|
Re: Is marriage a worthwhile social institution?
Posted 10/19/2011 11:17:21 AM by JenniferEver What does DOMA and gay marriage (We need a rainbow flag icon!ok..how about ?) Have to do with whether marriage is a worthwhile institution?Seems like two different questions to me. I value marriage. Many people do. I agree with the PP who said marriages don't work because people enter them with the wrong attitudes, expectations, etc. On the subject of gay marriage. How I would solve this debate is that the government gives out civil unions to everyone, male-female, female-female, male-male. It's up to the officiant to create the "marriage". Two separate things. Religious marriage, civil union. It basically is that way. For example, we had to fill out a marriage licesne certificate when we got married ALONG WITH a marriage certificate for the church AND a ketubah. So we had 3 different documents- The state of NY, The Catholic Church, and the jewish faith. It should just be like that. Two different documents. That way the state is in no way participating in or interfering in religious observances. They can't tell the Catholic Church that they have to give marriages to gay people, and they can't tell a Reform Rabbi that he can't. The state sets the rules for civil unions which define legal rights and benefits, and the religious authorities set the rules for religious marriage. Done and Done. |