Do you teach your child to hit back?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by GioiaMia Posted by 2BadSoSad We have a 3 strike rule: 1st time) Use your words to defend yourself 2nd time) Tell an adult/teacher 3rd time) Hit them back At some point, I feel like if you tried the right thing and it doesn't work you have to stand up for yourself. I like this! My DD has never been hit by anyone, but I would not hesitate to tell her to hit back IF she has tried all other options. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 11:05 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Do you teach your child to hit back? I give him the choice. He was told he will never get in trouble by me for hitting back...but he hit back once and felt like sh!t afterwards...so now he has learned to avoid situations and certain types of kids... |
|
Posted 4/23/13 11:24 AM
|
|
|
Do you teach your child to hit back? The kids I'm talking about are 3. I can understand teaching grade school kids to defend themselves but imho a 3 yo can't really process that well. My ds1 always says my ds2 "hit him" but it's most often ds2 just being a pushy 1 year old- not actually hitting. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 12:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Absolutely not. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 1:01 PM
|
|
|
Do you teach your child to hit back? Not at 3 yrs old...no way |
|
Posted 4/23/13 1:02 PM
|
|
|
Do you teach your child to hit back? I really like the '3 Strikes' idea. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 1:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Originally I would say no never... |
|
Posted 4/23/13 2:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? I taught my daughter that it was ok to defend herself. Message edited 2013-04-23 14:58:08.957000. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 2:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? If DH had it his way we would lol. But no. Our DS is a lover, not a fighter. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 3:22 PM
|
|
|
Do you teach your child to hit back? No I'd never teach them to hit another kid back - tit for tat... |
|
Posted 4/23/13 6:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by brownie And I'm sorry but if the schools are going to preach a ZERO tolerance policy with hitting/bullying etc they better enforce it. If they choose to ignore it, you bet I will be backing my kid if she ever has to defend herself. I'm so sick of the lack of reaction on schools' part. Sorry but if your kid has issues/problems and can't help but bully/hit etc then YOU need to remove them and figure out another solution. Not allow them to continue to hit other kids. What is it that you expect schools to do? In a public school (well the one I work in) if a child hits they get suspended, beyond that what can the school do? it is not like a private school where you have the power to expel over a fight, in a public school it would have to be a very serious offense and then the child might be transferred to another public school but a school cannot refuse education bc a child hits someone. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 7:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by DiamondGirl Posted by brownie And I'm sorry but if the schools are going to preach a ZERO tolerance policy with hitting/bullying etc they better enforce it. If they choose to ignore it, you bet I will be backing my kid if she ever has to defend herself. I'm so sick of the lack of reaction on schools' part. Sorry but if your kid has issues/problems and can't help but bully/hit etc then YOU need to remove them and figure out another solution. Not allow them to continue to hit other kids. What is it that you expect schools to do? In a public school (well the one I work in) if a child hits they get suspended, beyond that what can the school do? it is not like a private school where you have the power to expel over a fight, in a public school it would have to be a very serious offense and then the child might be transferred to another public school but a school cannot refuse education bc a child hits someone. I expect it to be addressed. That is the issue. So many times you hear that they DID tell someone and nothing was done. Schools need to be proactive in making sure they are protected. If my kid is being bullied or beat up in school and no one knows I would seriously question who the helll is watching these kids. No you can't be everywhere, but why have hall monitors or aids or security. IMHO it is the schools job to make sure my child is safe while in their care end.of.story. You can bet you asss I will teach my kids to defend themselves, but in an appropriate way. What is an appropriate way you may ask. Well it's respecting what you can do to someone and only DEFENDING your self and not beating the sh*t out of someone. I will NEVER make my child feel bad or punish them for defending them self. I also question why the parents are doing more. So the school said they did all they could then fine but are you, as a parent, contacting the other parents and doing anything? |
|
Posted 4/23/13 8:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by AllyMally I expect it to be addressed. That is the issue. So many times you hear that they DID tell someone and nothing was done. Schools need to be proactive in making sure they are protected. If my kid is being bullied or beat up in school and no one knows I would seriously question who the helll is watching these kids. No you can't be everywhere, but why have hall monitors or aids or security. IMHO it is the schools job to make sure my child is safe while in their care end.of.story. You can bet you asss I will teach my kids to defend themselves, but in an appropriate way. What is an appropriate way you may ask. Well it's respecting what you can do to someone and only DEFENDING your self and not beating the sh*t out of someone. I will NEVER make my child feel bad or punish them for defending them self. I also question why the parents are doing more. So the school said they did all they could then fine but are you, as a parent, contacting the other parents and doing anything? If my child was hit in a malicious way in a school and there was no consequence for the offender my child would be attending a different school, period. My point is that once a school gives a student a consequence and the behavior continues then what can they do other than continue to punish the child IN school? In this case the problem lies with the parent of the child not doing their job whether that be properly raising and disciplining their children or like you said finding a more appropriate setting (in this case the school should also be playing a role, if the child has an emotional disturbance or disability that is contributing to their behavior they should certainly be recommending the parent evaluate their child for the appropriate setting but once again the PARENT has to consent. My beef is when people blame the school for the job of the parents, that was the point of my post. So I will reiterate that if a school is so negligent as to ignore a child being physically harmed by another child I would raise hell, go all the way to the top and likely find another school for my DC. eta: I take no issue with parents teaching their children to defend themselves if they feel they need to and it is warranted, I plan to teach my child the same. That being said I also understand that ANY hitting in school is not allowed and if my son gets hit and needs to defend himself then he will likely have a consequence as well and we will have to accept it and keep it moving. Message edited 2013-04-23 22:30:28.120000. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 10:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by DiamondGirl Posted by brownie And I'm sorry but if the schools are going to preach a ZERO tolerance policy with hitting/bullying etc they better enforce it. If they choose to ignore it, you bet I will be backing my kid if she ever has to defend herself. I'm so sick of the lack of reaction on schools' part. Sorry but if your kid has issues/problems and can't help but bully/hit etc then YOU need to remove them and figure out another solution. Not allow them to continue to hit other kids. What is it that you expect schools to do? In a public school (well the one I work in) if a child hits they get suspended, beyond that what can the school do? it is not like a private school where you have the power to expel over a fight, in a public school it would have to be a very serious offense and then the child might be transferred to another public school but a school cannot refuse education bc a child hits someone. I'm talking about my 3yo DD who has been hit on numerous occasions and every time by the same kid (he hits others too). Every time its happened we've talked to the teachers and finally the director who all told us "they're working on it". Sorry but if its happened over several months and we were given the same response and it continues, that is the school's fault for allowing the kid to continue not shadowed there. NEEDLESS to say we are switching schools. |
|
Posted 4/24/13 1:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? For the most part my Child is the hitter and he has been known to hit the same child more than once, only because there are certain kids that play together. So therefore, when a conflict occurs, then it will happen with the same child. My child has also been hit by the same child before on several occassions, again thats because its almost like his close friend at school. |
|
Posted 4/24/13 1:53 PM
|
|
|
Do you teach your child to hit back? Just to add which i thought was funny, a few months ago there was a little girl that would tell us at the end of the day that AJ hit her. One day my husband told her next time he does that to hit him back. LOL |
|
Posted 4/24/13 1:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Sorry I still stand by what I said earlier...I don't care if it's being 'worked on' and months go by and my kid is still being hit. Once or twice, ok but repeatedly, over months and hitting other kids too and once even spitting on her face (and other kids too), then I don't give a $hit about how they're 'working on it'. I'm not paying a lot of money/taxes for my kid to go to school and this be the 'highlight' of what she talks about when she gets home. Get the kid services, a shadow something or take the kid out of the environment. The teachers can only keep them apart for so long and this particular kid hits everyone, so what are the teachers supposed to do...keep him isolated? Again, the admin/directors and parents together need to figure out a solution, not allow said kid to continue hitting others. It's BS. |
|
Posted 4/24/13 3:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Brownie--ITA with you, that is unacceptable and IMO you are doing the right thing by finding another school for your DC |
|
Posted 4/24/13 8:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by DiamondGirl Brownie--ITA with you, that is unacceptable and IMO you are doing the right thing by finding another school for your DC
|
|
Posted 4/24/13 8:50 PM
|
|
|
want2beamom
Member since 8/06 10164 total posts Name: |
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by MrsA714 Posted by 2BadSoSad We have a 3 strike rule: 1st time) Use your words to defend yourself 2nd time) Tell an adult/teacher 3rd time) Hit them back At some point, I feel like if you tried the right thing and it doesn't work you have to stand up for yourself. This. I want my kids to know that they have EVERY RIGHT to defend themselves if necessary. This is what we say as well. I will NEVER tolerate any of my kids bullying anyone...and I will also not allow other kids to bully my kids...bullying is real...and bad....from a young age ETA: in regards to a young age, you know when kids are doing it maliciously, or when they are doing it because they are excited, etc. Message edited 2013-04-24 20:56:08.637000. |
Posted 4/24/13 8:54 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 [3] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Had to share (sad story including a child being hit you are warned) | Xelindrya | 1/10/13 | 23 | Parenting |
| If Your Child Has Hit in School | Dulcinea | 2/15/12 | 5 | Parenting |
| Child hit by a car on my corner today *update* | fdnywife | 8/3/11 | 5 | Parenting |
| if your child hit/pushed another kid | nferrandi | 12/13/10 | 24 | Parenting |
| Child Hit & Killed by Campaign Vehicle | photoshopbabe | 1/6/09 | 15 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| When other children hit your child? | Michelle | 11/27/06 | 20 | Parenting |











