Family Dilema

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>

Diane
Hope is Contagious....catch it

Member since 5/05

30683 total posts

Name:
D

Family Dilema

Last Sundy was my boys birthday party, we had family and later some friends. My stomach is in a knot over all this.
I gave Matthew a toy he wanted and was anxious to put it together, and I was having a hard time. I asked DH several times to help me, and he said later, and later. I was nagging him, because Matthew was getting upset. DH started yelling at me in front of his parents, and my dad was walking up the driveway, and he heard it, and told DH NOT to speak to his daughter like that. My dad went on and on, saying he has a hot temper (which he can), and to go cool off, DH got real mad and started telling him how dare you come into my house telling me what to do. I told my dad why did you have to say saomething, and he said, he is not to speak to you like that.
It was so uncomfortable the rest of the day, and every wednesday my dad comes over. I dont want him to come by. Just too tense.
I am stuck in the middle of this. I havent talked to my dad. DH says he wants my dad to apologize, because he didnt see how I was nagging him about the toy. What do I do?? What do I say to my dad when I call him??
I am sick over this.Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/12 7:07 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Family Dilema

Sorry, and I may be WAY out of line here, but I think your DH should be apologizing to your dad. The way you make it "sound" he was berating you in a way that wasn't like a regular argument, and it was nice of your dad to stick up for you. it wasn't a private argument where your dad butted in - it was in public for anyone to see. Your DH had no reason to be mad at your dad, he should be mad at himself. To be honest I'd be mortified if my DH yelled at my dad like that.

Let your dad come over, and let him and your DH work it out. They are grown men,

Posted 9/19/12 7:29 AM
 

2boys4me
He's coming soon!

Member since 4/10

4260 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by headoverheels

Sorry, and I may be WAY out of line here, but I think your DH should be apologizing to your dad. The way you make it "sound" he was berating you in a way that wasn't like a regular argument, and it was nice of your dad to stick up for you. it wasn't a private argument where your dad butted in - it was in public for anyone to see. Your DH had no reason to be mad at your dad, he should be mad at himself. To be honest I'd be mortified if my DH yelled at my dad like that.

Let your dad come over, and let him and your DH work it out. They are grown men,



This. It's one thing to have an argument but it's another to be yelled at and berated, ESP in front of his family and yours. He's wrong not your dad. I'd be concerned if your dad didn't say anything and just sat back and let him yell at you like that.

Posted 9/19/12 7:39 AM
 

HeyJude
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/07

820 total posts

Name:
p

Re: Family Dilema

Nagging or not, I'd be livid if my DH yelled at me-esp in front of other people. I think your DH needs to apologize to you and your Dad. That is not the kind of behavior I want my DC to learn, so for a relative to step in and say something to stop it would be a-ok with me. Sorry this happened to you.

Posted 9/19/12 7:44 AM
 

Diane
Hope is Contagious....catch it

Member since 5/05

30683 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by headoverheels

Sorry, and I may be WAY out of line here, but I think your DH should be apologizing to your dad. The way you make it "sound" he was berating you in a way that wasn't like a regular argument, and it was nice of your dad to stick up for you. it wasn't a private argument where your dad butted in - it was in public for anyone to see. Your DH had no reason to be mad at your dad, he should be mad at himself. To be honest I'd be mortified if my DH yelled at my dad like that.

Let your dad come over, and let him and your DH work it out. They are grown men,




I agree, but DH does NOT think so.

Posted 9/19/12 7:45 AM
 

kristen92450
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

1041 total posts

Name:
kristen

Re: Family Dilema

I had a similiar situation..IMO your Dh is wrong and needs to apologize. Your dad was being sweet and defending his daughter.. You shouldn't punish your dad by not having him come over..if you don't want him to come over..then maybe meet up with him somewhere..I know it is a very difficult situation Chat Icon Also your Dh needs to know he is wrong or he will continue to disrespect you and your family..

Posted 9/19/12 7:49 AM
 

DumpsterBaby
My compass when I'm lost

Member since 5/11

2210 total posts

Name:
My anchor when I get tossed

Family Dilema

Um yeah DH is in the wrong and I think the bigger issue is that he would disrespect you like that and still can't see the error of his ways. He needs to own up to his behavior and apologize. To both you and your dad.

Posted 9/19/12 7:57 AM
 

jlm2008
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

5092 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by HeyJude

Nagging or not, I'd be livid if my DH yelled at me-esp in front of other people. I think your DH needs to apologize to you and your Dad. That is not the kind of behavior I want my DC to learn, so for a relative to step in and say something to stop it would be a-ok with me. Sorry this happened to you.



This . You are are grown woman and his wife....I would be livid if I was berated like that by DH especially in front of people. He needs to apologize to you and your father.

Posted 9/19/12 8:00 AM
 

StaceyWill
It's a girl!!!

Member since 6/10

21539 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: Family Dilema

Wow- what a tough situation for you to be in.
I would let your Dad still come over. It might be good for them to talk/clear the air. I know from personal experience that if you don’t address these family things right away, they can become even bigger of a problem.

Posted 9/19/12 8:04 AM
 

ny55angel
car seat tech & geek :-)

Member since 2/06

4346 total posts

Name:
P

Family Dilema

What was his parents reaction to him yelling at you? From the sounds of it your father was defending his daughter against her husband. I understand that you admitted to being nagging, but that was because it was for your son who you said was getting upset. I'm sorry, but your husband needs to realize that.

Whether you father knew you were nagging or not I think its wrong that your DH went off on him the way you said.

I'm sorry you have to deal with this. Can you meet up with your dad today to talk instead of him coming over? Do you think there is any middle ground he and your DH can agree on when it comes to apologizing?

Good luck Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-09-19 08:07:03.517000.

Posted 9/19/12 8:05 AM
 

leighdvm
My golden boys!

Member since 3/06

4419 total posts

Name:
Michele

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by headoverheels

Sorry, and I may be WAY out of line here, but I think your DH should be apologizing to your dad. The way you make it "sound" he was berating you in a way that wasn't like a regular argument, and it was nice of your dad to stick up for you. it wasn't a private argument where your dad butted in - it was in public for anyone to see. Your DH had no reason to be mad at your dad, he should be mad at himself. To be honest I'd be mortified if my DH yelled at my dad like that.

Let your dad come over, and let him and your DH work it out. They are grown men,



Agree 100%
Your DH was completely out of line to speak to you that way in front of anyone, regardless how much you "nagged" him. That's disrespectul......

Posted 9/19/12 8:18 AM
 

MsSissy
xoxoxo

Member since 3/07

39159 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by Diane

Posted by headoverheels

Sorry, and I may be WAY out of line here, but I think your DH should be apologizing to your dad. The way you make it "sound" he was berating you in a way that wasn't like a regular argument, and it was nice of your dad to stick up for you. it wasn't a private argument where your dad butted in - it was in public for anyone to see. Your DH had no reason to be mad at your dad, he should be mad at himself. To be honest I'd be mortified if my DH yelled at my dad like that.

Let your dad come over, and let him and your DH work it out. They are grown men,




I agree, but DH does NOT think so.



And that's his issue NOT yours.

Do you think your dad was wrong and should apologize?

Posted 9/19/12 8:19 AM
 

halfbaked
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6937 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

I don't know, I suppose I'm the only one, but I think they were both out of line. DH for getting upset and shouting over nothing, particularly in front of family, but also your father for getting involved. IMO, your relationship is your own and nobody outside of it has the right to interfere unless he was actually being abusive towards you.

Posted 9/19/12 8:24 AM
 

MommaDina
LIF Infant

Member since 8/12

315 total posts

Name:
DinaMarie

Re: Family Dilema

you know the term respect your elders ... well your DH was out of line for speaking to your father that way ... I'm sure if your DH heard someone speaking to his daughter like that he would say something no matter whos house he's in. I know you made a family with your husband but your father is always your father and being that my father is passed away I can tell you please dont let this come in between your relationship with your father because one day you'll regret it. I would tell your father that you know your his daughter and he loves you very much and the first instinct is to stick up for you but in your house next time try not to say anything because now your an adult and you'll take care of your relationship on your own unless you ask for his help (very nicely) and as for your husband i would tell him that your going to tell your father not to come in the middle of your marriage in your house but you are not asking him to apologize because your DH was out of line also for speaking to your father like that and two wrongs dont make a right and your not going to be in the middle of things because you love them both.

Posted 9/19/12 8:46 AM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by headoverheels

Sorry, and I may be WAY out of line here, but I think your DH should be apologizing to your dad. The way you make it "sound" he was berating you in a way that wasn't like a regular argument, and it was nice of your dad to stick up for you. it wasn't a private argument where your dad butted in - it was in public for anyone to see. Your DH had no reason to be mad at your dad, he should be mad at himself. To be honest I'd be mortified if my DH yelled at my dad like that.

Let your dad come over, and let him and your DH work it out. They are grown men,



Yeah I atotally agree. It is your Dad who is owed an apology, from both of you honestly. He was just standing up for you, and then you kind of turned on him too.

Posted 9/19/12 8:46 AM
 

rkl1130
LIF Adult

Member since 10/07

1476 total posts

Name:
Rose Ann

Re: Family Dilema

Like many on here, in many ways, I feel like your DH should apologize to your dad. You were having a public argument and your DH was berating you publicly in front of others - that in and of itself would make me livid. Naturally, your father would want to protect you and stand up for you. Your DH shouldn't have been talking to you and yelling at you like that in front of company - it's demeaning and degrading and humiliating.

Dh and your dad need to talk and work this out for themselves. They are adults.

Posted 9/19/12 8:46 AM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by headoverheels

Sorry, and I may be WAY out of line here, but I think your DH should be apologizing to your dad. The way you make it "sound" he was berating you in a way that wasn't like a regular argument, and it was nice of your dad to stick up for you. it wasn't a private argument where your dad butted in - it was in public for anyone to see. Your DH had no reason to be mad at your dad, he should be mad at himself. To be honest I'd be mortified if my DH yelled at my dad like that.

Let your dad come over, and let him and your DH work it out. They are grown men,



This. Your DH is 100% wrong.

Posted 9/19/12 8:52 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Family Dilema

Ok so DH is wrong but the bottom line is if my DH opened a mouth to me like that in front of my family I would have gone right back. And he knows it. That's private and he probably would have saved it for later (to yell at me). :)

Posted 9/19/12 9:13 AM
 

PhyllisNJoe
My Box Is Broken

Member since 6/11

9145 total posts

Name:
Phyllis

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by JennZ

Posted by headoverheels

Sorry, and I may be WAY out of line here, but I think your DH should be apologizing to your dad. The way you make it "sound" he was berating you in a way that wasn't like a regular argument, and it was nice of your dad to stick up for you. it wasn't a private argument where your dad butted in - it was in public for anyone to see. Your DH had no reason to be mad at your dad, he should be mad at himself. To be honest I'd be mortified if my DH yelled at my dad like that.

Let your dad come over, and let him and your DH work it out. They are grown men,



This. Your DH is 100% wrong.



I agree

Maybe if your DH and Dad sit and talk, your dad may admit he shouln't have jumped in like that, but your DH can admit he shouldn't have reacted in that way. Men argue very differently then women. They can be knocking each other out in 1 breath and laughing watching a game the next.

Your dad should come over and just let them figure it out. With that said, I think you need to speak to your DH about Yelling at you like that. I don't care if you're alone or people are around, it shouldn't happen. And if it does, it should be IMMEDIATELY followed by an apology. I know with stressful situations, sometimes you say things in a way you normally wouldn't. That may be something you guys have to figure out together. Plus him ever yelling at you in front of your child - no good. ever.

Good Luck

Message edited 2012-09-19 09:22:21.097000.

Posted 9/19/12 9:21 AM
 

Diane
Hope is Contagious....catch it

Member since 5/05

30683 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Family Dilema

I dont even know if I should call my dad, or what to say, or just let him come over. DH would probably just stay aout of the house.
DH says that he will still come over and sit on my couch and not say anything to rub it in his face.
I just hate this. I am at work now and have to teach, and I cant stop crying. I am embarased to say, I dont even know what to say to my dad when I call him laterChat Icon
My inlaws didnt say anything.
Thanks for listening
Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-09-19 09:29:45.190000.

Posted 9/19/12 9:28 AM
 

2boys4me
He's coming soon!

Member since 4/10

4260 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

I can't believe your in laws just sat there and didn't say anything.

Posted 9/19/12 9:31 AM
 

ThePinkGoose
In Your Hands

Member since 8/08

4706 total posts

Name:
Nunya

Family Dilema

This is a horrible situation for you. Big Hugs. DH sounds like he's being a jerk. I am tempted to say that your dad should have stayed out of it. I know that i've had arguments with DH in front of my Mom and if she got involved, it would have been a bad situation. I'm a grown woman, I can handle it. That said, I totally get where your dad was coming from and your DH should have cooled off by now. He should step up and do the right thing by apologizing no matter who is wrong. All in all, it was disrespectful of him to yell at you in front of ANYONE. It wasn't the time or place so tell him to suck it up and say he's sorry to your dad.

ETA: As far as what you should say to your dad, I think you should sneak out and call him and get this off of your chest. Sitting there crying and not being able to function in your day is not healthy and not helping anyone. From the way you say your dad reacted to defend you, I think he deserves to hear from you. Simply say, "hey dad....I'm sorry that you were put in that situation." I don't really know what else needs to be said. I would let him know that you need to work this out with your DH and that while you appreciate him looking out for you, you need to handle this.

Message edited 2012-09-19 09:36:40.807000.

Posted 9/19/12 9:31 AM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by headoverheels

Sorry, and I may be WAY out of line here, but I think your DH should be apologizing to your dad. The way you make it "sound" he was berating you in a way that wasn't like a regular argument, and it was nice of your dad to stick up for you. it wasn't a private argument where your dad butted in - it was in public for anyone to see. Your DH had no reason to be mad at your dad, he should be mad at himself. To be honest I'd be mortified if my DH yelled at my dad like that.

Let your dad come over, and let him and your DH work it out. They are grown men,



I agree, your DH was way out of line for speaking to you like that. Your dad was right for sticking up for you.

Posted 9/19/12 9:33 AM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by Kidsaplenty

Posted by headoverheels

Sorry, and I may be WAY out of line here, but I think your DH should be apologizing to your dad. The way you make it "sound" he was berating you in a way that wasn't like a regular argument, and it was nice of your dad to stick up for you. it wasn't a private argument where your dad butted in - it was in public for anyone to see. Your DH had no reason to be mad at your dad, he should be mad at himself. To be honest I'd be mortified if my DH yelled at my dad like that.

Let your dad come over, and let him and your DH work it out. They are grown men,



Yeah I atotally agree. It is your Dad who is owed an apology, from both of you honestly. He was just standing up for you, and then you kind of turned on him too.



I agree. Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/12 9:37 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Family Dilema

Posted by Diane

I dont even know if I should call my dad, or what to say, or just let him come over. DH would probably just stay aout of the house.
DH says that he will still come over and sit on my couch and not say anything to rub it in his face.
I just hate this. I am at work now and have to teach, and I cant stop crying. I am embarased to say, I dont even know what to say to my dad when I call him laterChat Icon
My inlaws didnt say anything.
Thanks for listening
Chat Icon



Really? Is your DH 5? I'm sorry for being rude and blunt but if he can't man up and face your dad and resorts to making snide remarks that your dad wants to "rub it in his face" by coming over, instead of the truth which is that he would be coming over to see his family, then you've got bigger problems than just this argument.

Posted 9/19/12 9:38 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 >>
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Daycare with a Family Member Dilema nraboni 5/7/12 5 Parenting
Family Dilema.... Geraldine 8/12/07 12 Families Helping Families ™
RP from Family Board - we need a... usuk2004 5/11/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
Goodnight Family.... Moehick 5/11/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
Tell Us About Your Family! Luvlylady 5/11/05 44 Families Helping Families ™
Family Problem!!! Mrs-Boop 5/10/05 18 Families Helping Families ™