Mumps Outbreak

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Here is another article which specifically identifies the number of kids "known" to have been vaccinated, together with the efficacy rates of the MUMPS portion of the MMR vaccine.

Posted 2/11/10 9:58 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: Mumps Outbreak

This makes me so nervous, I really need to get my DD vaccinated.

Posted 2/11/10 10:00 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

"Even so, "maintenance of high two-dose MMR vaccine coverage remains the most effective way to prevent and limit the size of mumps outbreaks," they added.

Public health officials in one of the New York counties involved in the outbreak began offering a third dose of mumps vaccine to students at certain schools, although no data exist in support of the effectiveness of a third dose for reducing the risk of mumps or altering the course of an outbreak, the authors said."

This is a quote from the above mentioned article.

So I ask then why is this not spreading yet to the general public or has never spread in all the years we are doing MMR vaccinations? Riddle me this. Just like recently we had a little girl here in the area with Measles and other incidents in the past but never such a large outbreak as this current MUMPS one among the Orthodox community?

Posted 2/11/10 10:03 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

And yet another article . . . this is MUCH more specific about the numbers

Posted 2/11/10 10:07 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by Goobster

So I ask then why is this not spreading yet to the general public or has never spread in all the years we are doing MMR vaccinations? Riddle me this. Just like recently we had a little girl here in the area with Measles and other incidents in the past but never such a large outbreak as this current MUMPS one among the Orthodox community?



I think the CDC said it best:

mumps can spread rapidly in congregate settings such as colleges and schools

Posted 2/11/10 10:09 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak




From that article, Transmission Outside the Religious Community

During June 28--October 30, five cases outside the affected religious community were reported. Two cases occurred in New York City, and three occurred in Ocean County, New Jersey. The two New York City patients were a man aged 40 years who had probable worksite exposures to members of the affected community and a boy aged 4 years who had no identified exposure. The three New Jersey cases were patients aged 17, 29, and 66 years who had no identified exposures. Two of the five patients had received 2 documented doses of mumps-containing vaccine, one had received 2 undocumented doses, and two had unknown vaccination status.



Not argueing with you, just also trying to figure out the true likeliness of children getting vaccinated among that community, b/c this would spread like wildfire, outside of the community, if the number of people vaccinated truly was the amt they state in this article (who still came down with it).

Posted 2/11/10 10:10 PM
 

sal79
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

1464 total posts

Name:

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by Goobster

So I ask then why is this not spreading yet to the general public or has never spread in all the years we are doing MMR vaccinations? Riddle me this. Just like recently we had a little girl here in the area with Measles and other incidents in the past but never such a large outbreak as this current MUMPS one among the Orthodox community?



I think the CDC said it best:

mumps can spread rapidly in congregate settings such as colleges and schools





it is not spreading outside their community since the have minimal contact with people outside their community.
it is spreading rapidly within the community because of close quarters- young adult/tenn boys- who are mostly affected- spend the majority of their day- can be from 7 am-6p in yeshivah with other boys

Posted 2/11/10 10:11 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by Goobster

So I ask then why is this not spreading yet to the general public or has never spread in all the years we are doing MMR vaccinations? Riddle me this. Just like recently we had a little girl here in the area with Measles and other incidents in the past but never such a large outbreak as this current MUMPS one among the Orthodox community?



I think the CDC said it best:

mumps can spread rapidly in congregate settings such as colleges and schools




Right but don't you think that the amt of people who travel outside of the country, who also go to schools, colleges, work, etc that we would see disease spreading not just in the Orthodox community? KWIM? Again, just trying to make sense of it all, not argueing, hope you know that.Chat Icon

Personally I question the amt of children vaccinated in this senario, despite what is being projected as vaccination rate amg ill children. Just doesn't make sense why this disease would not be spreading out to ALL communities, schools, etc if the vaccine was that weak re Mumps.

Either way, my DD was vaccinated 2 weeks ago and I am glad I did it, no matter what personally. I just don't buy these numbers and I am one who always questions vaccines and their necessity.Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-03-25 22:39:34.013000.

Posted 2/11/10 10:12 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by Goobster




From that article, Transmission Outside the Religious Community

During June 28--October 30, five cases outside the affected religious community were reported. Two cases occurred in New York City, and three occurred in Ocean County, New Jersey. The two New York City patients were a man aged 40 years who had probable worksite exposures to members of the affected community and a boy aged 4 years who had no identified exposure. The three New Jersey cases were patients aged 17, 29, and 66 years who had no identified exposures. Two of the five patients had received 2 documented doses of mumps-containing vaccine, one had received 2 undocumented doses, and two had unknown vaccination status.



Not argueing with you, just also trying to figure out the true likeliness of children getting vaccinated among that community, b/c this would spread like wildfire, outside of the community, if the number of people vaccinated truly was the amt they state in this article (who still came down with it).



I'm not saying the parents didn't lie about the vaccination status of their child. However, I do believe that if there is rapid spreading under certain circumstances (which are stated to be present in this case) AND the vaccine is not 100% effective, the two things combined created the high infection rate (which looking at the camp numbers, isn't so high as a percentage of the whole).

Posted 2/11/10 10:15 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by Goobster

Again, just trying to make sense of it all, not argueing, hope you know that.Chat Icon



Didn't take it as arguing at all. I'm actually happy that there is a discussion not a debate going on.

Posted 2/11/10 10:20 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by sal79

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by Goobster

So I ask then why is this not spreading yet to the general public or has never spread in all the years we are doing MMR vaccinations? Riddle me this. Just like recently we had a little girl here in the area with Measles and other incidents in the past but never such a large outbreak as this current MUMPS one among the Orthodox community?



I think the CDC said it best:

mumps can spread rapidly in congregate settings such as colleges and schools





it is not spreading outside their community since the have minimal contact with people outside their community.
it is spreading rapidly within the community because of close quarters- young adult/tenn boys- who are mostly affected- spend the majority of their day- can be from 7 am-6p in yeshivah with other boys



Well this surely may be a factor. But if the vaccine was THAT weak (based on these numbers stated in the article) then that means the general public also has such weak immunities and there must be other people who have travelled and came into contact with the Mumps, who also work and live in close quarters with others who have this "weak" vaccine. So why not the spread among other communities, groups, public, from their own travels, etc? Something just doesn't add up here.

Posted 2/11/10 10:21 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by Goobster

Again, just trying to make sense of it all, not argueing, hope you know that.Chat Icon



Didn't take it as arguing at all. I'm actually happy that there is a discussion not a debate going on.



Glad you understand, you know how boards are~!!

Message edited 2010-02-12 11:05:38.357000.

Posted 2/11/10 10:23 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by Goobster

Posted by sal79




it is not spreading outside their community since the have minimal contact with people outside their community.
it is spreading rapidly within the community because of close quarters- young adult/tenn boys- who are mostly affected- spend the majority of their day- can be from 7 am-6p in yeshivah with other boys



Well this surely may be a factor. But if the vaccine was THAT weak (based on these numbers stated in the article) then that means the general public also has such weak immunities and there must be other people who have travelled and came into contact with the Mumps, who also work and live in close quarters with others who have this "weak" vaccine. So why not the spread among other communities, groups, public, from their own travels, etc? Something just doesn't add up here.

You're right something doesn't add up, but what?? If we look at it and say, those vaccination numbers just CAN'T be right, the parents must by lying, then why didn't more kids at the camp get the mumps? IF this is a religious based objection, then the non-vaccination numbers would be higher, right? Wouldn't the infection rate then be higher as well?

Posted 2/11/10 10:24 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by Goobster

Posted by sal79




it is not spreading outside their community since the have minimal contact with people outside their community.
it is spreading rapidly within the community because of close quarters- young adult/tenn boys- who are mostly affected- spend the majority of their day- can be from 7 am-6p in yeshivah with other boys



Well this surely may be a factor. But if the vaccine was THAT weak (based on these numbers stated in the article) then that means the general public also has such weak immunities and there must be other people who have travelled and came into contact with the Mumps, who also work and live in close quarters with others who have this "weak" vaccine. So why not the spread among other communities, groups, public, from their own travels, etc? Something just doesn't add up here.



You're right something doesn't add up, but what?? If we look at it and say, those vaccination numbers just CAN'T be right, the parents must by lying, then why didn't more kids at the camp get the mumps? IF this is a religious based objection, then the non-vaccination numbers would be higher, right? Wouldn't the infection rate then be higher as well?

Well like any disease, sometimes some people have immunity, just like some never get CP despite being with siblings with CP, etc. Also maybe SOME are vaccinated but others are not? Maybe some have previously had a mild case and are immune (not sure, does one become immune after a bout of the MUMPS, I think so). Maybe it's a lack of reporting and it is spreading as we speak, etc. It's much more serious for boys than girls so maybe that is being underreported as well.

Posted 2/11/10 10:27 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by Deedlebugs

This makes me so nervous, I really need to get my DD vaccinated.



I know how scary it is but with the recent case of Measles in GC, I brought my 14 mth old in. I was scared as anything but 2 weeks tomorrow and so far so good. I am glad, very glad, I did it and got it over with. Hope it works.Chat Icon

Posted 2/11/10 10:32 PM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by Goobster

I have to say this...don't flame me but I would like to know how correct is the statement that the children were truly vaccinated, esp in this particular community? They often have strong religious beliefs and I don't know where they stand on vaccinations. Yet I don't know if this would "come out" b/c they are a very private, self contained community. I worked with the community years ago so I have some basis of where my thoughts come from.

I truly find this data questionable. JMO



There is New York State vaccine registry that requires every health care providers that give a child under 18 shots to put them in the system. So it would be impossible to lie about receiving the shot, since the information would be in that registry.

Posted 2/12/10 8:20 AM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Mumps Outbreak

First of all, the orthodox vaccinate their children!!! I work with someone who grew up in Woodmere/Lawrence in an orthodox home and attended a Yeshiva school. He was vaccinated according to schedule as a child, so are his nieces and nephews. They do not claim religious exemption from vaccinations based on religion.

Second, IMO it is impossible for the numbers to be wrong because doctors have to report vaccinations given. That is how the numbers are recorded. Given the number of cases in the past few months, I think 1,500...I would look into the vaccine batches that were administered. Maybe they were all given the same batch(es) of vaccines and there was a problem with those vaccines. That is really the only explanation possible with 88% of cases receiving at least the 1st dose of the MMR vaccine. Although many people don't realize that even when you are vaccinated you are not always given 100% immunity. Most cases it is only 90%. But that still wouldnt explain the large number of cases.

Last, mumps may go undiagnosed very easily because it may appear as just a normal viral/bacterial infection with fever, sore throat and swollen glands. People get sick regularly with those symptoms and many dr's dont normally think about mumps.

Message edited 2010-02-12 10:32:22.123000.

Posted 2/12/10 10:30 AM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by sal79

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by Goobster

So I ask then why is this not spreading yet to the general public or has never spread in all the years we are doing MMR vaccinations? Riddle me this. Just like recently we had a little girl here in the area with Measles and other incidents in the past but never such a large outbreak as this current MUMPS one among the Orthodox community?



I think the CDC said it best:

mumps can spread rapidly in congregate settings such as colleges and schools





it is not spreading outside their community since the have minimal contact with people outside their community.
it is spreading rapidly within the community because of close quarters- young adult/tenn boys- who are mostly affected- spend the majority of their day- can be from 7 am-6p in yeshivah with other boys



ITA!!! The orthodox do not claim religious exemption against vaccinating BUT they tend to stay within their community and have little contact with people outside their community.

Posted 2/12/10 10:34 AM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by ruby

Posted by KateDevine

You are right that this is a very self contained community and I totally see what you are saying. (Like what I said above..)

This is an honest question, do these kids go to NYC schools? There they would have to have proof of vaccinations?



I'm pretty sure the outbreak was in Monsey which is in Rockland, I grew up in Rockland County. They go to their own Yeshivas in Monsey and New Square and are subject to their own rules and regulations.



There is a huge outbreak there - I'm in Rockland and it was reported earlier this week there were over 300 reported cases.

Posted 2/12/10 10:59 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by jellybean1420
I would look into the vaccine batches that were administered. Maybe they were all given the same batch(es) of vaccines and there was a problem with those vaccines. That is really the only explanation possible with 88% of cases receiving at least the 1st dose of the MMR vaccine.



Hmm...I guess we would need to know the ages of the children. What are the odds this is all the same batch?

Posted 2/12/10 11:02 AM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by greeneyes361708

There is New York State vaccine registry that requires every health care providers that give a child under 18 shots to put them in the system. So it would be impossible to lie about receiving the shot, since the information would be in that registry.




That went into effect in 2008. These kids are between the ages of 10 & 14. Too old to be part of the registry.

Posted 2/12/10 11:06 AM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by greeneyes361708

There is New York State vaccine registry that requires every health care providers that give a child under 18 shots to put them in the system. So it would be impossible to lie about receiving the shot, since the information would be in that registry.




That went into effect in 2008. These kids are between the ages of 10 & 14. Too old to be part of the registry.



Aha. Good point. I love learning new things. Did not know this, so you make a good point.

Posted 2/12/10 11:07 AM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Mumps Outbreak

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by greeneyes361708

There is New York State vaccine registry that requires every health care providers that give a child under 18 shots to put them in the system. So it would be impossible to lie about receiving the shot, since the information would be in that registry.




That went into effect in 2008. These kids are between the ages of 10 & 14. Too old to be part of the registry.




If they are between the ages of 10 & 14, they should have received their 2nd shot around 5. This is even more disconcerning that most probably received 2 vaccines and still contracted mumps.

Posted 2/12/10 11:13 AM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Mumps Outbreak

I agree that if this vaccine were really as ineffective as suggested by this outbreak- then considering the amount of global travel that occurs within NYC alone, we would be seeing massive outbreaks amongst other groups as well (especially school age kids who are in close quarters. The fact that we are not seeing these outbreaks across the board suggests to me that the vaccine is rather effective and that instead there is something amiss in this situation.

Posted 2/12/10 11:33 AM
 

LoveBeingMrsT
Love my Boys!

Member since 12/05

4648 total posts

Name:

Re: Mumps Outbreak

the orthodox do vaccinate their children and they are ultra religious, i would guess lying isn't something they do (mostly) bc it goes against their beliefs.
and for the most part they don't care what the outside world thinks of them so why lie...

Message edited 2010-02-12 11:43:00.467000.

Posted 2/12/10 11:42 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
So, I just want to point out a BIG thing regarding this measles "outbreak".... Mommy2Boys 4/7/08 25 Parenting
There's a fifth disease outbreak at the college I coach at... EckoRed81504 2/8/08 5 Families Helping Families ™
I just called a business in NC and they are closed do to flu outbreak... LIMOMx2 2/7/07 7 Families Helping Families ™
Mumps outbreak in Brooklyn chikita315 10/23/09 2 Parenting
Outbreak of Mumps yankinmanc 8/30/07 12 Parenting
What does everyone think of the Measles outbreak/contamination - ADDED NEWSDAY ARTICLE . UPDATED AGAIN. CALLED THE HEALTH DEPT DeniseMarie 4/8/08 10 Pregnancy