LIRR Strike Question
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] | |
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by MsSissy Posted by Michelle1110 People are so cavalier because it doesn't affect them. They think so what- pay for your health insurance because I do. There's no empathy for other professions/fields/benefits, etc. But it does affect the riders with rate increases. So I can see why most people say pay into your benefits because I do. Even the employees are saying they don't have a problem paying into their benefits. The issue then becomes the same as for cops, firemen, etc. The big attraction with civil service jobs is the benefits. Regardless of what is printed in Newsday, most LIRR workers (represented workers, NOT management) aren't making $100K. Most (not all) could make better salaries in the private sector. What lures them into the LIRR or any public sector job, are the benefits. Cut those and the base salaries are going to have to be higher to attract a workforce. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:22 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 I'm actually very surprised that people are so cavalier about ANY type of benefit being cut - whether in the private or public sector. Once a benefit is cut, it is hardly ever replaced. Let's face it, like it or hate it, the LIRR isn't going anywhere. They are still one of the largest employers in the region and one day some of our sons and daughters may work for them. The union leaders and the MTA are messing with people's livelihoods (both the LIRR workers and those who have to commute to work). It's just a damn shame. It IS sad if the management wants to cut pensions. If so, let the WORKER pay more into it. My ticket covers a lot..I should not be expected to pay for YOUR pension. So yes, I don't relish the fact that benefits be cut and frankly didn't realize they are fighting about pension. BUT. Its not the ridership's responsibility to pay for that. The LIRR is GROSSLY mismanaged. I was speaking to one of the conductors yesterday. They told me that they used to speak to one person to get sick/vacation/personal etc days. That person retired. So the person that took over the job decided it was to much and hired 5 new people. One for sick, one for vacation, one for personal (etc). Now what does he do? Supervise the 5 girls he hired. He now has nothing to do and just watches those 5 girls work. GROSS mismanagement. Maybe we should be looking at how much those assholes are wasting to get back some of the benefits. Both sides suck. And yes, the workers should be paying into their own pension and healthcare. if you don't like the job get another job. I didn't have a raise in 4+ years. In fact I got some of my pay taken away. I found a new job. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Posted by MsSissy Posted by Michelle1110 People are so cavalier because it doesn't affect them. They think so what- pay for your health insurance because I do. There's no empathy for other professions/fields/benefits, etc. But it does affect the riders with rate increases. So I can see why most people say pay into your benefits because I do. Even the employees are saying they don't have a problem paying into their benefits. The issue then becomes the same as for cops, firemen, etc. The big attraction with civil service jobs is the benefits. Regardless of what is printed in Newsday, most LIRR workers (represented workers, NOT management) aren't making $100K. Most (not all) could make better salaries in the private sector. What lures them into the LIRR or any public sector job, are the benefits. Cut those and the base salaries are going to have to be higher to attract a workforce. That is a good point, but let's be honest, there are PLENTY of people looking for good jobs, I don't think that the workforce is going to be depleted because they trimmed benefits a little. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question The workers already pay into their pension. The "pension" is actually quite small. The amount that they are willing to pay into their pension for current employees isn't at issue. What is at issue for the unions, is the amount that the future employees will have to pay. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:35 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Posted by MsSissy Posted by Michelle1110 People are so cavalier because it doesn't affect them. They think so what- pay for your health insurance because I do. There's no empathy for other professions/fields/benefits, etc. But it does affect the riders with rate increases. So I can see why most people say pay into your benefits because I do. Even the employees are saying they don't have a problem paying into their benefits. The issue then becomes the same as for cops, firemen, etc. The big attraction with civil service jobs is the benefits. Regardless of what is printed in Newsday, most LIRR workers (represented workers, NOT management) aren't making $100K. Most (not all) could make better salaries in the private sector. What lures them into the LIRR or any public sector job, are the benefits. Cut those and the base salaries are going to have to be higher to attract a workforce. True. But I believe plenty of people would still be taking these jobs even having to pay a portion of their benefits or pensions. Since a lot of companies don't even off pensions anymore and the medical contributions have increased dramatically. And so have the deductibles and prescription plans. If you are even offered benefits. Message edited 2014-07-10 11:35:45.267000. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:35 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Posted by MsSissy Posted by Michelle1110 People are so cavalier because it doesn't affect them. They think so what- pay for your health insurance because I do. There's no empathy for other professions/fields/benefits, etc. But it does affect the riders with rate increases. So I can see why most people say pay into your benefits because I do. Even the employees are saying they don't have a problem paying into their benefits. The issue then becomes the same as for cops, firemen, etc. The big attraction with civil service jobs is the benefits. Regardless of what is printed in Newsday, most LIRR workers (represented workers, NOT management) aren't making $100K. Most (not all) could make better salaries in the private sector. What lures them into the LIRR or any public sector job, are the benefits. Cut those and the base salaries are going to have to be higher to attract a workforce.
|
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Sorry but I don't think their demands are unreasonable. I think the MTA needs to accept what TWO independent agencies recommended in their mediation. Message edited 2014-07-10 11:45:54.170000. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by MsSissy True. But I believe plenty of people would still be taking these jobs even having to pay a portion of their benefits or pensions. Since a lot of companies don't even off pensions anymore and the medical contributions have increased dramatically. And so have the deductibles and prescription plans. If you are even offered benefits. I agree - BUT we as a society have become so cold to this. If one of us comes on here and posts about our firm's new health insurance plan that costs us $500 a month and has a $3000 deductible, it's all tears and sympathy and outrage. Instead of saying "why should they get better benefits" we should be saying "why aren't we getting better benefits" |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by nrthshgrl Sorry but I don't think their demands are unreasonable. I think the MTA needs to accept what TWO independent agencies recommended in their mediation. I am tired of hearing people think because they have crappy benefits that other people should too. If the union accepts concessions for future employees, it weakens their position going forward FOREVER. Future employees will not see the benefit of joining the union & they will coninually lose membership. The fact is as one of the weathiest countries in the world, that wealth is at the top. We should be demanding on upgrade of benefits NOT a downgrade of benefits. The only reason corporations had to offer vacation & sick day pay was because they needed to meet the demands of unions. I look at other countries & see FREE college educations & I'm disgusted at how lobbyists and corporations have handicapped people in our country. I work in the private sector & I can tell you that the majority of corporations are fine with screwing over the lower paying guy. I've seen layoffs where admin staff was cut back, the remaining staff had to work longer hours & the VPs wound up in different jobs with the same pay. The NY POST (granted it's a POS paper) had a headline about "Millionaires on Strike. The article went on to detail that about 20% of the union will retire with a million dollars in their retirement funds. Do you think that's going to be your conductor? The guy picking up the trash? Nope. How much do you think Prendergast will have in his retirement fund? From 2012: With those payments and employer contributions to his 457 pension plan — a 401(k)-type fund for government workers — Prendergast earned $368,082.79 last year. He was the agency’s second-highest-paid employee after former CEO Jay Walder. http://nypost.com/2012/06/23/mta-fat-cats-sure-can-ue-a-vacation/ The MTA is in dire straits because of financial mismanagement & every decision maker lining their own pocket. ![]()
|
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:45 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by nrthshgrl Sorry but I don't think their demands are unreasonable. I think the MTA needs to accept what TWO independent agencies recommended in their mediation. I am tired of hearing people think because they have crappy benefits that other people should too. If the union accepts concessions for future employees, it weakens their position going forward FOREVER. Future employees will not see the benefit of joining the union & they will coninually lose membership. The fact is as one of the weathiest countries in the world, that wealth is at the top. We should be demanding on upgrade of benefits NOT a downgrade of benefits. The only reason corporations had to offer vacation & sick day pay was because they needed to meet the demands of unions. I look at other countries & see FREE college educations & I'm disgusted at how lobbyists and corporations have handicapped people in our country. I work in the private sector & I can tell you that the majority of corporations are fine with screwing over the lower paying guy. I've seen layoffs where admin staff was cut back, the remaining staff had to work longer hours & the VPs wound up in different jobs with the same pay. The NY POST (granted it's a POS paper) had a headline about "Millionaires on Strike. The article went on to detail that about 20% of the union will retire with a million dollars in their retirement funds. Do you think that's going to be your conductor? The guy picking up the trash? Nope. How much do you think Prendergast will have in his retirement fund? From 2012: With those payments and employer contributions to his 457 pension plan — a 401(k)-type fund for government workers — Prendergast earned $368,082.79 last year. He was the agency’s second-highest-paid employee after former CEO Jay Walder. http://nypost.com/2012/06/23/mta-fat-cats-sure-can-ue-a-vacation/ The MTA is in dire straits because of financial mismanagement & every decision maker lining their own pocket. ![]() and for the record, yes this strike will affect me, my job & my bottom line. If I can't work from home, I'll be taking days off. If my husband can't get to work, he won't get paid.
|
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:46 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Posted by MsSissy True. But I believe plenty of people would still be taking these jobs even having to pay a portion of their benefits or pensions. Since a lot of companies don't even off pensions anymore and the medical contributions have increased dramatically. And so have the deductibles and prescription plans. If you are even offered benefits. I agree - BUT we as a society have become so cold to this. If one of us comes on here and posts about our firm's new health insurance plan that costs us $500 a month and has a $3000 deductible, it's all tears and sympathy and outrage. Instead of saying "why should they get better benefits" we should be saying "why aren't we getting better benefits" Your last sentence says it all! "Why aren't WE getting better benefits"? Working in the medical field, it's DISGUSTING what I see. Patients who can't afford anything else pay extra into a medicaid HMO plan with the hopes that they'll get better care, access to more doctors, etc, only to find out that no one accepts the plan. And the same goes for the ACA plans. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by jessnbrian Your last sentence says it all! "Why aren't WE getting better benefits"? Working in the medical field, it's DISGUSTING what I see. Patients who can't afford anything else pay extra into a medicaid HMO plan with the hopes that they'll get better care, access to more doctors, etc, only to find out that no one accepts the plan. And the same goes for the ACA plans. I know people working in doctor's office that had no health insurance! We have downgraded our expectations to the point of risking our future financial security. There are many people that are an accident away from financially devastating themselves & their families. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:48 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Posted by MsSissy True. But I believe plenty of people would still be taking these jobs even having to pay a portion of their benefits or pensions. Since a lot of companies don't even off pensions anymore and the medical contributions have increased dramatically. And so have the deductibles and prescription plans. If you are even offered benefits. I agree - BUT we as a society have become so cold to this. If one of us comes on here and posts about our firm's new health insurance plan that costs us $500 a month and has a $3000 deductible, it's all tears and sympathy and outrage. Instead of saying "why should they get better benefits" we should be saying "why aren't we getting better benefits" This is why I said there was a lack of empathy. It shouldn't be a "if I can't have it, you can't have it" attitude, which IMO seems to be prevalent. "If you don't like it, go find a new job" or "Someone else will take the job" just seems cold to me. I don't know what the right answer is - but the LIRR workers are on the other side of this, too. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by jessnbrian Your last sentence says it all! "Why aren't WE getting better benefits"? Working in the medical field, it's DISGUSTING what I see. Patients who can't afford anything else pay extra into a medicaid HMO plan with the hopes that they'll get better care, access to more doctors, etc, only to find out that no one accepts the plan. And the same goes for the ACA plans. I know people working in doctor's office that had no health insurance! We have downgraded our expectations to the point of risking our future financial security. There are many people that are an accident away from financially devastating themselves & their families. I manage a practice - we offer NO health insurance. I am LUCKY to have excellent coverage through DH's job. But I have an employee who just got herself and her child on a state offered HMO plan. It's really sad. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Posted by MsSissy True. But I believe plenty of people would still be taking these jobs even having to pay a portion of their benefits or pensions. Since a lot of companies don't even off pensions anymore and the medical contributions have increased dramatically. And so have the deductibles and prescription plans. If you are even offered benefits. I agree - BUT we as a society have become so cold to this. If one of us comes on here and posts about our firm's new health insurance plan that costs us $500 a month and has a $3000 deductible, it's all tears and sympathy and outrage. Instead of saying "why should they get better benefits" we should be saying "why aren't we getting better benefits" You're right. And people have been arguing/fighting for better benefits forever. Why doesn't everyone have better benefits. Why do employers get away with offering these crappy benefits. Because they don't have unions fighting for them? Because employers want to keep the profits in their pockets? I don't know what the answer is. I just know so many people don't have insurance so it's had to get sympathy from everyone who's struggling. Right or wrong. I think it's only human. I know someone who worked for the LIRR for about 3-4 yrs. She quit about 4 yrs ago. She HATED it! Everyone told her she was crazy to walk away from the benefits. But she would come home miserable. She punched tickets on the train. And the final straw was when she got punched in the face by a rider who tried to pass himself off as an employee and she questioned him on it. When the train pulled into the station he punched her in the face and took off. She still says it's the best decision she ever made. ETS: I know a lot of people feel if you don't like the benefits leave. Go find another job. Someone else will gladly take that position. And I'm sure they would. Until the next contract negotiations and they're on the other side. I'm sure they would be singing a different tune. Message edited 2014-07-10 12:04:19.073000. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Let's just remember to have some empathy for those going through the strike - the workers and their families and those of us who commute and depend on the LIRR. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 12:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by jessnbrian Your last sentence says it all! "Why aren't WE getting better benefits"? Working in the medical field, it's DISGUSTING what I see. Patients who can't afford anything else pay extra into a medicaid HMO plan with the hopes that they'll get better care, access to more doctors, etc, only to find out that no one accepts the plan. And the same goes for the ACA plans. I know people working in doctor's office that had no health insurance! We have downgraded our expectations to the point of risking our future financial security. There are many people that are an accident away from financially devastating themselves & their families. So ******* true. Can't agree enough. It's like "so what if you get shit on? At least it's a job!" And employers know that. It's held over the heads of employees. It's like that saying about being treated the way you allow others to treat you. But most people are scared to make waves or go against their employer. You can't even say the words "let's get a union in here" in some private companies (if your company qualifies, that is) And I do agree there is a lot of arguments on both sides (been guilty of it myself) when someone says they lost their pension plan and someone responds "so have I. And then I lost my job , so quit whining!" We should all be on the same side as a majority of working class people. Boostin each other up when we can. It's sad that the majority doesn't get the breaks that a small percentage of people do. But I'm sure someone will jump in and say "well work hard and you can get there too." World doesn't work that way. It it did, more people would be in better positions than they are now. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 12:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by nrthshgrl Sorry but I don't think their demands are unreasonable. I think the MTA needs to accept what TWO independent agencies recommended in their mediation. I am tired of hearing people think because they have crappy benefits that other people should too. If the union accepts concessions for future employees, it weakens their position going forward FOREVER. Future employees will not see the benefit of joining the union & they will coninually lose membership. The fact is as one of the weathiest countries in the world, that wealth is at the top. We should be demanding on upgrade of benefits NOT a downgrade of benefits. The only reason corporations had to offer vacation & sick day pay was because they needed to meet the demands of unions. I look at other countries & see FREE college educations & I'm disgusted at how lobbyists and corporations have handicapped people in our country. I work in the private sector & I can tell you that the majority of corporations are fine with screwing over the lower paying guy. I've seen layoffs where admin staff was cut back, the remaining staff had to work longer hours & the VPs wound up in different jobs with the same pay. The NY POST (granted it's a POS paper) had a headline about "Millionaires on Strike. The article went on to detail that about 20% of the union will retire with a million dollars in their retirement funds. Do you think that's going to be your conductor? The guy picking up the trash? Nope. How much do you think Prendergast will have in his retirement fund? From 2012: With those payments and employer contributions to his 457 pension plan — a 401(k)-type fund for government workers — Prendergast earned $368,082.79 last year. He was the agency’s second-highest-paid employee after former CEO Jay Walder. http://nypost.com/2012/06/23/mta-fat-cats-sure-can-ue-a-vacation/ The MTA is in dire straits because of financial mismanagement & every decision maker lining their own pocket. ![]() and for the record, yes this strike will affect me, my job & my bottom line. If I can't work from home, I'll be taking days off. If my husband (not a transit worker) can't get to work, he won't get paid.
|
|
Posted 7/10/14 1:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by EatingMyVeggies Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by jessnbrian Your last sentence says it all! "Why aren't WE getting better benefits"? Working in the medical field, it's DISGUSTING what I see. Patients who can't afford anything else pay extra into a medicaid HMO plan with the hopes that they'll get better care, access to more doctors, etc, only to find out that no one accepts the plan. And the same goes for the ACA plans. I know people working in doctor's office that had no health insurance! We have downgraded our expectations to the point of risking our future financial security. There are many people that are an accident away from financially devastating themselves & their families. So ******* true. Can't agree enough. It's like "so what if you get shit on? At least it's a job!" And employers know that. It's held over the heads of employees. It's like that saying about being treated the way you allow others to treat you. But most people are scared to make waves or go against their employer. You can't even say the words "let's get a union in here" in some private companies (if your company qualifies, that is) And I do agree there is a lot of arguments on both sides (been guilty of it myself) when someone says they lost their pension plan and someone responds "so have I. And then I lost my job , so quit whining!" We should all be on the same side as a majority of working class people. Boostin each other up when we can. It's sad that the majority doesn't get the breaks that a small percentage of people do. But I'm sure someone will jump in and say "well work hard and you can get there too." World doesn't work that way. It it did, more people would be in better positions than they are now. It's sad because it used to be. My grandfather dropped out of college, did the army thing, then started in the mail room of an advertising firm. By the time he retired he was the executive Vice President of Y&R - no lucky breaks, just worked his a$$ off, sacrificed spending time with family, and it paid off for him. You can't do that anymore. Now it's entirely about who you know - especially to get one of the coveted civil service jobs. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 1:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question http://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/03/opinion/reagan-vs-patco-the-strike-that-busted-unions.html?_r=0 |
|
Posted 7/10/14 2:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question I work for MTA HQ. I am in the union for HQ office employees. I spoke to my union rep today and he is a rep for LIRR employees too and today still has no idea what is going on. I am still hoping last minute things will change. I was informed today that we cannot use vacation days or work from home. We are to either take unpaid days or get to work even if we are late. I was told last week I could use vacation days and now today no its not ok. I am aggravated and mad really. I know people at LIRR and they are not happy about this either. It is going to be a mess for any commuter whether you drive or take the train. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 3:37 PM
|
|
|
saraH
Member since 5/05 16555 total posts Name: |
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Let's just remember to have some empathy for those going through the strike - the workers and their families and those of us who commute and depend on the LIRR. I am sure 99% of the LIRR workers just want to go to work, collect their paychecks, and come home to their families like the rest of us. Let the workers do what they need to do and hope that it's a quick and easy strike for everyone. Thank you. MY Dh is an engineer. If they strike, he can't go to work so he won't get paid. He's of course hoping it doesn't come to that. I see if from his side. I know it sucks but I think they deserve a better contract. |
Posted 7/10/14 5:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Trust me, the members don't want a strike. I'm sad to see so many people lumping them all together as bad people. They bust their butts and for the past 4 years their living costs have gone up but their salaries haven't, while watching fares go up, up up... Not a dime of it going to fair wages. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 6:43 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silly Indecisive Question About LIRR | Jesaroo | 10/15/06 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| LIRR question - Ronkonkoma Line | SweetTooth | 8/30/06 | 16 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| LIRR...Service Question | Ang-Rich | 4/20/06 | 18 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| LIRR monthly ticket question | Shelly | 11/2/05 | 8 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| LIRR question... | Myrockette | 6/21/05 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Question about the LIRR? | preciouslove | 6/6/05 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |










