Re: Madoff investers....
Posted 3/16/2009 4:18:09 PM by Ophelia
Posted by Ali1
While I feel truly sorry for these people and think Madoff should Rot for a long time I do take issue with something I read in Newsday this weekend and others have alluded to on this thread.
One couple lost what they claimed to be 1 million and that was what they are going to fight for, but their original investment was $10,000. I don't recall how many years there were investing but I have to assume a long time.
They stated they believe the government should recoup them for the $1 million and not just 10K. I have an issue with that. They should get their money back from the IRS for the gains they might have claimed and the original 10K, but not the other 990,000. Sorry.....you trusted one man to invest all your money. You clearly didn't research him too much because there were many people outspoken on the fact that this man was not on the up and up. Plus those "gains" are fabricated. Someone else who invested the same amount, probably didn't have constant 10% gains like Madoff was claiming these people had.
I feel it's like me asking the government to recoup my investments that i have lost in the past few months. If you invest (or even turn money over to someone to invest) in the stock market you are taking on risk. You can't expect the government to compensate you for what was an error in judgement by you.
So while I feel incredibly sad for these people and hope they can get back some of their money, I do believe their are some being a little greedy about what the government should recoup to them.
JMO...
I agree with this.
I can't (and won't comment) on anything about the case, however, there is no way people should be recouped for the total amount they believed they gained on the investment.
if ANYTHING, and average rate of return over similar funds for the duration of the scam should be calculated, and then applied to the original investment...essentially try to figure out how much the average person would have gained if they had invested in a fund that was NOT a Ponzi from the point of their initial investment.
ETA: for me, it's not even that they were wrong to sink it all into one fund...it's just that the ROR promised by Madoff was a fiction...so the actual losses suffered should be calculated by FACT.
|