Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Ethical quandry - WWYD?

This is complicated... sorry.

So, obviously my father passed away almost two weeks ago Chat Icon I am named one of the executors of the will, though I know my father knew I would take over the primary role, which I have. Problem is, in that role, I seem to have inherited some of the discord between my parents.

They had been separated for almost 10 years, and were going through the proceedings for a divorce, but were at a standstill because they couldn't agree on a settlement.

So, to protect his assets, he wrote a will, disinheriting my mother. This means, under the law, instead of being entitled to the entire estate as a surviving spouse, she is entitled only to 1/3 of the Estate, with the rest passing to my brothers and I.

We have agreed that, instead of going through the courts, my brothers and I will allocate 1/3 of our share of the assets to my mother, after they have been distributed.

One problem: There is one account, an IRA account, that my father changed the beneficiary two years ago to my brothers and I, instead of the Estate. This means, this particular account falls outside the Estate, is not subject to probate, and not subject to my mother's 1/3 share. It is a fairly large account, making up about 1/3 of the total assets.

I mentioned this in passing to her and she became very upset, said that it was marital property and she is entitled to it, and that my father shouldn't have done that because she wouldn't spend the money, only use the interest, and would pass it on to my brothers and I in her will anyway.

So, here is the ethical question: Do I give her 1/3 of everything, including this particular account, even though she isn't legally entitled to it, as a gesture of good faith? Of course, I would have to get my brothers on board with this as well, as I can't make the decision for their shares.

Or, do I fight her on it and tell her in no uncertain terms that this is what my father wanted, and that she is not entitled to the proceeds of that account?

What would you do?

Posted 2/5/09 9:34 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Michi
My Love

Member since 5/05

31600 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

I am very sorry for your loss sweety. I know it is not an easy thing to deal with and then to have to make family decisions is even worse :(

I think I would do what works for your living family. I know it is a tough call because it is going against what ur dad stated vs. what you know you should maybe do.

b/c ur dad is not here and u r left to make the decision and deal with the fall out i would make the decision where the pple living can have the least heartache from the situation.Chat Icon

does that make sense?

Message edited 2009-02-05 09:39:18.503000.

Posted 2/5/09 9:39 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Bxgell2

Or, do I fight her on it and tell her in no uncertain terms that this is what my father wanted, and that she is not entitled to the proceeds of that account?




doing this would most likely damage your relationship with your mother.

I don't know what it's like to start with, but you and only you can judge if it's worth 1/3 of 1/3....especially if you BELIEVE it will eventually be re-inherited by your brothers and you after your mom's passing (or any children you and your brothers may have)

I personally probably would NOT give her the money, but it's only b/c my mother is TERRIBLE with managing money...and it would be for HER benefit, and not b/c of something I think my late father wanted.

Posted 2/5/09 9:39 AM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

First, Beth, I'm so sorry you are going through this, and again I am SO sorry for the loss of your father. I don't envy your position and it certainly sounds like you are doing the best you can to be fair.

If I were you, honestly, I would find a way to step down as executor of the will. I know that sounds harsh, but this is a really tough position for you to be in, and I think someone else (not a family member) should take over. As executor, you need to execute your father's wishes... of course, your relationship with your mother is going to affect that job. I think it would be better if someone without the family relationship stepped into this role... I only say that b/c other issues unrelated to this account may arise and I fear you'll be put in an uncomfortable position. I wouldn't want anyone to pin any blame on you for doing what you're supposed to do and therefore make this situation even more difficult.

ETA -- I would take your brothers' wishes and also any tax considerations into account. (Helping your mother financially later with this money versus allowing her to inherit any of it)... It's a very tough decision. I'm really sorry you have to make it. Also, in making this decision, bear in mind that I'm sure your father NEVER intended to harm your relationship with your mother and your family. Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-02-05 09:48:40.117000.

Posted 2/5/09 9:39 AM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

as easy as it would be to say that this was the decision your dad made, and he was clear in his wishes... he is no longer here Chat Icon and won't have to deal with the fallout.

if your brothers will agree to it, i would include it in the 1/3 you will be giving to your mother.

legally you are not obligated to do anything, of course, you already know that... but if it would help your mother to be able to live off the interest, and leave the rest to you and your brothers, i don't see the harm in it Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 9:42 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

First off, I think you and your brothers need to come to a decision on what you (collectively) want to do. Once the three of you decide, you can take it from there.

If the three of you decide not to give it to your mom, (which considering the circumstances is something I would vote for), I would have someone OTHER THAN YOU tell her. The only way to do this is to keep a united front amongst your siblings.

If you can't, I would follow Kara's suggestion and get neutral third party to be the executor. That way, when the (rightfully) conclude that since your mom was divorcing your dad, she is not entitled to teh IRA, she has no family to blame.

Posted 2/5/09 9:44 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Bxgell2


I mentioned this in passing to her and she became very upset, said that it was marital property and she is entitled to it, and that my father shouldn't have done that because she wouldn't spend the money, only use the interest, and would pass it on to my brothers and I in her will anyway.




I have a question...how valid is this claim? that he should not have done it in the first place?

if that is the case, wouldn't it be wrong of ANY executor to not give her the money if she should not have been removed from it in the first place?

Message edited 2009-02-05 09:52:35.830000.

Posted 2/5/09 9:44 AM
 

NextStopBabytown
TTC #2

Member since 11/08

3141 total posts

Name:
Lindsey

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

First let me start out by saying that I am so sorry for your loss. I lost my father not too long ago. I am in no way/shape an expert on this manner but it seems to me that you should get some sort of an attorney/accountant to handle this for you all. The problem when loved ones die is often their assets and how to divvy it up.

In my honest opinion I think that it would be in the best interest of everyone to just split the money up equally between you, your brothers, and your mother. Even if this isn't exactly as your father had intended the money to be allocated, you need to remember that your mom IS alive and this will most likely cause a huge rift in your relationship if you choose not to give her a fair share of this money.

Unfortunately money brings out the worst in people and at a time like this I truly believe that equal inheritances for each family member will cause the least problems.

With that being said I wish you the best of luck!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 9:45 AM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Kara

First, Beth, I'm so sorry you are going through this, and again I am SO sorry for the loss of your father. I don't envy your position and it certainly sounds like you are doing the best you can to be fair.

If I were you, honestly, I would find a way to step down as executor of the will. I know that sounds harsh, but this is a really tough position for you to be in, and I think someone else (not a family member) should take over. As executor, you need to execute your father's wishes... of course, your relationship with your mother is going to affect that job. I think it would be better if someone without the family relationship stepped into this role... I only say that b/c other issues unrelated to this account may arise and I fear you'll be put in an uncomfortable position. I wouldn't want anyone to pin any blame on you for doing what you're supposed to do and therefore make this situation even more difficult.

ETA -- I would take your brothers' wishes and also any tax considerations into account. (Helping your mother financially later with this money versus allowing her to inherit any of it)... It's a very tough decision. I'm really sorry you have to make it.



I agree with this and I'm sorry you have to deal with this...especially in a time of grief Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Good luck w/your decision Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 9:47 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Ok, I will add some facts here.

Before my father passed away, he and my mother shared two properties, one in Great Neck, one in East Hampton. She wanted her share of the Great Neck house, and that was in large part the impetus to file for divorce. He sold the house in 2006. They split the proceeds evenly. He was never given a share of the East Hampton house. I believe he did this, for this particular account, to shield the proceeds from the Great Neck house.

My mother is in very VERY good financial shape for her retirement - rock solid, and was in a much better financial position than my father.

Last, I have to admit some of what is weighing me down is the circumstances of the last few years, in which she left while right when he started to become very ill, and unloaded 90% of the responsibility on me.

I don't want to have a disagreeable relationship with my mother, but I have to admit, it's not a very good one to start with. I DO however, want to be fair, and obviously I recognize that they WERE married for 30 years and should honor that to some degree.

I do appreciate your advice, and am starting to think that a neutral party is a good idea. In the alternative, one of my brothers has agreed to take over communication with my mom about these issues. He isn't quite as sensitive or emotional as I am when it comes to this stuff...

Message edited 2009-02-05 09:52:50.470000.

Posted 2/5/09 9:49 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Bxgell2


I mentioned this in passing to her and she became very upset, said that it was marital property and she is entitled to it, and that my father shouldn't have done that because she wouldn't spend the money, only use the interest, and would pass it on to my brothers and I in her will anyway.




I have a questio...how valid is this claim? that he should not have done it in the first place?

if that is the case, wouldn't it be wrong of ANY executor to not give her the money if she should not have been removed from it in the first place?



From what I understand, he couldn't have done this if he was living in NY. But he moved to PA to live with me two years ago, when I took on the bulk of his caretaking responsibilities. In PA, you CAN change a beneficiary to this kind of account, whereas you can't in NY. He was an attorney, knew the law, and knew it was different in PA, and took advantage of it.

Posted 2/5/09 9:51 AM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

The bigger problem will be the tax implications of giving her 1/3 of the IRA account.

First, it's going to be distributed to the named beneficiaries as stated. Then you have to get all the beneficiaries to agree to give your mom 1/3. However, the beneficiaries will have to claim that distribution as ordinary income not your mother.

Personally, your father named who he wanted to have the assets by naming beneficiaries. He did that specifically so to give his children, his assets.

I really don't know what I would do in your situation but I would make sure you know what all the consequences are either way. Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 9:51 AM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

There's a lot going on here, Beth. I think stepping down as executor and getting someone neutral in to make these decisions would be the best idea. I know you're trying to do right by everybody, and I know you're trying to be fair, but this just isn't stress you need right now. I really hope it all works out. Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 9:52 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Kara

There's a lot going on here, Beth. I think stepping down as executor and getting someone neutral in to make these decisions would be the best idea. I know you're trying to do right by everybody, and I know you're trying to be fair, but this just isn't stress you need right now. I really hope it all works out. Chat Icon



I agree...between all of the details and your grief...let someone else sort it all out.

I wish you and your family well. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 9:53 AM
 

NextStopBabytown
TTC #2

Member since 11/08

3141 total posts

Name:
Lindsey

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Bxgell2

Ok, I will add some facts here.

Before my father passed away, he and my mother shared two properties, one in Great Neck, one in East Hampton. She wanted her share of the Great Neck house, and that was in large part the impetus to file for divorce. He sold the house in 2006. They split the proceeds evenly. He was never given a share of the East Hampton house.

My mother is in very VERY good financial shape for her retirement - rock solid, and was in a much better financial position than my father.

Last, I have to admit some of what is weighing me down is the circumstances of the last few years, in which she left while right when he started to become very ill, and unloaded 90% of the responsibility on me.

I don't want to have a disagreeable relationship with my mother, but I have to admit, it's not a very good one to start with. I DO however, want to be fair, and obviously I recognize that they WERE married for 30 years and should honor that to some degree.

I do appreciate your advice, and am starting to think that a neutral party is a good idea. In the alternative, one of my brothers has agreed to take over communication with my mom about these issues. He isn't quite as sensitive or emotional as I am when it comes to this stuff...



See I think that this really changes the dynamic of the family inheritance. IMO I think you need to meet with someone to have as either a new executor of the will or maybe even some type of a legal mediator. You must also keep in mind that there are many different types of taxes that need to be paid. I am in CT so I know that our inheritance laws are different than NY but this is why I think you should get a professional involved in this matter. At the end of the day, you have to do what will allow you to sleep at night. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 9:53 AM
 

GraceAndAdam
LIF Toddler

Member since 12/08

487 total posts

Name:
Grace

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

I"m very sorry for your loss! Chat Icon I don't know what kind of financial situation your mom is in (whether she needs the money or not). If she needs the money because she has no other income, and she is older so she can't work, then she should be entitled to her share since if your father hadn't passed away it would have gone to her in the divorce settlement anyway. I'm so sorry to hear that in this time of loss you are faced with the responsibility of a decision that could pull you and your mom apart instead of bringing you closer together. I hope it all works out and that your family makes it through this! It's sad that money can cause fights between close family members...
Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 9:54 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Kara

There's a lot going on here, Beth. I think stepping down as executor and getting someone neutral in to make these decisions would be the best idea. I know you're trying to do right by everybody, and I know you're trying to be fair, but this just isn't stress you need right now. I really hope it all works out. Chat Icon



Yeah, I was trying to avoid this as much as possible to keep costs down for everyone, especially because I am an attorney and can handle the bulk of the probate myself. But for obvious reasons, I'm starting to see this just mihgt not be feasible.

Posted 2/5/09 9:55 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Bxgell2


Yeah, I was trying to avoid this as much as possible to keep costs down for everyone, especially because I am an attorney and can handle the bulk of the probate myself. But for obvious reasons, I'm starting to see this just mihgt not be feasible.



is there a way you can split it up? have the neutral party just divvy everything up and then take over from there? would that help the costs any?

I don't know how much any of this costs...but it may be worth it if it will keep your family on good terms with each other.

Posted 2/5/09 9:59 AM
 

MrsDrMatt
Live and RUN like a Ninja!

Member since 5/06

3104 total posts

Name:
MrsDrMatt

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Is the money worth putting your relationship with your mom at risk? Sounds like a cruel heartless question but I think thats what it comes down to.

Posted 2/5/09 10:08 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Bxgell2


Yeah, I was trying to avoid this as much as possible to keep costs down for everyone, especially because I am an attorney and can handle the bulk of the probate myself. But for obvious reasons, I'm starting to see this just mihgt not be feasible.



is there a way you can split it up? have the neutral party just divvy everything up and then take over from there? would that help the costs any?

I don't know how much any of this costs...but it may be worth it if it will keep your family on good terms with each other.



I've already probated the will, which is a big chunk of the work. I suppose I could contact some attorneys I know and try to reach an agreement whereby I would do the bulk of the probate work, the forms, inventory, etc., and have someone else deal with the distribution of the assets.

I do have an accountant I'm using already who is advising us on all the tax implications with regard to the inheritance, and how to divy up the proceeds to my mom afterwards.

Posted 2/5/09 10:13 AM
 

1stimemom
Love my boys

Member since 2/08

8766 total posts

Name:
Mrs Dee

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

It sound to me like your mom got what she was "entitled" to as far as marital assets in the divorce. I would respect your father's wishes. I am so sorry you are going through this. What an awful position she is putting you inChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 10:15 AM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by MrsDrMatt

Is the money worth putting your relationship with your mom at risk? Sounds like a cruel heartless question but I think thats what it comes down to.



I don't think it has to do with $$, it has to do with honoring her late father's wishes.

Beth, I am so sorry for your loss and all you are going through Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 10:18 AM
 

robynfs
12/6/10!!

Member since 9/05

4947 total posts

Name:

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by Kara

There's a lot going on here, Beth. I think stepping down as executor and getting someone neutral in to make these decisions would be the best idea. I know you're trying to do right by everybody, and I know you're trying to be fair, but this just isn't stress you need right now. I really hope it all works out. Chat Icon



I agree...between all of the details and your grief...let someone else sort it all out.

I wish you and your family well. Chat Icon Chat Icon



Oh Beth, what a difficult situation to be in. I agree with these ladies. Let someone not emotionally attached to this situation deal with it. You have so much on your plate right now, and to add trying to do the right thing and the guilt that may come along with that...you don't need it.

I wish you all the best. Please take care of yourself through all this..you are in my thoughts.

Posted 2/5/09 10:19 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

I agree about the neutral party. Others have already given you good advice.

I'm so sorry that this is falling all on you. Such a kick in the pants to have to deal with this after your dad's passing.

I'm inclined to suggest you find out what is right or wrong about the IRA assets and how they relate to your mom.

I'm not sure they were marital assets. I'm not an attorney or an accountant so if it were me, I would get that advice first.

I hope this gets easier for you.Chat Icon

Posted 2/5/09 10:25 AM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Ethical quandry - WWYD?

I think the best thing for you to do is to honor your father's wishes - Regardless of what they are or who thinks he was right/wrong -

Posted 2/5/09 10:37 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
ethical question- wwyd? second update- i called the store antoinette 10/16/07 25 Families Helping Families ™
WWYD...IL situation jellybean78 2/2/07 6 Families Helping Families ™
WWYD? angel7 1/3/07 3 Infertility
WWYD....Long jellybean78 1/1/07 10 Infertility
Furniture: WWYD? lcherian 12/20/06 5 Home