If you support public education...
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by justbeachy Math teacher here. (Well, I was until I gave birth. Now I'm at home) I taught pre and post CC. CC Math, in theory is great. Deepen a child's conceptual knowledge! Make them really understand WHY percents, fractions, decimals are related and how to interchange them! Explain and show WHAT division means, etc. And I too, support some level of standardized testing. I personally won't have my daughter opt out of testing, because she will face testing for the rest of her life and she needs to be accustomed to those practices associated with standardized testing. However, I do not support the proposed reforms, and I do not support the CC in its current form and state. I liken the new CC math program to a rewiring of a kid's brain wires. You are making them 'think' in a completely different fashion. Perhaps in a generation or two, CC will make more sense as by that time those parents will be accustomed to the 'new' way of learning and can help their kids. But my BIGGEST issue with common core right now is that they are allowing kids to ONLY answer in 1 method. Do you know what that does to anxious students who are grounded in their understanding of pre-CC methods!? Or those students who have special needs and can only do math in a traditional way? What frustrated me the most was marking a student WRONG for answering a math problem in a method that differed from the CC curriculum. Terrible. Students arte frustrated. Students are beginning to hate school and learning! I've seen anxieties go through the roof. And for what? This latest educational experiment that we're observing? This new fad method that in a decade will be thrown out for something different?! I won't dive into the related teacher tenure issue, as I feel like there are many people on LIF who have slightly jaded and negative opinions on teachers. However, I will give those people in particular something to think about. This proposed reform will make the socioeconomic CRISIS our schools are facing even worse. The traditionally high performing school districts (usually associated with the wealthiest districts) will be minimally affected by this reform (in terms of teacher turn over). Their students will continue to perform, so those teachers will stay put. But what about those teachers who are exceptional but teach in underperforming (and traditionally more diverse/less affluent) districts? Will those teachers risk staying there if their future depends on their students' performance? Students who haven't eaten breakfast, haven't bathed, haven't had parental supervision, etc? I believe that we will see teacher turnover rise, with many decent teachers leaving for private schools, parochial schools, or the private sector. I'd be very concerned if I lived in one of those districts. Love this!!! Your last paragraph says it all!!! |
|
Posted 3/26/15 8:46 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by beachgirl Thank you for replying. I hate the common core method - cannot understand it...always revert back to my way of understanding things and how I was thought. However my DD who is a third grader seems to get it. She understands it. Her teacher explains it to her and she gets it. So while I dont and I think that my way makes more sense do I really have a leg to stand on to show me that the way my DD is being taught and what he is learning is not the right way? Do you see what I mean. I dont know. I would really love to hear from teachers on here who have been teaching before common core and now during common core and if they could expand on this and tell us how its affecting their classroom on a day to day basis. I am really trying to get in under this from every angle to fully understand it. TIA I am a teacher and I appreciate your questions and interest in the situation! To me, it's not so much about common core as it is about the state tests. They are 2 separate issues to me. The ideas behind common core are not bad ones. The intention is to raise standards for what children are learning and to make sure children in all parts of the country are leaving school with the same knowledge. I don't have a problem with any of that. In fact, I think it's a good idea. My issue is with the state tests. The state tests are based on common core but from what I have seen, they are extremely difficult and are manipulated by the state education department and Pearson. They make the tests, administer the tests, score the tests and then decide what constitutes passing. Several years ago, they changed what constituted passing on the ELA after too many kids were passing. Last year, they predicted that 30% of children would pass the ELA statewide and shockingly only 30% did. So, my issue is with how the tests are already being misused and how they will continue to be misused. Good teachers will lose their jobs because of the performance of their students on one or two state tests. Education is not going to improve for children if teachers are either losing their jobs or worried about losing their jobs and feel forced to teach to a test. There are better ways to assess student progress and growth as well as better ways to reform tenure. In my opinion, Cuomo is playing on people's issues with teachers in order to break the unions and save the state money. It's all about money for him, not children. |
|
Posted 3/26/15 8:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education...
|
|
Posted 3/26/15 9:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... nm Message edited 2015-03-26 22:59:06.157000. |
|
Posted 3/26/15 10:21 PM
|
|
|
If you support public education... Can't write much on a phone but... As a teacher, I hate cc And I hate the tests. My bright kids are missing out on art, research, creativity, problem solving, creative writing, enrichment, etc because we have to prepare them to spend over 8 hours next month testing . Think 8 hours is a lot? If your child is in special ed, they will get to spend roughly 13 hours testing. Rather than learning new material, we are teaching them how to answer the questions properly. I'm bored, they're bored, it's utterly pathetic. Message edited 2015-03-26 22:34:59.660000. |
|
Posted 3/26/15 10:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by MissJones Can't write much on a phone but... As a teacher, I hate cc And I hate the tests. My bright kids are missing out on art, research, creativity, problem solving, creative writing, enrichment, etc because we have to prepare them to spend over 8 hours next month testing . Think 8 hours is a lot? If your child is in special ed, they will get to spend roughly 13 hours testing. Rather than learning new material, we are teaching them how to answer the questions properly. I'm bored, they're bored, it's utterly pathetic. Don't get me wrong. I believe in holding high standards. But reasonable ones. I think teachers need to be held accountable. But much of the problems that deal with poor academic success do NOT begin with school. They begin at home. Absolutely!
|
|
Posted 3/26/15 11:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by cj7305 Posted by MissJones Can't write much on a phone but... As a teacher, I hate cc And I hate the tests. My bright kids are missing out on art, research, creativity, problem solving, creative writing, enrichment, etc because we have to prepare them to spend over 8 hours next month testing . Think 8 hours is a lot? If your child is in special ed, they will get to spend roughly 13 hours testing. Rather than learning new material, we are teaching them how to answer the questions properly. I'm bored, they're bored, it's utterly pathetic. Don't get me wrong. I believe in holding high standards. But reasonable ones. I think teachers need to be held accountable. But much of the problems that deal with poor academic success do NOT begin with school. They begin at home. Absolutely! Yes! |
|
Posted 3/27/15 12:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by justbeachy Math teacher here. (Well, I was until I gave birth. Now I'm at home) I taught pre and post CC. CC Math, in theory is great. Deepen a child's conceptual knowledge! Make them really understand WHY percents, fractions, decimals are related and how to interchange them! Explain and show WHAT division means, etc. And I too, support some level of standardized testing. I personally won't have my daughter opt out of testing, because she will face testing for the rest of her life and she needs to be accustomed to those practices associated with standardized testing. However, I do not support the proposed reforms, and I do not support the CC in its current form and state. I liken the new CC math program to a rewiring of a kid's brain wires. You are making them 'think' in a completely different fashion. Perhaps in a generation or two, CC will make more sense as by that time those parents will be accustomed to the 'new' way of learning and can help their kids. But my BIGGEST issue with common core right now is that they are allowing kids to ONLY answer in 1 method. Do you know what that does to anxious students who are grounded in their understanding of pre-CC methods!? Or those students who have special needs and can only do math in a traditional way? What frustrated me the most was marking a student WRONG for answering a math problem in a method that differed from the CC curriculum. Terrible. Students arte frustrated. Students are beginning to hate school and learning! I've seen anxieties go through the roof. And for what? This latest educational experiment that we're observing? This new fad method that in a decade will be thrown out for something different?! I won't dive into the related teacher tenure issue, as I feel like there are many people on LIF who have slightly jaded and negative opinions on teachers. However, I will give those people in particular something to think about. This proposed reform will make the socioeconomic CRISIS our schools are facing even worse. The traditionally high performing school districts (usually associated with the wealthiest districts) will be minimally affected by this reform (in terms of teacher turn over). Their students will continue to perform, so those teachers will stay put. But what about those teachers who are exceptional but teach in underperforming (and traditionally more diverse/less affluent) districts? Will those teachers risk staying there if their future depends on their students' performance? Students who haven't eaten breakfast, haven't bathed, haven't had parental supervision, etc? I believe that we will see teacher turnover rise, with many decent teachers leaving for private schools, parochial schools, or the private sector. I'd be very concerned if I lived in one of those districts. I agree but that second paragraph, I just want to add. I was that kid who got things wrong for not doing it the ONE WAY that everyone here calls 'traditional'. The Traditional to me was stupid and overly complicated and so black and white that I felt I was constantly having to RELEARN how to do math and learning new formulas to memorize without knowing why the math worked. It wasn't until I got higher up it made sense. I HATED MATH Because it was always THEIR WAY is the ONLY way. Ironically I always scored very highly in math because on tests with scan sheets.. I didn't have to show my work.. with that, I was free to ace tests. class work and home work nearly sunk me. To me, that hasn't changed. As an adult. I still do math my way but have learned from long ago to 'double check' all my math their way or the old way. Even in Excel I create formulas to double check math because I'm so used to be forced to show my work the 'old way' to get credit. You can do math anyway you want if the answer's right but show your work their way or lose credit. Dumb but not new. ETA: AJ is doing CC Math. At first anything 'common core' turned me off.. then I saw it. I saw WHAT she was doing. My hubby is lost but I 'see' it. So after she's in bed I show him "this is the building blocks to algebra.. Look" and its so strange I have to slow down and show him piece by piece. Now I'm a fan. This early learning in this format will serve her VERY well in the future. I remember kids freaking about letters in math.. x+1=5... because it a letter? My 1st grader can figure that out. Letters are place holders she says. You can always flip the sign (plus or minus) rewrite the problem to find it. YES! Its the same math, just told so it makes sense for later (to me). Message edited 2015-03-27 10:30:51.397000. |
|
Posted 3/27/15 10:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by DaisyGirl I am a teacher and I appreciate your questions and interest in the situation! To me, it's not so much about common core as it is about the state tests. They are 2 separate issues to me. The ideas behind common core are not bad ones. The intention is to raise standards for what children are learning and to make sure children in all parts of the country are leaving school with the same knowledge. I don't have a problem with any of that. In fact, I think it's a good idea. My issue is with the state tests. The state tests are based on common core but from what I have seen, they are extremely difficult and are manipulated by the state education department and Pearson. I agree with this strongly. I have concerns that the anti-test camp is doing too much lumping together of CC and tests when I see them as separate. I was a teacher, had CC training in ELA, gave CC training, and have done a lot of work with it as a contractor/freelancer. The ELA standards are solid, in my professional opinion. I was a little distressed to see literature taking more of a back seat but the reality is, whatever your child does after high school will require him or her to deal with informational text, so we need to focus on it more. I do think the interpretative part is getting lost and some of the content is over the heads of the kids, and it should have been rolled out differently for the older kids. But we do need to raise the bar and I think CC does that. I do struggle with DD's math work but she is getting it, and I trust her teacher who is smart and professional. I am not sure what to do about dead wood teachers but using tests won't cut it. Pearson, Bill Gates, etc, need to get out of education. It should not be about money. I am against the tests and will be opting my child out next year when she goes to 3rd grade. |
|
Posted 3/27/15 10:59 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by jessnbrian I am one person who does believe that education needs to change in this country. I'm ashamed that our educational system fails so many children each year. But it's not a matter of test scores, nor is it truly a matter of "bad teachers". It's a socioeconomic issue that has roots that are deeper than "bad tenured teachers". You can put the best teacher in the world in a classroom of failing students who don't have support systems at home or at school, and I'm sorry, but that teacher is also going to have a poor outcome. I don't want my child's education to be dictated by the corporate bigwigs who create the textbooks. I want EDUCATIONAL PROFESSIONALS to be creating the curriculum for my children. Cuomo is an A$$. He should be ashamed to deny schools funding based on test scores and teacher evaluations Message edited 2015-03-27 11:07:26.650000. |
|
Posted 3/27/15 11:05 AM
|
|
|
If you support public education... How else are we going to be certain that all kids get a solid education and that poor teachers, and there are those, get either retraining or moved out? |
|
Posted 3/27/15 12:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... I really think people have such a misconception of what tenure really is! It is the right to a fair trial. It doesn't guarantee a job. |
|
Posted 3/27/15 2:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by sunnyflies How else are we going to be certain that all kids get a solid education and that poor teachers, and there are those, get either retraining or moved out? I'd like to eliminate tenure. No other jobs have such protection. Bad teachers hide behind it and their unions protect them. Tenure does not mean a teacher automatically gets to retain their job even if they are terrible. It just means they are entitled to due process if they are not doing their job. In my opinion, administrators need to be honest and truthful in their evaluations of bad teachers. I also have no problem making changes to the tenure process or the ability of teachers to be let go. I do have concerns about eliminating tenure entirely. I would be concerned that good teachers who stand up for students would be targeted. Don't forget- districts have a bottom line. Teachers feel free to speak up to administrators and fight for what the children need even if the administrators don't like it. If you get rid of tenure, I think you impact a teachers ability to do so. To answer your first question, I think we have to have fair assessments that are made public as well as other methods of assessing the growth of children. Reading levels and writing samples are additional ways the progress of children can be measured. |
|
Posted 3/27/15 5:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by sunnyflies How else are we going to be certain that all kids get a solid education and that poor teachers, and there are those, get either retraining or moved out? I'd like to eliminate tenure. No other jobs have such protection. Bad teachers hide behind it and their unions protect them. One of the biggest reasons teachers have tenure is so that they can advocate for their students without getting by bullied administration, which is still hard to avoid even when you do have tenure. Just a thought Message edited 2015-03-27 20:23:35.160000. |
|
Posted 3/27/15 8:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by sunnyflies How else are we going to be certain that all kids get a solid education and that poor teachers, and there are those, get either retraining or moved out? I'd like to eliminate tenure. No other jobs have such protection. Bad teachers hide behind it and their unions protect them. I'm just confused, I understand the need for reform but how does using 1 test score to come up with 50 % of a teachers APPR score make sense? Especially when the test is hardly a reflection of what the child actually knows. The readability of these tests are grade levels above the grade of the students testing (for example the 3rd grade test has passages between the 6th & 7th grade reading level!). Just like children, teachers need to be evaluated fairly and over time and in numerous ways. Putting so much weight on ANY one thing is absurd and leads to an absolutely skewed view of the individual. Oh and there is no way to guarantee that every child will receive a solid education because you are taking family life, socioeconomic status, home support, etc. out of the equation. So yes, teachers should absolutely do all they can for EVERY child in their class, but once that child leaves their classroom, many other factors affect who the are as learners. THESE are the issues our governor needs to focus on. |
|
Posted 3/27/15 9:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by Xelindrya I agree but that second paragraph, I just want to add. I was that kid who got things wrong for not doing it the ONE WAY that everyone here calls 'traditional'. The Traditional to me was stupid and overly complicated and so black and white that I felt I was constantly having to RELEARN how to do math and learning new formulas to memorize without knowing why the math worked. It wasn't until I got higher up it made sense. I HATED MATH Because it was always THEIR WAY is the ONLY way. Ironically I always scored very highly in math because on tests with scan sheets.. I didn't have to show my work.. with that, I was free to ace tests. class work and home work nearly sunk me. To me, that hasn't changed. As an adult. I still do math my way but have learned from long ago to 'double check' all my math their way or the old way. Even in Excel I create formulas to double check math because I'm so used to be forced to show my work the 'old way' to get credit. You can do math anyway you want if the answer's right but show your work their way or lose credit. Dumb but not new. ETA: AJ is doing CC Math. At first anything 'common core' turned me off.. then I saw it. I saw WHAT she was doing. My hubby is lost but I 'see' it. So after she's in bed I show him "this is the building blocks to algebra.. Look" and its so strange I have to slow down and show him piece by piece. Now I'm a fan. This early learning in this format will serve her VERY well in the future. I remember kids freaking about letters in math.. x+1=5... because it a letter? My 1st grader can figure that out. Letters are place holders she says. You can always flip the sign (plus or minus) rewrite the problem to find it. YES! Its the same math, just told so it makes sense for later (to me). Just as a point of clarification. Before CC, my students executed their work in whichever way was best for them. I taught multiplication and division in a variety of ways (traditional, lattice, models, blocks, on graph paper, etc...). As long as students could show how they arrived at the answer, they received credit. This is not true today. CC wants work done in a specific manner. Frustrating to those who don't learn in that specific manner (much like your own experience with math). |
|
Posted 3/27/15 9:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by justbeachy Posted by Xelindrya I agree but that second paragraph, I just want to add. I was that kid who got things wrong for not doing it the ONE WAY that everyone here calls 'traditional'. The Traditional to me was stupid and overly complicated and so black and white that I felt I was constantly having to RELEARN how to do math and learning new formulas to memorize without knowing why the math worked. It wasn't until I got higher up it made sense. I HATED MATH Because it was always THEIR WAY is the ONLY way. Ironically I always scored very highly in math because on tests with scan sheets.. I didn't have to show my work.. with that, I was free to ace tests. class work and home work nearly sunk me. To me, that hasn't changed. As an adult. I still do math my way but have learned from long ago to 'double check' all my math their way or the old way. Even in Excel I create formulas to double check math because I'm so used to be forced to show my work the 'old way' to get credit. You can do math anyway you want if the answer's right but show your work their way or lose credit. Dumb but not new. ETA: AJ is doing CC Math. At first anything 'common core' turned me off.. then I saw it. I saw WHAT she was doing. My hubby is lost but I 'see' it. So after she's in bed I show him "this is the building blocks to algebra.. Look" and its so strange I have to slow down and show him piece by piece. Now I'm a fan. This early learning in this format will serve her VERY well in the future. I remember kids freaking about letters in math.. x+1=5... because it a letter? My 1st grader can figure that out. Letters are place holders she says. You can always flip the sign (plus or minus) rewrite the problem to find it. YES! Its the same math, just told so it makes sense for later (to me). Just as a point of clarification. Before CC, my students executed their work in whichever way was best for them. I taught multiplication and division in a variety of ways (traditional, lattice, models, blocks, on graph paper, etc...). As long as students could show how they arrived at the answer, they received credit. This is not true today. CC wants work done in a specific manner. Frustrating to those who don't learn in that specific manner (much like your own experience with math). This drives me INSANE. Not everyone thinks the same way. I hate that they want them to use certain strategies to solve various problems. Hate it. Get the answer in any way you know how. That is what we do as adults so why should children not be given the same freedom. Ridiculous. Message edited 2015-03-27 21:53:01.810000. |
|
Posted 3/27/15 9:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by MrsProfessor Posted by DaisyGirl I am a teacher and I appreciate your questions and interest in the situation! To me, it's not so much about common core as it is about the state tests. They are 2 separate issues to me. The ideas behind common core are not bad ones. The intention is to raise standards for what children are learning and to make sure children in all parts of the country are leaving school with the same knowledge. I don't have a problem with any of that. In fact, I think it's a good idea. My issue is with the state tests. The state tests are based on common core but from what I have seen, they are extremely difficult and are manipulated by the state education department and Pearson. I agree with this strongly. I have concerns that the anti-test camp is doing too much lumping together of CC and tests when I see them as separate. I was a teacher, had CC training in ELA, gave CC training, and have done a lot of work with it as a contractor/freelancer. The ELA standards are solid, in my professional opinion. I was a little distressed to see literature taking more of a back seat but the reality is, whatever your child does after high school will require him or her to deal with informational text, so we need to focus on it more. I do think the interpretative part is getting lost and some of the content is over the heads of the kids, and it should have been rolled out differently for the older kids. But we do need to raise the bar and I think CC does that. I do struggle with DD's math work but she is getting it, and I trust her teacher who is smart and professional. I am not sure what to do about dead wood teachers but using tests won't cut it. Pearson, Bill Gates, etc, need to get out of education. It should not be about money. I am against the tests and will be opting my child out next year when she goes to 3rd grade. I agree word for word !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My problem is not CC as I've stated time and time again. My problem is the testing. |
|
Posted 3/28/15 7:53 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by sunnyflies How else are we going to be certain that all kids get a solid education and that poor teachers, and there are those, get either retraining or moved out? I'd like to eliminate tenure. No other jobs have such protection. Bad teachers hide behind it and their unions protect them. If a teacher gets an ineffective rating two years in a row, their job is in jeopardy regardless of tenure. This is NOT a tenure issue. |
|
Posted 3/28/15 7:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Sad day for public education today. Absolutely disgusting. |
|
Posted 3/30/15 8:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by MrsProfessor I have concerns that the anti-test camp is doing too much lumping together of CC and tests when I see them as separate. I was a teacher, had CC training in ELA, gave CC training, and have done a lot of work with it as a contractor/freelancer. The ELA standards are solid, in my professional opinion. I was a little distressed to see literature taking more of a back seat but the reality is, whatever your child does after high school will require him or her to deal with informational text, so we need to focus on it more. I do think the interpretative part is getting lost and some of the content is over the heads of the kids, and it should have been rolled out differently for the older kids. But we do need to raise the bar and I think CC does that. I do struggle with DD's math work but she is getting it, and I trust her teacher who is smart and professional. I am not sure what to do about dead wood teachers but using tests won't cut it. Pearson, Bill Gates, etc, need to get out of education. It should not be about money. I agree with all this. I think having a universal set of learning standards is a good thing. I don't think teachers should be told HOW to get their students there. Teach in whatever way makes it happen, whatever way works. I was undecided on the tests until I read that the thresholds for passing (cut scores) were decided AFTER students took the test AND that different states have different cut scores. Makes no sense- if Common Core's purpose is to make sure every American student has a solid and "equal" foundation- then they should all be graded the same way. Message edited 2015-03-31 16:08:14.953000. |
|
Posted 3/31/15 4:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by kahlua716 Posted by MrsProfessor I have concerns that the anti-test camp is doing too much lumping together of CC and tests when I see them as separate. I was a teacher, had CC training in ELA, gave CC training, and have done a lot of work with it as a contractor/freelancer. The ELA standards are solid, in my professional opinion. I was a little distressed to see literature taking more of a back seat but the reality is, whatever your child does after high school will require him or her to deal with informational text, so we need to focus on it more. I do think the interpretative part is getting lost and some of the content is over the heads of the kids, and it should have been rolled out differently for the older kids. But we do need to raise the bar and I think CC does that. I do struggle with DD's math work but she is getting it, and I trust her teacher who is smart and professional. I am not sure what to do about dead wood teachers but using tests won't cut it. Pearson, Bill Gates, etc, need to get out of education. It should not be about money. I agree with all this. I think having a universal set of learning standards is a good thing. I don't think teachers should be told HOW to get their students there. Teach in whatever way makes it happen, whatever way works. I was undecided on the tests until I read that the thresholds for passing (cut scores) were decided AFTER students took the test AND that different states have different cut scores. Makes no sense- if Common Core's purpose is to make sure every American student has a solid and "equal" foundation- then they should all be graded the same way. I am a teacher also and the standards themselves are not terrible. It is how the schools and state want them to be taught that is terrible. I despise the tests. I know I have a stake in it, but they are not developmentally appropriate. I have no idea who writes the questions for the tests, but they are way over most students head. I believe the passing rate for NY State is below 50%. That should raise a red flag. NOT to the teachers but to the test itself. The fifth grade standards states that a child on fifth grade should be reading on a fifth grade to forth grade level texts. Why does the fifth grade tests go up to seventh grade reading passages? Does that make sense to anybody? Today I gave a practice. WE gave the students a 7th grade ELA NY State test from 2008. It is easier than the 5th grade passages we gave to the students last year on their test. If you go to EngageNY you all can find past tests and compare them. The Common Core passages are very difficult now compared to in the past and the questions are ridiculous. We really need to wake up and see what these tests are really measuring. Not only are the tests more difficult, but they got rid of the listening part of the test. There use to be a listening section on the test, that at least my students who have disabilities were successful with. So, they are not even measuring all the ELA standards on top of giving these students passages that are way too difficult with questions that are too difficult. Again, this is not developmentally appropriate. If you want to measure how successful I am, I have no problem giving the kids a test at the beginning of the year and giving them one at the end of the year. However, it has to be at the students' instructional level. I will give you an example. I have a fifth grade student who came into my class not being able to multiply fluently single to double digit numbers. Well, they can now multiply a double and double and almost a triple and double. The fifth grade math test will not show that because they will give them a problem that is 4 digit to a three digit. So, how is growth going to be shown? They only measure the fifth grade standards, not what the student didn't know and now does know. |
|
Posted 3/31/15 7:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: If you support public education... Posted by My2Girlz11 I have a fifth grade student who came into my class not being able to multiply fluently single to double digit numbers. Well, they can now multiply a double and double and almost a triple and double. The fifth grade math test will not show that because they will give them a problem that is 4 digit to a three digit. So, how is growth going to be shown? They only measure the fifth grade standards, not what the student didn't know and now does know. This is a great point! The tests are supposedly graded with a growth model but how can lower students show growth when the concepts are so far above them? It's not testing the skills they are working on. The same could be said for special education students who are working far below grade level yet have to take the same tests as their grade level peers. How are they going to show growth? |
|
Posted 3/31/15 8:03 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Our Public Schools Need Your Support Now | CAMCaps | 3/15/12 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| special education public school teachers | groovypeg | 10/30/10 | 1 | Teachers |
| The Public/Private School Debate Continues | JenniferEver | 8/18/05 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Public Service Announcement | Redhead | 7/31/05 | 107 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| my public apology | luvsbob4603 | 5/22/05 | 16 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Just Wanted to Make a Public THANKS... | AndreaLMT | 5/15/05 | 47 | Families Helping Families ™ |












