Re: If you support public education...
Posted 3/27/2015 10:24:58 AM by Xelindrya
Posted by justbeachy
Math teacher here. (Well, I was until I gave birth. Now I'm at home)
I taught pre and post CC.
CC Math, in theory is great. Deepen a child's conceptual knowledge! Make them really understand WHY percents, fractions, decimals are related and how to interchange them! Explain and show WHAT division means, etc.
And I too, support some level of standardized testing. I personally won't have my daughter opt out of testing, because she will face testing for the rest of her life and she needs to be accustomed to those practices associated with standardized testing.
However, I do not support the proposed reforms, and I do not support the CC in its current form and state.
I liken the new CC math program to a rewiring of a kid's brain wires. You are making them 'think' in a completely different fashion. Perhaps in a generation or two, CC will make more sense as by that time those parents will be accustomed to the 'new' way of learning and can help their kids. But my BIGGEST issue with common core right now is that they are allowing kids to ONLY answer in 1 method. Do you know what that does to anxious students who are grounded in their understanding of pre-CC methods!? Or those students who have special needs and can only do math in a traditional way? What frustrated me the most was marking a student WRONG for answering a math problem in a method that differed from the CC curriculum. Terrible. Students arte frustrated. Students are beginning to hate school and learning! I've seen anxieties go through the roof. And for what? This latest educational experiment that we're observing? This new fad method that in a decade will be thrown out for something different?!
I won't dive into the related teacher tenure issue, as I feel like there are many people on LIF who have slightly jaded and negative opinions on teachers. However, I will give those people in particular something to think about. This proposed reform will make the socioeconomic CRISIS our schools are facing even worse. The traditionally high performing school districts (usually associated with the wealthiest districts) will be minimally affected by this reform (in terms of teacher turn over). Their students will continue to perform, so those teachers will stay put. But what about those teachers who are exceptional but teach in underperforming (and traditionally more diverse/less affluent) districts? Will those teachers risk staying there if their future depends on their students' performance? Students who haven't eaten breakfast, haven't bathed, haven't had parental supervision, etc? I believe that we will see teacher turnover rise, with many decent teachers leaving for private schools, parochial schools, or the private sector. I'd be very concerned if I lived in one of those districts.
I agree but that second paragraph, I just want to add. I was that kid who got things wrong for not doing it the ONE WAY that everyone here calls 'traditional'. The Traditional to me was stupid and overly complicated and so black and white that I felt I was constantly having to RELEARN how to do math and learning new formulas to memorize without knowing why the math worked. It wasn't until I got higher up it made sense. I HATED MATH Because it was always THEIR WAY is the ONLY way. Ironically I always scored very highly in math because on tests with scan sheets.. I didn't have to show my work.. with that, I was free to ace tests. class work and home work nearly sunk me.
To me, that hasn't changed.
As an adult. I still do math my way but have learned from long ago to 'double check' all my math their way or the old way. Even in Excel I create formulas to double check math because I'm so used to be forced to show my work the 'old way' to get credit. You can do math anyway you want if the answer's right but show your work their way or lose credit. Dumb but not new.
ETA: AJ is doing CC Math. At first anything 'common core' turned me off.. then I saw it. I saw WHAT she was doing. My hubby is lost but I 'see' it. So after she's in bed I show him "this is the building blocks to algebra.. Look" and its so strange I have to slow down and show him piece by piece. Now I'm a fan. This early learning in this format will serve her VERY well in the future. I remember kids freaking about letters in math.. x+1=5... because it a letter? My 1st grader can figure that out. Letters are place holders she says. You can always flip the sign (plus or minus) rewrite the problem to find it. YES! Its the same math, just told so it makes sense for later (to me).
|