Mumps Outbreak

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

mrsej
The cutest!

Member since 1/07

2495 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by LoveBeingMrsT

the orthodox do vaccinate their children and they are ultra religious, i would guess lying isn't something they do (mostly) bc it goes against their beliefs.
and for the most part they don't care what the outside world thinks of them so why lie...



I have no idea about why this is occuring in this community but i am not too sure about the lying thing (work in the court system and have dealt with numerous cases involving orthodox defendants committing grand larceny/fraud).

I agree that since they do tend to isolate themselves, the mumps would spread like wildfire.

Posted 2/12/10 11:55 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

mbg1007
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1247 total posts

Name:

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Just for clarification, there is a HUGE difference between Orthodox Jews and Hassidic Jews. Orhtodox Jews are out in the community, doctors, lawyers, teachers, etc and may send their kids to public school although most do not. They are more observant but for the most part their religious beliefs do not insulate them from the secular world.
Hassidic jews (aka ultra orhtodox jews) DO NOT send their kids to public schools are an extememly self-contained community. They do not want to be part of the outside world for the most part.

Sometimes, "orthodox" is used as a catch-all for all religious jews ( but it shouldnt be bc there are big differences.

However, there is no religious reason in Judaism, orthodox, hassidic or otherwise that would be a basis for not getting vaccinated. So, if they are not getting their kids vaccinated, it is for another reason.

Message edited 2010-02-12 12:02:38.397000.

Posted 2/12/10 11:58 AM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by Goobster

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by greeneyes361708

There is New York State vaccine registry that requires every health care providers that give a child under 18 shots to put them in the system. So it would be impossible to lie about receiving the shot, since the information would be in that registry.




That went into effect in 2008. These kids are between the ages of 10 & 14. Too old to be part of the registry.



Aha. Good point. I love learning new things. Did not know this, so you make a good point.



I didn't know about the registry at all, so I looked it up. I found that it does indeed exist, but only went into effect January 1, 2008.

Posted 2/12/10 12:05 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by mbg1007

Just for clarification, there is a HUGE difference between Orthodox Jews and Hassidic Jews. Orhtodox Jews are out in the community, doctors, lawyers, teachers, etc and may send their kids to public school although most do not. They are more observant but for the most part their religious beliefs do not insulate them from the secular world.
Hassidic jews (aka ultra orhtodox jews) DO NOT send their kids to public schools are an extememly self-contained community. They do not want to be part of the outside world for the most part.

Sometimes, "orthodox" is used as a catch-all for all religious jews ( but it shouldnt be bc there are big differences.

However, there is no religious reason in Judaism, orthodox, hassidic or otherwise that would be a basis for not getting vaccinated. So, if they are not getting their kids vaccinated, it is for another reason.



thank you for sharing this information

But as I posted below...The Hassidics do have programs in the NYC Dept of Ed for their disabled children. Their disabled children, children with down syndrome, etc attend NYC public schools. I worked with them, in Brooklyn, in the heart of their community. They have special classes and programs for their children alone, including Hassidic teachers.

Message edited 2010-02-12 12:25:02.330000.

Posted 2/12/10 12:05 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by stickydust

I agree that if this vaccine were really as ineffective as suggested by this outbreak- then considering the amount of global travel that occurs within NYC alone, we would be seeing massive outbreaks amongst other groups as well (especially school age kids who are in close quarters. The fact that we are not seeing these outbreaks across the board suggests to me that the vaccine is rather effective and that instead there is something amiss in this situation.



This is what i keep coming back to when I think of this situation.

Posted 2/12/10 12:06 PM
 

mrsej
The cutest!

Member since 1/07

2495 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by mbg1007

Just for clarification, there is a HUGE difference between Orthodox Jews and Hassidic Jews. Orhtodox Jews are out in the community, doctors, lawyers, teachers, etc and may send their kids to public school although most do not. They are more observant but for the most part their religious beliefs do not insulate them from the secular world.
Hassidic jews (aka ultra orhtodox jews) DO NOT send their kids to public schools are an extememly self-contained community. They do not want to be part of the outside world for the most part.

Sometimes, "orthodox" is used as a catch-all for all religious jews ( but it shouldnt be bc there are big differences.

However, there is no religious reason in Judaism, orthodox, hassidic or otherwise that would be a basis for not getting vaccinated. So, if they are not getting their kids vaccinated, it is for another reason.



very good point

Posted 2/12/10 12:08 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by mrsej

Posted by LoveBeingMrsT

the orthodox do vaccinate their children and they are ultra religious, i would guess lying isn't something they do (mostly) bc it goes against their beliefs.
and for the most part they don't care what the outside world thinks of them so why lie...



I have no idea about why this is occuring in this community but i am not too sure about the lying thing (work in the court system and have dealt with numerous cases involving orthodox defendants committing grand larceny/fraud).

I agree that since they do tend to isolate themselves, the mumps would spread like wildfire.




I don't agree with the above statement at all. Following religious observations and lying are two seperate entities. Anyone, regardless of religion, is capable of lying. I agree with what mrsej wrote.

Message edited 2010-02-12 12:27:27.530000.

Posted 2/12/10 12:09 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by mbg1007

Hassidic jews (aka ultra orhtodox jews) DO NOT send their kids to public schools are an extememly self-contained community. They do not want to be part of the outside world for the most part.



The Hassidics do have programs in the NYC Dept of Ed for their disabled children. Their disabled children, children with down syndrome, etc attend NYC public schools that have Special Ed settings. I worked with them, in Brooklyn, in the heart of their community. They have special classes and programs for their children alone, no other children with disabilities are included in their classes. They even have Hassidic teachers. So that is the group I refer to when I stated I worked in the NYC schools with them. They are definitely Hassidic, not just Orthodox.

IMO, the bottom line is, we can only wait and see what happens. If the spread comes out of the community, then it's pretty clear the vaccine isn't working that great. If it does not, I will continue to think there is a greater reason it is remaining so self contained within one community. Just b/c they live so isolated, I find it hard to believe that spread would not occur OTHER ways (not from them and their outbreak, but from the main source out of the country).

Message edited 2010-02-12 12:45:55.930000.

Posted 2/12/10 12:11 PM
 

Jazzyt
My Girl!!!

Member since 8/07

2977 total posts

Name:
Giselle

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by Goobster

Posted by Goldi0218

I have my theories about this but they are flame worthy.



I am with you on this.




Totally agreeChat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/12/10 1:06 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Mumps Outbreak

I will NOT beat a dead horse but there are many different types of orthodoxy within the Jewish Community. I grew up with a family business in Williamsburg where the Satmars (SUPER ULTRA orthodox are - think furry round hats, satin coats and short pants). I have been working in Crown Heights for the past 14 years in a Lubavitcher neighborhood right down the block from the headquarters. I also lived in Kew Garden Hills for six years amongst the modern orthodox (yet not Lubavitchers).

There are some cross over practices and there are some that are not. There are different levels of being/keeping kosher. There are different levels of how to handle infertility. There are different levels of everything.

They are very homogeneous and some will not mix outside of their own sect - they all would not consider the religion that I practice as Judaism, however the Lubavitchers had NO problem asking my father for donations to support their Chabad house every Friday as they pressured him to wrap tefillin and pray. I had to ask him to stop giving money - a great deal of their supporters do in fact come from the Reform and Conservative movements of Judaism and I felt that if they don't accept us, then we cannot support them.

There is a large group of chidlren with disabilities within orthodoxy. There is a specific panel of testing for Ashkenazi Jews for a reason. I had it. I often wonder how many orthodox people have those screenings. If they do, I am sure their relgious beliefs would prevent them from terminating a pregnancy UNLESS it would have a life threatening effect on the mother thus preventing her from having MORE children. Having MANY children in Orthodoxy is considered to be a big deal.

There are MANY who DO use religious exemption to get out of vaccinations. there are also many other religions who do not for the same reason as well. However we are talking about basically ONE such community with an outbreak and not the population at large.

Excuse my excessiveness. I am not judging this group. I am not slamming or flaming either. I speak from personal and direct experience.

Posted 2/12/10 1:28 PM
 

mbg1007
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1247 total posts

Name:

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by Goobster

Posted by mbg1007

Hassidic jews (aka ultra orhtodox jews) DO NOT send their kids to public schools are an extememly self-contained community. They do not want to be part of the outside world for the most part.



The Hassidics do have programs in the NYC Dept of Ed for their disabled children. Their disabled children, children with down syndrome, etc attend NYC public schools that have Special Ed settings. I worked with them, in Brooklyn, in the heart of their community. They have special classes and programs for their children alone, no other children with disabilities are included in their classes. They even have Hassidic teachers. So that is the group I refer to when I stated I worked in the NYC schools with them. They are definitely Hassidic, not just Orthodox.

IMO, the bottom line is, we can only wait and see what happens. If the spread comes out of the community, then it's pretty clear the vaccine isn't working that great. If it does not, I will continue to think there is a greater reason it is remaining so self contained within one community. Just b/c they live so isolated, I find it hard to believe that spread would not occur OTHER ways (not from them and their outbreak, but from the main source out of the country).




good point, I was just referring to where they choose to send their kids for the mainstream schooling, not the specialty programs for special needs children

Posted 2/12/10 1:44 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by Goldi0218

I will NOT beat a dead horse but there are many different types of orthodoxy within the Jewish Community. I grew up with a family business in Williamsburg where the Satmars (SUPER ULTRA orthodox are - think furry round hats, satin coats and short pants). I have been working in Crown Heights for the past 14 years in a Lubavitcher neighborhood right down the block from the headquarters. I also lived in Kew Garden Hills for six years amongst the modern orthodox (yet not Lubavitchers).

There are some cross over practices and there are some that are not. There are different levels of being/keeping kosher. There are different levels of how to handle infertility. There are different levels of everything.

They are very homogeneous and some will not mix outside of their own sect - they all would not consider the religion that I practice as Judaism, however the Lubavitchers had NO problem asking my father for donations to support their Chabad house every Friday as they pressured him to wrap tefillin and pray. I had to ask him to stop giving money - a great deal of their supporters do in fact come from the Reform and Conservative movements of Judaism and I felt that if they don't accept us, then we cannot support them.

There is a large group of chidlren with disabilities within orthodoxy. There is a specific panel of testing for Ashkenazi Jews for a reason. I had it. I often wonder how many orthodox people have those screenings. If they do, I am sure their relgious beliefs would prevent them from terminating a pregnancy UNLESS it would have a life threatening effect on the mother thus preventing her from having MORE children. Having MANY children in Orthodoxy is considered to be a big deal.

There are MANY who DO use religious exemption to get out of vaccinations. there are also many other religions who do not for the same reason as well. However we are talking about basically ONE such community with an outbreak and not the population at large.

Excuse my excessiveness. I am not judging this group. I am not slamming or flaming either. I speak from personal and direct experience.



I am glad you posted your experience.

I personally think we ALL have a right to know the truth b/c OUR children are mandated to get this vaccination and ANY doubt of it's effectiveness will only add to the masses of people who are hesitant to get the MMR for their DC. So it is ALL of our rights to know the truth in this senario. So that's where my concern re this topic is coming from. Like you said, not to slam any group but just to get the facts straight re what is reallly going on with the MMR vaccine and it's effectiveness.

I just got it for my 14 mth old and even though I do not regret it, now I am a bit unsure WHAT kind of protection she really has, after reading this senario (senario being they are supposedly vaccinated yet SO many of them are contracting the Mumps). I wonder what my ped would say. Next time I see her i plan on asking her her opinion.

Message edited 2010-02-12 14:00:22.290000.

Posted 2/12/10 1:53 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Here is what I think (I am not a doctor, this is only a theory):

The reason it is so self-contained is because you need multiple, prolonged exposure to the mumps to contract it. The vaccine, even a double dose, may prevent someone who had only casual contact with an infected person from contracting it.

That being said - even a double dose of the vaccine isn't 100% effect, but I bet I know what is... actual infection.

Remember chicken pox parties? Is it possible these parents are hoping to immunize their children that way?

Posted 2/12/10 1:58 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by headoverheels

Here is what I think (I am not a doctor, this is only a theory):

The reason it is so self-contained is because you need multiple, prolonged exposure to the mumps to contract it. The vaccine, even a double dose, may prevent someone who had only casual contact with an infected person from contracting it.

That being said - even a double dose of the vaccine isn't 100% effect, but I bet I know what is... actual infection.

Remember chicken pox parties? Is it possible these parents are hoping to immunize their children that way?



I don't think so (re CP parties). It's a pretty severe illness that can leave males sterile. I really don't think that is what is going on here at all.

From what I read, you really do not need such prolonged exposure. It is transmitted the same way a cold and flu virus are. Very easily.

"Mumps Transmission
The most common mumps transmission method is through coughing or sneezing, which can spread droplets of saliva and mucus infected with the mumps virus. Transmission of the virus also occurs when someone touches an infected surface and then touches the eyes, nose, or mouth. The time period between transmission and the appearance of symptoms is anywhere from 12 to 25 days."

Message edited 2010-02-12 14:16:06.937000.

Posted 2/12/10 2:01 PM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by Goldi0218

I will NOT beat a dead horse but there are many different types of orthodoxy within the Jewish Community. I grew up with a family business in Williamsburg where the Satmars (SUPER ULTRA orthodox are - think furry round hats, satin coats and short pants). I have been working in Crown Heights for the past 14 years in a Lubavitcher neighborhood right down the block from the headquarters. I also lived in Kew Garden Hills for six years amongst the modern orthodox (yet not Lubavitchers).

There are some cross over practices and there are some that are not. There are different levels of being/keeping kosher. There are different levels of how to handle infertility. There are different levels of everything.

They are very homogeneous and some will not mix outside of their own sect - they all would not consider the religion that I practice as Judaism, however the Lubavitchers had NO problem asking my father for donations to support their Chabad house every Friday as they pressured him to wrap tefillin and pray. I had to ask him to stop giving money - a great deal of their supporters do in fact come from the Reform and Conservative movements of Judaism and I felt that if they don't accept us, then we cannot support them.

There is a large group of chidlren with disabilities within orthodoxy. There is a specific panel of testing for Ashkenazi Jews for a reason. I had it. I often wonder how many orthodox people have those screenings. If they do, I am sure their relgious beliefs would prevent them from terminating a pregnancy UNLESS it would have a life threatening effect on the mother thus preventing her from having MORE children. Having MANY children in Orthodoxy is considered to be a big deal.

There are MANY who DO use religious exemption to get out of vaccinations. there are also many other religions who do not for the same reason as well. However we are talking about basically ONE such community with an outbreak and not the population at large.

Excuse my excessiveness. I am not judging this group. I am not slamming or flaming either. I speak from personal and direct experience.



I agree word for word with Leslie. I grew up most of my childhood in Kew Gardens Hills, and not only lived next door to hassidic jews, but also went to an all girls yeshiva where the girls would go...not necessarily hassidic, but ultra ultra orthodox....

Posted 2/12/10 2:20 PM
 

SKPtzu
Oh boys

Member since 6/08

1388 total posts

Name:
SKPtzu

Re: Mumps Outbreak

I just wanted to add another dimension to this discussion...

There is a genetic component to the immune response to a vaccine. It is entirely possible that vaccinated children in this group did not respond well to the vaccine. There have been studies done that show that antibody titers after vaccination vary among different diseases and different ethnic populations.

Unless antibody titers are done on every child, even if you vaccinate your child, it doesn't mean that they are necessarily immune after a vaccine. That is why "herd immunity" is so important. Within such an isolated community, it only really takes 1 person to transmit the disease to every other person who's immunity isn't strong enough.

Posted 2/12/10 3:03 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by SKPtzu

I just wanted to add another dimension to this discussion...

There is a genetic component to the immune response to a vaccine. It is entirely possible that vaccinated children in this group did not respond well to the vaccine. There have been studies done that show that antibody titers after vaccination vary among different diseases and different ethnic populations.

Unless antibody titers are done on every child, even if you vaccinate your child, it doesn't mean that they are necessarily immune after a vaccine. That is why "herd immunity" is so important. Within such an isolated community, it only really takes 1 person to transmit the disease to every other person who's immunity isn't strong enough.



Interesting theory,definitely worth pondering!

Or did these children all recieve vaccinations at the same office, same pediatrician, same batch/lot? This is possible also, in such a tight knit self contained community.

Posted 2/12/10 3:10 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
So, I just want to point out a BIG thing regarding this measles "outbreak".... Mommy2Boys 4/7/08 25 Parenting
There's a fifth disease outbreak at the college I coach at... EckoRed81504 2/8/08 5 Families Helping Families ™
I just called a business in NC and they are closed do to flu outbreak... LIMOMx2 2/7/07 7 Families Helping Families ™
Mumps outbreak in Brooklyn chikita315 10/23/09 2 Parenting
Outbreak of Mumps yankinmanc 8/30/07 12 Parenting
What does everyone think of the Measles outbreak/contamination - ADDED NEWSDAY ARTICLE . UPDATED AGAIN. CALLED THE HEALTH DEPT DeniseMarie 4/8/08 10 Pregnancy