Non-drama religious post

Posted By Message

heathergirl
Cocktail Time!

Member since 10/08

4978 total posts

Name:
American mouth

Non-drama religious post

I was baptized Catholic, but I was not raised Catholic. My parents are different religions and had issues with the idea of organized religion. We were baptized to make my Grandmother happy, then we were allowed to explore religions, believe in what we wanted, etc. My parents didn't force us to do anything.

That said, my fiancee is Catholic, but also has some very minor issues with the Church as well. It is important for him, however, to get married in the Church, which we are, even though the priest had to make a big deal that I hadn't made my other sacraments, and FH had to sign a dispensation, etc. Stuff like that is what gets under my skin. FH has also said that he wants to raise our children Catholic, go to Church, make sacraments.

I guess I am trying to figure out how I feel about this. I am NOT against religion, or Catholicism, for that matter. If anything, I'd say most of all my beliefs fall in line with Catholicism. My issues are more with the ethics/morals of the Church. Is it hypocritical to be involved in raising my children Catholic, even if I don't agree with certain things?

Sorry if I sound naive, I just don't have much experience in this.

Message edited 2010-03-26 06:18:43.617000.

Posted 3/26/10 6:17 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Non-drama religious post

No I don't think so. There are many people that are jewish and catholic couples and both parents are involved with raising the child in one faith or the other.
But, you might find in being involved in it that you get into your faith as well. When you take your child to CCD classes they do require Sunday mass (at my church at least) and ask the children to write about the homilies for homework. So, it is quite a committment on the part of the parent. If you are going to find yourself being resentful because you don't like the Catholic Church.. this could be a problem. Your children will pick up on that feeling.

Posted 3/26/10 6:33 AM
 

NinaLemon
It's a boy!!!

Member since 10/07

6453 total posts

Name:
Jeannine

Re: Non-drama religious post

I was raised Catholic, went to parochial school and everything and I don't agree with everything the Church says (gay marriage, birth control, etc) and I would have no issue raising my children Catholic and teaching them to not take everything at face value. I am probably not a very good Catholic because I don't go to Church often.

I do believe faith is important, however I also believe that the Church and God are very different, the Church is a community of people gathering together to express and learn from their faith. People can be wrong, I think it is our obligation as humans to take the information given to us by the Church and decide it it is right for our own hearts.

To me the most important lesson in Catholicism and many other religions is to have faith and to treat others as you would be treated. What Church you choose to practice this in I think has more to do with comfort. I enjoy the rituals, sounds and scents of a Catholic Mass, that is what I know, just being in a Mass can bring me a feeling of peace.

I find nothing wrong with taking pieces of a religion and teaching our children to think for themselves, to have an open mind and decide for themselves what is right.

Posted 3/26/10 7:46 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Non-drama religious post

I think it's difficult, if not impossible for most people to 100% believe in 100% of what the Church says. Even people who follow everything may have some hidden issues with parts of it.
I believe that we are all individuals, with our own ideas, thoughts, and beliefs. You find a church that aligns with most of your ideas, and work within your bounds and the church's bounds to handle the differences.

As long as YOU are OK with the way that YOU worship, I think everything is OK in the world... Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/26/10 7:48 AM
 

MikesWife
Wanting...........

Member since 1/06

6887 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Non-drama religious post

In my opinion you can’t really fault the Church for encouraging Catholics to adhere to its canon laws. It is their job and they honestly feel these laws have merit.
Having said that, I do not believe that you, I, or any other Catholic out there are damned to H E L L because we do not adopt its philosophy at every level.
I personally believe our God is merciful – that He loves us, knows our intentions and our good will and to me, that is what is most important.
You are by far a hypocrite for going to Church and questioning certain beliefs and/or traditions – that’s human nature.
Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/26/10 8:13 AM
 

MrsA714
Baby #2 is here!

Member since 8/07

8806 total posts

Name:

Re: Non-drama religious post

Posted by GoldenRod

I think it's difficult, if not impossible for most people to. 100% believe in 100% of what the Church says. Even people who follow everything may have some hidden issues with parts of it.
I believe that we are all individuals, with our own ideas, thoughts, and beliefs. You find a church that aligns with most of your ideas, and work within your bounds and the church's bounds to handle the differences.

As long as YOU are OK with the way that YOU worship, I think everything is OK in the world... Chat Icon Chat Icon



Well said. Everyone has their own opinions, beliefs and views - that's what makes us individuals - and IMO I think it is rare to agree 100% with all the views and ideas of the faith you follow...much like politics - you can align yourself with one party but doesn't mean you don't disagree with some of their ideas. To be honest, when I think of someone NOT having their own views or ideas within any organization they follow it almost sounds cult-like to me.

I am Catholic and disagree with some of the church's views. Does that make me a bad Catholic? Probably to some, but I practice my religion how I choose to and I believe there is only 1 judgment I have to worry about. You should do what makes you comfortable. Chat Icon

Posted 3/26/10 8:32 AM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Non-drama religious post

First I would like to say I am was raised and am a practicing Catholic but do not believe every single thing.

I am pro choice, for gay marriage for example--so no I do not think you have to blindly follow all the laws of the church.


Posted by heathergirl

Ieven though the priest had to make a big deal that I hadn't made my other sacraments, and FH had to sign a dispensation, etc. Stuff like that is what gets under my skin.
.



I have to say "stuff like this getting under your skin?" I mean then do not get married in a church. I don't mean to be rude but they have rules and you either follow them or don't.

I know some parishes that would have made you recieve communion and be confirmed before they married you (like my SIL and friend had to do), this church made you sign a dispensation IMO it is not a big deal.

People can do what they want and believe what they want but it bothers me a little when they WANT to get married in a church but are bothered by any rules or inconviences of the church.

Posted 3/26/10 8:33 AM
 

Mrs007
Im obsessed w my lil man!

Member since 3/09

2528 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Non-drama religious post

No I do not think you are a hypocrite.

I was raised Catholic, went to Catholic school my whole life (even my college was a Catholic college) and I do not agree with their views on everything either. Actually, I think more Catholics are starting to "wake up" and see that some stuff they preach against is not all bad. Just to give you an idea, my aunt who is a nun is a democrat and voted for Obama! Chat Icon

I do follow the church's teachings, but am against their views on BCP, abortion, and gay marriages to name a few. DH and I plan on raising our children Catholic but let them decide what they want to believe in or what they think is wrong or right, unlike my parents who raised us to believe that abortion, gay marriages, etc were completely wrong "because the church says so." I will let my children, as I do, make an educated decision on their views and not believe something because someone tells them to believe it.

Posted 3/26/10 8:38 AM
 

RadioLau
LIF Adult

Member since 4/07

2179 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: Non-drama religious post

My DH and I were in a similiar situation. I had made all my sacraments though so that wasn't an issue. He wanted to get married in a church so we did. (I really wanted to get married at the catering hall.) He also made it clear he wanted to raise our children catholic and I agreed even though I really don't believe in anything.

Posted 3/26/10 8:47 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Non-drama religious post

I don't think I know anyone who is a practicing Catholic that doesn't have some issue with the Church. But, maybe I run with the rabble rousers. Chat Icon

Here's the issue as I see it: If your DH wants to raise the kids Catholic, I think you need to be on board with this. I know someone who is dealing with this issue right now. She didn't really care if they raised the child Catholic and thought her DH thought the same, but I think he assumed they would because they were married in the Church. She has come to realize that the whole religious ed/making sacraments thing is not really going to work if she refuses to participate.

I think it's great that you are discussing this before marriage, but as most parents discover, sometimes those decisions and feelings change once the child is here. I think this is one of those types of decisions. I don't think it's hypocritical to participate in raising the children Catholic if you have some issues, but I do think you need to be supportive and not talk about some of your issues until the child is old enough to understand them.

I am choosing to raise my DS Catholic, but if he chooses something else later, that's OK with me. I think it's helpful to have a framework in which to teach him about God and faith.

Posted 3/26/10 9:27 AM
 

photoshopbabe
wow....

Member since 5/07

2197 total posts

Name:
linda

Re: Non-drama religious post

I don't think you are doing something wrong at all...in fact, this is the way I feel.

I was brought up Catholic, did all my things, but never went to church.

I dont agree with the Catholic church for a LOT of things, but it's really all ive ever known, kwim?

I prob plan to raise my kids Catholic too.

Posted 3/26/10 9:30 AM
 

MrsH2009
Thank you St. Gerard!

Member since 8/09

6631 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Non-drama religious post

I also wanted to add that different churches have different rulings on this. My DH isn't Catholic (he's Greek Orthodox), but we found a church that was fine with everything as long as he was baptized in any Christian faith. We've decided to raise our children Catholic b/c I go to church, where as he doesn't. I went to CCD and then Catholic school. They never asked my parents to go to church, only to pay. LOL!
I think it's important to raise your children in an organized religion, but you can teach them how you feel about certain issues as well. We love learning about science and nature, and I'm planning on teaching my kids all about evolution and natural selection. We'll find a way to make it mesh.

Posted 3/26/10 9:50 AM
 

heathergirl
Cocktail Time!

Member since 10/08

4978 total posts

Name:
American mouth

Re: Non-drama religious post

Posted by DiamondGirl

First I would like to say I am was raised and am a practicing Catholic but do not believe every single thing.

I am pro choice, for gay marriage for example--so no I do not think you have to blindly follow all the laws of the church.


Posted by heathergirl

Ieven though the priest had to make a big deal that I hadn't made my other sacraments, and FH had to sign a dispensation, etc. Stuff like that is what gets under my skin.
.



I have to say "stuff like this getting under your skin?" I mean then do not get married in a church. I don't mean to be rude but they have rules and you either follow them or don't.

I know some parishes that would have made you recieve communion and be confirmed before they married you (like my SIL and friend had to do), this church made you sign a dispensation IMO it is not a big deal.

People can do what they want and believe what they want but it bothers me a little when they WANT to get married in a church but are bothered by any rules or inconviences of the church.




I should have made myself more clear that I have no issue with the rule or the things we had to do in order to get married in the Church.

I was unhappy with the way I was treated by the preist because I did not make communion and confirmation, because I was "not a child of Christ" as he put it.

Posted 3/26/10 10:05 AM
 

Danyell48
LIF Toddler

Member since 6/09

391 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Non-drama religious post

We have this conversation alot...I was "raised" Catholic and so was DH, we were baptized and made our other sacraments. We both started to wander away from it. We didn't get married in a church because we don't agree with the ideals. We tend to lean towards buddism, if you want to label it. We toyed with the idea of baptizing our children when the time comes, "to give them some direction" but we recently went to one and in the beginning they ask the parents a couple of questions. "do you believe in god, the church etc) And we couldn't answer those questions. I can't see raising/teaching my children something i don't believe in. I know when the time does come we will get alot of problems from the family, but in the end it is our choice. But i think our situation is easier since we both have the same thoughts. If you have most of the same beliefs as catholicism, you can give them those beliefs as well. In the end I believe they'll make their own decision about religion. I know someone who was raise jewish but converted to catholicism.

Message edited 2010-03-26 10:09:59.550000.

Posted 3/26/10 10:08 AM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: Non-drama religious post

Posted by DiamondGirl

First I would like to say I am was raised and am a practicing Catholic but do not believe every single thing.

I am pro choice, for gay marriage for example--so no I do not think you have to blindly follow all the laws of the church.


Posted by heathergirl

Ieven though the priest had to make a big deal that I hadn't made my other sacraments, and FH had to sign a dispensation, etc. Stuff like that is what gets under my skin.
.



I have to say "stuff like this getting under your skin?" I mean then do not get married in a church. I don't mean to be rude but they have rules and you either follow them or don't.

I know some parishes that would have made you recieve communion and be confirmed before they married you (like my SIL and friend had to do), this church made you sign a dispensation IMO it is not a big deal.

People can do what they want and believe what they want but it bothers me a little when they WANT to get married in a church but are bothered by any rules or inconviences of the church.




I agree with all of this! It sounds like they welcomed you actually- but I think that there may be some value in at least learning about the sacraments- if you plan on raising your children catholic, you may want to know a little more about it

good luck Chat Icon

Posted 3/26/10 10:14 AM
 

heathergirl
Cocktail Time!

Member since 10/08

4978 total posts

Name:
American mouth

Re: Non-drama religious post

Thanks everyone Chat Icon Your posts made me feel a lot better, as I see I am not the only one. I don't agree with a lot of the teachings and beliefs, such as abortion, gay marriage, etc. I want to believe that I am a good person, even if I do not go to church, I shouldn't be considered any less. I believe in good and evil, and I believe in something "more" once we have passed. I definitely know I need become more educated in religion for sure. There's a whole lot I don't know. I believe in being a spiritual person, whatever that may be. I guess my issues are with the dogma that some people push on others, I'm better than you because I go to church, yet I cheat on my wife, etc. And I also know I that I have to deal with my own opinions towards those types of things. I don't want to deny my future children the benefits and beliefs of the church, I just need to get more involved so I know what's going on.

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/26/10 10:49 AM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Non-drama religious post

Posted by heathergirl

Thanks everyone Chat Icon Your posts made me feel a lot better, as I see I am not the only one. I don't agree with a lot of the teachings and beliefs, such as abortion, gay marriage, etc. I want to believe that I am a good person, even if I do not go to church, I shouldn't be considered any less. I believe in good and evil, and I believe in something "more" once we have passed. I definitely know I need become more educated in religion for sure. There's a whole lot I don't know. I believe in being a spiritual person, whatever that may be. I guess my issues are with the dogma that some people push on others, I'm better than you because I go to church, yet I cheat on my wife, etc. And I also know I that I have to deal with my own opinions towards those types of things. I don't want to deny my future children the benefits and beliefs of the church, I just need to get more involved so I know what's going on.

Chat Icon Chat Icon



If people push the "i'm better than you thing" then it's the person, not the church doing it- and they are wrong... ask yourself what jesus would do, or better yet- read the story of the Prodigal Son in the bible... a parable Jesus used to teach.

Posted 3/26/10 11:10 AM
 

pandaworm
LIF Adult

Member since 8/08

1125 total posts

Name:
bethany

Re: Non-drama religious post

my parents had sort of the same issue - mom was catholic and dad is lutheran. dad didn't agree with many of the catholic doctrines and after years of catholic school/church, mom didn't either. they did some research and decided to raise us lutheran and are very happy they did.

this is not to say that one is better than the other, but if you're uncomfortable with some of the doctrines of the catholic church, then maybe another branch of christianity would suit your beliefs better (hey, maybe even another religion - who knows!). point is, i would have a very hard time raising my children with beliefs that i didn't completely agree with or feel comfortable with and i would want my dh and i on the same page. do a bit of research and see if something suits you better. also, talk to your fh and see WHY it's important to him - does he want the religion, the tradition, christianity, morals, catholicism, etc. you should understand why it's important, you know?

Posted 3/26/10 11:20 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Sort of a spinoff to the "pretty religious jewelry post" lipglossjunky73 3/24/10 25 Families Helping Families ™