God parent spinoff

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

bunnyluck
LIF Adult

Member since 1/14

3196 total posts

Name:

God parent spinoff

My DH and I were talking about god parents the other day for our soon to be born DC.

He wants to ask his brother - who is Jewish...

Is it even possible for a non Christian to be a witness?

We've been going back and forth about this. I would like both godparents to share the same beliefs as our child...My DH is not at all religious and was the 'god father' at his nephews baptism so he doesn't see the big deal...But we are not even sure if his nephew was baptised Roman Catholic and/or if his brother and SIL lied to the church at the time, or if it is allowed.

I guess if the church permits it, I can get off my high horse.






Message edited 2015-02-12 16:27:32.523000.

Posted 2/12/15 4:26 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

God parent spinoff

I think that as long as one of the Godparents is baptized/confirmed in the Catholic church then it is ok if the other is not. But I also thinkthe rules varies by parish - some are stricter than others

Posted 2/12/15 4:30 PM
 

mrsm-2011
He is my world!

Member since 6/12

3009 total posts

Name:
Theresa

Re: God parent spinoff

Yes, but it depends on the church. Some are stricter than others. My cousin's Godfather is Jewish and her Godmother is Catholic.

Posted 2/12/15 4:34 PM
 

JennLala
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/14

601 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

God parent spinoff

Depends on the church. My friend had wanted me to be her youngest son's godmother and her church said no because I was Jewish.

Posted 2/12/15 4:45 PM
 

PaddysGirl
Little princess is here!

Member since 4/07

5923 total posts

Name:
Crystal

Re: God parent spinoff

Posted by chilltocam

I think that as long as one of the Godparents is baptized/confirmed in the Catholic church then it is ok if the other is not. But I also thinkthe rules varies by parish - some are stricter than others



This is correct. It all depends on the Church. My Church required both receive all sacraments but another Church I know allowed just 2 of the 3 Sacraments

Posted 2/12/15 4:58 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

God parent spinoff

Depends on the church specifically.

My nephew was baptized with no issues after a $500 donation from myself to the local church. Paperwork was no longer necessarily all of a sudden. My brother had to become catholic for that event. My nephews godparents - one is catholic, the other is just non denominational Christian.

I've been god parent and I'm agnostic nearly atheist.
For her son, I would (if never the need arose) teach him HER way of religion. This I can do because I see good in all faiths. To be fair, her faith wasn't catholic

My daughter's "godparents" if you want to call them that (because *WE* call them that), are Jewish. But for her its different since my belief doesn't require another person to speak on behalf of myself or my daughter to make such an arrangement. It is just that I trust them to raise my daughter honestly and truthfully about religion as *I* see it. It was well after we found out that my mother's mother was Jewish herself so they now take their godparenting roles very seriously. Actually we make sure to see them each time we are in NY and they try to visit Texas when they can. We adore them!

Posted 2/12/15 4:59 PM
 

MC09
arrrghhh!!!!

Member since 2/09

5674 total posts

Name:
Me speaks pirate!

Re: God parent spinoff

Posted by chilltocam

I think that as long as one of the Godparents is baptized/confirmed in the Catholic church then it is ok if the other is not. But I also thinkthe rules varies by parish - some are stricter than others



This exactly! It varies by church.

Posted 2/12/15 5:18 PM
 

luckysmom
Yes it is! Going as planned:)

Member since 6/07

5339 total posts

Name:

God parent spinoff

Depends in the church. I'm Jewish only because my mom was although I don't follow any religion and they gave me a hard time about being my god daughters god mother. My brother is the same as me and he is my sons god mother. Different church. One of the god parents had to be Catholic and baptized.

Posted 2/12/15 6:08 PM
 

bunnyluck
LIF Adult

Member since 1/14

3196 total posts

Name:

God parent spinoff

Thanks, everyone! Sounds like my best bet is to call my church and see.

Posted 2/12/15 6:29 PM
 

Sparrow
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

6826 total posts

Name:

Re: God parent spinoff

I don't see the point of having a Godparent of a totally different faith. Their role is to teach the child how to live in the Catholic faith but I guess if the church is ok with it, then who am I to say otherwise.

Posted 2/12/15 7:07 PM
 

VickiC
Rocking the party

Member since 5/05

4937 total posts

Name:
Vicki

God parent spinoff

As someone who worked in a church rectory for many years, NO a Jewish person cannot be a Godparent to a Catholic. Judaism does not believe the same things at all that a Catholic does and the role of of a God parent to help raise a child in the chosen faith. A Jewish person cannot do that as they believe something completely different.

Posted 2/12/15 7:55 PM
 

bunnyluck
LIF Adult

Member since 1/14

3196 total posts

Name:

Re: God parent spinoff

Posted by Sparrow

I don't see the point of having a Godparent of a totally different faith. Their role is to teach the child how to live in the Catholic faith but I guess if the church is ok with it, then who am I to say otherwise.



My thoughts exactly...

Posted 2/12/15 10:25 PM
 

bunnyluck
LIF Adult

Member since 1/14

3196 total posts

Name:

Re: God parent spinoff

Posted by VickiC

As someone who worked in a church rectory for many years, NO a Jewish person cannot be a Godparent to a Catholic. Judaism does not believe the same things at all that a Catholic does and the role of of a God parent to help raise a child in the chosen faith. A Jewish person cannot do that as they believe something completely different.



I know they cannot be a "godparent" but how about a "witness" who stands next to the godmother but isn't put on documentation? It seems that's where the rules get fuzzy.

Posted 2/12/15 10:28 PM
 

LuckyStar
LIF Adult

Member since 7/14

7274 total posts

Name:

Re: God parent spinoff

Posted by VickiC

As someone who worked in a church rectory for many years, NO a Jewish person cannot be a Godparent to a Catholic. Judaism does not believe the same things at all that a Catholic does and the role of of a God parent to help raise a child in the chosen faith. A Jewish person cannot do that as they believe something completely different.



What if one parent is Jewish?

Posted 2/12/15 10:47 PM
 

VickiC
Rocking the party

Member since 5/05

4937 total posts

Name:
Vicki

Re: God parent spinoff

Posted by bunnyluck

Posted by VickiC

As someone who worked in a church rectory for many years, NO a Jewish person cannot be a Godparent to a Catholic. Judaism does not believe the same things at all that a Catholic does and the role of of a God parent to help raise a child in the chosen faith. A Jewish person cannot do that as they believe something completely different.



I know they cannot be a "godparent" but how about a "witness" who stands next to the godmother but isn't put on documentation? It seems that's where the rules get fuzzy.



A "witness" is still put on documentation. If a person is Lutheran or Protestant, they are known as Christian Witness and noted as such in the books. If you are standing up there with the parents, you are documented.

Posted 2/13/15 8:12 AM
 

VickiC
Rocking the party

Member since 5/05

4937 total posts

Name:
Vicki

Re: God parent spinoff

Posted by LuckyStar

Posted by VickiC

As someone who worked in a church rectory for many years, NO a Jewish person cannot be a Godparent to a Catholic. Judaism does not believe the same things at all that a Catholic does and the role of of a God parent to help raise a child in the chosen faith. A Jewish person cannot do that as they believe something completely different.



What if one parent is Jewish?



For lack of a better phrase, a parent being Jewish doesn't count, so to speak, since you don't choose your parents. The burden of teaching the Catholic faith falls to the Catholic parent since they are choosing Catholicism for their child. Which makes the choice of Godparents even more important.

Posted 2/13/15 8:16 AM
 

noworlater
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

1528 total posts

Name:
Now!

Re: God parent spinoff

If YOUR church allows it, please allow it, the meaning of godparents varies by belief, church and person but if your church is ok with it, and it's your church then i assume you are OK with your church's beliefs. Most need just one godparent / witness of same religion.

I was asked to be god parent to my nephew but church said no. I'm Christian but not catholic. It broke my heart. I would have been a great god mother.

Posted 2/13/15 8:18 AM
 

jlm2008
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

5092 total posts

Name:

Re: God parent spinoff

Posted by bunnyluck

Posted by Sparrow

I don't see the point of having a Godparent of a totally different faith. Their role is to teach the child how to live in the Catholic faith but I guess if the church is ok with it, then who am I to say otherwise.



My thoughts exactly...



I don't get it either, what is the point? The are supposed to be your spiritual guides in the Catholic faith. To each their own I guess.

Posted 2/13/15 10:54 AM
 

MrsM84
LIF Adult

Member since 2/13

2352 total posts

Name:

God parent spinoff

This is why I plan on not having a religious ceremony but instead something very simple and generic with immediate family -- a "celebration of life", if you will. All of these rules and regulations are absurd. You should be able to pick whoever you want to be your child's moral/spiritual/ethical/whatever you want to call it compass. SIL wanted her brother (my DH) and their other brother to be the godparents to her first daughter. No godmother, just 2 godfathers. Both are Catholic and received all the sacraments in the church. Church said no because it was 2 men. Ridiculous.

Message edited 2015-02-13 12:12:40.333000.

Posted 2/13/15 12:06 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: God parent spinoff

Not sure if this is parish by parish or a rule but MY parish said that the whole point of a godparent is to help guide the childs religious journey and to help teach them their faith which is impossible unless the person is Catholic so they would not allow it. I happen to agree with this.

Posted 2/13/15 12:14 PM
 

oldtimerocknroll
LIF Adult

Member since 11/14

1657 total posts

Name:

Re: God parent spinoff

Posted by MrsM84

This is why I plan on not having a religious ceremony but instead something very simple and generic with immediate family -- a "celebration of life", if you will. All of these rules and regulations are absurd. You should be able to pick whoever you want to be your child's moral/spiritual/ethical/whatever you want to call it compass. SIL wanted her brother (my DH) and their other brother to be the godparents to her first daughter. No godmother, just 2 godfathers. Both are Catholic and received all the sacraments in the church. Church said no because it was 2 men. Ridiculous.



Of course you are allowed to pick whomever you wish to be a moral/spiritual/ethical compass, but a godparent in the Catholic church has a specific definition. A godparent is different from a role model, moral influence, etc.

You're saying that you aren't having a baptism, but complaining that your DH couldn't be a godfather. A person not raising his or her children as Catholics does not fulfill the definition of a godparent in the Catholic church. It encompasses, but is not exclusively limited to, those roles.

While I do not agree with all of the church's teachings and practices, I completely agree with them having rules about godparents. The role is, IMO, taken too lightly.

Message edited 2015-02-13 12:21:34.677000.

Posted 2/13/15 12:19 PM
 

JDubs
different, not less

Member since 7/09

13160 total posts

Name:

Re: God parent spinoff

Each church is different. My church one godparent had to be catholic and the other could have only been christian if not catholic.

Posted 2/13/15 12:20 PM
 

MrsM84
LIF Adult

Member since 2/13

2352 total posts

Name:

Re: God parent spinoff

Posted by oldtimerocknroll

Posted by MrsM84

This is why I plan on not having a religious ceremony but instead something very simple and generic with immediate family -- a "celebration of life", if you will. All of these rules and regulations are absurd. You should be able to pick whoever you want to be your child's moral/spiritual/ethical/whatever you want to call it compass. SIL wanted her brother (my DH) and their other brother to be the godparents to her first daughter. No godmother, just 2 godfathers. Both are Catholic and received all the sacraments in the church. Church said no because it was 2 men. Ridiculous.



Of course you are allowed to pick whomever you wish to be a moral/spiritual/ethical compass, but a godparent in the Catholic church has a specific definition. A godparent is different from a role model, moral influence, etc.

You're saying that you aren't having a baptism, but complaining that your DH couldn't be a godfather. A person not raising his or her children as Catholics does not fulfill the definition of a godparent in the Catholic church. It encompasses, but is not exclusively limited to, those roles.

While I do not agree with all of the church's teachings and practices, I completely agree with them having rules about godparents. The role is, IMO, taken too lightly.



First off, I'm not complaining. DH was in fact selected to be the godfather. I think the fact that the church wouldn't allow 2 men to be godparents is upsetting/ridiculous/silly, both of whom are Catholic. I also don't believe that you have to baptize your child to raise them Catholic. You can still raise a child with a certain religion's teachings/morals/beliefs in mind without going through the organized/official ceremonies. That comment will probably open a bag of worms here, but its my opinion.

Message edited 2015-02-13 12:28:54.017000.

Posted 2/13/15 12:25 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: God parent spinoff

Posted by MrsM84

Posted by oldtimerocknroll

Posted by MrsM84

This is why I plan on not having a religious ceremony but instead something very simple and generic with immediate family -- a "celebration of life", if you will. All of these rules and regulations are absurd. You should be able to pick whoever you want to be your child's moral/spiritual/ethical/whatever you want to call it compass. SIL wanted her brother (my DH) and their other brother to be the godparents to her first daughter. No godmother, just 2 godfathers. Both are Catholic and received all the sacraments in the church. Church said no because it was 2 men. Ridiculous.



Of course you are allowed to pick whomever you wish to be a moral/spiritual/ethical compass, but a godparent in the Catholic church has a specific definition. A godparent is different from a role model, moral influence, etc.

You're saying that you aren't having a baptism, but complaining that your DH couldn't be a godfather. A person not raising his or her children as Catholics does not fulfill the definition of a godparent in the Catholic church. It encompasses, but is not exclusively limited to, those roles.

While I do not agree with all of the church's teachings and practices, I completely agree with them having rules about godparents. The role is, IMO, taken too lightly.



First off, I'm not complaining. DH was in fact selected to be the godfather. I think the fact that the church wouldn't allow 2 men to be godparents is upsetting/ridiculous/silly, both of whom are Catholic. I also don't believe that you have to baptize your child to raise them Catholic. You can still raise a child with a certain religion's teachings/morals/beliefs in mind without going through the organized/official ceremonies. That comment will probably open a bag of worms here, but its my opinion.



My DD has two godmothers, one technically served as a "witness" bc in the Catholic faith there is only one god parent in the book anyway. I had to put up a fight and my argument was that they are two practicing Catholic who would be guiding DD's faith and I won that fight.

If you are not Catholic though then iMO you should not be a godparent bc you cant teach a child something you don't believe in.

Posted 2/13/15 12:30 PM
 

mbg1007
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1247 total posts

Name:

Re: God parent spinoff

my BIL is jewish and SIl is catholic, my husband, who is jewish, was the godfather at the baptism of his nephew (and also at the bris). The godmother at the baptism was catholic. Whether or not he was a "witness" on paper, during the ceremony he did what all the other godfathers did, although I have to say he wasnt told beforehand what he would be saying/doing and he was a little uncomfortable so just fill in your godparents on what it entails so they are comfortable as well.

Message edited 2015-02-13 13:55:56.187000.

Posted 2/13/15 1:55 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
God parent gifts? For baptism? JaimeLee11 4/22/14 15 Parenting
Do you have to give God Parent Gifts??? ckone 9/5/09 4 Parenting
God Parent ?? BeachMom 4/3/09 8 Pregnancy
Very dumb question about a God-Parent picture frame- opinions needed Bops 3/13/09 6 Parenting
In a god-parent pickle ..... Bops 2/10/09 31 Parenting
God Parent Gift littlejoy06 4/24/07 0 Pregnancy