LIRR Strike Question
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 | |
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Right now it takes the average LIRR worker 5 years to get up to 100% of their pay grade. So they get hired as say a station cleaner and are told the salary is say $40K a year (made up number) - the first year they will only make say $32K (80% of their salary); the next year $34K, etc. until they reach 100% of their salary. The MTA wants to extend that amount of time for each individual union by 2 years. The MTA wants to abolish night differential pay. Try finding someone who wants to work the 2:30 am train from Penn without offering an incentive. I wouldn't do it. The MTA wants to abolish incentives for achieving additional certifications. What difference does the above really make? In your example it really doesn't matter if the base pay is 40k and takes you 5 years to get there. The fact is you are being hired at 32k and the employee should realize that the 32k is his salary. That is the number that would go on other job applications. That is the number that gets reported to the IRS. As far as finding somebody who wants to work a 2:30am train, the last time I looked there are plenty of people that are unemployed that would more than happy take that job to put food on the table for their family. Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. |
Posted 7/9/14 2:45 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question ugh this is terrible that all of these people are at the mercy of this.... for some (like my DH) they don't have the option to work from home. DH will have to drive in each day. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 2:46 PM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by ave1024 Posted by Mill188 Right now it takes the average LIRR worker 5 years to get up to 100% of their pay grade. So they get hired as say a station cleaner and are told the salary is say $40K a year (made up number) - the first year they will only make say $32K (80% of their salary); the next year $34K, etc. until they reach 100% of their salary. The MTA wants to extend that amount of time for each individual union by 2 years. The MTA wants to abolish night differential pay. Try finding someone who wants to work the 2:30 am train from Penn without offering an incentive. I wouldn't do it. The MTA wants to abolish incentives for achieving additional certifications. What difference does the above really make? In your example it really doesn't matter if the base pay is 40k and takes you 5 years to get there. The fact is you are being hired at 32k and the employee should realize that the 32k is his salary. That is the number that would go on other job applications. That is the number that gets reported to the IRS. As far as finding somebody who wants to work a 2:30am train, the last time I looked there are plenty of people that are unemployed that would more than happy take that job to put food on the table for their family. Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. And this is from the wife of a union DH. Difference is, his contract is STILL unsettled for YEARS and guess what, they aren't allowed to strike by law. I hate to say it, but I can't stand unions lately. |
Posted 7/9/14 2:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by CookiePuss The other issue being reported as a road block is what new employees would pay towards their health care. Imagine you and I got hired at the same company. We make the same amount of money. If you go over and above your job duties, and I do the bare minimum, we get paid the same amount, no bonuses, etc. It doesn't matter that your job performance is exemplary and mine is just average. Now imagine I started one day before you. I pay 1% of my salary to my health insurance, you pay 2%. We get paid the same exact amount, you might possibly be doing a better job, but I actually make more money. By it's definition, a union is a "brotherhood." They can't sell out their future members for the benefit of the current members. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 2:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by ave1024 Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. It's not a 17% guaranteed raise over "5" years. At this point, it's a "raise" over 2 years. Four years of it is in back pay....if the MTA negotiated the contract 4 years ago it would be in raises. Right there is one of the reasons NYS is in trouble financially. They need to fix problems as they arise: from Nassau County's antiquated system of assessment and refunding of tax over payments to not dealing with expired contracts until the 11th hour. I work in the private sector. I had a pay cut back in 2009. I haven't had a raise since 2011. I can leave if I'm not happy - and so can the LIRR workers. I'm not saying that the unions are right or wrong. I just find the entire thing completely stupid. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 3:00 PM
|
|
|
ave1024
Member since 12/07 6153 total posts Name: |
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Posted by ave1024 Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. It's not a 17% guaranteed raise over "5" years. At this point, it's a "raise" over 2 years. Four years of it is in back pay....if the MTA negotiated the contract 4 years ago it would be in raises. It's still a raise no matter how much you want to spin it. Again many people haven't gotten raises in the past few years. In this case the MTA is offering to retro their raises for the four missed years and tack on two more guaranteed yearly raises. Sounds like a pretty sweet deal. |
Posted 7/9/14 3:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by ANewDayHasCome The mta chairman is in dc today asking them to intervene. So who knows. Congress said "Go F yourself" today. (I just got an update.) This is a Republican congress dealing with a blue state and a blue Gov. They could not give one shit about us. The union is full of crap. They are holding us hostage and should be ASHAMED. I have no sympathy whatsoever if they go on strike. In the end they will come to SOME contract and will each (mostly) get a $21k back pay check. They wont hurt. The management of the LIRR is full of crap. Both sides are about 2% apart. It has to do with their 17% raise over 6 years or 7. Of course there are other issues, but the raise is the main sticking point over how many years. Im disgusted with both sides |
|
Posted 7/9/14 3:08 PM
|
|
|
LIRR Strike Question My husbands best friend works for lirr and he said they definitely will strike but then they will be forced back to work after a day or two by the presidents board |
|
Posted 7/9/14 3:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by ave1024 Posted by Mill188 Right now it takes the average LIRR worker 5 years to get up to 100% of their pay grade. So they get hired as say a station cleaner and are told the salary is say $40K a year (made up number) - the first year they will only make say $32K (80% of their salary); the next year $34K, etc. until they reach 100% of their salary. The MTA wants to extend that amount of time for each individual union by 2 years. The MTA wants to abolish night differential pay. Try finding someone who wants to work the 2:30 am train from Penn without offering an incentive. I wouldn't do it. The MTA wants to abolish incentives for achieving additional certifications. What difference does the above really make? In your example it really doesn't matter if the base pay is 40k and takes you 5 years to get there. The fact is you are being hired at 32k and the employee should realize that the 32k is his salary. That is the number that would go on other job applications. That is the number that gets reported to the IRS. As far as finding somebody who wants to work a 2:30am train, the last time I looked there are plenty of people that are unemployed that would more than happy take that job to put food on the table for their family. Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. I have to agree. There are a ton of people that would love to take these jobs for less pay/ less benefits in a heart beat. It would be better for the public (lower prices) to hire all new people for less $ and no pension. The service is a crap shoot as it is, these guys really have no have sympathy from the public. It will be tough/ impossible for commuters and for the companies that will be short staffed if this strike happens. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 3:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 By it's definition, a union is a "brotherhood." They can't sell out their future members for the benefit of the current members. but its ok to pass that along to me, the rider? Does everyone know that 75% of the money raised by tickets is for the pension? Look, I'm not anti union (not a big fan, but not anti). but you know what? pay for yourself. And yes, maybe the future DOES have to pay a little more than the people working today. I don't see anything wrong with that, union or not. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 3:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Posted by CookiePuss The other issue being reported as a road block is what new employees would pay towards their health care. Imagine you and I got hired at the same company. We make the same amount of money. If you go over and above your job duties, and I do the bare minimum, we get paid the same amount, no bonuses, etc. It doesn't matter that your job performance is exemplary and mine is just average. Now imagine I started one day before you. I pay 1% of my salary to my health insurance, you pay 2%. We get paid the same exact amount, you might possibly be doing a better job, but I actually make more money. By it's definition, a union is a "brotherhood." They can't sell out their future members for the benefit of the current members. That actually happened to me at a job. I was on the job for 6 months and new hires were getting starting salaries higher then mine with mine to move up to theirs at the end of a year. I went and found a new job. I don't think there is anything wrong with changing things for future members..Lots of private companies do it and have done it. Pensions have been eliminated for new hires even though old timers have it. Benefit payment structure changes - it is what happens. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 3:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Millie3 Posted by ave1024 Posted by Mill188 Right now it takes the average LIRR worker 5 years to get up to 100% of their pay grade. So they get hired as say a station cleaner and are told the salary is say $40K a year (made up number) - the first year they will only make say $32K (80% of their salary); the next year $34K, etc. until they reach 100% of their salary. The MTA wants to extend that amount of time for each individual union by 2 years. The MTA wants to abolish night differential pay. Try finding someone who wants to work the 2:30 am train from Penn without offering an incentive. I wouldn't do it. The MTA wants to abolish incentives for achieving additional certifications. What difference does the above really make? In your example it really doesn't matter if the base pay is 40k and takes you 5 years to get there. The fact is you are being hired at 32k and the employee should realize that the 32k is his salary. That is the number that would go on other job applications. That is the number that gets reported to the IRS. As far as finding somebody who wants to work a 2:30am train, the last time I looked there are plenty of people that are unemployed that would more than happy take that job to put food on the table for their family. Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. I have to agree. There are a ton of people that would love to take these jobs for less pay/ less benefits in a heart beat. It would be better for the public (lower prices) to hire all new people for less $ and no pension. The service is a crap shoot as it is, these guys really have no have sympathy from the public. It will be tough/ impossible for commuters and for the companies that will be short staffed if this strike happens. Is it at all possible to do to MTA what Reagan did with the PATCO strike in the 80's? |
|
Posted 7/9/14 3:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by CookiePuss Posted by Mill188 Posted by CookiePuss The other issue being reported as a road block is what new employees would pay towards their health care. Imagine you and I got hired at the same company. We make the same amount of money. If you go over and above your job duties, and I do the bare minimum, we get paid the same amount, no bonuses, etc. It doesn't matter that your job performance is exemplary and mine is just average. Now imagine I started one day before you. I pay 1% of my salary to my health insurance, you pay 2%. We get paid the same exact amount, you might possibly be doing a better job, but I actually make more money. By it's definition, a union is a "brotherhood." They can't sell out their future members for the benefit of the current members. That actually happened to me at a job. I was on the job for 6 months and new hires were getting starting salaries higher then mine with mine to move up to theirs at the end of a year. I went and found a new job. I don't think there is anything wrong with changing things for future members..Lots of private companies do it and have done it. Pensions have been eliminated for new hires even though old timers have it. Benefit payment structure changes - it is what happens. I agree with this. If I had started my job a couple of months earlier, my company's 401k contribution would be much better than it is. I also took a substantial hit to my compensation in 2009 and have yet to get close to where I was yet my health care contributions haven't stopped going up over those same years. But alas, things change... it sucks but that's life... doesnt mean you should get to essentially hold all of LI hostage until your demands are met |
|
Posted 7/9/14 3:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by CookiePuss Posted by Millie3 Posted by ave1024 Posted by Mill188 Right now it takes the average LIRR worker 5 years to get up to 100% of their pay grade. So they get hired as say a station cleaner and are told the salary is say $40K a year (made up number) - the first year they will only make say $32K (80% of their salary); the next year $34K, etc. until they reach 100% of their salary. The MTA wants to extend that amount of time for each individual union by 2 years. The MTA wants to abolish night differential pay. Try finding someone who wants to work the 2:30 am train from Penn without offering an incentive. I wouldn't do it. The MTA wants to abolish incentives for achieving additional certifications. What difference does the above really make? In your example it really doesn't matter if the base pay is 40k and takes you 5 years to get there. The fact is you are being hired at 32k and the employee should realize that the 32k is his salary. That is the number that would go on other job applications. That is the number that gets reported to the IRS. As far as finding somebody who wants to work a 2:30am train, the last time I looked there are plenty of people that are unemployed that would more than happy take that job to put food on the table for their family. Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. I have to agree. There are a ton of people that would love to take these jobs for less pay/ less benefits in a heart beat. It would be better for the public (lower prices) to hire all new people for less $ and no pension. The service is a crap shoot as it is, these guys really have no have sympathy from the public. It will be tough/ impossible for commuters and for the companies that will be short staffed if this strike happens. Is it at all possible to do to MTA what Reagan did with the PATCO strike in the 80's? Could be possible. I think it's very telling that no one is willing to step in at this point. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 3:35 PM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Paramount Posted by Mill188 By it's definition, a union is a "brotherhood." They can't sell out their future members for the benefit of the current members. but its ok to pass that along to me, the rider? Does everyone know that 75% of the money raised by tickets is for the pension? Look, I'm not anti union (not a big fan, but not anti). but you know what? pay for yourself. And yes, maybe the future DOES have to pay a little more than the people working today. I don't see anything wrong with that, union or not. And just to bring up a point, in the NYPD the pension system changed for FUTURE members. At the time my DH started it was 20 years to a pension. Now, for new recruits, it's 25 years. Changes had to be made because the city could not afford to keep doing things the way they were. So that stuff about "brotherhood" and selling out future members is BS IMO. It's been done in unions before.... Message edited 2014-07-09 15:43:06.577000. |
Posted 7/9/14 3:35 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by CookiePuss Posted by Millie3 Posted by ave1024 Posted by Mill188 Right now it takes the average LIRR worker 5 years to get up to 100% of their pay grade. So they get hired as say a station cleaner and are told the salary is say $40K a year (made up number) - the first year they will only make say $32K (80% of their salary); the next year $34K, etc. until they reach 100% of their salary. The MTA wants to extend that amount of time for each individual union by 2 years. The MTA wants to abolish night differential pay. Try finding someone who wants to work the 2:30 am train from Penn without offering an incentive. I wouldn't do it. The MTA wants to abolish incentives for achieving additional certifications. What difference does the above really make? In your example it really doesn't matter if the base pay is 40k and takes you 5 years to get there. The fact is you are being hired at 32k and the employee should realize that the 32k is his salary. That is the number that would go on other job applications. That is the number that gets reported to the IRS. As far as finding somebody who wants to work a 2:30am train, the last time I looked there are plenty of people that are unemployed that would more than happy take that job to put food on the table for their family. Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. I have to agree. There are a ton of people that would love to take these jobs for less pay/ less benefits in a heart beat. It would be better for the public (lower prices) to hire all new people for less $ and no pension. The service is a crap shoot as it is, these guys really have no have sympathy from the public. It will be tough/ impossible for commuters and for the companies that will be short staffed if this strike happens. Is it at all possible to do to MTA what Reagan did with the PATCO strike in the 80's? But what would that solve. Reagan fired all the employees that did nto return to work. If that were to happen we would be without train service for a much longer time. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 3:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by alli3131 But what would that solve. Reagan fired all the employees that did nto return to work. If that were to happen we would be without train service for a much longer time. I would think that the employee would would return to work/vote against a strike. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 3:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Mill188 Posted by ave1024 Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. It's not a 17% guaranteed raise over "5" years. At this point, it's a "raise" over 2 years. Four years of it is in back pay....if the MTA negotiated the contract 4 years ago it would be in raises. Right there is one of the reasons NYS is in trouble financially. They need to fix problems as they arise: from Nassau County's antiquated system of assessment and refunding of tax over payments to not dealing with expired contracts until the 11th hour. I work in the private sector. I had a pay cut back in 2009. I haven't had a raise since 2011. I can leave if I'm not happy - and so can the LIRR workers. I'm not saying that the unions are right or wrong. I just find the entire thing completely stupid. Where I work we were without a contract for many years. We didn't get a raise for those years. We settled for a 6 year contract. 3 ( I think) years of it were already done because of the years we were without out contract. We don't see any type of raise until the 4th year. It's 1% and then another percent the next year and 1.5% the last year. Being without a contract doesn't guarantee you get a raise for the years you are without contract. Yes, if your union negotiates a raise for the years that have already passed, it's backpay.. but, it's a still a raise. ETA: 17% even over 6 years is A LOT! I am a teacher and we got 3.5% over 6 years. So not even the ever hated teachers are getting that. Do you realize how much 17% is? Message edited 2014-07-09 16:10:55.530000. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 4:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by alli3131 Posted by CookiePuss Posted by Millie3 Posted by ave1024 Posted by Mill188 Right now it takes the average LIRR worker 5 years to get up to 100% of their pay grade. So they get hired as say a station cleaner and are told the salary is say $40K a year (made up number) - the first year they will only make say $32K (80% of their salary); the next year $34K, etc. until they reach 100% of their salary. The MTA wants to extend that amount of time for each individual union by 2 years. The MTA wants to abolish night differential pay. Try finding someone who wants to work the 2:30 am train from Penn without offering an incentive. I wouldn't do it. The MTA wants to abolish incentives for achieving additional certifications. What difference does the above really make? In your example it really doesn't matter if the base pay is 40k and takes you 5 years to get there. The fact is you are being hired at 32k and the employee should realize that the 32k is his salary. That is the number that would go on other job applications. That is the number that gets reported to the IRS. As far as finding somebody who wants to work a 2:30am train, the last time I looked there are plenty of people that are unemployed that would more than happy take that job to put food on the table for their family. Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. I have to agree. There are a ton of people that would love to take these jobs for less pay/ less benefits in a heart beat. It would be better for the public (lower prices) to hire all new people for less $ and no pension. The service is a crap shoot as it is, these guys really have no have sympathy from the public. It will be tough/ impossible for commuters and for the companies that will be short staffed if this strike happens. Is it at all possible to do to MTA what Reagan did with the PATCO strike in the 80's? But what would that solve. Reagan fired all the employees that did nto return to work. If that were to happen we would be without train service for a much longer time. They would return to work immediately, unless they are independently wealthy. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 4:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by CookiePuss Posted by Mill188 Posted by CookiePuss The other issue being reported as a road block is what new employees would pay towards their health care. Imagine you and I got hired at the same company. We make the same amount of money. If you go over and above your job duties, and I do the bare minimum, we get paid the same amount, no bonuses, etc. It doesn't matter that your job performance is exemplary and mine is just average. Now imagine I started one day before you. I pay 1% of my salary to my health insurance, you pay 2%. We get paid the same exact amount, you might possibly be doing a better job, but I actually make more money. By it's definition, a union is a "brotherhood." They can't sell out their future members for the benefit of the current members. That actually happened to me at a job. I was on the job for 6 months and new hires were getting starting salaries higher then mine with mine to move up to theirs at the end of a year. I went and found a new job. I don't think there is anything wrong with changing things for future members..Lots of private companies do it and have done it. Pensions have been eliminated for new hires even though old timers have it. Benefit payment structure changes - it is what happens. Even the NYS retirement system has tiers. The Tier one people have an insane deal. The newest hires are much worse off. It all depends on what tier was in place when you get hired. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 4:13 PM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Millie3 Posted by alli3131 Posted by CookiePuss Posted by Millie3 Posted by ave1024 Posted by Mill188 Right now it takes the average LIRR worker 5 years to get up to 100% of their pay grade. So they get hired as say a station cleaner and are told the salary is say $40K a year (made up number) - the first year they will only make say $32K (80% of their salary); the next year $34K, etc. until they reach 100% of their salary. The MTA wants to extend that amount of time for each individual union by 2 years. The MTA wants to abolish night differential pay. Try finding someone who wants to work the 2:30 am train from Penn without offering an incentive. I wouldn't do it. The MTA wants to abolish incentives for achieving additional certifications. What difference does the above really make? In your example it really doesn't matter if the base pay is 40k and takes you 5 years to get there. The fact is you are being hired at 32k and the employee should realize that the 32k is his salary. That is the number that would go on other job applications. That is the number that gets reported to the IRS. As far as finding somebody who wants to work a 2:30am train, the last time I looked there are plenty of people that are unemployed that would more than happy take that job to put food on the table for their family. Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. I have to agree. There are a ton of people that would love to take these jobs for less pay/ less benefits in a heart beat. It would be better for the public (lower prices) to hire all new people for less $ and no pension. The service is a crap shoot as it is, these guys really have no have sympathy from the public. It will be tough/ impossible for commuters and for the companies that will be short staffed if this strike happens. Is it at all possible to do to MTA what Reagan did with the PATCO strike in the 80's? But what would that solve. Reagan fired all the employees that did nto return to work. If that were to happen we would be without train service for a much longer time. They would return to work immediately, unless they are independently wealthy. There is also something called the Taylor Law which imposes fines of up to $1000 a day on employees who strike. However, it does not apply here I assume. Taylor Law |
Posted 7/9/14 4:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by Pumpkin1 Posted by alli3131 But what would that solve. Reagan fired all the employees that did nto return to work. If that were to happen we would be without train service for a much longer time. I would think that the employee would would return to work/vote against a strike. But it didn't work back in the 80s....the ATC still stayed out and I think the same would happen now. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 4:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question I am really hoping that there is not. DH and I are staying at my in-laws for a week to watch the dog on LI and DH has said that he will have to take a bus to the subway and leave almost an hour and a half earlier to allow additional time if the buses aren't running on schedule. I would help out by driving to the subway him here and there, but on the days that I'm subbing it won't be possible. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 4:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: LIRR Strike Question Posted by NervousNell Posted by Millie3 Posted by alli3131 Posted by CookiePuss Posted by Millie3 Posted by ave1024 Posted by Mill188 Right now it takes the average LIRR worker 5 years to get up to 100% of their pay grade. So they get hired as say a station cleaner and are told the salary is say $40K a year (made up number) - the first year they will only make say $32K (80% of their salary); the next year $34K, etc. until they reach 100% of their salary. The MTA wants to extend that amount of time for each individual union by 2 years. The MTA wants to abolish night differential pay. Try finding someone who wants to work the 2:30 am train from Penn without offering an incentive. I wouldn't do it. The MTA wants to abolish incentives for achieving additional certifications. What difference does the above really make? In your example it really doesn't matter if the base pay is 40k and takes you 5 years to get there. The fact is you are being hired at 32k and the employee should realize that the 32k is his salary. That is the number that would go on other job applications. That is the number that gets reported to the IRS. As far as finding somebody who wants to work a 2:30am train, the last time I looked there are plenty of people that are unemployed that would more than happy take that job to put food on the table for their family. Sorry but the union gets no sympathy from me. A 17% guaranteed raise over 5 years regardless of your job performance seems very generous to me. Many people in the private sector don't even get raises and some get pay cuts. This entire situation is a joke. I have to agree. There are a ton of people that would love to take these jobs for less pay/ less benefits in a heart beat. It would be better for the public (lower prices) to hire all new people for less $ and no pension. The service is a crap shoot as it is, these guys really have no have sympathy from the public. It will be tough/ impossible for commuters and for the companies that will be short staffed if this strike happens. Is it at all possible to do to MTA what Reagan did with the PATCO strike in the 80's? But what would that solve. Reagan fired all the employees that did nto return to work. If that were to happen we would be without train service for a much longer time. They would return to work immediately, unless they are independently wealthy. There is also something called the Taylor Law which imposes fines of up to $1000 a day on employees who strike. However, it does not apply here I assume. Taylor Law Taylor Law doesn't apply to LIRR! |
|
Posted 7/9/14 5:59 PM
|
|
|
LIRR Strike Question The whole thing is just ridiculous. There is no reason why there needs to be unions to decide pay and benefits. It should always be merit based and employees who get raises that are not merit have no incentive to do better (of course there are exceptions to the rule). I have no issue with there being a union of some sort to regulate safety procedures but other than that, there is no reason for it. They should disband the union and just put in a safety board. Let the workers earn their raises when they deserve one just like the rest of private sector. And my dad and ex husband work/ed for the LIRR. Union talk was not allowed in our houses as we have very different opinions on them. As far as striking, I don't think the average LIRR worker wants to strike because they loose pay. They want it resolved just like everyone else. I would love to take a look at the MTA management budget though and weed through all the excess money they are wasting on their level. The whole system needs to be privatized and run by people who make it beneficial to all, workers and riders alike. |
|
Posted 7/9/14 6:31 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silly Indecisive Question About LIRR | Jesaroo | 10/15/06 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| LIRR question - Ronkonkoma Line | SweetTooth | 8/30/06 | 16 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| LIRR...Service Question | Ang-Rich | 4/20/06 | 18 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| LIRR monthly ticket question | Shelly | 11/2/05 | 8 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| LIRR question... | Myrockette | 6/21/05 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Question about the LIRR? | preciouslove | 6/6/05 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |









