by Michi Posted by bird382 I read this as "the stimulus plan is so stupid, even a chimp could have written it." It's incredibly insensitive to the woman who was attacked by the chimp, but I don't see it as offensive or racist. correct me if im wrong here and mayeb i am wayyyyy off base but can u not see the comparison between a chimp or monkey to a black or mixed colored person? thats the first thought i had...maybe im the only one who saw this comparison and thats why im utterly digusted by it there have been plenty of political cartoons of President Bush as a chimp/ape, so this is not a new thing for Obama. I took the cartoon as a PP stated....that even a chimp can write the plan. This is how I took it as well. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 1:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by Renee615 Posted by Lisa Posted by Michi Posted by bird382 I read this as "the stimulus plan is so stupid, even a chimp could have written it." It's incredibly insensitive to the woman who was attacked by the chimp, but I don't see it as offensive or racist. correct me if im wrong here and mayeb i am wayyyyy off base but can u not see the comparison between a chimp or monkey to a black or mixed colored person? thats the first thought i had...maybe im the only one who saw this comparison and thats why im utterly digusted by it there have been plenty of political cartoons of President Bush as a chimp/ape, so this is not a new thing for Obama. I took the cartoon as a PP stated....that even a chimp can write the plan. This is how I took it as well. This cartoonist knew exactly what he was doing when he drew this. Yes, you can easily take the cartoon as just a jab at the stimulus plan (even a chimp could've written it) - however it was in extremely poor taste for the artist to use the chimp in the cartoon, because the portrayal of black people as primates has been used throughout our history as an incredibly offensive and racist tool. Add in two dopey looking white cops, and that only adds fuel to the fire. Not to mention a poor woman is lying in the hospital with no face because of this tragedy. The chimp attack has nothing to do with government.. so why correlate the two events other than for the express purpose of insulting Obama? (doesn't matter that Obama didn't write the plan directly, its attributed to him) I don't see the comparison with calling Bush a chimp. Bush is not black, Obama is. Calling Bush a chimp is NOT the same as calling Obama a chimp because of the historical implications of the word. plain and simple. i'm usually not offended by things - but this made me really ill. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 1:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon DH and I saw it on the news yesterday and it seriously makes me sick on so many levels- first that the NY Post would print that second that it is getting so much news- which is only further getting that racist message out |
|
Posted 2/19/09 1:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon i dont think it was intended to be construced as racist (Al Sharpton jumps on anything). I think it was more a political comment that the stimulus bill was not well thought out. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 3:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by BunnyWife Am I the only one who feels like this has more to do with the stimulus plan being like an out of control spending chimp (instead of a face mauling chimp) then Obama? i agree with this. it is mocking washington and them writing that ridiculous stimulous plan AND not even reading it before they signed it |
|
Posted 2/19/09 4:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by Shelly I don't think its in good taste- but I don't think its offensive. I believe the chimp was used in light of the recent chimp mauling this week where the cops killed the attacking chimp. In THAT CONTEXT, I believe that this cartoon is an attack on those who wrote the stimulus bill -Democrats and not just Obama- as "chimps" who wrote a crappy bill. Honestly, it didn't even occur to me that people would interpret the chimp as Obama until I saw the controversy on this. OK this was me too...I think I am more offended by the allusion that the {President was shot rather than relating him (b/c he's black) to a monkey |
|
Posted 2/19/09 5:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by mrswask So offensive on so many levels! We were talking about this last night at dinner and ITA....it is so beyond wrong I don't even have a comment. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 5:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by DandN People in the 19th century published articles that blacks in america were direct descendants of chimps - and this was not in the spirit of Darwin's evolutionary theories. It was a way to explain why blacks in this country shouldnt be treated equally. There has been racist cartoons depicting african americans as chimps (or having altered physical characteristics to depict them as looking like chimps) all through the 19th century and into the 20th century. I think the cartoon calls to mind not just that racist analogy against blacks - but also suggests that white police officers (as depicted in the cartoon) are racist as well. Exactly, that's why I think it was wrong--even in the chance it would be interpreted this way should have been enough to not print it. As a PP said before, Bush isn't black (it still wasn't right to compare him to a chimp either), but to compare the chimp to Obama is wrong on so many more levels. This after the Jessica Simpson cartoon I say two thumbs down to the POST. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 5:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Honestly, the only thing i find offensive here is that SO many people's first thought was to find this offensive because if it has a monkey, it must be comparing it to black people. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 5:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by neenie Honestly, the only thing i find offensive here is that SO many people's first thought was to find this offensive because if it has a monkey, it must be comparing it to black people. Sorry, i don't see monkey and assume a reference to African Americans. ESPECIALLY when there was just something in the news about a chimp running rampant. But... if people want to find racism, they will. Anything can be twisted to be what you want it to be. It's sad. And to those that argue its not that way, i'll just echo the others who mentioned that Bush was ALWAYS represented by a monkey, yet there was NEVER any talk of it being offensive. Twist it however you will, but it's all in what people choose to see what's in front of them. If in one lifetime blacks were compared, in a racist way, to chimps, it would be pretty ignorant to IGNORE that connotation here. It wasn't very hard to find the racism in this, I think it was pretty blatant. And I agree, comparing Bush to a chimp was wrong too, but w/Obama, there are so many other levels of how offensive it is. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 5:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: NY Post Cartoon Posted by brownie If in one lifetime blacks were compared, in a racist way, to chimps, it would be pretty ignorant to IGNORE that connotation here. It wasn't very hard to find the racism in this, I think it was pretty blatant. And I agree, comparing Bush to a chimp was wrong too, but w/Obama, there are so many other levels of how offensive it is. There's not so many other levels to it- just a double standard, that's all. I don't see the connotation there at all. I'm not IGNORING it, i'm just not reading into something that isn't there. Yes, it's sad that there were such comparisons in our lifetime, but i don't see how uying into it, taking it and running with it, moves ANY of us forward AT ALL. But, people are going to see what they want to see. What can ya do. And, FTR, i'm pretty sure the same cartoon would still exist if Bush were still Pres, but i'm sure that doesn't matter either. |
|
Posted 2/19/09 5:34 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| when I grow up I'm going to be just like my mom "Stripper Cartoon" post | Acerone | 6/14/08 | 2 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Bad Mommy - forgot to post these pictures | Marcie | 3/23/06 | 16 | Pets |
| April 1st - 12pm - Photo GTG - UPDATE 1st post | nrthshgrl | 3/23/06 | 38 | Parenting |
| I have to post this | IGLover | 3/22/06 | 33 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Need Good Vibes (maybe TMI) updates at top post | waytogo | 3/22/06 | 16 | Pregnancy |
| .... | LAMGAJ28 | 3/19/06 | 250 | Families Helping Families ™ |





















Sorry, i don't see monkey and assume a reference to African Americans. ESPECIALLY when there was just something in the news about a chimp running rampant. But... if people want to find racism, they will. Anything can be twisted to be what you want it to be. It's sad. And to those that argue its not that way, i'll just echo the others who mentioned that Bush was ALWAYS represented by a monkey, yet there was NEVER any talk of it being offensive. Twist it however you will, but it's all in what people choose to see what's in front of them.