LIRR Strike Question
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 | |
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question It just annoys me that the MTA has no plan. They are asking riders to work from home or stay in the city b/c they will have very limited shuttle bus service. Not really an option for everyone! |
|
Posted 7/9/14 8:44 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by LolasMom Posted by NervousNell Posted by Millie3 Posted by alli3131 Posted by CookiePuss Posted by Millie3 Posted by ave1024 Posted by Mill188 Right now it takes the average LIRR worker 5 years to get up to 100% of their pay grade. So they get hired as say a station cleaner and are told the salary is say $40K a year (made up number) - the first year they will only make say $32K (80% of their salary); the next year $34K, etc. until they reach 100% of their salary. The MTA wants to extend that amount of time for each individual union by 2 years. The MTA wants to abolish night differential pay. Try finding someone who wants to work the 2:30 am train from Penn without offering an incentive. I wouldn't do it. The MTA wants to abolish incentives for achieving additional certifications. What difference does the above really make? In your example it really doesn't matter if the base pay is 40k and takes you 5 years to get there. The fact is you are being hired at 32k and the employee should realize that the 32k is his salary. That is the number that would go on other job applications. That is the number that gets reported to the IRS. As far as finding somebody who wants to work a 2:30am train, the last time I looked there are plenty of people that are unemployed that would more than happy take that job to put food on the table for their family. Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. I have to agree. There are a ton of people that would love to take these jobs for less pay/ less benefits in a heart beat. It would be better for the public (lower prices) to hire all new people for less $ and no pension. The service is a crap shoot as it is, these guys really have no have sympathy from the public. It will be tough/ impossible for commuters and for the companies that will be short staffed if this strike happens. Is it at all possible to do to MTA what Reagan did with the PATCO strike in the 80's? But what would that solve. Reagan fired all the employees that did nto return to work. If that were to happen we would be without train service for a much longer time. They would return to work immediately, unless they are independently wealthy. There is also something called the Taylor Law which imposes fines of up to $1000 a day on employees who strike. However, it does not apply here I assume. Taylor Law Taylor Law doesn't apply to LIRR! Yeah I figured as much. It applies to NYPD because having cops on strike would be a major safety issue obviously |
Posted 7/9/14 9:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by NervousNell Posted by Paramount Posted by Mill188 By it's definition, a union is a "brotherhood." They can't sell out their future members for the benefit of the current members. but its ok to pass that along to me, the rider? Does everyone know that 75% of the money raised by tickets is for the pension? Look, I'm not anti union (not a big fan, but not anti). but you know what? pay for yourself. And yes, maybe the future DOES have to pay a little more than the people working today. I don't see anything wrong with that, union or not. And just to bring up a point, in the NYPD the pension system changed for FUTURE members. At the time my DH started it was 20 years to a pension. Now, for new recruits, it's 25 years. Changes had to be made because the city could not afford to keep doing things the way they were. So that stuff about "brotherhood" and selling out future members is BS IMO. It's been done in unions before.... I was going to make this point about the NYPD! |
|
Posted 7/9/14 9:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by sfp0701 ETA: 17% even over 6 years is A LOT! This is what I keep thinking! That is a big %! Also wanted to add about the pension changing for new members. Im pretty sure this is the case for the Verizon union. A friend who's been there 5 yrs does not have the same pension as another friend who's there almost 20. That all changed during the last contract negotiations. But it seems the LIRR is in it's own world. Most things don't apply to them. Message edited 2014-07-09 21:28:25.347000. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 9:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Posted by CookiePuss The other issue being reported as a road block is what new employees would pay towards their health care. Imagine you and I got hired at the same company. We make the same amount of money. If you go over and above your job duties, and I do the bare minimum, we get paid the same amount, no bonuses, etc. It doesn't matter that your job performance is exemplary and mine is just average. Now imagine I started one day before you. I pay 1% of my salary to my health insurance, you pay 2%. We get paid the same exact amount, you might possibly be doing a better job, but I actually make more money. By it's definition, a union is a "brotherhood." They can't sell out their future members for the benefit of the current members. They SHOULDN'T, but school districts do this all the time... |
|
Posted 7/9/14 9:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question No. They strike at 12:00 and are ordered back by 12:01. They are mandated. The "strike" though once made official will give the union bargaining power. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 10:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question
|
|
Posted 7/10/14 12:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question DH is on LIRR and he is hearing that they lose 2 days pay for every day out. Trust me he's not wanting this. I will say though that these jobs are nothing like what the public thinks. DH was an asst. conductor and they don't just punch tickets. There is a qualification process to become a conductor and extremely difficult tests that have to be passed. DH studied for a year and didn't pass one of them. He ultimately lost his job which was devastating and is now cleaning the trains. Took a big pay cut, but I guess my point is that everyone has something to say, but in your job you'd want to earn what you deserve too. Let's just hope this is resolved. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 1:10 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Sorry but they should be paying into healthcare. It's insane to me that I pay $325 a month and the price goes up every year....but employees aren't paying anything for their healthcare? Give me a break. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 7:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question I'd also like to know what type of refund monthly ticket holders will be receiving in the event of a strike. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 7:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by skinny I'd also like to know what type of refund monthly ticket holders will be receiving in the event of a strike. . None |
|
Posted 7/10/14 7:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by NervousNell Posted by Paramount Posted by Mill188 By it's definition, a union is a "brotherhood." They can't sell out their future members for the benefit of the current members. but its ok to pass that along to me, the rider? Does everyone know that 75% of the money raised by tickets is for the pension? Look, I'm not anti union (not a big fan, but not anti). but you know what? pay for yourself. And yes, maybe the future DOES have to pay a little more than the people working today. I don't see anything wrong with that, union or not. And just to bring up a point, in the NYPD the pension system changed for FUTURE members. At the time my DH started it was 20 years to a pension. Now, for new recruits, it's 25 years. Changes had to be made because the city could not afford to keep doing things the way they were. So that stuff about "brotherhood" and selling out future members is BS IMO. It's been done in unions before.... FDNY has made changes as well that effect future members. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 9:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Teach723 DH is on LIRR and he is hearing that they lose 2 days pay for every day out. Trust me he's not wanting this. I will say though that these jobs are nothing like what the public thinks. DH was an asst. conductor and they don't just punch tickets. There is a qualification process to become a conductor and extremely difficult tests that have to be passed. DH studied for a year and didn't pass one of them. He ultimately lost his job which was devastating and is now cleaning the trains. Took a big pay cut, but I guess my point is that everyone has something to say, but in your job you'd want to earn what you deserve too. Let's just hope this is resolved. sorry for your DH :( thanks for adding a dif perspective. I don't think a lot of people are concerning themselves with the LIRR employees but they should.
|
|
Posted 7/10/14 9:59 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by ali120206 Posted by NervousNell Posted by Paramount Posted by Mill188 By it's definition, a union is a "brotherhood." They can't sell out their future members for the benefit of the current members. but its ok to pass that along to me, the rider? Does everyone know that 75% of the money raised by tickets is for the pension? Look, I'm not anti union (not a big fan, but not anti). but you know what? pay for yourself. And yes, maybe the future DOES have to pay a little more than the people working today. I don't see anything wrong with that, union or not. And just to bring up a point, in the NYPD the pension system changed for FUTURE members. At the time my DH started it was 20 years to a pension. Now, for new recruits, it's 25 years. Changes had to be made because the city could not afford to keep doing things the way they were. So that stuff about "brotherhood" and selling out future members is BS IMO. It's been done in unions before.... FDNY has made changes as well that effect future members. Teachers as well. DH and I have different pension plans and were hired 5 years apart. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 10:00 AM
|
|
|
LIRR Strike Question Just to keep the stories correct, the LIRR has in the past changed the pension plans for new hires. My father and ExDH had very different plans. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 10:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question It's nothing less than hostage negotiations - with the ridership being victimized. They are the only ones I sympathize with at this point. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 10:53 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by KarenK122 Just to keep the stories correct, the LIRR has in the past changed the pension plans for new hires. My father and ExDH had very different plans. There are several tiers to the LIRR pension (like in most pension systems). The problem with the latest offer is how much the MTA wants to cut the pension. The media keeps focusing on the 17% when that's actually such a small portion of what the unions are negotiating. I'm actually very surprised that people are so cavalier about ANY type of benefit being cut - whether in the private or public sector. Once a benefit is cut, it is hardly ever replaced. Let's face it, like it or hate it, the LIRR isn't going anywhere. They are still one of the largest employers in the region and one day some of our sons and daughters may work for them. The union leaders and the MTA are messing with people's livelihoods (both the LIRR workers and those who have to commute to work). It's just a damn shame. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:04 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by skinny You can hold hundreds of thousands of people hostage and have no ramifications. They've done it before, that's why my grandfather hates the MTA - he's no longer commuting (retired for MANY years) but can't stop b!tching about them and how they don't care about the commuters. People who think it's going to be over in a day are going to be very surprised if they repeat previous strikes - he's been through a few, he said the shortest one was 2-3 weeks, the longest was 2 months. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:06 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Posted by KarenK122 Just to keep the stories correct, the LIRR has in the past changed the pension plans for new hires. My father and ExDH had very different plans. There are several tiers to the LIRR pension (like in most pension systems). The problem with the latest offer is how much the MTA wants to cut the pension. The media keeps focusing on the 17% when that's actually such a small portion of what the unions are negotiating. I'm actually very surprised that people are so cavalier about ANY type of benefit being cut - whether in the private or public sector. Once a benefit is cut, it is hardly ever replaced. Let's face it, like it or hate it, the LIRR isn't going anywhere. They are still one of the largest employers in the region and one day some of our sons and daughters may work for them. The union leaders and the MTA are messing with people's livelihoods (both the LIRR workers and those who have to commute to work). It's just a damn shame. People are so cavalier because it doesn't affect them. They think so what- pay for your health insurance because I do. There's no empathy for other professions/fields/benefits, etc. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:09 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by jessnbrian Posted by skinny You can hold hundreds of thousands of people hostage and have no ramifications. They've done it before, that's why my grandfather hates the MTA - he's no longer commuting (retired for MANY years) but can't stop b!tching about them and how they don't care about the commuters. People who think it's going to be over in a day are going to be very surprised if they repeat previous strikes - he's been through a few, he said the shortest one was 2-3 weeks, the longest was 2 months. The 1987 strike lasted 11 days. The 1994 strike lasted 2 days. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:14 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Michelle1110 People are so cavalier because it doesn't affect them. They think so what- pay for your health insurance because I do. There's no empathy for other professions/fields/benefits, etc. But it does affect the riders with rate increases. So I can see why most people say pay into your benefits because I do. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:17 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Michelle1110 People are so cavalier because it doesn't affect them. They think so what- pay for your health insurance because I do. There's no empathy for other professions/fields/benefits, etc. That makes me For everyone's sake, I hope this strike is a short one for the commuters and the workers. There isn't one LIRR worker I know (and I know several) that wants this strike. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Michelle1110 Posted by Mill188 Posted by KarenK122 Just to keep the stories correct, the LIRR has in the past changed the pension plans for new hires. My father and ExDH had very different plans. There are several tiers to the LIRR pension (like in most pension systems). The problem with the latest offer is how much the MTA wants to cut the pension. The media keeps focusing on the 17% when that's actually such a small portion of what the unions are negotiating. I'm actually very surprised that people are so cavalier about ANY type of benefit being cut - whether in the private or public sector. Once a benefit is cut, it is hardly ever replaced. Let's face it, like it or hate it, the LIRR isn't going anywhere. They are still one of the largest employers in the region and one day some of our sons and daughters may work for them. The union leaders and the MTA are messing with people's livelihoods (both the LIRR workers and those who have to commute to work). It's just a damn shame. People are so cavalier because it doesn't affect them. They think so what- pay for your health insurance because I do. There's no empathy for other professions/fields/benefits, etc. I think people are so cavalier because most of us in the private sector went through it in 2008, 2009. 2010, etc. Most of us lost benefits and haven't seen them come back. A lot of us were just happy to work and have a job. And yes, health care insurance has changed dramatically in the past 20 years and benefits need to change. I don't think it's unreasonable to expect employees to help pay for that benefit whether is be public or private sector. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Posted by jessnbrian Posted by skinny You can hold hundreds of thousands of people hostage and have no ramifications. They've done it before, that's why my grandfather hates the MTA - he's no longer commuting (retired for MANY years) but can't stop b!tching about them and how they don't care about the commuters. People who think it's going to be over in a day are going to be very surprised if they repeat previous strikes - he's been through a few, he said the shortest one was 2-3 weeks, the longest was 2 months. The 1987 strike lasted 11 days. The 1994 strike lasted 2 days. Yea, my gpa was retired by '94, lol, so I guess he wouldn't remember that one. When I say he's been retired for many years, he retired in his 50's, almost 30 years ago.... I'm just saying, don't be surprised if it lasts longer than the 1 minute someone suggested before - there is no mandate or law saying they have to come back to work. |
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:19 AM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by CookiePuss Posted by Michelle1110 Posted by Mill188 Posted by KarenK122 Just to keep the stories correct, the LIRR has in the past changed the pension plans for new hires. My father and ExDH had very different plans. There are several tiers to the LIRR pension (like in most pension systems). The problem with the latest offer is how much the MTA wants to cut the pension. The media keeps focusing on the 17% when that's actually such a small portion of what the unions are negotiating. I'm actually very surprised that people are so cavalier about ANY type of benefit being cut - whether in the private or public sector. Once a benefit is cut, it is hardly ever replaced. Let's face it, like it or hate it, the LIRR isn't going anywhere. They are still one of the largest employers in the region and one day some of our sons and daughters may work for them. The union leaders and the MTA are messing with people's livelihoods (both the LIRR workers and those who have to commute to work). It's just a damn shame. People are so cavalier because it doesn't affect them. They think so what- pay for your health insurance because I do. There's no empathy for other professions/fields/benefits, etc. I think people are so cavalier because most of us in the private sector went through it in 2008, 2009. 2010, etc. Most of us lost benefits and haven't seen them come back. A lot of us were just happy to work and have a job. And yes, health care insurance has changed dramatically in the past 20 years and benefits need to change. I don't think it's unreasonable to expect employees to help pay for that benefit whether is be public or private sector.
|
|
Posted 7/10/14 11:20 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silly Indecisive Question About LIRR | Jesaroo | 10/15/06 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| LIRR question - Ronkonkoma Line | SweetTooth | 8/30/06 | 16 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| LIRR...Service Question | Ang-Rich | 4/20/06 | 18 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| LIRR monthly ticket question | Shelly | 11/2/05 | 8 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| LIRR question... | Myrockette | 6/21/05 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Question about the LIRR? | preciouslove | 6/6/05 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |










I'm so over this. My DH is LIRR and I hear about it every day. Simply put, this is a battle of the meatheads. The president of the union is a bonehead and the president of the MTA is another chump. When DH was initially filling me in, I really thought he was confused or drinking too much of the Kool aide or something but no. He was accurate. It's really appalling that these men hold such important positions at the LIRR because they seem to lack the necessary capacity to perform adequately. That's the reason nothing is being accomplished. Meanwhile, nobody is winning here. The poor commuters will be victimized and, like it or not, so are the workers. 




