Down sides to buying a Co-op?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Down sides to buying a Co-op?

Here's the background...I am approx 4 months pregnant. Our lease is up Oct 1. Baby is due beginning of November. we are not in a position to buy a house at this time. Currently we rent a 1 bedroom co-op which we have been comfortable in for the past three years but there will absolutely not be enough room in here for a baby. I have started looking around at apartments in complexes (we started off renting in people's houses and really dont want to go back there again). Looking at apartments got me looking into co-ops and I started comparing the costs...even with maintance charges, we could realistically buy a three bedroom co-op in PJS for what it would cost us to rent a 2 bedroom apartment. To me, this sounds ideal. Now...to the problem....

DH is ADAMENTLY opposed to buying a co-op. Before we met he used to help his cousin out with his RE business in Conneticut and took some RE classes and he was told/taught/whatever that unless you are buying a co-op in NYC that co-ops are never a good idea and are a loosing proposition. He keeps saying over and over...you dont own ANYTHING. You only own shares. My rebuttal is at least we own SOMETHING, rather than renting and paying for something that we have no interest in at all.

On paper, I do not see how a co-op is a bad thing for us and do not understand DH's objections. Maybe I am the one being pigheaded and dont see his concerns....I'm trying to look at it from all sides....is there someone that can explain to me what the downsides to co-op ownership is with regard to our situation? Any positives (as ammunition) would be nice tooChat Icon TIA

Posted 6/6/09 11:31 AM
 
Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Long Island Weddings

lovemy2boys
LIF Adult

Member since 10/07

3915 total posts

Name:

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

we have a coop and are very happy here! we have writeoffs each year, we don't do any outside work, and our payment is lower every month than what people are paying for rent these days

Posted 6/6/09 12:25 PM
 

NASP09
...

Member since 6/05

6030 total posts

Name:

Re:

Message edited 2010-03-04 19:53:28.127000.

Posted 6/6/09 12:42 PM
 

kgs11
LIF Adult

Member since 2/07

1424 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

i also own a co-op and it was the perfect first step for us. the money we spend every month on our mortgage is still ours. its like taking money out of our left pocket to put it in the right pocket, KWIM?

the maintanance is a pain in the ***, but it pays for heat, hot water, and taxes, so i dont feel like thats a waste either. we would have those expenses no matter where we lived.

good luck!

Posted 6/6/09 3:11 PM
 

Moehick
Ready for the sun!

Member since 5/05

30339 total posts

Name:
Properly perfectâ„¢

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

We bought a co-op in '04 and sold it in '08 for a very sizable profit. Without that co-op and all the $$ we made we would not have been able to buy a house.

Posted 6/6/09 3:17 PM
 

My4GirlsMyLife
My 4 girlies

Member since 2/08

9702 total posts

Name:
Valerie

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

I own a co-op in PJS and we are selling it and will make a "nice profit " off of it ! I think it would be a great investment IMO ! The market is down and the co-op's are cheap but nice ! They did so many new things at mine , that in a few yrs it will propably be worth alot when the market is better !! We now have gates, brand new pool being put in, a gym, pool house, new landscaping, a security guard, I believe a new playground !

Posted 6/6/09 3:22 PM
 

queensgal
Smile

Member since 4/09

3287 total posts

Name:

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

We are happy in our Coop as well.

For us, it has allowed us to own a "home" with an easy commute to work. The house we could afford would have been much much further from the city where we both work.

Also, the Coop allows us to save money in many ways, we share 1 car (close to public transit so it is easy), commute via subway instead of railroad, cheaper homeowners insurance, cheaper utilities, no outside landscaping costs, etc. Also, no time spent doing outdoor maintenence, etc.

For us, we were not able to afford the type of home we would want (size, condition, location). So this is a good starting point. We are putting a little away each month and hopefully we can sell for at least what we paid and upgrade to a home later on.

Posted 6/6/09 7:53 PM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

Boy...there is not even one negative. I think my DH is just stubborn as a muleChat Icon

Posted 6/7/09 11:47 AM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

I owned a co-op before we got married. I loved it. Lots of room, never had any issues, if there were problems you called mantainance.....

I actually sold of for more $$$ than I paid for it. It was a great experience.

Posted 6/7/09 7:16 PM
 

Lola
LIF Adult

Member since 1/07

1854 total posts

Name:

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

We bought our co-op around six years ago and I really can't see any down sides. We bought a house a year ago and if we had sold the co-op we would have made really nice profit. Instead, we decided to keep the co-op and rent it out, so our tenant pretty much pays the costs to keep it as an investment property. If we rented all of those years, it would have costs us the same amount of money each month and we would have nothing to show for it in the end.

Posted 6/7/09 7:32 PM
 

fabrichick
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

2479 total posts

Name:

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

We currently have a co-op in an apartment building. We had a studio and upgraded in the same building b/c we love it here.

The only downside to this particular building is that we can't rent. The upside is that everyone here owns and cares about the building - we have alot of young families here and socialized with a couple of our neighbors.

Posted 6/7/09 7:50 PM
 

belladi
LIF Adult

Member since 9/06

1011 total posts

Name:
diana

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

Posted by krissy888

we have a coop and are very happy here! we have writeoffs each year, we don't do any outside work, and our payment is lower every month than what people are paying for rent these days



Ditto... Years ago coops used to get a really bad rap, but with prices of homes these days, they have become rather popular.... Just as long as the finances are sound, its not a bad investment

Posted 6/7/09 7:57 PM
 

IrishLasss334
I'll be there soon!

Member since 1/08

6549 total posts

Name:
Patty

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

My Dad lives in a coop in Mineola and loves it. What I would ask would be:

1. How much is left on the mortage of the building? (My Dad's coop board was strong they paid off the mortage and lowered the maintenance ALOT.)
2. How much of the 'shares' are owned by people in the building, as opposed to the management company?
3. What are the rules regarding renting out an owned apartment?
4. What is the percentage of owned apartments vs. rentals vs. management owned apts being rented?


Good luck!Chat Icon

Posted 6/7/09 8:13 PM
 

Leeners
:)

Member since 5/05

4898 total posts

Name:
Eileen

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

Posted by Moehick

We bought a co-op in '04 and sold it in '08 for a very sizable profit. Without that co-op and all the $$ we made we would not have been able to buy a house.



Ditto except the dates - bought in '06, selling in '09.

Posted 6/7/09 9:40 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

Posted by Domino

even with maintance charges, we could realistically buy a three bedroom co-op in PJS for what it would cost us to rent a 2 bedroom apartment. To me, this sounds ideal.





I hate to be the debbie downer here, but I have to ask.

BUYING a THREE bedroom co-op for the same price as renting a two bedroom?

I am not saying it's impossible, but I find this hard to believe. Every three bedroom co-op I have seen has insanely high maintenance.

Can you post a sample listing of what a 3br co-op is going in the area you are looking and what you think a two bedroom rental is going to cost? My friend had a house with a legal 2.5 br upstairs apartment that he is renting to a tenant for $1650 a month (W.Babylon).

Message edited 2009-06-07 22:20:31.467000.

Posted 6/7/09 10:20 PM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Domino

even with maintance charges, we could realistically buy a three bedroom co-op in PJS for what it would cost us to rent a 2 bedroom apartment. To me, this sounds ideal.





I hate to be the debbie downer here, but I have to ask.

BUYING a THREE bedroom co-op for the same price as renting a two bedroom?

I am not saying it's impossible, but I find this hard to believe. Every three bedroom co-op I have seen has insanely high maintenance.

Can you post a sample listing of what a 3br co-op is going in the area you are looking and what you think a two bedroom rental is going to cost? My friend had a house with a legal 2.5 br upstairs apartment that he is renting to a tenant for $1650 a month (W.Babylon).




Go to mlsli.com. Here's the listing number: ML#: 2150516. I think you made my point exactly. Why should I help pay someone else's mortgage payment when I could be paying my own? Complexes around the area for 2 bedroom 2 bath are going for approx 1700+ (I have a cat and love the fact that I have to pay rent for for herChat Icon )

Message edited 2009-06-07 22:39:14.763000.

Posted 6/7/09 10:35 PM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

here are a few more things to consider


how long do you plan on living there? if it's less then 5 years- it's not a good idea to buy anything

you need at least 5 years to re-coup closing costs

and the first 5 to 7 years of a mortgage are just interest- so after 5 years- you would not have even put a dent in what you owe

next question- the maintence is $778

that doesn't include anything other then water and heat - and I assume the taxes

that leaves you paying electric and cable

I am going to assume you are putting 10% down - so your mortgage payment will be about- $930 a month

($155K mortgage at 6% for 30 years- rates tend to be higher on co-ops- and loans are harder to get b/c both you and the co-op need to be approved)

so that's $1708 with out electric and cable

now what would your rent be?

would you be able to save money while paying this- b/c I don't see this co-op appericating enough in 5 years to leave you with a huge profit after RE fees and closing costs

it's never a good idea to buy just to buy so many people are stuck now b/c they bought a house just to buy one- and now 4 years later they can't sell it and it's not the right house for them

Message edited 2009-06-08 10:04:05.750000.

Posted 6/8/09 10:03 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

Posted by Leeners

Posted by Moehick

We bought a co-op in '04 and sold it in '08 for a very sizable profit. Without that co-op and all the $$ we made we would not have been able to buy a house.



Ditto except the dates - bought in '06, selling in '09.



And you're making a profit? I'm impressed! We bought in '06, and if we sold now, I think we would have to sell for less than we bought.

A lot of people who never owned a co-op think they are a really bad idea.

I think you can't expect to profit off of it in a few years the way you could a few years ago, and you have to make sure the specific co-op is in good financial shape & that their rules are reasonable for you.

Keep in mind though, that like rents, maintainance payments can go up yearly, and there can be additional costs added on (called assesments) for things that come up like major repair or higher than usual fuel costs. These are usually temporary.




Posted 6/8/09 12:14 PM
 

MST9106
My life:)

Member since 6/06

9589 total posts

Name:

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

Posted by Domino

He keeps saying over and over...you dont own ANYTHING. You only own shares.



Uhm, I don't think your husband realizes what he is saying...when you sell those shares, you will most likely have a nice chunk of change to put down for a downpayment for a home...I say go for it! Buying a co-op is a very smart investment! My mom made a QUADRUPLE profit off of her co-op!

Posted 6/8/09 12:18 PM
 

babyfaith
Onward and Upward!

Member since 2/08

3210 total posts

Name:

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

My mom lives in a co-op and is very happy. The only drawback is that you need co-op board approval to do any kind of rennovations. Owning shares in a co-op is beter than renting and owning nothing IMO. I also know people who bought and sold their co-ops for profit and were then able to buy a house. You can also tell your DH that this is a once in a lifetime real estate market. Prices are low, interest rates are low, and supply is high.

Posted 6/8/09 12:21 PM
 

belladi
LIF Adult

Member since 9/06

1011 total posts

Name:
diana

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

From post above thats how I got my coop family sold it to buy house in massapequa. They were originally asking 60k more than I paid cause market was still high, they refused my offer at first then called when they got desperate. I bought under and if I wanted to sell now I would make money, the family made money also/

I dont know, I think it depends on where the coop is, if its financially sound and if its a desireable area. At the end of the year I get money back instead of paying through the nose too because I dont have any deductions.. For me its worth it

Message edited 2009-06-08 13:11:53.547000.

Posted 6/8/09 1:05 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

Posted by Domino

Go to mlsli.com. Here's the listing number: ML#: 2150516. I think you made my point exactly. Why should I help pay someone else's mortgage payment when I could be paying my own? Complexes around the area for 2 bedroom 2 bath are going for approx 1700+ (I have a cat and love the fact that I have to pay rent for for herChat Icon )




Wow that's a cheap price. I was expecting the price to exceed 250k.

Why is this co-op priced so cheap? How is the area/schools?

I would ask the realtor how long these houses are sitting on the market for and what the recent comps are.

It may not be a bad deal to buy. I personally have nothing against co-ops. But when you initially said you can rent a 2 bedroom for the same price as buying a three I was skeptical. But it seems like I stand corrected.

Posted 6/8/09 1:58 PM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

Posted by babyfaith

My mom lives in a co-op and is very happy. The only drawback is that you need co-op board approval to do any kind of rennovations. Owning shares in a co-op is beter than renting and owning nothing IMO. I also know people who bought and sold their co-ops for profit and were then able to buy a house. You can also tell your DH that this is a once in a lifetime real estate market. Prices are low, interest rates are low, and supply is high.

exactly.
We are in the process of buying a coop in Queens now, and if it all ends well we will be paying almost the same as our rent now.
We are planning on staying for at least 5 years and the good thing(for us at least) is that if/when we decide to buy a house down the road we can sell for profit(depending on the market) or we are also allowed to rent it out by the board approval, as long as we have lived there for 2 yrs or more. So it'll be perfect for us.
One thing I have heard from various sources though is what your(OP) DH said ,that unless you are buying in NYC (Manhattan, Queens,Brooklyn) it's not a good idea to buy a co-op. I am not sure why , I guess maybe it's harder to sell down the road or something.

Posted 6/8/09 2:02 PM
 

Leeners
:)

Member since 5/05

4898 total posts

Name:
Eileen

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

Posted by tourist

Posted by Leeners

Posted by Moehick

We bought a co-op in '04 and sold it in '08 for a very sizable profit. Without that co-op and all the $$ we made we would not have been able to buy a house.



Ditto except the dates - bought in '06, selling in '09.



And you're making a profit? I'm impressed! We bought in '06, and if we sold now, I think we would have to sell for less than we bought.



Yup. Purchase price to selling price, about a 27% margin. We put in $ though so all told, we're making about a 15% margin. Still pretty good and good enough for us to sell it, pay off my car, a family loan and put a good sized downpayment on a house.

To the OP - like anything else in real estate, there are good co-op deals and bad. You need to look at complex size, % increase in maintenance over the past 3 years, % of the maintenance that's tax deductible and other complex-specific issues (how many assessments have they had, what does their reserve look like, % of the units owned v. rented, etc). What works well for some (us) may not work for everyone.

Good luck in your decision!

Posted 6/8/09 2:31 PM
 

KimberlyScott
Graceyn=My World <3

Member since 10/08

4173 total posts

Name:
Kimberly

Re: Down sides to buying a Co-op?

I agree with alot of the other posters on here. I owned a co-op and never has any issues. I loved it. The only thing that I didn't like was that in my building I was unable to control the thermostat and I wasn't allowed to sublet either. If I was I would have never sold it. I made a HUGE profit too!

Posted 6/8/09 4:05 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Selling a House and Buying a New House - $$$ CaseyGirl 3/18/06 11 Home
I think we're buying a new house! Bxgell2 3/9/06 16 Home
If you bought or are thinking of buying a house... LAMGAJ28 3/6/06 28 Families Helping Families â„¢
Buying land???? ladybug78 2/28/06 9 Home
Why do I feel like I am CONSTANTLY buying diapers... BabyAvocado 2/27/06 8 Parenting
when did you start buying maternity clothes? nferrandi 2/22/06 18 Pregnancy