MIL issues

Posted By Message
Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6

Sweets13
Bella Bambini

Member since 5/05

9300 total posts

Name:

Re: MIL issues

Posted by MikesWife

Posted by Sweets13

I come from a VERY close family and we spend LOTS of time together. My kids also spends LOTS of time ALONE with their grandparents and I am a FTWM. I spent A LOT of time with my grandparents and have so many great memories! I see NO problem with leaving my kids for a few hours alone with my parents and inlaws. You wouldn't bellieve the bond my kids have their grandparents. Actually, my parents and inlaws are envied by other grandparents because of the "freedom" they have with the grandkids. IMO, there is too much "ownership" going on. YES, your kids are YOUR kids but they are also YOUR parents and YOUR Dh's parents grandkids. Maybe I am wrong for thinking this but grandchildren bring back memories of when WE were kids and that has to be so warming for grandparents. We see how fast out kids grow up. So many things my DS does reminds my MIL of when my DH was younger. She will just sit and stare at my son play and I can see the tears in her eyes. It brings them back. Are they so wrong for enjoying it?

I am rambling...but unless a grandparent does something to HARM your child they should not be bashed for wanting to spend time with them....alone. It's a different visit when we are there with them.

ETA: I see a lot people stating that they would not give up any alone wtht with DC just so they can spend it with the grandparents. IMO, 2 hours away is not going to kill you. 2 hours spent with grandparents is MEMORIES.



But she is not saying that the grandparents can't spend time with her daughter and make memories. They are saying that she isn't allowed to be there to make those memories. IMO that's hurtful and in the end will cause nothing but resentment.



EVERYTIME??? They dont want Tilde there EVER?

Posted 11/12/10 2:16 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

2PreciousBlessings
The Perfect Pair

Member since 5/06

19861 total posts

Name:
Best Wife & Mommy

Re: MIL issues

Posted by MikesWife

Posted by Sweets13

I come from a VERY close family and we spend LOTS of time together. My kids also spends LOTS of time ALONE with their grandparents and I am a FTWM. I spent A LOT of time with my grandparents and have so many great memories! I see NO problem with leaving my kids for a few hours alone with my parents and inlaws. You wouldn't bellieve the bond my kids have their grandparents. Actually, my parents and inlaws are envied by other grandparents because of the "freedom" they have with the grandkids. IMO, there is too much "ownership" going on. YES, your kids are YOUR kids but they are also YOUR parents and YOUR Dh's parents grandkids. Maybe I am wrong for thinking this but grandchildren bring back memories of when WE were kids and that has to be so warming for grandparents. We see how fast out kids grow up. So many things my DS does reminds my MIL of when my DH was younger. She will just sit and stare at my son play and I can see the tears in her eyes. It brings them back. Are they so wrong for enjoying it?

I am rambling...but unless a grandparent does something to HARM your child they should not be bashed for wanting to spend time with them....alone. It's a different visit when we are there with them.

ETA: I see a lot people stating that they would not give up any alone wtht with DC just so they can spend it with the grandparents. IMO, 2 hours away is not going to kill you. 2 hours spent with grandparents is MEMORIES.



But she is not saying that the grandparents can't spend time with her daughter and make memories. They are saying that she isn't allowed to be there to make those memories. IMO that's hurtful and in the end will cause nothing but resentment.



I am one of those posters that said I do not think it is necessary for her to be there when her DD is spending with her grandmother. It is not like I was saying that she is not allowed. Also, I am sure there will be resentment on both sides if compromises cannot be made.

Message edited 2010-11-12 14:18:14.787000.

Posted 11/12/10 2:17 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: MIL issues

Posted by Sweets13

Posted by MikesWife

Posted by Sweets13

I come from a VERY close family and we spend LOTS of time together. My kids also spends LOTS of time ALONE with their grandparents and I am a FTWM. I spent A LOT of time with my grandparents and have so many great memories! I see NO problem with leaving my kids for a few hours alone with my parents and inlaws. You wouldn't bellieve the bond my kids have their grandparents. Actually, my parents and inlaws are envied by other grandparents because of the "freedom" they have with the grandkids. IMO, there is too much "ownership" going on. YES, your kids are YOUR kids but they are also YOUR parents and YOUR Dh's parents grandkids. Maybe I am wrong for thinking this but grandchildren bring back memories of when WE were kids and that has to be so warming for grandparents. We see how fast out kids grow up. So many things my DS does reminds my MIL of when my DH was younger. She will just sit and stare at my son play and I can see the tears in her eyes. It brings them back. Are they so wrong for enjoying it?

I am rambling...but unless a grandparent does something to HARM your child they should not be bashed for wanting to spend time with them....alone. It's a different visit when we are there with them.

ETA: I see a lot people stating that they would not give up any alone wtht with DC just so they can spend it with the grandparents. IMO, 2 hours away is not going to kill you. 2 hours spent with grandparents is MEMORIES.



But she is not saying that the grandparents can't spend time with her daughter and make memories. They are saying that she isn't allowed to be there to make those memories. IMO that's hurtful and in the end will cause nothing but resentment.



EVERYTIME??? They dont want Tilde there EVER?



I don't even think it's the MIL who is saying this - it's the husband (and Tilde can correct me if I'm wrong)

He wants the mother to have alone time with the baby, which is fine - but it doesn't have to be every time ---- it is not a competition between Grandmothers.

Posted 11/12/10 2:18 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: MIL issues

I think we need to give Tilde a break her.

it's her FIRST few days back to work.

let her worry about someone else's feelings next month.

we all know how hard those first days are (working moms!!)

Posted 11/12/10 2:19 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: MIL issues

Posted by Diana1215

[I don't even think it's the MIL who is saying this - it's the husband (and Tilde can correct me if I'm wrong)

He wants the mother to have alone time with the baby, which is fine - but it doesn't have to be every time ---- it is not a competition between Grandmothers.



exactly. I think this is more of an issue for her dh than for anyone else.

I am sure grandma II is just fine with seeing her granddaughter with momma present.

Posted 11/12/10 2:20 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: MIL issues

Posted by Diana1215

ETA: If the MIL wants to watch my two boys I can be there in an hour. For real Chat Icon



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Chat Icon

Posted 11/12/10 2:21 PM
 

cinnabon
Complete..

Member since 6/10

1592 total posts

Name:
B

Re: MIL issues

Posted by labonnevie

eh- i'm on your side. if i worked all day and came home i would not want to sacrifice my time so MIL can spend time with her. i'm not sure why others are saying you're depriving MIL of her time. i think that's a little ridiculous.

perhaps your DH can drop your DD off with MIL 1x a week for a few hours while you work so he can run errands. but i would NOT sacrifice my time for her, i wouldn't do it for my own mom! mommy time is mommy time!



I agree also, I don't see the dif if ur there, or not there.

Posted 11/12/10 2:22 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: MIL issues

Posted by GaryElla

Posted by MikesWife

Posted by Sweets13

I come from a VERY close family and we spend LOTS of time together. My kids also spends LOTS of time ALONE with their grandparents and I am a FTWM. I spent A LOT of time with my grandparents and have so many great memories! I see NO problem with leaving my kids for a few hours alone with my parents and inlaws. You wouldn't bellieve the bond my kids have their grandparents. Actually, my parents and inlaws are envied by other grandparents because of the "freedom" they have with the grandkids. IMO, there is too much "ownership" going on. YES, your kids are YOUR kids but they are also YOUR parents and YOUR Dh's parents grandkids. Maybe I am wrong for thinking this but grandchildren bring back memories of when WE were kids and that has to be so warming for grandparents. We see how fast out kids grow up. So many things my DS does reminds my MIL of when my DH was younger. She will just sit and stare at my son play and I can see the tears in her eyes. It brings them back. Are they so wrong for enjoying it?

I am rambling...but unless a grandparent does something to HARM your child they should not be bashed for wanting to spend time with them....alone. It's a different visit when we are there with them.

ETA: I see a lot people stating that they would not give up any alone wtht with DC just so they can spend it with the grandparents. IMO, 2 hours away is not going to kill you. 2 hours spent with grandparents is MEMORIES.



But she is not saying that the grandparents can't spend time with her daughter and make memories. They are saying that she isn't allowed to be there to make those memories. IMO that's hurtful and in the end will cause nothing but resentment.



I am one of those posters that said I do not think it is necessary for her to be there when her DD is spending with her grandmother. It is not like I was saying that she is not allowed. Also, I am sure there will be resentment on both sides if compromises cannot be made.



We will definitely come to a compromise about this. This thread has helped me to see DH's side of it - I have to get over my own sadness of leaving DD and in time I will.

But DH has to give me some time. I can't cry every day over going to work and then cry on the weekends leaving her at my ILs. It is just too much right now.

Thank you everyone for your opinions Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/12/10 2:23 PM
 

MikesWife
Wanting...........

Member since 1/06

6887 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: MIL issues

I will add that as your kids get older, you get more "comfortable" with leaving them in addition to your normal work week. I, myself, have made great progress in this area in the past year. DD is now 17.5 months and I find it easier to leave her to go out on dates, weddings, hair appts. I think that as your kid communicates with you, it gets easier. At least for me it did.

There is something to be said for the smile and excitement of "mommy" when you get home that makes it ok. Like she hasn't forgotten you.

When they are little you wonder more and question more........

Posted 11/12/10 2:27 PM
 

Sweets13
Bella Bambini

Member since 5/05

9300 total posts

Name:

Re: MIL issues

Posted by Tilde

Posted by GaryElla

Posted by MikesWife

Posted by Sweets13

I come from a VERY close family and we spend LOTS of time together. My kids also spends LOTS of time ALONE with their grandparents and I am a FTWM. I spent A LOT of time with my grandparents and have so many great memories! I see NO problem with leaving my kids for a few hours alone with my parents and inlaws. You wouldn't bellieve the bond my kids have their grandparents. Actually, my parents and inlaws are envied by other grandparents because of the "freedom" they have with the grandkids. IMO, there is too much "ownership" going on. YES, your kids are YOUR kids but they are also YOUR parents and YOUR Dh's parents grandkids. Maybe I am wrong for thinking this but grandchildren bring back memories of when WE were kids and that has to be so warming for grandparents. We see how fast out kids grow up. So many things my DS does reminds my MIL of when my DH was younger. She will just sit and stare at my son play and I can see the tears in her eyes. It brings them back. Are they so wrong for enjoying it?

I am rambling...but unless a grandparent does something to HARM your child they should not be bashed for wanting to spend time with them....alone. It's a different visit when we are there with them.

ETA: I see a lot people stating that they would not give up any alone wtht with DC just so they can spend it with the grandparents. IMO, 2 hours away is not going to kill you. 2 hours spent with grandparents is MEMORIES.



But she is not saying that the grandparents can't spend time with her daughter and make memories. They are saying that she isn't allowed to be there to make those memories. IMO that's hurtful and in the end will cause nothing but resentment.



I am one of those posters that said I do not think it is necessary for her to be there when her DD is spending with her grandmother. It is not like I was saying that she is not allowed. Also, I am sure there will be resentment on both sides if compromises cannot be made.



We will definitely come to a compromise about this. This thread has helped me to see DH's side of it - I have to get over my own sadness of leaving DD and in time I will.

But DH has to give me some time. I can't cry every day over going to work and then cry on the weekends leaving her at my ILs. It is just too much right now.

Thank you everyone for your opinions Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I was commenting more of "in time" rather than "right now". I agree that "right now" may be too emotional for you to leave DD just for the sake of your MIL having alone time. The guilt will NEVER go away but it definitely gets easier. Chat Icon

Posted 11/12/10 2:28 PM
 

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: MIL issues

Posted by MikesWife

Posted by Lucky09

I'm on your side. When I'm not at work I want to be with my kids. End of story.



ITA! So you should be forced to go out and DO something just because MIL wants "alone" time with the baby? Nah, I don't think so.
I would feel the same way. I'm not going to just walk out of spending quality time with MY kid so that someone else can.

I totally get that it's not a trust issue and if you needed her to watch the baby and she was available you would. But to force the issue? I don't see a reason for it.



Agree 10000000%

It *might* be different if you weren't willing to bring her there at all. But you are.Chat Icon You shouldn't be forced into occupying yourself so they have alone time.

TOTALLY with you here.

Posted 11/12/10 2:29 PM
 

Serendipity
Summer!

Member since 4/07

7631 total posts

Name:
PrayingWishingHopingALOT

Re: MIL issues

I am sooo confusedChat Icon

Well Whatever..Tilde hope it works outwhere you are ok with whatever happens!

Good Luck

Posted 11/12/10 2:32 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: MIL issues

I don't mean this to sound mean but what is the difference between your mom being alone with her versus his mom?

You trust her but you won't give her alone time?

My father wanted alone time with my kiddo and I didn't get it at first. But now I do. Its those quiet moments, watching her every twitch, the way she slept as a newborn Chat Icon the way her facial expressions were, the farty smiles even. Its not the same at 1 or 2yrs old. Those first few months are special.

I think if your Mom can have those moments, why can't his?

But... then again.. I totally get the possessive mommy syndrome too! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-11-12 14:47:49.070000.

Posted 11/12/10 2:42 PM
 

Superkat
More a stranger than a friend

Member since 5/06

9730 total posts

Name:
K

Re: MIL issues

Posted by Ophelia

I think we need to give Tilde a break her.

it's her FIRST few days back to work.

let her worry about someone else's feelings next month.

we all know how hard those first days are (working moms!!)




Agreed! Once you are back to work, it is very tough to "let go" of your child until the mommy guilt is under control.

Posted 11/12/10 2:50 PM
 

Jazzyt
My Girl!!!

Member since 8/07

2977 total posts

Name:
Giselle

Re: MIL issues

I am a full time working mom. Every Saturday night starting at about 6 weeks old my mom babysat my daughter at her house. At first I was reluctant as for the most part weekends is all I had with DD but its not for DD its for her grandmother. So now Saturday nights I know I have babysitiing DH and I either go out or have some together time or go out with our respective friends and on Sundays we clean its has done wonders for our relationship as we realize time alone time is very rare. Now DD is 2.4 and she looks forward to hanging with her Grandma and Papa and asks to go when we don't take her (like if we're going out with her or something) she always asks for grandmaChat Icon ....I said all this to say they have formulated a bond.

Posted 11/12/10 2:56 PM
 

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: MIL issues

After I responded I realized how late I came in on this and read the other responses.

I am glad the tide has turned and more people seem to be in agreement with Tilde.

She maintains she's willing to have MIL spend time with her. She says she brings her there once a week (I believe.) That's way more than my in laws see my DS and they don't live all that far. That's MORE than cooperative.

She JUST went back to work, for Pete's sake. She should NOT be having to deal with pressure from her DH to get his mother alone time with her kid.Chat Icon

Tilde, tell your husband to stuff it.

Posted 11/12/10 2:58 PM
 

piggy007
Mommy of 2!!

Member since 11/08

1742 total posts

Name:

Re: MIL issues

Posted by cinnabon

Posted by labonnevie

eh- i'm on your side. if i worked all day and came home i would not want to sacrifice my time so MIL can spend time with her. i'm not sure why others are saying you're depriving MIL of her time. i think that's a little ridiculous.

perhaps your DH can drop your DD off with MIL 1x a week for a few hours while you work so he can run errands. but i would NOT sacrifice my time for her, i wouldn't do it for my own mom! mommy time is mommy time!



I agree also, I don't see the dif if ur there, or not there.



I couldn't agree more.

Posted 11/12/10 3:16 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: MIL issues

Posted by Xelindrya

I don't mean this to sound mean but what is the difference between your mom being alone with her versus his mom?

You trust her but you won't give her alone time?

My father wanted alone time with my kiddo and I didn't get it at first. But now I do. Its those quiet moments, watching her every twitch, the way she slept as a newborn Chat Icon the way her facial expressions were, the farty smiles even. Its not the same at 1 or 2yrs old. Those first few months are special.

I think if your Mom can have those moments, why can't his?

But... then again.. I totally get the possessive mommy syndrome too! Chat Icon Chat Icon



Tilde's mom watches her LO because she has to go to work. Her MIL feels that she should get all this alone time I'm guessing because she doesn't think it's fair that her mom gets so much time with the baby BUT................Tilde has to be away from her DD enough throughout the week that to *expect* her to just drop off her DD with her MIL for hours every weekend I think is unreasonable and selfish. I get where the MIL is coming from but it's not her kid so she doesn't have a right to demand "X" amount of time nor does she have the right to demand it's alone time. Tilde's time with her DD is precious, it goes so fast, and as a working mom every minute you get with your children is valuable and I can see where you wouldn't want to share that.............especially this early on. Things may change down the road as her DD gets older but right now if Tilde wants to be with her DD when she sees her Grandma then so be it and honestly, the MIL (or her DH for that matter) has NO right to get upset. She has NO right to demand that Tilde share her DD every single weekend. If my DH tried to pull this cr@p I would've laughed in his face to be honest. I don't owe his mom anything..............it's my child and while I of course want my DD to have a relationship with her family nobody but me is going to set those parameters for time together. I'm the mom and I'm sorry, it's my needs and wants before anyone else's when it comes to my child.

Posted 11/12/10 3:17 PM
 

MamaLeen
:)

Member since 10/09

4594 total posts

Name:
E

Re: MIL issues

Posted by Hofstra26

Tilde's mom watches her LO because she has to go to work. Her MIL feels that she should get all this alone time I'm guessing because she doesn't think it's fair that her mom gets so much time with the baby BUT................Tilde has to be away from her DD enough throughout the week that to *expect* her to just drop off her DD with her MIL for hours every weekend I think is unreasonable and selfish. I get where the MIL is coming from but it's not her kid so she doesn't have a right to demand "X" amount of time nor does she have the right to demand it's alone time. Tilde's time with her DD is precious, it goes so fast, and as a working mom every minute you get with your children is valuable and I can see where you wouldn't want to share that.............especially this early on. Things may change down the road as her DD gets older but right now if Tilde wants to be with her DD when she sees her Grandma then so be it and honestly, the MIL (or her DH for that matter) has NO right to get upset. She has NO right to demand that Tilde share her DD every single weekend. If my DH tried to pull this cr@p I would've laughed in his face to be honest. I don't owe his mom anything..............it's my child and while I of course want my DD to have a relationship with her family nobody but me is going to set those parameters for time together. I'm the mom and I'm sorry, it's my needs and wants before anyone else's when it comes to my child.




ITA. Chat Icon

Good luck Tilde! IMO right now you have to adjust to your work schedule and put this on the back burner...hopefully everything will iron itself out in the end.

My DS is 6 months and still I hate to be away for even a couple of hours so I completely understand. Chat Icon

Posted 11/12/10 3:24 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: MIL issues

Did this discussion only start once you went back to work? It seems like this is really just jealousy over your mom spending more time with DD than your MIL. I didn't go back to work until my DS was 11 months and I will say those first few months, I did not want to leave him with anyone on the weekends for the same reason you are stating. I missed him so much during the week that I wanted to spend the little time I did have with him on the weekends.

I will add, however, that now that my DS is almost 3, I think back about how incredibly fast those early days went and how I wish I hadn't been so nervous and could have enjoyed it more. I think if we, as moms, think that first year flies by, think how fast it must go by for grandparents. Take the time you need, but I think it would be wonderful for your DD to spend time with MIL alone if you can bear it.

Posted 11/12/10 3:30 PM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: MIL issues

Posted by JennB

I totally understand what you are saying.

Because you are back to work you have limited time with DD. So you want to spend whatever time you do have with her - even when she goes to visit grandma. I know how you feelChat Icon

You should take advantage of it though - go on date nights once a week or every other week so everyone is happy!



ITA! Chat Icon

Posted 11/12/10 3:38 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: MIL issues

a 5+ pager from Tilde?

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/12/10 3:57 PM
 

Nik211
my little monkey<3

Member since 5/08

3303 total posts

Name:
Nik

Re: MIL issues

i'm crashing - not a parent yet - so i have no real experience with this BUT if i just started working full time after my baby was born i'd want to spend my "off" time with my child - i wouldn't want to drop them off at my mother's house or mother-in-law's house or anyone's house....

i think your MIL should be more understanding - you don't really want to work but you do it and you want to spend the time when you get home with your LO. what is wrong with a mother wanting to bond with their child?

right now you are feeling like your time is limited with her and that is understandable b/c you just started working again Chat Icon i wouldn't worry about my MIL if i were you....i'd worry about ME...if you bring her there once a week i think that is fine (and you shouldn't have to leave!)...

your MIL might feel left out b/c your mom watches the baby - but if your MIL was able to babysit during the week i am sure they would share the babysitting - but if it can't be done it can't be done and that doesn't mean you should have to take away from "your" time with your child...

i think in a few months when you get back into the swing of things you may want to bring your DD to MIL's once in awhile during the week (alone) but if you aren't ready i don't see why you have to do that...as long as you allow MIL to come over your house during the week if she wants and you are bringing DD there once a week i don't see an issue.

maybe she can be the go to babysitter when you guys go out on dates? so she feels more involved?

Message edited 2010-11-12 16:13:23.233000.

Posted 11/12/10 4:12 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: MIL issues

I don't have time to read through all the posts but I agree with you 100%. It might be different if you were a SAHM but you are away from your DD more than you would like as it is. You don't need to drop her off at MIL's just to keep her happy. She's your baby and you miss her. End of discussion.

Posted 11/12/10 4:17 PM
 

megsm3
Life is Good!!

Member since 8/06

3867 total posts

Name:
M

Re: MIL issues

If there was a need for you to have a babysitting then I would definitely ask her. But to just drop her there so she can have alone time is absurd in my opinion. I also work FT and I hate doing anything that has them being watched when I could be with them. She can bond while you visit, which I think is awesome that you do that weekly!

Posted 11/12/10 4:26 PM
 
Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
childcare issues - my MIL quit! help... artjunkie 10/5/07 11 Parenting
MIL issues saraH 4/17/07 31 Pregnancy
MIL issues PrincessP 1/27/07 3 Families Helping Families ™
For ALL My Girls Who Have MIL Issues LadyMaravilla 8/1/06 37 Families Helping Families ™