Re: God parent spinoff
Posted 2/13/2015 12:30:45 PM by DiamondGirl


Posted by MrsM84


Posted by oldtimerocknroll


Posted by MrsM84

This is why I plan on not having a religious ceremony but instead something very simple and generic with immediate family -- a "celebration of life", if you will. All of these rules and regulations are absurd. You should be able to pick whoever you want to be your child's moral/spiritual/ethical/whatever you want to call it compass. SIL wanted her brother (my DH) and their other brother to be the godparents to her first daughter. No godmother, just 2 godfathers. Both are Catholic and received all the sacraments in the church. Church said no because it was 2 men. Ridiculous.



Of course you are allowed to pick whomever you wish to be a moral/spiritual/ethical compass, but a godparent in the Catholic church has a specific definition. A godparent is different from a role model, moral influence, etc.

You're saying that you aren't having a baptism, but complaining that your DH couldn't be a godfather. A person not raising his or her children as Catholics does not fulfill the definition of a godparent in the Catholic church. It encompasses, but is not exclusively limited to, those roles.

While I do not agree with all of the church's teachings and practices, I completely agree with them having rules about godparents. The role is, IMO, taken too lightly.



First off, I'm not complaining. DH was in fact selected to be the godfather. I think the fact that the church wouldn't allow 2 men to be godparents is upsetting/ridiculous/silly, both of whom are Catholic. I also don't believe that you have to baptize your child to raise them Catholic. You can still raise a child with a certain religion's teachings/morals/beliefs in mind without going through the organized/official ceremonies. That comment will probably open a bag of worms here, but its my opinion.



My DD has two godmothers, one technically served as a "witness" bc in the Catholic faith there is only one god parent in the book anyway. I had to put up a fight and my argument was that they are two practicing Catholic who would be guiding DD's faith and I won that fight.

If you are not Catholic though then iMO you should not be a godparent bc you cant teach a child something you don't believe in.
Print Post      Close Window