God parent spinoff

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

Sparrow
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

6826 total posts

Name:

Re: God parent spinoff

Posted by oldtimerocknroll

Posted by MrsM84

This is why I plan on not having a religious ceremony but instead something very simple and generic with immediate family -- a "celebration of life", if you will. All of these rules and regulations are absurd. You should be able to pick whoever you want to be your child's moral/spiritual/ethical/whatever you want to call it compass. SIL wanted her brother (my DH) and their other brother to be the godparents to her first daughter. No godmother, just 2 godfathers. Both are Catholic and received all the sacraments in the church. Church said no because it was 2 men. Ridiculous.



Of course you are allowed to pick whomever you wish to be a moral/spiritual/ethical compass, but a godparent in the Catholic church has a specific definition. A godparent is different from a role model, moral influence, etc.

You're saying that you aren't having a baptism, but complaining that your DH couldn't be a godfather. A person not raising his or her children as Catholics does not fulfill the definition of a godparent in the Catholic church. It encompasses, but is not exclusively limited to, those roles.

While I do not agree with all of the church's teachings and practices, I completely agree with them having rules about godparents. The role is, IMO, taken too lightly.



I completely agree with this. Many people have no understanding of what the role is and use it inappropriately.

Posted 2/13/15 2:40 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MamaPapaBear
my little girl

Member since 1/11

2045 total posts

Name:
my whole world

Re: God parent spinoff

I wanted to have people of faith for my DD's Godparents. However, there is no one we are close with who are religious. So we chose my brother and his wife, because they have the closest family values and beliefs as we do…even though they are Agnostic.

As long as you are comfortable with it, and the church allows it….just do what feels right.

But I do agree that the point of a Godparent is to help guide the child's spirituality.

Posted 2/13/15 6:57 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
God parent gifts? For baptism? JaimeLee11 4/22/14 15 Parenting
Do you have to give God Parent Gifts??? ckone 9/5/09 4 Parenting
God Parent ?? BeachMom 4/3/09 8 Pregnancy
Very dumb question about a God-Parent picture frame- opinions needed Bops 3/13/09 6 Parenting
In a god-parent pickle ..... Bops 2/10/09 31 Parenting
God Parent Gift littlejoy06 4/24/07 0 Pregnancy