Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

lullabella
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

2246 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

I would... When my FIL died, my husband his sister spilt everything down the middle even though there was a large account who just listed him as the beneficiary. Family is family and these things have a way of causing alot of problems... IMO money isnt worth it.

Message edited 2009-02-05 10:43:49.917000.

Posted 2/5/09 10:43 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

lullabella
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

2246 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by shamrock124

The bigger problem will be the tax implications of giving her 1/3 of the IRA account.

First, it's going to be distributed to the named beneficiaries as stated. Then you have to get all the beneficiaries to agree to give your mom 1/3. However, the beneficiaries will have to claim that distribution as ordinary income not your mother.

Personally, your father named who he wanted to have the assets by naming beneficiaries. He did that specifically so to give his children, his assets.

I really don't know what I would do in your situation but I would make sure you know what all the consequences are either way. Chat Icon



Good point....you have to look at the whole picture.

Posted 2/5/09 10:46 AM
 

2girlsforme
LIF Adult

Member since 8/06

3071 total posts

Name:
XXXXXXXXX

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Kara

There's a lot going on here, Beth. I think stepping down as executor and getting someone neutral in to make these decisions would be the best idea. I know you're trying to do right by everybody, and I know you're trying to be fair, but this just isn't stress you need right now. I really hope it all works out. Chat Icon



ITA!!!! In fact, as I was reading your initial post, it was the very first thought I had. Again, I am so sorry for the loss of your father but, right now do whatever you can to alleviate the stress you are feeling. Get a lawyer in Pa. to handle this.

Posted 2/5/09 10:50 AM
 

zeta1996
YUMMY!

Member since 9/06

2365 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

As you said your father moved to PA, so I am not sure the rules about IRA's there, but here in NY I know for sure that you cannot remove a spouse as a beneficiary without their consent. So if he did change the beneficiary, she would have had to sign a form allowing him to do so, and if she did, then she waived her rights to that account. So sorry you are dealing with all of this!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 10:54 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by zeta1996

As you said your father moved to PA, so I am not sure the rules about IRA's there, but here in NY I know for sure that you cannot remove a spouse as a beneficiary without their consent. So if he did change the beneficiary, she would have had to sign a form allowing him to do so, and if she did, then she waived her rights to that account. So sorry you are dealing with all of this!Chat Icon Chat Icon



There is no such rule in PA. You can remove a spouse as a beneficiary without their consent, and it effectively removes the account from probate and from the spouse's elective share.

Posted 2/5/09 11:03 AM
 

babymakes3
Almost there!

Member since 7/06

7376 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Has she been taken care of by your father before/during their separation? Spousal support or the equivalent, shares of the house, etc?

If so, then I think her entitlement is done.

The IRA is being left to the children produced from this marriage and I would leave it at that.

ETA: I'm sorry you are in this position too, but I think your mother shouldn't put you into this position. If I were her (already rock solid for retirement), I'd want the money to go to my children.




Message edited 2009-02-05 11:15:42.907000.

Posted 2/5/09 11:12 AM
 

S00N2BEAMOM
LIF Toddler

Member since 12/07

390 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Bxgell2


One problem: There is one account, an IRA account, that my father changed the beneficiary two years ago to my brothers and I, instead of the Estate. This means, this particular account falls outside the Estate, is not subject to probate, and not subject to my mother's 1/3 share. It is a fairly large account, making up about 1/3 of the total assets.

I mentioned this in passing to her and she became very upset, said that it was marital property and she is entitled to it, and that my father shouldn't have done that because she wouldn't spend the money, only use the interest, and would pass it on to my brothers and I in her will anyway.




I am so sorry for your loss and the situation you are in. But I think I would honor my Dad's wishes and this is not something YOU are doing to your mother. This is a desicion your father made and she can't hold you responsible for the way he set things up before he passed.

Message edited 2009-02-05 11:34:37.673000.

Posted 2/5/09 11:34 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Again, I am sorry for your loss and sorry this is something you have to deal with right now.

Unless I miscalculated, I think your mom is still getting about 37% of the total estate, even if you don't give her the IRA money. Given the additional info you stated, I think your dad set the IRA up that way to make sure your mom did not get that money, whether it was from the sale of the house or whatever. I think I would honor his wishes.

Posted 2/5/09 11:47 AM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Your mom is well taken care of and the IRA falls outside the estate. I think you'll sleep better at night if you honor your father's wishes with respect to that account. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 12:05 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Kara

First, Beth, I'm so sorry you are going through this, and again I am SO sorry for the loss of your father. I don't envy your position and it certainly sounds like you are doing the best you can to be fair.

If I were you, honestly, I would find a way to step down as executor of the will. I know that sounds harsh, but this is a really tough position for you to be in, and I think someone else (not a family member) should take over. As executor, you need to execute your father's wishes... of course, your relationship with your mother is going to affect that job. I think it would be better if someone without the family relationship stepped into this role... I only say that b/c other issues unrelated to this account may arise and I fear you'll be put in an uncomfortable position. I wouldn't want anyone to pin any blame on you for doing what you're supposed to do and therefore make this situation even more difficult.



I completely agree with Kara on this.

When you agree to divorce, yes possible inherited assets would be lost. That's something she should have considered when she was divorcing him. By reallocating some of the 1/3 of the assets, you are already going against what he intended.

You need to either separate yourself as the daughter & be able to carry out your father's wishes (thereby causing a riff with your mom) OR you need to step down & appoint someone who can carry out his wishes without an unbiased view.

I'm sure your dad did it because he trusted you & valued your opinion. However, you've been put in an awful position. I'm sorry you're in the middle.

Posted 2/5/09 12:40 PM
 

wannabemom
look who's freshly baked!

Member since 12/07

7364 total posts

Name:
aka marriedinportjeff

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

if she is not financially hurting, and she is bickering already with you (as executor) over the $$, I find this to be rather concerning. I hate to say it, but IMO, she's selfish/greedy.

My mother is financially hurting and she would NEVER argue for money that would be inherited by me (her only kid). Why is your mother eyeing money that is being given to you and your brothers when she lives in the Hamptons and is not financially strapped at all?

So sorry you're in this situation.... I like the idea of the OP.... excuse yourself as executor, and make a lawyer an executor.... that way, you will not be in the center of this mess, and your family won't get angry at each other

Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 12:46 PM
 

neenie

Member since 5/05

22351 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

I would follow your father's wishes. She may not want to hear it, but it's not for you to change or interpret what he wants- its just to DO what he wanted done with his money. I know its nearly impossible to do, but I would try to stay as objective with her as possible, restating that it's really not your place to reallocate his assets as his heirs seem fit, but as HE wished. That's it.

Posted 2/5/09 12:58 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

I would carry out my father's wishes. Obviously he wanted that account outside the estate and away from your mother. That's why things were at a standstill.

There is no guarantee that your mother wouldn't burn through the money. Let's face it, you can turn it around on her and say, if you aren't going to spend it, and it's going to come to us anyway, why not just leave it as is.

Remind her also, that any legal fight will be paid for out of the estate which will necessarily reduce her share of the estate.

I also advise you to consult an estate attorney. If your parents were legally separated, she might not be entitled to as much as she (or you) thinks she is.

Posted 2/5/09 3:44 PM
 

IVFGIRL
LIF Infant

Member since 1/09

139 total posts

Name:
Eva

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

If they were going through a divorce and the bulk of this money was accumulated during the marriage, then she might have a point that she is entitled to at least 1/2 of that account. If they were in the process of a diivorce, he probably shouldn't of changed the beneficiary until the settlement was worked out. I agree with other posters that a third party should decide. I do think if it was part of the marital assets, she is entitled to 1/2, but only a divorce attorney or probate attorney would know for sure. Good Luck!

Posted 2/5/09 5:26 PM
 

munchkinfacemama
LOVE

Member since 11/07

15800 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by Kara

There's a lot going on here, Beth. I think stepping down as executor and getting someone neutral in to make these decisions would be the best idea. I know you're trying to do right by everybody, and I know you're trying to be fair, but this just isn't stress you need right now. I really hope it all works out. Chat Icon



Yeah, I was trying to avoid this as much as possible to keep costs down for everyone, especially because I am an attorney and can handle the bulk of the probate myself. But for obvious reasons, I'm starting to see this just mihgt not be feasible.



ITA as a fellow attorney-it seems that you realize that you have a conflict of interest here and especially knowing that you have your own growing family to keep in mind, the stress might be too much on you. Good luck!

Posted 3/15/09 10:19 PM
 

lovemy2boys
LIF Adult

Member since 10/07

3915 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

I am very sorry for your loss. but I would do exactly as your father asks. they have been separated for a very long time. I would just explain to her that you have to do what your father wants for your own peace of mind Chat Icon

Posted 3/15/09 10:46 PM
 

butterfly20
Party of 5 - 2015

Member since 4/06

7390 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Kerie-is-so-very

Your mom is well taken care of and the IRA falls outside the estate. I think you'll sleep better at night if you honor your father's wishes with respect to that account. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



ita! in our family it was the motto- you do, so your children have more than you did. At this age she is set, and your dad intended to help his children. honor his wishes....

Posted 3/16/09 9:53 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
ethical question- wwyd? second update- i called the store antoinette 10/16/07 25 Families Helping Families ™
WWYD...IL situation jellybean78 2/2/07 6 Families Helping Families ™
WWYD? angel7 1/3/07 3 Infertility
WWYD....Long jellybean78 1/1/07 10 Infertility
Furniture: WWYD? lcherian 12/20/06 5 Home