Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

She wanted the part. She got the part not just every day. Still, she got the play.

I think it's a good deal. If she is as good as she think she is, she will be selected again for another play and maybe next time she will get the play all by herself.

Instead of spending her energy on bashing the other girl and complain about the deal, I would tell her to be thankful that she got what she wanted and to PROVE in her action that she is better. Sing better, act better than the other girl. Acting like a brat will get her nowhere. Many talented Hollywood actors/actresses are not getting roles even with all their talent because nobody wants to deal with them. Which could happen to her next time if she keeps complaining. I am sure she is bashing the girl openly so EVERYBODY is aware of her displeasure.

As a parent, NO WAY I would call the school and cancel unless the other girl had gotten the part and was not as good as my DD.

Posted 4/29/09 5:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by smdl

As a parent, NO WAY I would call the school and cancel unless the other girl had gotten the part and was not as good as my DD.



i agree with everything else you wrote sophie except for this.

even if *I* thought that the other girl wasn't as good, it's not my decision to make. and calling the teacher to complain isn't going to change things, and would only make me look like a spoiled mom trying to get something for my spoiled child that she may or may not deserve.

i would speak with my DD and tell her that i believed that the teacher was only trying to be fair, and that if she wanted to get the part for herself the next time then she should work hard now and do the best job she can.

i actually really like that the two girls are splitting the part. that never happened in my HS and we definitely cultivated some divas because of it Chat Icon

and i would also probably say something to her about her attitude. i understand that people sometimes just don't like each other, for no good reason, but for her to come home and stomp around and complain about not liking this girl "just because" is just bratty. i don't know how much of that i would tolerate.

Posted 4/29/09 6:03 PM
 

Karen
Just chillin'!!

Member since 1/06

9690 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

I think I'm more bothered by the parent's reaction than the childs. The parent took a valuable teaching opportunity and instead continued the "entitlement" mentality that is rampant in our society!

Posted 4/29/09 6:10 PM
 

avamamma
My Girl

Member since 7/06

3395 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

I would not call. I would assume that the teacher/Director was trying to be fair and give more than 1 student the chance to play a specific role in the play.

I would tell my child that was the fair way to do it.

Message edited 2009-04-29 18:27:37.990000.

Posted 4/29/09 6:27 PM
 

Michelle1123
Baby #5 on the way!

Member since 9/05

7919 total posts

Name:

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by Kate

The kid should suck it up and the parent should stay out of it.



Totally agree.

Posted 4/29/09 6:29 PM
 

angelbear217
Mommy of 2

Member since 5/05

4313 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

I agree with what PP have said. The child should be grateful that she got the part at all and deal with the situation. The parent calling to complain undermines the teacher/director's decision to make it a 2 person part in the first place. The parent never should have called, but used this as an opportunity to teach her child about fairness.

Posted 4/29/09 6:34 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

My younger stepdaughter was in Wicked, and she played the witch - and shared the part with 5 other girls. Chat Icon Think of it as representing the job market these days. If she wants the part, thats how it is.

Posted 4/29/09 6:36 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by Karen

I think I'm more bothered by the parent's reaction than the childs. The parent took a valuable teaching opportunity and instead continued the "entitlement" mentality that is rampant in our society!



ITA plus, maybe if this was not set up as a sharing part, she may not have gotten anything. Plus, she is the one saying she's better but who's to say that is correct.

Posted 4/29/09 6:41 PM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by Bxgell2

Um, I think that's life - the kid has to suck it up and deal with the distribution of parts, or drop out of the play. I certainly would never call the school to complain, it's not at all my place, and I think totally inappropriate. If my daughter had such a problem with it, my advice to her would be deal with it, make it something positive for yourself, or pass on the role.



ITA! I would never ever call the school to complain in this situation! I'd tell my kid to suck it up and deal with it or I'd tell them they couldn't be in the play.

Posted 4/29/09 7:06 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Sorry, as the music director of my school's musical, you need to tell your daughter to deal with it. That's the way it goes sometimes. Trust me, it could be a lot worse.

Posted 4/29/09 7:09 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

If my daughter was the one who was complaining about sharing the role, and saying the other girl was a horrible singer, I'd call the school, of course...to let them know I've removed her from the play until she can behave nicely. Chat Icon

Posted 4/29/09 7:34 PM
 

chelle
It's a Good Life

Member since 8/06

15404 total posts

Name:
Isn't it obvious?

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by greeneyes361708

I would never ever call the school to complain in this situation! I'd tell my kid to suck it up and deal with it or I'd tell them they couldn't be in the play.



100%!!!!!

Posted 4/29/09 7:35 PM
 

staceyd
LIF Adult

Member since 8/08

2052 total posts

Name:
stacey

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Is this a middle school by any chance? I may know a school that might do that...

Posted 4/29/09 7:37 PM
 

Blissful
Ultimate Expression of LOVE

Member since 6/08

4985 total posts

Name:
Maria

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by Bxgell2

Um, I think that's life - the kid has to suck it up and deal with the distribution of parts, or drop out of the play. I certainly would never call the school to complain, it's not at all my place, and I think totally inappropriate. If my daughter had such a problem with it, my advice to her would be deal with it, make it something positive for yourself, or pass on the role.



ITA.............Life isn't always as fair or perfect as we would like it to be. It will be easier on a child if they learn this early on. I assume that a child that can experience this level of jealousy or rivalry can handle being told to make the best of the situation or drop out. I'd NEVER get involved.....

Posted 4/29/09 7:39 PM
 

Mrs. Patticakes
SPREAD KINDNESS

Member since 9/06

17330 total posts

Name:

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

I agree. The child has to learn teamwork. The parent would be out of line to get involved.

Posted 4/29/09 8:00 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by lehcar

Sorry, as the music director of my school's musical, you need to tell your daughter to deal with it. That's the way it goes sometimes. Trust me, it could be a lot worse.



ITA and I want to hear more about this story with details...Chat Icon

Posted 4/29/09 8:17 PM
 

munchkinbugs
My little loves!

Member since 1/06

8093 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

I think the child needs to be taught how to share. Everyone should get a chance to be in the play.

ETA.....I was not into plays, but I played sports in HS....and there is nothing more ANNOYING than a parent who begs for their child to get more time in whatever activity it is. That's just teaching your child not to have to work hard because mom and dad will just complain until they get their way. So wrong! Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-04-29 20:19:58.273000.

Posted 4/29/09 8:17 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by lehcar

Sorry, as the music director of my school's musical, you need to tell your daughter to deal with it. That's the way it goes sometimes. Trust me, it could be a lot worse.



Give me more credit than that!!!!Chat Icon

It's not my daughter.....

Posted 4/29/09 9:13 PM
 

dawnygirl25
Growing up soo fast..

Member since 1/06

14917 total posts

Name:
Dawn

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by Bxgell2

Um, I think that's life - the kid has to suck it up and deal with the distribution of parts, or drop out of the play. I certainly would never call the school to complain, it's not at all my place, and I think totally inappropriate. If my daughter had such a problem with it, my advice to her would be deal with it, make it something positive for yourself, or pass on the role.


ITA with this.

Posted 4/29/09 9:19 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by PrincessP

Posted by lehcar

Sorry, as the music director of my school's musical, you need to tell your daughter to deal with it. That's the way it goes sometimes. Trust me, it could be a lot worse.



ITA and I want to hear more about this story with details...Chat Icon




Essentially that is exactly the way it goes.

It was just hard to pen the post without putting in my own 2 cents...

Without giving my specific opinion on the matter lets just say that...My girls both played the part of Michael in Mary Poppins last year....they shared the role between them and another girl.

Posted 4/29/09 9:20 PM
 

cantbelieveit
Love these kids!

Member since 10/05

4708 total posts

Name:
Tammy

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

I think sharing the part is a fair decision.

Posted 4/29/09 9:23 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by hbugal

Posted by PrincessP

Posted by lehcar

Sorry, as the music director of my school's musical, you need to tell your daughter to deal with it. That's the way it goes sometimes. Trust me, it could be a lot worse.



ITA and I want to hear more about this story with details...Chat Icon




Essentially that is exactly the way it goes.

It was just hard to pen the post without putting in my own 2 cents...

Without giving my specific opinion on the matter lets just say that...My girls both played the part of Michael in Mary Poppins last year....they shared the role between them and another girl.



No but you werent the parent (complainer) the other one was ...correct? Also, what did the teacher say? or is this currently ongoing?

Message edited 2009-04-29 21:53:43.423000.

Posted 4/29/09 9:52 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by PrincessP

Posted by hbugal

Posted by PrincessP

Posted by lehcar

Sorry, as the music director of my school's musical, you need to tell your daughter to deal with it. That's the way it goes sometimes. Trust me, it could be a lot worse.



ITA and I want to hear more about this story with details...Chat Icon




Essentially that is exactly the way it goes.

It was just hard to pen the post without putting in my own 2 cents...

Without giving my specific opinion on the matter lets just say that...My girls both played the part of Michael in Mary Poppins last year....they shared the role between them and another girl.



No but you werent the parent (complainer) the other one was ...correct? Also, what did the teacher say? or is this currently ongoing?



This is currently going on...

It doesnt involve one of my children...

Im sure there will be more to come. I'll be sure to update...

Message edited 2009-04-29 21:56:24.167000.

Posted 4/29/09 9:55 PM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

I'd say that the daughter inherited her dramatic gift from her mommy Chat Icon
That kid's a brat and the mother's a jerk. There, I said it, I feel better now Chat Icon

Posted 4/29/09 10:06 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Need OPINIONs on this scenario...

Posted by hbugal

Posted by lehcar

Sorry, as the music director of my school's musical, you need to tell your daughter to deal with it. That's the way it goes sometimes. Trust me, it could be a lot worse.



Give me more credit than that!!!!Chat Icon

It's not my daughter.....



No, I knew it wasn't your daughterChat Icon I worded it wrongChat Icon

Posted 4/29/09 10:43 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
need opinions on planning trip for out of state wedding Myrockette 3/24/06 2 Families Helping Families ™
So, I need opinions... LIPrincess 3/23/06 9 TTC
decided to at least start pumping...questions and opinions? mable 3/22/06 12 Parenting
Need your opinions ladies!! CityNYGirl 3/22/06 9 TTC
Dilemma, need your opinions. bee 3/21/06 8 Pregnancy
Vacation question...Need opinions... nov04libride 3/21/06 2 Families Helping Families ™