Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Just another debate topic...

With 50% of marriages ending in divorce, the DoMA, gay marriage, etc, is marriage as it currently exists, a worthwhile institution?

Could we just have two or more people living together, and sign some legal documents giving access to hospital visits, death benefits, etc, etc. if they wanted?

(It's not really a Relationships topic, since it's more about legal contracts of adults who want to associate with each other)

Message edited 2011-10-19 09:21:04.933000.

Posted 10/19/11 9:20 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

caps612
In love with my little guys!!

Member since 8/10

5108 total posts

Name:

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Not that I am super religious, but I think more people see it as a religious and spiritual thing and it is a sacrament. I don't think everyone sees it as a "legal" thing!

Posted 10/19/11 9:30 AM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by caps612

Not that I am super religious, but I think more people see it as a religious and spiritual thing and it is a sacrament. I don't think everyone sees it as a "legal" thing!



I was going to say the same thing.

Posted 10/19/11 9:35 AM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Clearly it's worthwhile. So many people still value it...

Posted 10/19/11 9:37 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by Mrs213

Clearly it's worthwhile. So many people still value it...



but with a 50% divorce rate, is the current institution actually worthwhile, or can/should it be modified to make it work better somehow?

Posted 10/19/11 9:42 AM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by Mrs213

Clearly it's worthwhile. So many people still value it...



but with a 50% divorce rate, is the current institution actually worthwhile, or can/should it be modified to make it work better somehow?



Maybe its not the institution of marriage that needs to be modified. Maybe it is the people entering the marriage that need to modify their understanding of marriage.

Posted 10/19/11 9:46 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

It depends on context to me.

If you're highly religious, then it becomes a religious thing.

If you're not religious, it's a legal thing.

There are two very separate, unique types of marriage: legal and religious.

I can get married by a minister without being legally married.

I can be married by a judge without being religiously married.

Divorce is almost always a legal issue.

Most people don't go back to their religious leader and ask for a divorce, but almost all go to a judge.

I don't think many of us work hard enough at our marriages.

Message edited 2011-10-19 09:50:40.653000.

Posted 10/19/11 9:49 AM
 

Bella01
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

3708 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Message edited 2011-10-19 09:49:59.723000.

Posted 10/19/11 9:49 AM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by Mrs213

Clearly it's worthwhile. So many people still value it...



but with a 50% divorce rate, is the current institution actually worthwhile, or can/should it be modified to make it work better somehow?



I dont think it's the institution that needs changing, it's people's attitudes. Nobody wants to work things out these days...

Posted 10/19/11 9:51 AM
 

Bella01
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

3708 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by neener1211

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by Mrs213

Clearly it's worthwhile. So many people still value it...



but with a 50% divorce rate, is the current institution actually worthwhile, or can/should it be modified to make it work better somehow?



Maybe its not the institution of marriage that needs to be modified. Maybe it is the people entering the marriage that need to modify their understanding of marriage.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/19/11 9:52 AM
 

femalej
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/11

833 total posts

Name:

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by Mrs213

Clearly it's worthwhile. So many people still value it...



but with a 50% divorce rate, is the current institution actually worthwhile, or can/should it be modified to make it work better somehow?



better somehow? like what? making it easier to dissolve the relationship? i don't really get the question.

if two people are okay with not getting married, they can live together. and some insurances provide for this too.

but marriage is supposed to be a lifelong commitment and it should be valued as such.

if the people entering the marriage don't place the value on the commitment and the work (yes, work, ::gasp::) that may be involved, then should marriage be blamed? perhaps its a false sense of what that means. if people think everything will be happy-go-lucky once you say "i do," then that thought process is flawed.

it is for better or worse. sickness and health. etc. etc.

Posted 10/19/11 9:52 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by Mrs213

Clearly it's worthwhile. So many people still value it...



but with a 50% divorce rate, is the current institution actually worthwhile, or can/should it be modified to make it work better somehow?



First, I *personally* think marriage is a VERY worthwhile institution for a multitude of reasons.

That being said, a marriage is only as strong and as worthwhile as what the two people who are together put into it.

When one (or both people) become complacent and stop working towards their relationship that's when things go wrong. That's when people lose interest, or seek out others, or cheat. You can't check out of your relationship, you need to be present all the time and show your spouse respect and love as much as you can. Everyone wants to feel valued, it's when someone doesn't feel valued anymore that problems arise.

I also don't think there is one perfect way to be in order for a marriage to work because truth is, what works for one may not work for another. I see plenty of marriages where the relationship is ENTIRELY different than my own but it works for them and those people are very happily married.

The only thing that I think that needs to be in every HAPPY marriage is a mutual respect for one another. If you don't respect the person you're with including respecting their beliefs, feelings, ideas, interests, etc. then I think it's likely marital problems will arise.





Posted 10/19/11 10:01 AM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

I believe it's worthwhile, but I also value my marriage more then anything other then my children. I think the problem comes into play when people don't have a full understanding of what marriage is really about.
People go into a marriage over-romanticizing what their lives will be like. And when it doesn't measure up, they give up before giving 100% effort. Or they use imperfection as an excuse/reason to cheat.
Then I believe there are many divorces that come to be from relationships that were never solid to begin with. It's like people think marriage will fix all of their existing problems, meanwhile nothing could be further from the truth. Your problems only get get amplified and more numerous after marriage- mortgage, kids, bills, health issues, etc...
And just for the record, I don't believe that all divorces fall into these two categories. I know there are plenty of situations where people can simply grow apart.

Posted 10/19/11 10:02 AM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by Mrs213

I dont think it's the institution that needs changing, it's people's attitudes. Nobody wants to work things out these days...



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon


Very much agree.

I've seen so many people who get married because they think it's the "next step" or something and don't truly understand or put thought into how marriage is not just something you do, it's something that you should believe in and put your whole heart into.

I've known friends who had the mentality of "well if it doesn't work out, there's always divorce."

I truly believe in marriage and I think it's a wonderful institution that I value immensely.

Posted 10/19/11 10:08 AM
 

Michi
My Love

Member since 5/05

31600 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by neener1211

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by Mrs213

Clearly it's worthwhile. So many people still value it...



but with a 50% divorce rate, is the current institution actually worthwhile, or can/should it be modified to make it work better somehow?



Maybe its not the institution of marriage that needs to be modified. Maybe it is the people entering the marriage that need to modify their understanding of marriage.



DING DING DING! ita!!

Posted 10/19/11 10:09 AM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

I absolutely think it's worthwhile. I think that for religious/spiritual people, there's the force of a religious/spiritual bond. I think for non-religious/non-spiritual people, there's the force of a legal bond.

I'm pretty sure that the 50% statistic is inaccurate though. I know that I've read that in the past, and the United States Census Bureau backs that up.

If you Google "50% of marriages end in divorce myth," a number of sources pop up. I don't have time to read through them all now, but it seems that the general idea is that the 50% figure is about 30 years old, and divorces have declined in this century.

Message edited 2011-10-19 10:38:42.657000.

Posted 10/19/11 10:20 AM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by tarabelle99

It depends on context to me.

If you're highly religious, then it becomes a religious thing.

If you're not religious, it's a legal thing.

There are two very separate, unique types of marriage: legal and religious.




I was thinking this, as well, but now I'm not so sure. I don't consider myself religious by any means, but I still consider marriage something more than a contract, KWIM? It's a partnership and that has nothing to do with religion or the law in my eyes. But yes, I absolutely think that marriage is a worthwhile social institution. Besides, with the way the economy is going, it's nearly impossible to be financially independent. People are going to start getting married just so they can split their bills, share health insurance, and get a tax break. Not that they don't do that already. Chat Icon

Posted 10/19/11 10:35 AM
 

tink23
Step by step....

Member since 6/11

1061 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by neener1211

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by Mrs213

Clearly it's worthwhile. So many people still value it...



but with a 50% divorce rate, is the current institution actually worthwhile, or can/should it be modified to make it work better somehow?



Maybe its not the institution of marriage that needs to be modified. Maybe it is the people entering the marriage that need to modify their understanding of marriage.



Chat Icon I couldn't agree more!!

Posted 10/19/11 11:09 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

What does DOMA Chat Icon and gay marriage (We need a rainbow flag icon!ok..how about Chat Icon Chat Icon ?) Have to do with whether marriage is a worthwhile institution?

Seems like two different questions to me.

I value marriage. Many people do. I agree with the PP who said marriages don't work because people enter them with the wrong attitudes, expectations, etc.

On the subject of gay marriage. How I would solve this debate is that the government gives out civil unions to everyone, male-female, female-female, male-male. It's up to the officiant to create the "marriage". Two separate things. Religious marriage, civil union. It basically is that way. For example, we had to fill out a marriage licesne certificate when we got married ALONG WITH a marriage certificate for the church AND a ketubah. So we had 3 different documents- The state of NY, The Catholic Church, and the jewish faith. It should just be like that. Two different documents. That way the state is in no way participating in or interfering in religious observances. They can't tell the Catholic Church that they have to give marriages to gay people, and they can't tell a Reform Rabbi that he can't. The state sets the rules for civil unions which define legal rights and benefits, and the religious authorities set the rules for religious marriage. Done and Done.

Posted 10/19/11 11:17 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by tarabelle99

It depends on context to me.

If you're highly religious, then it becomes a religious thing.

If you're not religious, it's a legal thing.

There are two very separate, unique types of marriage: legal and religious.




I was thinking this, as well, but now I'm not so sure. I don't consider myself religious by any means, but I still consider marriage something more than a contract, KWIM? It's a partnership and that has nothing to do with religion or the law in my eyes. But yes, I absolutely think that marriage is a worthwhile social institution. Besides, with the way the economy is going, it's nearly impossible to be financially independent. People are going to start getting married just so they can split their bills, share health insurance, and get a tax break. Not that they don't do that already. Chat Icon



I agree with you, but my views don't seem to echo society's. People don't work hard enough at their marriages and divorce has become just another thing to do for many people I know. There's not sticking by people through thick and thin. It's OK well, we don't love each other anymore so we're getting divorced. People need to start thinking before they say "I DO"

Posted 10/19/11 11:19 AM
 

ItsTime2011
Meh...

Member since 1/11

2148 total posts

Name:

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by neener1211


Maybe its not the institution of marriage that needs to be modified. Maybe it is the people entering the marriage that need to modify their understanding of marriage.



*DING DING DING* This is the issue. It's so easy to just get married and get divorced. I am not saying that everyone who has been divorced has done so without seriously weighing the issues (myself included). I never got into it thinking "well if it doesn't work out - we'll just get divorced. No biggie!"

I got out of my first marriage because it was physically damaging me, other than that I was determined to work it out. It just wasn't safe anymore. I am not in my current marriage with the mindset that if it doesn't work out we will divorce. It is not an option (unless abusive). Marriage is hard and, like anything good and worthy in life, it should be. Committing to be with one person for the rest of your life should be something that you continually work at.

Posted 10/19/11 11:37 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

The ability to legally care for and sustain another .. I think that should be given. I’ll take it a step farther than just gay marriage…

I want to add my father to my plan. I would WILLINGLY pay triple the premiums I pay now, if I could include my father on my health plan. More so, if I had been able to insure my grandmother back in the days before she died because her doctors chose the cheaper path of service.

What about my brother? He’s unable to care for himself in most ways but it’s a competent and legally independent adult. For now. What happens if I need to care for him? I am not going to marry my brother am I?

I am one of those who sees the uninsured everyday. They are my family. I have insurance and I would love to include them in my coverage.

I understand the costs associated with such an endeavor. I understand the fear of the insurance companies that would have all their decades long actuarial information tossed out the window. And the domino affect that would occur…

I don’t care who you are. I don’t care who you want to marry. I don’t even care if you want to marry more than one or all of some. I am not judging you or your decisions in life.

If you are going to pay into the system, why not shouldn’t you be able to use the resources? And if you do both of those are you directly affecting me?

Other than that, who cares? I can legally bequeath my meager possessions and assets to whoever I want. I can make my boss my legal medical advisor, I can do all of that without marriage. Question is.. WHY do they want to get married? Because you don’t marriage for love, financial assets or most legal causes.

Maybe I’m missing something. But frankly, I don’t care. Get married, get divorced, keep them divorce lawyers happy and rich (part of the 99% LOL).

As far as God is concerned.. I figure let him figure it out later. Never was my place to stand in this place and judge others. I certainly wouldnt want the job, either!

Meh.

Posted 10/19/11 12:59 PM
 

NASP09
...

Member since 6/05

6030 total posts

Name:

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by neener1211

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by Mrs213

Clearly it's worthwhile. So many people still value it...



but with a 50% divorce rate, is the current institution actually worthwhile, or can/should it be modified to make it work better somehow?



Maybe its not the institution of marriage that needs to be modified. Maybe it is the people entering the marriage that need to modify their understanding of marriage.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/19/11 1:02 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Actually the rate is more than 50%. Like 59% from what I have read.

For both legal and religious purposes, it is worth it.

And plenty of divorced people do get remarried and the rated for 2nd marriage divorce is not as high as 1st marriages.

Also it is important to remember that 60-70 years ago, it was frowned upon to be divorced for a woman. Seen as a failure. Women were really just starting to enter the work force. A lot being SAHM dependent on their DH for support. Women turned their head to infidility, being abused, etc... You just shut up and keep the appareances.

As women became more independent, speaking up for themselves, the stress of life requiring more than 1 income, technology to catch emails from cheating DH/DW, etc.. The rate raised.

I don't think people cheat more now than 50 years ago. People are just not taking the $hit anymore and willing to break up the marriage contract.

Posted 10/19/11 1:17 PM
 

hazeleyes33
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

13060 total posts

Name:
Ginger

Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?

Posted by Mrs213

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by Mrs213

Clearly it's worthwhile. So many people still value it...



but with a 50% divorce rate, is the current institution actually worthwhile, or can/should it be modified to make it work better somehow?



I dont think it's the institution that needs changing, it's people's attitudes. Nobody wants to work things out these days...



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/19/11 1:27 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2