Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 | |
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by Bxgell2 I guess I see the other side of it - I highly respect defense attorneys. It's not something I could do personally, but without them, many MANY people woud go to jail for crimes they never commited. And, many, MANY people would receive punishments that aren't equitable, given their mitigating circumstances. After all, our constitution DOES guarantee a fair defense. That doesn't mean getting off for a crime you committed, but it does entail a fitting punishment for the crime and the circumstances, and a guarantee that prosecutors follow rules and ethics when charging someone with a crime. You're right that the Constitution does guarantee us all of those things, but since it IS human beings that wrote, interpret, and enforce those laws, I think it's safe to say that not everyone gets what they're entitled to. And yes, people do get off sometimes. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:10 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by GoldenRod Posted by MsMBV Mostly I do not think attorneys are scumbags. I do, however, have an issue with "ambulance chasers" and the frivolous "quick-to-sue" lawyers. And by ambulance chasers, I do not mean all PI attorneys. I mean the ones you actually see hanging around ER waiting rooms handing out business cards to the family members... This is exactly what I mean about the "bad" lawyers spoiling it for the rest. It's lawyers like this that people remember and talk about. (On a related side note, which term is preferred? Attorney, or lawyer? Is there a difference? Are the interchangeable?) Well that is what I hate. There are some immoral or desperate and highly publicised lawyers out there who seem to form a public opinion of an entire profession. It drives me nuts. I think it takes a lot of dedication and drive to become an attorney. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:11 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by bomb-blast It probably stems from: the fact that attorneys are known to charge exorbitant fees...there definitely are many lawyers out there who are so slimy and unethical that they give a bad name to the entire profession...attorneys are often seen as mercenaries for hire...defense attorneys often have to defend clients who they know are guilty, because the law gives them a right to a trial...many politicians are attorneys and most politicians are seen as untrustworthy...we see attorneys on TV who play the race card, or the gender card, or whatever, so we associate that behavior to the rest of the profession...the list can go on. But these can be said for so many other professions. Have you seen a doctor's bil? My ob charged me (not my insurance) $500 to remove the afterbirth so that I could DONATE my DD's cord blood. Its a process that took about 5 minutes. And as for criminal defense attorneys, do you really think all police are infallable or even ethical? Don't you think race plays a card in who gets arrested sometimes? Think about how many people are arrested for crimes they didn't commit out of mistake, laziness or some corruption on behalf of the police department. Without defense attorneys, these men and women would be going to jail. Message edited 2008-02-29 10:18:39.733000. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? It is the same with every profession. Message edited 2008-02-29 12:39:34.883000. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:15 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Just a personal observation.. when I was working with defense attorneys and corporate attorneys - they were generally pretty stand up folks. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by bomb-blast Posted by Bxgell2 I guess I see the other side of it - I highly respect defense attorneys. It's not something I could do personally, but without them, many MANY people woud go to jail for crimes they never commited. And, many, MANY people would receive punishments that aren't equitable, given their mitigating circumstances. After all, our constitution DOES guarantee a fair defense. That doesn't mean getting off for a crime you committed, but it does entail a fitting punishment for the crime and the circumstances, and a guarantee that prosecutors follow rules and ethics when charging someone with a crime. ITA!! I've stayed out of this thus far and I'm a lawyer. Obviously, I don't think lawyers are scum, far from it. I come from a family filled with lawyers. My father is a criminal defense attorney and has made law in New York on many occasions. I am constantly floored when I see people talking about "getting off" Its not about "getting off", its about forcing the government (who has many resources at its disposal) to do its job. So, if someone who is guilty "gets off" the government didn't do its job. As a society, its in everyone's best interest to have the government do its job. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? I hope not |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by Shelly But these can be said for so many other professions. Have you seen a doctor's bil? My ob charged me (not my insurance) $500 to remove the afterbirth so that I could DONATE my DD's cord blood. Its a process that took about 5 minutes. And as for criminal defense attorneys, do you really think all police are infallable or even ethical? Don't you think race plays a card in who gets arrested? Think about how many people are arrested for crimes they didn't commit out of mistake, laziness or some corruption on behalf of the police department. Without defense attorneys, these men and women would be going to jail. Yes, doctors do charge high fees, but how often do you hear people say they hate doctors (besides going to see them) or that doctors are scumbags? Not very often...because doctors are basically seen as trying to help the general public. I never said police were infallible. I was only answering the question about lawyers. Yes, many people "hate" the police and some of them don't even know why. But unlike attorneys, police are often placed in highly dangerous situations, where they can't just call their asistant to open a law book and tell them how to proceed. Police also don't send out $100 invoices for making a photocopy. The OP was about people's general perceptions regarding attorneys and whether right or wrong, I think the general public has a slightly negative view of them. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? NOt most of them, just you. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? In my past experience, any scumbag attorney I ever knew was a scumbag before they even entered law school. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? My first thought after hearing someone is an attorney is "What field are you in?" |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by Chatham-Chick In my past experience, any scumbag attorney I ever knew was a scumbag before they even entered law school. As usual...ITA!
|
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? no, I don't think that. I think like in any other profession there are "good eggs" and "bad eggs." |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Not at all. Dh is a lawyer amd 99% of the lawyers I have met through him are upstanding. YOu'll find scumbags in any field if you look! |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? No, 2 of our really good friends are lawyers |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by 2girlsforme ITA!! I've stayed out of this thus far and I'm a lawyer. Obviously, I don't think lawyers are scum, far from it. I come from a family filled with lawyers. My father is a criminal defense attorney and has made law in New York on many occasions. I am constantly floored when I see people talking about "getting off" Its not about "getting off", its about forcing the government (who has many resources at its disposal) to do its job. So, if someone who is guilty "gets off" the government didn't do its job. As a society, its in everyone's best interest to have the government do its job. Very true...though in the mind of the public, it's still a questionable act when you defend someone who you know is guilty and that person gets to walk simply because the government couldn't prove they were or couldn't convince a jury that they were guilty. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:36 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by racheeeee NOt most of them, just you. That's it! This is WAR! You're just jealous because I have the skills to prevent my car from floating away in a river whilst in it
|
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:42 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by bomb-blast Posted by 2girlsforme ITA!! I've stayed out of this thus far and I'm a lawyer. Obviously, I don't think lawyers are scum, far from it. I come from a family filled with lawyers. My father is a criminal defense attorney and has made law in New York on many occasions. I am constantly floored when I see people talking about "getting off" Its not about "getting off", its about forcing the government (who has many resources at its disposal) to do its job. So, if someone who is guilty "gets off" the government didn't do its job. As a society, its in everyone's best interest to have the government do its job. Very true...though in the mind of the public, it's still a questionable act when you defend someone who you know is guilty and that person gets to walk simply because the government couldn't prove they were or couldn't convince a jury that they were guilty. I understand that, but that doesn't really matter. Personally, I am more frightened of the government having unchecked power. Let's face it the defendant is at deficit just by being the defendant. I have a good friend who is a defense attorney who says that anti defense people, suddenly do a 180 degree turn the first time their spouse, brother, father has a dwi. This is of course a gross generalization but it makes you think. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:43 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by Chatham-Chick In my past experience, any scumbag attorney I ever knew was a scumbag before they even entered law school. Ok, so here's a question - do you think that the field of law somehow draws more "scumbag" people? Or, is that the legal field is often more publicized so it just appears as if it has more scumbags than any other profession? |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:44 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by bomb-blast Posted by 2girlsforme ITA!! I've stayed out of this thus far and I'm a lawyer. Obviously, I don't think lawyers are scum, far from it. I come from a family filled with lawyers. My father is a criminal defense attorney and has made law in New York on many occasions. I am constantly floored when I see people talking about "getting off" Its not about "getting off", its about forcing the government (who has many resources at its disposal) to do its job. So, if someone who is guilty "gets off" the government didn't do its job. As a society, its in everyone's best interest to have the government do its job. Very true...though in the mind of the public, it's still a questionable act when you defend someone who you know is guilty and that person gets to walk simply because the government couldn't prove they were or couldn't convince a jury that they were guilty. It's sad, really. Because by the same token, if we didn't have the right to fair representation, even IF guilty, people would be in an uproar. This is exactly the foundation of a free, democratic society. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:45 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by bomb-blast Yes, doctors do charge high fees, but how often do you hear people say they hate doctors (besides going to see them) or that doctors are scumbags? Not very often...because doctors are basically seen as trying to help the general public. I think that is my point. Doctors do charge incredible fees and even perform unncessary procedures, but don't have the same reputation. Posted by bomb-blast I never said police were infallible. I was only answering the question about lawyers. Yes, many people "hate" the police and some of them don't even know why. But unlike attorneys, police are often placed in highly dangerous situations, where they can't just call their asistant to open a law book and tell them how to proceed. Police also don't send out $100 invoices for making a photocopy. I don't know any attorney who has ever called up their assistant "to open a law book and tell them how to proceed." Yikes! I have never even heard of that. Have you? |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by 2girlsforme I understand that, but that doesn't really matter. Personally, I am more frightened of the government having unchecked power. Let's face it the defendant is at deficit just by being the defendant. I have a good friend who is a defense attorney who says that anti defense people, suddenly do a 180 degree turn the first time their spouse, brother, father has a dwi. This is of course a gross generalization but it makes you think. What doesn't matter? And please give an example of this unchecked power? If it's that frightening, I guess we should go to another country where govts ARE held in check...good luck finding one. Everyone can have an opinion about something until it affects them personally. It's human nature. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:52 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by Shelly I don't know any attorney who has ever called up their assistant "to open a law book and tell them how to proceed." Yikes! I have never even heard of that. Have you? So then it must never happen, since you've never heard of it. Aren't there people called 'paralegals'? |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? i work with attorneys every day. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 10:57 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you think attorneys are mostly scumbags? Posted by bomb-blast Posted by Shelly I don't know any attorney who has ever called up their assistant "to open a law book and tell them how to proceed." Yikes! I have never even heard of that. Have you? So then it must never happen, since you've never heard of it. Aren't there people called 'paralegals'? I actually laughed at that one. Paralegals don't do any interpretation or research of the law. I don't have time to explain their job in depth, but I can guarantee you we don't call them up and ask them how to proceed. And, it's very naive to think that there's some book of laws out there and every law is black and white. One of the beauties of a partially common law system is that very few facets of the law are black and white. |
|
Posted 2/29/08 11:00 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Any attorneys that deal w/ employment issues (on the side of the employee) here? | Mom-2-Liam | 12/4/06 | 2 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Any attorneys on here? | alnem | 10/18/06 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Real Estate Attorneys | cjik | 9/4/06 | 4 | Home |
| CALLING ALL ATTORNEYS...advice needed | MsMBV | 6/5/06 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Attorneys / legal people, I have a question. | CaseyGirl | 1/15/06 | 3 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Are there any attorneys out there that specialize in labor relations?? | karacg | 12/7/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |










Don't know how he "knew" unless he was an eyewitness or alibi, but whatever.




