LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

Posted By Message

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

I need some opinions and this is going to be LONG. We are currently in a north shore town, in a 3BR co-op. We bought at the height of the market as our "starter home" almost 10 years ago. Luckily, we were young when we bought this (25 years old) and we had the foresight to know, since it was 3 BRs we had room to grow into it and were in good district and we didn't take any of the subprime mortgage offers, we bought what we could afford at 25 years old. The only downside is we don't have a yard. Yes, we have a large common area where the kids can play, but I can't just safely let them out to play like it was a safe backyard. I just feel like every little kid deserves to have a yard to play in. It is now worth FAR FAR less than what we paid for it and we are stuck here for the next 3 years, we figure until we at least break even or take a small loss then. My neighbors unit is for sale almost 100K less than what we paid at the height.

Problem is...we both make very good salaries now and have a decent amount in savings. However, if we sold this and took a loss and good chunk of that would be depleted paying the difference and then closing costs, and then what? My parents have a 2 family in a neighboring town. They have offered us the 2nd family unit (very decent size, several BRs, 2 bathrooms, private yard, updated etc.) which my grandmother currently lives in and she would move in with them. The yard for the kids to play in whenever they want is a HUGE draw to move back to the 2nd family portion of my parents. My issue isn't with the selling or buying, necessarily. Before the offer from my parents, since my 1 DC is in early elementary grade, the plan was to wait it out now until DC was wrapping up 4th grade in a few years since so DC didn't have to leave DC current school, and start over. Once middle school starts they all funnel into new schools anyway, so we would wait it out until then.

Now, though, I feel like if we take them up on the offer, my DC would be in the neighboring schools (where we grew up) and I wouldn't want to move DC AGAIN back to where we are now and have DC start all over AGAIN. If we did it, we would stay in my parents town. My concern is, again, not the buying and selling but my original hometown. My hometown will always be my home, and I love it more than anything, but the town I grew up in, I feel, isn't the same town it is today. I know, my current town has it drug problems too. From what I **hear**, its worse in my hometown though and it isn't only the schools, its parts of town. My friend who also grew up with us in my hometown, recently decided to pull her kid from school at 13 and relocate out of the township altogether bc of the drug issues.

I know, both towns have our fair share of similar issues. My DC is still in early elem, my other DC are still in preschool/daycare. So who knows if the issue for either district will still be there over a decade from now. I can't see myself leaving the township we are in either way. My hometown will always be my home, my parents, in-laws and sister in law and her family are still there. From what I **hear** though, I just don't know if I am OK with moving back to to my hometown? What do you think?

Message edited 2014-02-09 23:11:04.380000.

Posted 2/9/14 10:25 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

Thats a really tough decision. I first have to ask, what are your thoughts on living in your parents home? Seeing family daily? etc? If you and your DH are ok with that, then is it only a matter of not wanting to be in your old town? And only based on reasons of drug concerns?

For me, hearing what you wrote, I value my privacy and I generally go with my gut. And from what I am reading your gut says you won't be happy there b/c its not the way you recall. That is what I would be concerned with for you. If I were you, I would not move back if I felt that strongly about how things have changed. I also prefer privacy from family but you didn't voice any of that so thats just MO.

Posted 2/9/14 10:50 PM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

Posted by Goobster

Thats a really tough decision. I first have to ask, what are your thoughts on living in your parents home? Seeing family daily? etc? If you and your DH are ok with that, then is it only a matter of not wanting to be in your old town? And only based on reasons of drug concerns?

For me, hearing what you wrote, I value my privacy and I generally go with my gut. And from what I am reading your gut says you won't be happy there b/c its not the way you recall. That is what I would be concerned with for you. If I were you, I would not move back if I felt that strongly about how things have changed. I also prefer privacy from family but you didn't voice any of that so thats just MO.



As for the living situation, it is a COMPLETELY separate unit added on as an extension, there isn't even access to my parents home from it. The yard is fenced off and completely separate . Its a 2 story extension they put over the garage and out the back with its own separate entrance. The thing is, my mom watches our kids, so I am there almost EVERY day anyway to get them for dinner, I am there on the weekends, to hang out with them and my siblings. We are there ALL the time anyway. It would also be SUPER convenient in the mornings....we wouldn't have to drop the kids off there (its out of our way right now) and vice versa for my mom. We are SUPER close and are together ALL the time. Even with my inlaws who are around the block from my parents.

My concern is where the town is heading overall.....even if my parents get on my nerves, it is only temporary, KWIM?

Message edited 2014-02-09 23:02:38.340000.

Posted 2/9/14 10:57 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

Posted by 2BadSoSad

Posted by Goobster

Thats a really tough decision. I first have to ask, what are your thoughts on living in your parents home? Seeing family daily? etc? If you and your DH are ok with that, then is it only a matter of not wanting to be in your old town? And only based on reasons of drug concerns?

For me, hearing what you wrote, I value my privacy and I generally go with my gut. And from what I am reading your gut says you won't be happy there b/c its not the way you recall. That is what I would be concerned with for you. If I were you, I would not move back if I felt that strongly about how things have changed. I also prefer privacy from family but you didn't voice any of that so thats just MO.



As for the living situation, it is a COMPLETELY separate unit added on as an extension, there isn't even access to my parents home from it. The yard is fenced off and completely separate . The thing is, my mom watches our kids, so I am there almost EVERY day anyway to get them for dinner, I am there on the weekends, to hang out with them and my siblings. We are there ALL the time anyway. It would also be SUPER convenient in the mornings....we wouldn't have to drop the kids off there (its out of our way right now) and vice versa for my mom. We are SUPER close and are together ALL the time. Even with my inlaws who are around the block from my parents.

My concern is where the town is heading overall.....even if my parents get on my nerves, it is only temporary, KWIM?



Ok so based on those details, I would probably take my chances on the other issues you are concerned about. It seems like the pros outweigh the cons and being with your family sounds like it would work for you in so many ways. So I would just take a chance on the rest b/c the reality is who knows where any town is headed down the line? KWIM? And also, any child can get caught up in doing the wrong thing, in any district.

Posted 2/9/14 11:04 PM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

Posted by Goobster

Posted by 2BadSoSad

Posted by Goobster

Thats a really tough decision. I first have to ask, what are your thoughts on living in your parents home? Seeing family daily? etc? If you and your DH are ok with that, then is it only a matter of not wanting to be in your old town? And only based on reasons of drug concerns?

For me, hearing what you wrote, I value my privacy and I generally go with my gut. And from what I am reading your gut says you won't be happy there b/c its not the way you recall. That is what I would be concerned with for you. If I were you, I would not move back if I felt that strongly about how things have changed. I also prefer privacy from family but you didn't voice any of that so thats just MO.



As for the living situation, it is a COMPLETELY separate unit added on as an extension, there isn't even access to my parents home from it. The yard is fenced off and completely separate . The thing is, my mom watches our kids, so I am there almost EVERY day anyway to get them for dinner, I am there on the weekends, to hang out with them and my siblings. We are there ALL the time anyway. It would also be SUPER convenient in the mornings....we wouldn't have to drop the kids off there (its out of our way right now) and vice versa for my mom. We are SUPER close and are together ALL the time. Even with my inlaws who are around the block from my parents.

My concern is where the town is heading overall.....even if my parents get on my nerves, it is only temporary, KWIM?



Ok so based on those details, I would probably take my chances on the other issues you are concerned about. It seems like the pros outweigh the cons and being with your family sounds like it would work for you in so many ways. So I would just take a chance on the rest b/c the reality is who knows where any town is headed down the line? KWIM? And also, any child can get caught up in doing the wrong thing, in any district.



So true. but thats what scares me too. I can be ANY child. I have seen children, who were straight A students, star athletes from perfectly GREAT homes, whose parents did everything right...go down the wrong path and end up addicted. It scares me. It can happen to anyone, anywhere, really.

I feel like the town I am in now, while its an issue, its not a townwide issue. With my parents town, its not just the younger generations, I feel like the population of the town overall is taking a turn for the worst. Its still the minority in town, the issue, but its there nonetheless. I don't see that here is the neighboring town. I see it in our youth and younger generations, but not as a general overview of the population at large. I know no one can answer this for me...I just don't know if Im seeing my original town through rose colored glasses and if Im willing to put the overall direction of the town aside. The majority of the people, are still good, hardworking people, who have grown up there....whose roots are there. Its part of what I love...those who a raised there, tend to stay. It makes for a tight knit community. Im just trying not to make my decision based on the fear of what could be. In so many ways, my parents is a GREAT opportunity for us, but its also a PERMANENT opportunity in terms of where we call our forever home.

Posted 2/9/14 11:26 PM
 

Christine2
LIF Adult

Member since 2/09

1217 total posts

Name:

Re: LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

With your child already in elementary school with friends, and it being a town that you think is "safer" ( although as you and others have pointed out no place is really immune), I would probably suck it up and take the loss on buying a better home in your current district. Property values will always be reflected in the community's reputation. If you think your hometown is heading in a negative direction, then others likely do too. I don't recommend being house poor, but it is still a good time to buy. The home you buy now would've been much more at the height of the market, kwim?

Posted 2/9/14 11:58 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

Honestly, drugs are everywhere these days.

I've also seen A LOT of people get hooked once they left for college.

Posted 2/10/14 5:18 AM
 

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

You didn't mention any financial benefits. Wouldn't you then be able to rent out your co-op?

This is a tough one but since you didn't mention financial benefits the tone of your post makes it sound like you are moving mainly because of the yard.

If that's true - and it might not be, I might have read it wrong - I wouldn't let the yard be a major factor.

My 3 yr DS does play in our yard but probably more than half the time he wants to go to the local playground anyway. We just have a swing set, not multiple jungle gyms and other kids to play with lol.

My 12 yo DSD lost interest a couple of years ago.

Your kids will know what they grow up with as normal. I have never in my life heard anyone say that they were disappointed that they had no backyard growing up.

As long as there are parks nearby I wouldn't sweat it.

Posted 2/10/14 6:14 AM
 

JDubs
different, not less

Member since 7/09

13160 total posts

Name:

Re: LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

Posted by JennP

You didn't mention any financial benefits. Wouldn't you then be able to rent out your co-op?

This is a tough one but since you didn't mention financial benefits the tone of your post makes it sound like you are moving mainly because of the yard.

If that's true - and it might not be, I might have read it wrong - I wouldn't let the yard be a major factor.

My 3 yr DS does play in our yard but probably more than half the time he wants to go to the local playground anyway. We just have a swing set, not multiple jungle gyms and other kids to play with lol.

My 12 yo DSD lost interest a couple of years ago.

Your kids will know what they grow up with as normal. I have never in my life heard anyone say that they were disappointed that they had no backyard growing up.

As long as there are parks nearby I wouldn't sweat it.



I have to agree with this. My nieces (going on 3 and 4) have a huge swing set in their backyard and yet always want to go to the park to play!

Posted 2/10/14 9:56 AM
 

Millie3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/13

1280 total posts

Name:

Re: LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

We moved from a coop (oh I thought you said north shore towers, NM) to a house, BUT we outgrew our apt and HAD to move. If I were you, I would stay in the apartment, keep saving and saving. In 3 years from now your apt may be worth a lot of $$$$. If not, can you rent out the apt and then buy a home with the money you have saved? If our apt. was bigger we would have stayed much longer.

If your parents were in an amazing district, I would say go. You have reservations, so I think you should stay.
My kids are rarely in the yard, they like to go to the parks to play with other kids.

FTR, I can't wait to sell this house and move back into a coop once the kids finish HS!!!!

Message edited 2014-02-10 10:51:48.733000.

Posted 2/10/14 10:47 AM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

I would NOT want to share any kind of space with my parents or in-laws. That, invariably, leads to issues of some kind. Just becauase the two homes aren't accessable to each other from the inside, you still share walls.

Lets just say, you have an arguement; now, your neighbors hear it, and they continue on with their day. There, your parents and grandparent hear it. No bueno.

I think it's one of those situations that looks good on paper but in the end is not a good idea in practice.

Stay where you are or if you really want to leave and get a home with a yard, rent your current place and buy a home somewhere else.

As for the drugs, I agree with the other posters who said it's everywhere; I wouldn't have that sway me. School district performance and what they offer my child would be a bigger issue for me.

Posted 2/10/14 11:00 AM
 

MST9106
My life:)

Member since 6/06

9589 total posts

Name:

Re: LONG LONG LONG - WWYD

Honestly, I would stay where you are. Continue living in the 3 bedroom co-op and keep your kids in the better school district. Who knows where the market will be in a few years. You're building equity on your current place anyway. Maybe in a few years it'll be wiser to sell or maybe you'll be in a position to buy something else and rent out your co-op. But based on what you said, I wouldn't move. We have a yard that we spend 1/8th of our time in. When you have school aged kids you're always out and about anyway. Whether its sport events or the park. My kids prefer the park to their yard anytime.

Posted 2/10/14 11:56 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
okay, another WWYD... I find this odd... Kara 10/3/07 32 Home
WWYD? Neighbors dog left out in rain...I am so upset Goobster 9/11/07 19 Pets
WWYD? Buyers and realtors, a question. greenfreak 9/5/07 7 Home
WWYD? about the hotel we stayed at on my vacation DanaRenee 5/1/07 4 Travel & Vacations
WWYD? Etiquette related. greenfreak 4/19/07 31 Families Helping Families ™
xpost: old bff comes out of the wood worx wwyd? need some more opinions Nicole728 1/7/07 10 Families Helping Families ™