Re: If you support public education...
Posted 3/31/2015 7:47:39 PM by My2Girlz11


Posted by kahlua716


Posted by MrsProfessor


I have concerns that the anti-test camp is doing too much lumping together of CC and tests when I see them as separate. I was a teacher, had CC training in ELA, gave CC training, and have done a lot of work with it as a contractor/freelancer. The ELA standards are solid, in my professional opinion. I was a little distressed to see literature taking more of a back seat but the reality is, whatever your child does after high school will require him or her to deal with informational text, so we need to focus on it more.

I do think the interpretative part is getting lost and some of the content is over the heads of the kids, and it should have been rolled out differently for the older kids. But we do need to raise the bar and I think CC does that. I do struggle with DD's math work but she is getting it, and I trust her teacher who is smart and professional. I am not sure what to do about dead wood teachers but using tests won't cut it.

Pearson, Bill Gates, etc, need to get out of education. It should not be about money.





I agree with all this.

I think having a universal set of learning standards is a good thing. I don't think teachers should be told HOW to get their students there. Teach in whatever way makes it happen, whatever way works.

I was undecided on the tests until I read that the thresholds for passing (cut scores) were decided AFTER students took the test AND that different states have different cut scores. Makes no sense- if Common Core's purpose is to make sure every American student has a solid and "equal" foundation- then they should all be graded the same way.




I am a teacher also and the standards themselves are not terrible. It is how the schools and state want them to be taught that is terrible.

I despise the tests. I know I have a stake in it, but they are not developmentally appropriate. I have no idea who writes the questions for the tests, but they are way over most students head. I believe the passing rate for NY State is below 50%. That should raise a red flag. NOT to the teachers but to the test itself. The fifth grade standards states that a child on fifth grade should be reading on a fifth grade to forth grade level texts. Why does the fifth grade tests go up to seventh grade reading passages? Does that make sense to anybody? Today I gave a practice. WE gave the students a 7th grade ELA NY State test from 2008. It is easier than the 5th grade passages we gave to the students last year on their test. If you go to EngageNY you all can find past tests and compare them. The Common Core passages are very difficult now compared to in the past and the questions are ridiculous. We really need to wake up and see what these tests are really measuring. Not only are the tests more difficult, but they got rid of the listening part of the test. There use to be a listening section on the test, that at least my students who have disabilities were successful with. So, they are not even measuring all the ELA standards on top of giving these students passages that are way too difficult with questions that are too difficult. Again, this is not developmentally appropriate.

If you want to measure how successful I am, I have no problem giving the kids a test at the beginning of the year and giving them one at the end of the year. However, it has to be at the students' instructional level. I will give you an example. I have a fifth grade student who came into my class not being able to multiply fluently single to double digit numbers. Well, they can now multiply a double and double and almost a triple and double. The fifth grade math test will not show that because they will give them a problem that is 4 digit to a three digit. So, how is growth going to be shown? They only measure the fifth grade standards, not what the student didn't know and now does know.


Print Post      Close Window