Re: Nanny vs Daycare?
Posted 5/11/2010 9:46:19 AM by Hofstra26

I think that both options have something to offer. I will say that I *personally* am not a huge fan of day care centers more because I am not comfortable with the lack of education and experience the teachers are required to have to work there. I worked in a few day care centers prior to becoming a teacher and most require nothing more than a general associates degree and a 30hr. childcare certificate. I just never felt comfortable with the idea of leaving my child in the hands of someone who isn't a true educator. And speaking as a certified elementary school teacher I can promise that most day care "teachers" are not full, certified teachers with Masters degrees simply because day care centers don't pay even close to what a real teachers salary is. They pay very minimally and it's the reason why the turnover rate is pretty high in day care centers. All that being said, people need daycare and there are merits to both a center and a nanny.

I don't think you can assume that because a child is with a nanny they won't be stimulated or learn a lot or be engaged all day. It wasn't long ago that pretty much ALL moms were home with their kids and the concept of a day care center was practically foreign and yet we all turned out okay. KWIM??? I am a SAHM and I can tell you that my DD is thriving being at home with me all day. Maybe it's because I am a teacher and have the background and experience but she has LOVED books since she was just a few months old, she holds the books correctly, turns the pages, points as she "reads" aloud, she knows more words than I can count, she is happy, well adjusted, and learning by leaps and bounds every day. So taking that into consideration I do think a nanny can do just as good a job as a center. Also,not all centers are created equal and while some may offer a lot and do a lot with the kids there are many out there that plop your kid down and don't really bother too much with them all day.

I think it comes down to a comfort level. Whether it's a nanny or a center you need to find what you're most comfortable with. There will always be pros and cons to both but it's for you to weigh out and decide what works best for you. Good luck!

Chat Icon

EDIT - I realized reading back that I should have made mention that I realize a parent vs. a nanny can be quite different. Nobody will do for your child what you will do for your child and I know a SAHM with her kids all day is quite different from a nanny with your kids all day. However, depending on a nanny's experience and education I am sure they can provide enough stimulation, learning experiences, and fun as a center. It all depends on who you find. Just wanted to clarify. Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window