Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases I am in the process of interviewing potential nannies/housekeepers (it's a job in itself!). Out of nowhere I had a panic attack that the nanny could carry a disease. Did any of you who have nannies ask if they were HIV/Hepatitis/Herpes positive? Would they even be honest? It's a personal and odd question, but I think it's important to know. I doubt anyone would want to go get blood tested and show me the results, but after my mini panic attack I really want to know. I am working through various nanny agencies. For the most part the people I am interviewing are immigrants (which doesn't mean they carry anything, but I don't know if the ones I've been interviewing have insurance). I found one I really like, and now I am getting nervous! The whole nanny thing is still new to me Message edited 2011-12-19 20:11:56.843000. |
|
Posted 12/19/11 7:51 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q I would totally be worried about this too, but I dont know if it's legal to ask this on an interview...like of you didn't hire them they could say it was discrimination...kwim?? Maybe if you go through an agency, the agency would know? Good luck! |
|
Posted 12/19/11 8:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q It's so nerve wrecking! I doubt the people I've been interviewing would file for discrimination though. For the most part they want to be paid cash off the books. The better agencies that do large background checks and know everything there is to know about the nannies charge 15% of the annual income as a placement fee! That's about 4k! I'm going through small local agencies, and also using care.com. |
|
Posted 12/19/11 8:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q do you mean herpes like the kind you get on your mouth or the STD? I don't think that it would matter if you had genital herpes. if it does, then you have more problems than your nanny just having an STD. |
|
Posted 12/19/11 8:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q Posted by lululu do you mean herpes like the kind you get on your mouth or the STD? I don't think that it would matter if you had genital herpes. if it does, then you have more problems than your nanny just having an STD. Oral herpes- a nanny can pass it just by kissing my dd. And I'm not worried about STDs specifically, just things they can give to my DD. AIDS/HIV and Hep you can get from unclean needles and things like that. Am I being a little crazy/over thinking things? Message edited 2011-12-19 20:08:54.697000. |
|
Posted 12/19/11 8:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases You have a very valid concern ESP bc most of these nannies are not from here! HIV rates among other rings can be much higher in other countries then in the US |
|
Posted 12/19/11 8:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases I do believe it's illegal to ask about HIV/Aids.. I'm pretty sure people's medical histories are private and you are not allowed to discriminate against someone for having a disease, etc. Message edited 2011-12-19 20:33:32.870000. |
|
Posted 12/19/11 8:33 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases Posted by eroxgirl I do believe it's illegal to ask about HIV/Aids.. I'm pretty sure people's medical histories are private and you are not allowed to discriminate against someone for having a disease, etc. At the same time, someone with HIV/Aids is most likely NOT going to want to work with children. A small child is prone to catching every little cold bug out there... that's a death sentence to someone with HIV. I understand why you're concerned, but don't drive yourself crazy over this particular issue, because you can't demand an answer to it anyway. This |
|
Posted 12/19/11 9:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases HIV/Aids wouldn't be passed unless blood passed. after 30 seconds to one minute exposure to air HIV is killed. Would you ask all of your child's teachers in school if they had HIV or Herpes? I think your concern should be more focused on why they would be kissing your child in the first place. |
|
Posted 12/19/11 9:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases Posted by monkeybride Posted by eroxgirl I do believe it's illegal to ask about HIV/Aids.. I'm pretty sure people's medical histories are private and you are not allowed to discriminate against someone for having a disease, etc. At the same time, someone with HIV/Aids is most likely NOT going to want to work with children. A small child is prone to catching every little cold bug out there... that's a death sentence to someone with HIV. I understand why you're concerned, but don't drive yourself crazy over this particular issue, because you can't demand an answer to it anyway. This ITA. I don't think it's legal to ask
|
|
Posted 12/19/11 10:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases Not sure how it works with nannies but I do know that myself, as a licensed home daycare provider must have a medical filled out by my PCP every renewal period stating that I am in good health and free of communicable diseases (amongst some other criteria) Message edited 2011-12-19 22:54:56.263000. |
|
Posted 12/19/11 10:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases ok, so...I really don't mean to be snarky AT ALL...but the more I think about this...the more this post bothers me for a few different reasons. |
|
Posted 12/19/11 11:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases Not sure if it's legal to ask BUT I would be highly concerned about these things as well. |
|
Posted 12/19/11 11:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases Posted by MrsMeloyellow ok, so...I really don't mean to be snarky AT ALL...but the more I think about this...the more this post bothers me for a few different reasons. I get your concern but 1) WHY would the nanny have dirty needles near your child??? 2) you can't get aids from holding hands, hugging, etc. 3) unless your nanny and child are snogging like mad and both have open sores, bleeding gums...HIV is not a threat...and if they were snogging...you have a bigger issue to deal with. Herpes is also same scenario...ANYBODY could have it and you wouldn't know it. Your own family members included...do you plan to question family members as well? 4) What difference does it make that they are immigrants...yes, india and africa have higer amounts of people with aids....but america is pretty high up there with 1.2 million (2007). I'm just wondering if this thought would have crossed your mind if they were american nannies. 5) what difference does it make if they have insurance? I'm sorry...I have a cousin born with HIV through no fault of her own and it bothers me that people would treat hr like she had the cooties w/o getting the facts re: the disease. Unless ur native american we are ALL immigrants. how would you feel if someone assumed because you were an immigrant you might be more likely to carry disease? Not everyone who is an immigrant is from some dirty 3rd world country. I understand your points. But anyone caring for a child can have blood to blood contact. Let's say the nanny is carrying the child and they both fall, and get open wounds. The nanny then has to tend to the child's wounds. So I do think it's a valid senario to be concerned with. As for needles, alot of older people have diabetes and need to finger stick themselves, so the needle issue could be a risk if you do not know someone's health status. A lot of people, esp English as a second language, are unfamiliar with diseases they carry and how it's transmitted, etc. Or lack the insurance to receive proper yearly exams and medical care, screening, etc. Message edited 2011-12-19 23:26:07.393000. |
|
Posted 12/19/11 11:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases We are all concerned re: the health of our children. It's just very unlikely of a scenario though. Air contact kills HIV virus within seconds. So your nanny would first have to be HIV positive, AND fall, while holding your child AND have injuries pressed so tightly against each other that there is no air contact. Message edited 2011-12-19 23:52:21.303000. |
|
Posted 12/19/11 11:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases here's a great link for you |
|
Posted 12/19/11 11:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases Posted by MrsMeloyellow ok, so...I really don't mean to be snarky AT ALL...but the more I think about this...the more this post bothers me for a few different reasons. I get your concern but 1) WHY would the nanny have dirty needles near your child??? 2) you can't get aids from holding hands, hugging, etc. 3) unless your nanny and child are snogging like mad and both have open sores, bleeding gums...HIV is not a threat...and if they were snogging...you have a bigger issue to deal with. Herpes is also same scenario...ANYBODY could have it and you wouldn't know it. Your own family members included...do you plan to question family members as well? 4) What difference does it make that they are immigrants...yes, india and africa have higer amounts of people with aids....but america is pretty high up there with 1.2 million (2007). I'm just wondering if this thought would have crossed your mind if they were american nannies. 5) what difference does it make if they have insurance? I'm sorry...I have a cousin born with HIV through no fault of her own and it bothers me that people would treat hr like she had the cooties w/o getting the facts re: the disease. Unless ur native american we are ALL immigrants. how would you feel if someone assumed because you were an immigrant you might be more likely to carry disease? Not everyone who is an immigrant is from some dirty 3rd world country. I don't think you understood my concerns at all, and I think your opinions are very biased because you have a cousin with HIV. First of all, I'm not stupid. I know HIV cannot be passed by hugging. I never said that they'd have dirty needles in my houses, it's a way someone could have acquired HIV. My daughter runs around a lot, bangs into things, and bleeds- A LOT. I know it's very very hard to transmit HIV from open blood wounds, but it's possible. I also know it's more likely someone will get into an accident, but as a parent, my role is to protect my child. You cannot eliminate all risks and prevent everything, but I do as much as I can. What about hepatitis (hep A)? You completely disregarded that concern. To address all your remarks, 2 family members DO have herpes. I know who they are. When the cold sores are present, they don't kiss my dd. It's something I'd like to know. Her daycare teachers currently kiss her a lot, they are affectionate. I don't mind. I am just saying, it's something I don't want her to catch. Also, obviously being an immigrant doesn't mean you carry a disease, and being American doesn't mean you don't. I don't think I am being ignorant in my concerns. America has pretty good health facilities and I am just saying that some people from other countries don't have as much access to health education or treatment. That's not being stupid and biased, it's a fact. Most of the people I've interviewed have/had children. In America, you must be tested for HIV when pregnant. I don't know if it's the same in other countries. Also, my mom is an immigrant. I don't think all immigrants carry diseases. Lastly, insurance matters b/c if someone doesn't have insurance they may not be able to get treatment for any medical condition. Also, they may not have been tested for various illnesses or diseases or know they have it, and they most certainly won't line up to go get tested if I did ask and they didn't know (although it seems like I cannot or should not ask anyway) I do think your remarks were a bit snarky. I interviewed one nanny and liked her a lot. she told me that she had to stop working at her last job b/c she got toxoplasmosis, and she said she's better now. It's what got me thinking and made me nervous. Toxoplaspmosis is dangerous if you are pregnant, but I'm pretty sure it's not contagious. That's not a concern of mine, but it led to my concerns and my OP. Thanks Message edited 2011-12-20 06:05:46.797000. |
|
Posted 12/20/11 5:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases Totally illegal to ask for medical information. |
|
Posted 12/20/11 8:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases We have had our nanny for the past 7 months. She came very highly recommended from other families in our neighborhood and worked for a number of years at a local daycare. I have to admit, when she walked in the door of my home I just knew she was the woman I wanted in my home, with my child. I was very thorough, checked references and did an extensive background check through my DH's office. I just knew and the thought of illnesses and diseases just didn't even cross my mind. I understand your concern, because thinking about it does seem scary. If you can't get the answers you are looking for legally, maybe trust your gut and instinct and find someone who was born in the US who would be more likely vaccinated and exposed to the same things you and your family are. Message edited 2011-12-20 08:41:05.537000. |
|
Posted 12/20/11 8:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases Posted by MrsMeloyellow 5) what difference does it make if they have insurance? I'm sorry...I have a cousin born with HIV through no fault of her own and it bothers me that people would treat hr like she had the cooties w/o getting the facts re: the disease. Unless ur native american we are ALL immigrants. how would you feel if someone assumed because you were an immigrant you might be more likely to carry disease? Not everyone who is an immigrant is from some dirty 3rd world country. I don't have a nanny but I do think whether they have insurance IS an important thing to know. If she doesn't have health insurance she might not be getting treatment when she is ill. So if she comes down with something like strep and doesn't get antibiotics she could be passing it on to your DC even if she feels better. It is a fact that people who don't have insurance are far more likely to not seek medical care when they might need it. While you don't need antibiotics for many illnesses there are things that you do require care for so they don't get passed on to others. Someone who doesn't have health insurance might not go to the doctor for a rash - so they won't know if they have say chicken pox or just an allergic reaction to something. That can be a big difference when working with young children. That doesn't mean that they necessarily would go but by having insurance a person is more likely to go to the doctor than not. So I can understand why someone interviewing potential nannies might have that one questions. As to the other issue - I don't think it is legal to ask personal medical questions. I'm not sure if it is something that say a nanny agency might do in a background check - but I would doubt it. I know I would want to know if they were vaccinated against things that my child was too young to have gotten yet - but again that is private medical history that I'm sure is illegal to ask. |
|
Posted 12/20/11 10:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases Posted by Lillykat Posted by MrsMeloyellow 5) what difference does it make if they have insurance? I'm sorry...I have a cousin born with HIV through no fault of her own and it bothers me that people would treat hr like she had the cooties w/o getting the facts re: the disease. Unless ur native american we are ALL immigrants. how would you feel if someone assumed because you were an immigrant you might be more likely to carry disease? Not everyone who is an immigrant is from some dirty 3rd world country. I don't have a nanny but I do think whether they have insurance IS an important thing to know. If she doesn't have health insurance she might not be getting treatment when she is ill. So if she comes down with something like strep and doesn't get antibiotics she could be passing it on to your DC even if she feels better. It is a fact that people who don't have insurance are far more likely to not seek medical care when they might need it. While you don't need antibiotics for many illnesses there are things that you do require care for so they don't get passed on to others. Someone who doesn't have health insurance might not go to the doctor for a rash - so they won't know if they have say chicken pox or just an allergic reaction to something. That can be a big difference when working with young children. That doesn't mean that they necessarily would go but by having insurance a person is more likely to go to the doctor than not. So I can understand why someone interviewing potential nannies might have that one questions. As to the other issue - I don't think it is legal to ask personal medical questions. I'm not sure if it is something that say a nanny agency might do in a background check - but I would doubt it. I know I would want to know if they were vaccinated against things that my child was too young to have gotten yet - but again that is private medical history that I'm sure is illegal to ask. This is a very good point. The only problem I see is that from my experience, our nanny pays out of pocket when she goes to the doctor. Her and husband opt to not use her husbands policy because it's far more expensive for them to pay monthly then to pay as they go. Of course it's a risk but that's how they do it. So she has no coverage but I know for a fact she sees her doctor for a knee issue and high blood pressure and also pays for her meds. Message edited 2011-12-20 10:32:00.250000. |
|
Posted 12/20/11 10:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases Did you ask her current daycare providers if they have HIV or any other diseases? |
|
Posted 12/20/11 10:37 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases As the prior poster noted, those working in daycare I believe must have a medical filled out by my PCP every renewal period stating that they are in good health and free of communicable diseases (amongst some other criteria), just as I need to show that my daughter has been vaccinated routinely. |
|
Posted 12/20/11 11:20 AM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases again, I wasn't Trying to be snarky. People often hire immigrant nannies because they offer lower rates. Then they turn around and have all these standards. Are YOU offering her medical insurance? Is the agency you are working with offering her insurance? If not then I think it's unfair of you to make that one of your standards. Plenty of people HAVE insurance and STILL don't go to the Dr unless they think they are dying. You wouldn't know that unless you were a fly on their wall. So to have that standard seems silly to me. I was born in the u.s...am educated on health standards and safety, have medical insurance...and I don't always run to the DR. first thing...I may take nyquil and see if it gets better, I may try a few things before going to get a diagnosis. Also, I could pass a medical screening and then contract something during my time working for you and you wouldn't know it. So if you get what I'm saying, Medical insurance or not...the risk of spreading disease is there regardless of who you choose and their criteria. I never said you were stupid. I just feel like it's ignorant to assume that because someone is an immigrant they are less educated on disease. It MAY be the case for some...but thats even the case for many americans. I don't think that their status as immigrants should have even been brought up. Bottom line is, when dealing with strangers, you just don't know. You just have to choose someone you trust, someone who understands cleanliness and proper health practices. If you honestly feel that the majority of people you are interviewing from this agency aren't of a class that would understand that, then why bother continuing to interview from this agency? |
|
Posted 12/20/11 12:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nanny- weird interview Q/diseases Posted by RSB34 As the prior poster noted, those working in daycare I believe must have a medical filled out by my PCP every renewal period stating that they are in good health and free of communicable diseases (amongst some other criteria), just as I need to show that my daughter has been vaccinated routinely. Right. I didn't think HIV or Hepatitis was considered communicable. I thought that label was for things easily transmitted, like measles, mumps, rubella, tuberculosis, etc. But I guess not. You have NO idea who has HIV or other diseases. The other babies, toddlers, pre-schooler's and children could all have HIV, etc. and you would never know it! There was a story in the news recently about a boy who was denied entrance to a school because he has HIV. Honestly that makes me sick (and yes I read the entire story about it, and their reasoning, and it still makes me sick). Message edited 2011-12-20 12:11:34.433000. |
|
Posted 12/20/11 12:10 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weird question about interview attire | stickydust | 6/8/11 | 11 | Career |
| Interview Related-kind of weird | Pumpkin | 2/8/07 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Nanny/Babysitter Interview Questions? | randella | 2/9/10 | 2 | Parenting |
| Nanny interview help! | sasha96 | 10/23/08 | 2 | Parenting |
| Questions to ask Nanny during interview? | RM23 | 4/28/08 | 0 | Parenting |










