|
Ethical quandry - WWYD?
Posted 2/5/2009 9:34:46 AM by Bxgell2 This is complicated... sorry. So, obviously my father passed away almost two weeks ago I am named one of the executors of the will, though I know my father knew I would take over the primary role, which I have. Problem is, in that role, I seem to have inherited some of the discord between my parents.They had been separated for almost 10 years, and were going through the proceedings for a divorce, but were at a standstill because they couldn't agree on a settlement. So, to protect his assets, he wrote a will, disinheriting my mother. This means, under the law, instead of being entitled to the entire estate as a surviving spouse, she is entitled only to 1/3 of the Estate, with the rest passing to my brothers and I. We have agreed that, instead of going through the courts, my brothers and I will allocate 1/3 of our share of the assets to my mother, after they have been distributed. One problem: There is one account, an IRA account, that my father changed the beneficiary two years ago to my brothers and I, instead of the Estate. This means, this particular account falls outside the Estate, is not subject to probate, and not subject to my mother's 1/3 share. It is a fairly large account, making up about 1/3 of the total assets. I mentioned this in passing to her and she became very upset, said that it was marital property and she is entitled to it, and that my father shouldn't have done that because she wouldn't spend the money, only use the interest, and would pass it on to my brothers and I in her will anyway. So, here is the ethical question: Do I give her 1/3 of everything, including this particular account, even though she isn't legally entitled to it, as a gesture of good faith? Of course, I would have to get my brothers on board with this as well, as I can't make the decision for their shares. Or, do I fight her on it and tell her in no uncertain terms that this is what my father wanted, and that she is not entitled to the proceeds of that account? What would you do? |