Family Dilema

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5

Annie91606
Brotherly love

Member since 12/07

1816 total posts

Name:
Anne

Re: Family Dilema

I am sorry that you are caught in the middle here.Chat Icon

It sounds to me like this is not the first time your Dad witnessed DH yelling at you or talking to you in a disrespectful way. So he just snapped and said something this time. Normally, I don't agree with others stepping in between an argument between two spouses. But, if someone is being bullied, then maybe someone should stick up for them.

BTW, your nagging him was NO excuse for him to talk to you that way. It didn't sound like you were nagging anyway. You kept asking him and he put you off, and it was about something important. It wasn't like you were pestering him about some crumbs on the counter.

Since DH is wrong, I would not take his side against your Dad. I would continue to talk to/and see my Dad as normal. I would also have a chat with my DH about how he talks to me. You don't deserve to be treated like that!!!!Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/12 1:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Onemoretime
LIF Adult

Member since 9/12

1077 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by Diane

I dont even know if I should call my dad, or what to say, or just let him come over. DH would probably just stay aout of the house.
DH says that he will still come over and sit on my couch and not say anything to rub it in his face.
I just hate this. I am at work now and have to teach, and I cant stop crying. I am embarased to say, I dont even know what to say to my dad when I call him laterChat Icon
My inlaws didnt say anything.
Thanks for listening
Chat Icon



Really? Is your DH 5? I'm sorry for being rude and blunt but if he can't man up and face your dad and resorts to making snide remarks that your dad wants to "rub it in his face" by coming over, instead of the truth which is that he would be coming over to see his family, then you've got bigger problems than just this argument.



Yeah sounds like you have bigger issues. If my sons dw's yelled at them in front of me ( in the future) I would say something as well. How can you not?

Posted 9/19/12 1:29 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Family Dilema

I agree with the others who say your DH is 100% in the wrong. If he had an issue with your nagging, he could have ignored it or spoken with you privately - not yell at you in front of everyone.
From what I can piece together from your posts, it sounds like this is somewhat of a regular occurrence. I do not blame your dad one bit for standing up to you.
I also think if this is a regular thing, maybe your DH needs to seek some help in dealing with his anger.

Posted 9/19/12 1:39 PM
 

ourlivesstartnow2012
New Year, New Everything!

Member since 6/12

2689 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

I have to say that both were wrong in this situation.

You're husband didn't have to yell at you in front of everyone. Even if you are nagging him there is a time and place to voice what you have to say. He could have easily said "not now, we'll talk about this at home".

And while your dad was just protecting his daughter, he should have stayed out of it (although I can DEF see why he said something). You might have to have a talk with your dad about staying out of your marriage. If he has a problem with something, he should speak to you about it afterwards.

I think there needs to be a lot of apologies going on. Your dad should apologize to your DH, your DH should apologize to you, and you should apologize to your DH.

I'm not sure a lot of women will agree with me that you have to apologize but you were nagging him and your dad did get involved. While it was with good intentions on both accounts I would imagine that everyone needs to apologize for peace and harmony again.

Posted 9/19/12 1:39 PM
 

Gdesq
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

1314 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by LisaW

I think your dad is AWESOME for standing up for you Chat Icon

Your DH should be mortified for speaking to you like that- especially in front of your parents

He should be begging both you and your dad for forgiveness- and if not- YOU should be PISSED at HIM





This 100%!

Posted 9/19/12 2:01 PM
 

pnbplus1
Family

Member since 5/09

5751 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Family Dilema

I definitely do not think your dad needs to apologize to your DH for anything. If anything, your DH needs to apologize to you and tell your dad that he (your DH) can understand why your dad was upset and why in turn he got upset. I'm not sure he needs to apologize to your dad unless your DH was disrespectful to him, if so, then an apology to him also.

Your DH should not be yelling at you and most definitely not in front of other people. Of course yelling between couples happens, none of us is perfect, but I think that when around others we should all try to NOT yell at our DH and vice versa.

Now, your dad was just protecting you as can be expected. Should he have stayed quiet, probably. I think his instinct was just to stand up for you bc your are his DD but when parents get involved, it just makes things so difficult. I think you should talk to your dad and actually thank him for trying to protect you and standing up for you, but also tell him that you think it would be better if he didn't make a comment during the incident but instead maybe talked to you/your DH when everyone has calmed down. I'm an only child and I can totally see something like this happening if things ever got out of hand- only that I'm the yeller and not DH. My dad usually sides with DH.

ETA: Didn't realize how long this thread was when I posted. Since your dad has had enough and won't stand for it, it's clear that this has gone on too many times and in front of others. You dad definitely does not need to apologize - someone needs to stand up for you since it doesn't seem (from what you wrote) that you are standing up for yourself. And that's the problem, you need to stand up for yourself and make sure your DH knows his yelling at you is unacceptable. You need to put a stop to it. His having a bad temper is no excuse.


Message edited 2012-09-19 14:26:54.187000.

Posted 9/19/12 2:16 PM
 

Diane
Hope is Contagious....catch it

Member since 5/05

30683 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Family Dilema

Wow...just told dh that my dad feels he doesnt need to apologize. Now dh is yelling at me and said i need to handle this. If he wont apologize he wont be welcomed hereChat Icon
I cant believe how freaking stubborn he is being.

Posted 9/19/12 3:09 PM
 

JRsMaMa
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

2044 total posts

Name:
Jake's Mama

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by Diane

Wow...just told dh that my dad feels he doesnt need to apologize. Now dh is yelling at me and said i need to handle this. If he wont apologize he wont be welcomed hereChat Icon
I cant believe how freaking stubborn he is being.

I see a pattern... He's yelling at you again

It is both of yours home. I would be royally pissed that he is saying your father isn't welcomed!

Posted 9/19/12 3:11 PM
 

GraciesMom
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

1636 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

Forgive me, but your DH is an ass. Like I said earlier, start with removing your father from the conversation and focus on how your DH spoke to you period and infront of others no less. That was wrong. He should acknowledge that (but from the sounds of it he is not likely to). I think you need to hold your ground and stick up for yourself. Continue with your relationship with your father as is, thank him for standing up for you and welcome him into your house or go to him. It is your house to! So mad for you!

Posted 9/19/12 3:15 PM
 

KristenRSF
LIF Toddler

Member since 5/10

487 total posts

Name:
Kris

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by Diane

Wow...just told dh that my dad feels he doesnt need to apologize. Now dh is yelling at me and said i need to handle this. If he wont apologize he wont be welcomed hereChat Icon
I cant believe how freaking stubborn he is being.



Aside from where or who witnesses, this is twice in how long that he has yelled at you? Who the fk does he think he is yelling at you? I am really sorry you are dealing with this but you need to stand up for yourself.

Posted 9/19/12 3:17 PM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Family Dilema

While I do not think your DH handled it right IMO your dad should not have gotten involved. My dad would let me handle my business unless DH was physical.

Posted 9/19/12 3:31 PM
 

leighdvm
My golden boys!

Member since 3/06

4419 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: Family Dilema

That wouldn't fly with me Diane, not one bit. He has no right to forbid your own father for coming into YOUR home. Your DH does not control you!!!!

Posted 9/19/12 3:31 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Family Dilema

You need to start yelling back -

Did you explain to your DH WHY your father doesn't feel he deserves an apology? Because he as a father REPEATEDLY witnesses his daughter being screamed at?

Taking sides isn't going to get you anywhere with your DH - I CAN understand why he'd be annoyed that your Dad got involved (I still think he should have stayed out of it and let you handle it)
But your DH is hiding behind that and he's now so blinded by it that he's making HIMSELF the victim .......He's missing the whole point here, which is that he should NOT have been screaming at you - particularly in public for everyone to hear. THAT is what you need to be focusing on - not how your Dad feels or what he said .......how YOU feel about his screaming at you - NOT how you feel about the fact that he's mad at your father.

if ANYONE deserves an apology - it's YOU!!

Posted 9/19/12 3:38 PM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by MarisaK

You need to start yelling back -

Did you explain to your DH WHY your father doesn't feel he deserves an apology? Because he as a father REPEATEDLY witnesses his daughter being screamed at?

Taking sides isn't going to get you anywhere with your DH - I CAN understand why he'd be annoyed that your Dad got involved (I still think he should have stayed out of it and let you handle it)
But your DH is hiding behind that and he's now so blinded by it that he's making HIMSELF the victim .......He's missing the whole point here, which is that he should NOT have been screaming at you - particularly in public for everyone to hear. THAT is what you need to be focusing on - not how your Dad feels or what he said .......how YOU feel about his screaming at you - NOT how you feel about the fact that he's mad at your father.

if ANYONE deserves an apology - it's YOU!!



Exactly, word for word.

Is your Dh usually this stubborn? Does it take him a little time to step back and take a look at a situation to see it differently? If so, maybe give him a few days (or however long it usually take him) to cool off and maybe he'll see the light. He's obviously still majorly POed about the whole thing and it sounds like there is no reasoning with him while he's still like this.

If this is a usual occurrence, the yelling, degrading - then maybe your dad getting involved was a blessing. It's time to stop it. Now.

This sure isn't easy. Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/12 3:54 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Family Dilema

No matter how old we get, I think it's ingrained that our parents will stand up for us, always. Even those of us with small kids know it's instinctive really.

You don't deserve to have your DH yelling at you. Not over this, or anything else really.

Posted 9/19/12 4:13 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by HeyJude

Nagging or not, I'd be livid if my DH yelled at me-esp in front of other people. I think your DH needs to apologize to you and your Dad. That is not the kind of behavior I want my DC to learn, so for a relative to step in and say something to stop it would be a-ok with me. Sorry this happened to you.



Same and I'm sorry you have to deal with that. If I'm 'nagging' DH he has a choice to either ignore or TALK to me, not yell at me. While this is doesn't happen 100% of the time and of course there have been times he's yelled at me, he would NEVER yell at me in front of other people, especially family Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/12 4:20 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by headoverheels

Posted by Diane

I dont even know if I should call my dad, or what to say, or just let him come over. DH would probably just stay aout of the house.
DH says that he will still come over and sit on my couch and not say anything to rub it in his face.
I just hate this. I am at work now and have to teach, and I cant stop crying. I am embarased to say, I dont even know what to say to my dad when I call him laterChat Icon
My inlaws didnt say anything.
Thanks for listening
Chat Icon



Really? Is your DH 5? I'm sorry for being rude and blunt but if he can't man up and face your dad and resorts to making snide remarks that your dad wants to "rub it in his face" by coming over, instead of the truth which is that he would be coming over to see his family, then you've got bigger problems than just this argument.



ITA

and how disgusting his parents said nothing...

I don't know but has your dad witnessed this stuff before? I could see maybe the first time it might be better to stay out of it but I don't think a dad would stand up for his daughter like that unless he REALLY felt like she was being disrespected, KWIM?

Posted 9/19/12 4:24 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by Diane

Wow...just told dh that my dad feels he doesnt need to apologize. Now dh is yelling at me and said i need to handle this. If he wont apologize he wont be welcomed hereChat Icon
I cant believe how freaking stubborn he is being.



Wow, I'm sorry for being blunt but your DH seems immature, manipulative and abusive. HE messed up, he should be apologizing, not yelling at you AGAIN.

Your Dad says this IS NOT the first time so I can totally see WHY he would step in. It sounds like your dad KNOWS he is being abusive to you and just had it. We're a parent always right?

Posted 9/19/12 4:31 PM
 

digweed
LIF Toddler

Member since 6/12

455 total posts

Name:
p

Family Dilema

No additional advice, but seems like you are going thru a lot with DH (post on parenting about fighting over parties), so just wanted to give you hugs.

Posted 9/19/12 4:33 PM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Diane, I am so sorry. He's yelling at you again?
That would NOT fly with me. You need to work this out.
Your DH should be apologizing to your dad AND you.
Please stand up for yourself. Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/12 4:34 PM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by headoverheels

Sorry, and I may be WAY out of line here, but I think your DH should be apologizing to your dad. The way you make it "sound" he was berating you in a way that wasn't like a regular argument, and it was nice of your dad to stick up for you. it wasn't a private argument where your dad butted in - it was in public for anyone to see. Your DH had no reason to be mad at your dad, he should be mad at himself. To be honest I'd be mortified if my DH yelled at my dad like that.

Let your dad come over, and let him and your DH work it out. They are grown men,



agreed! DH would have no balls left if he ever spoke down to my parents. He should be apologizing to your father because he was right. You are his child no matter what and for him to berate you at all but especially in front of others is not acceptable.

Posted 9/19/12 4:40 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by Gdesq

Posted by LisaW

I think your dad is AWESOME for standing up for you Chat Icon

Your DH should be mortified for speaking to you like that- especially in front of your parents

He should be begging both you and your dad for forgiveness- and if not- YOU should be PISSED at HIM





This 100%!



This. No way he should treat you like that ... in front of others or NOT. Maybe this is good so you can see that it is WRONG and you guys need help.

Your father was 100% in the right

Your husband (im sorry) has some balls to say your father owes HIM an apology.

I would be on the phone immediately with my Dad. Because he did nothing wrong. He did what parent SHOULD do.... help when he saw his child being abused (verbally) and he set a better example for your son than your husband did (JMHO).

Posted 9/19/12 5:22 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by lvdolphins

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Diane, I am so sorry. He's yelling at you again?
That would NOT fly with me. You need to work this out.
Your DH should be apologizing to your dad AND you.
Please stand up for yourself. Chat Icon



Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/12 5:23 PM
 

ItsTime2011
Meh...

Member since 1/11

2148 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

ugh - this is NOT a good situation to be in. AND it is not a good pattern of behavior. Coming from a previous emotional abusive marriage I know that it is hard to deal with someone yelling at you all the time. After a while you forget that you did nothing wrong and you walk around nervous all the time. Many hugs for you and I hope that you are able to work this out and change this pattern of behavior but NOBODY deserves to be talked down to.

Posted 9/19/12 5:54 PM
 

springchick
make a wish

Member since 5/08

3566 total posts

Name:
justask

Family Dilema

Wow I think your DH is in the wrong, no one should be yelling at you and I think what your dad did was to protect you. For what you explain your DH tend to yell at you and your Dad explain he couldn't tolerate witnessing the situation. I 100% agree with your Dad and in my opinion abuse in a relationship is not only physical. Your DH should be apologizing to you for the way he behave and not yelling more an acting like an ass. I think their is a more serious situation going on with you guys than the situation with your dad.

Posted 9/19/12 6:31 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Daycare with a Family Member Dilema nraboni 5/7/12 5 Parenting
Family Dilema.... Geraldine 8/12/07 12 Families Helping Families ™
RP from Family Board - we need a... usuk2004 5/11/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
Goodnight Family.... Moehick 5/11/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
Tell Us About Your Family! Luvlylady 5/11/05 44 Families Helping Families ™
Family Problem!!! Mrs-Boop 5/10/05 18 Families Helping Families ™