Do you teach your child to hit back?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? No, but as as a former teacher I can tell you a lot of parents do. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 5:27 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Do you teach your child to hit back? Never, ever. I was not taught that way and have never gotten into a physical fight in my entire life. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 6:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Not sure but as a mom of boys this terrifies me! I hope no one ever hits them! If someone hit my son when he was an older kid and he hit them back I can't say that I would be mad at him for it. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 6:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by buttercup I will teach DD to defend herself when she is old enough to understand. My mom always taught me that and I will teach my daughter the same. Ditto When I was in elementary school my mom always said that if someone was hitting me that I could hit back. She didn't want me to be the one to hit first, but once hit she always said I can defend myself. I was never bullied or picked on because you learned the first time that I wouldn't let anyone hit me. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 6:46 PM
|
|
|
Do you teach your child to hit back? No, I do not. I teach them to turn the other cheek and be the better person. There are times where I haven't wanted to do it, I wanted to tell them to smack the sh!t out of some little punk who was bothering them. But I truly believe that is not how you solve problems. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 6:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? I'm curious...for those that say they tell their child not to ever hit back...what do you tell your child to do if they are getting repeatedly "abused" and no one is around to help? I have seen this happen - where one kid is basically on top of another beating on them and NO ONE is there to help (teacher not paying attention, parent etc.) - in that case, would you want your kid to lay there and take it or push the kid off hard enough that they leave them alone? Message edited 2013-04-22 19:05:41.063000. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 7:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? No way. We don't hit in our house and my DS has been taught his whole life that hitting is unacceptable. I think there is time to discuss defending yourself as in preschool there should be an adult present at all times. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 7:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? We have a 3 strike rule: Message edited 2013-04-22 20:52:55.780000. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 7:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by 2BadSoSad We have a 3 strike rule: 1) Use your words to defend yourself 2) Tell an adult/teacher 3) Hit them back At some point, I feel like if you tried the right thing and it doesn't work you have to stand up for yourself.
|
|
Posted 4/22/13 8:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by OffWithHerHead23 No, I do not. I teach them to turn the other cheek and be the better person. There are times where I haven't wanted to do it, I wanted to tell them to smack the sh!t out of some little punk who was bothering them. But I truly believe that is not how you solve problems. Also, for those of you who answered that as long as they didn't throw the first punch it was OK, be aware that most schools have Zero Tolerance policies now. Any kid who was involved in a fight will be suspended, regardless of who threw the first punch or who started. It's automatic suspensions regardless. In my son's middle school, every morning they are read something over the loudspeaker after the pledge that starts, "Violence is never acceptable. If you have a problem and you handle it poorly, you will face the consequences." If my child came home and was in trouble because she defended herself against someone who was bullying her, or hit her first, i would tell the school that I do not agree with their policy. Bullies pick on the weak, if you don't defend yourself they will keep coming back, and a "F" off, is not going to solve the problem. A teacher may be able to protect you on school grounds, but what happens after school? I am not saying you are right or wrong, but this is how I feel, and how I was raised. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 9:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by Hofstra26 Posted by alli3131 At that age no I would not. When they are older they will be taught to protect themselves. I think there is a time when they need to be taught the difference between fighting and protecting oneself. This. Yes, I agree exactly with this. Im sorry, but my kid is not going to sit back and get beat up on. He will learn to defend himself and that mommy will be there to back him up. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 9:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by PennyJ923 Posted by OffWithHerHead23 No, I do not. I teach them to turn the other cheek and be the better person. There are times where I haven't wanted to do it, I wanted to tell them to smack the sh!t out of some little punk who was bothering them. But I truly believe that is not how you solve problems. Also, for those of you who answered that as long as they didn't throw the first punch it was OK, be aware that most schools have Zero Tolerance policies now. Any kid who was involved in a fight will be suspended, regardless of who threw the first punch or who started. It's automatic suspensions regardless. In my son's middle school, every morning they are read something over the loudspeaker after the pledge that starts, "Violence is never acceptable. If you have a problem and you handle it poorly, you will face the consequences." If my child came home and was in trouble because she defended herself against someone who was bullying her, or hit her first, i would tell the school that I do not agree with their policy. Bullies pick on the weak, if you don't defend yourself they will keep coming back, and a "F" off, is not going to solve the problem. A teacher may be able to protect you on school grounds, but what happens after school? I am not saying you are right or wrong, but this is how I feel, and how I was raised. I was raised differently and feel differently, so I guess I will have to respectfully disagree. Sorry. But if the school's policy is a zero tolerance policy, your child WILL be suspended for any involvement in a fight. It doesn't matter what your personal beliefs are in the matter. They tell the incoming sixth grade parents and kids that in my son's school, and they keep telling them that constantly throughout their three years there. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 9:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by OffWithHerHead23 Posted by PennyJ923 Posted by OffWithHerHead23 No, I do not. I teach them to turn the other cheek and be the better person. There are times where I haven't wanted to do it, I wanted to tell them to smack the sh!t out of some little punk who was bothering them. But I truly believe that is not how you solve problems. Also, for those of you who answered that as long as they didn't throw the first punch it was OK, be aware that most schools have Zero Tolerance policies now. Any kid who was involved in a fight will be suspended, regardless of who threw the first punch or who started. It's automatic suspensions regardless. In my son's middle school, every morning they are read something over the loudspeaker after the pledge that starts, "Violence is never acceptable. If you have a problem and you handle it poorly, you will face the consequences." If my child came home and was in trouble because she defended herself against someone who was bullying her, or hit her first, i would tell the school that I do not agree with their policy. Bullies pick on the weak, if you don't defend yourself they will keep coming back, and a "F" off, is not going to solve the problem. A teacher may be able to protect you on school grounds, but what happens after school? I am not saying you are right or wrong, but this is how I feel, and how I was raised. I was raised differently and feel differently, so I guess I will have to respectfully disagree. Sorry. But if the school's policy is a zero tolerance policy, your child WILL be suspended for any involvement in a fight. It doesn't matter what your personal beliefs are in the matter. They tell the incoming sixth grade parents and kids that in my son's school, and they keep telling them that constantly throughout their three years there. At that point I would accept the suspension. Self defense is more important in my opinion. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 9:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by PennyJ923 Posted by OffWithHerHead23 Posted by PennyJ923 Posted by OffWithHerHead23 No, I do not. I teach them to turn the other cheek and be the better person. There are times where I haven't wanted to do it, I wanted to tell them to smack the sh!t out of some little punk who was bothering them. But I truly believe that is not how you solve problems. Also, for those of you who answered that as long as they didn't throw the first punch it was OK, be aware that most schools have Zero Tolerance policies now. Any kid who was involved in a fight will be suspended, regardless of who threw the first punch or who started. It's automatic suspensions regardless. In my son's middle school, every morning they are read something over the loudspeaker after the pledge that starts, "Violence is never acceptable. If you have a problem and you handle it poorly, you will face the consequences." If my child came home and was in trouble because she defended herself against someone who was bullying her, or hit her first, i would tell the school that I do not agree with their policy. Bullies pick on the weak, if you don't defend yourself they will keep coming back, and a "F" off, is not going to solve the problem. A teacher may be able to protect you on school grounds, but what happens after school? I am not saying you are right or wrong, but this is how I feel, and how I was raised. I was raised differently and feel differently, so I guess I will have to respectfully disagree. Sorry. But if the school's policy is a zero tolerance policy, your child WILL be suspended for any involvement in a fight. It doesn't matter what your personal beliefs are in the matter. They tell the incoming sixth grade parents and kids that in my son's school, and they keep telling them that constantly throughout their three years there. At that point I would accept the suspension. Self defense is more important in my opinion. I would as well. In our 3 strike rule case, (if it happens a 3rd time you can hit back) then I feel the school has failed to protect him and handle the situation and that would be my argument to them, how was it allowed to happen 3 times? IMO, and in OUR family, you have to learn to protect yourself bc bullies prey on the weak and if you let them know that you will let them and not do anything about it, it will continue. Which is why we have the 3 strike rule, at some point you draw the line and defend yourself. |
|
Posted 4/22/13 9:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Has anyone ever seen their own child get bit or hit by another child? I happened to be at dd school at the right time I guess...when another girls smacked my dd directly in the face and THEN bit her. I stood there in shock and I watched my smiley dd started to get down on her knees and cry hysterically while this little girl kept going at it. Omg it was one of the the saddest days. I love her school and her teachers. Luckily I was able to have this girl separated from her permanently because I was the voice for my child. I saw it happen! |
|
Posted 4/22/13 10:12 PM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by PennyJ923 Posted by OffWithHerHead23 No, I do not. I teach them to turn the other cheek and be the better person. There are times where I haven't wanted to do it, I wanted to tell them to smack the sh!t out of some little punk who was bothering them. But I truly believe that is not how you solve problems. Also, for those of you who answered that as long as they didn't throw the first punch it was OK, be aware that most schools have Zero Tolerance policies now. Any kid who was involved in a fight will be suspended, regardless of who threw the first punch or who started. It's automatic suspensions regardless. In my son's middle school, every morning they are read something over the loudspeaker after the pledge that starts, "Violence is never acceptable. If you have a problem and you handle it poorly, you will face the consequences." If my child came home and was in trouble because she defended herself against someone who was bullying her, or hit her first, i would tell the school that I do not agree with their policy. Bullies pick on the weak, if you don't defend yourself they will keep coming back, and a "F" off, is not going to solve the problem. A teacher may be able to protect you on school grounds, but what happens after school? I am not saying you are right or wrong, but this is how I feel, and how I was raised.
|
|
Posted 4/22/13 10:14 PM
|
|
|
Do you teach your child to hit back? Yes I do teach my DD to defend herself and to stand up for herself. She is pretty shy and at church she is the only girl old enough to really play. The boys are older and rougher so she has to learn to stand up for her self. She will be playing by herself and 1 of the boys will come and steal her basketball for no reason. We taught her to go ask for it back, to tell a parent, and if that fails to take it back. She knows hitting is not ok, but it's also not ok for other kids to treat her poorly. As for actual hitting we have not been in that situation yet, but we will teach her to NEVER hit another person, but if she needs to fight back she can. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 12:15 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by 2BadSoSad We have a 3 strike rule: 1st time) Use your words to defend yourself 2nd time) Tell an adult/teacher 3rd time) Hit them back At some point, I feel like if you tried the right thing and it doesn't work you have to stand up for yourself. I wholeheartedly agree. I dont believe its right for my child to get hit for no reason and there is not always someone to go tell or someone there to help her. If the child does not stop, I would teach her to defend herself. We live in a different world now and I need her, especially as a girl, to be able to defend herself if she feels threatened or hurt. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 7:49 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by 2BadSoSad We have a 3 strike rule: 1st time) Use your words to defend yourself 2nd time) Tell an adult/teacher 3rd time) Hit them back At some point, I feel like if you tried the right thing and it doesn't work you have to stand up for yourself. I like this. There's an aggressive boy that likes to hit in ds' 3 year old nursery class. He hasn't hit my son, but just the other day he told me that this kid gets in trouble a lot for it. I told him that if this child ever lays a hand on him he should do 1 & 2 and then tell me. If/when that happens we'll be doing this 3 strike rule if the teachers don't nip it in the bud. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 9:04 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by lynnd126 Another mom told me that she and her dh teach their son this- if a kid in school hits you, hit them back. I was shocked. Then someone I told the story to agreed with her. FTR our kids are preschool age- not sure if that matters. Yes I do. I tell them to never hit first but if someone hits them they can hit back. Do they? No and it bothers me seeing them get pushed around. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 9:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by OffWithHerHead23 But if the school's policy is a zero tolerance policy, your child WILL be suspended for any involvement in a fight. It doesn't matter what your personal beliefs are in the matter. They tell the incoming sixth grade parents and kids that in my son's school, and they keep telling them that constantly throughout their three years there. If the school has a zero tolerance policy yet my child was defending themselves I will let my child be suspended but my child will not be punished at home. I will have the discussion with them about what happened and how its not right to fight/hit but in certain circumstances one must defend themselves. While I do not agree with a zero tolerance policy for defending onself I would have to abide by the schools punishment of the child but I do not have to punish my child for soemthign I did not think was wrong. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 9:33 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Not at that age. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 9:34 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? I was bullied as a kid. It was terrible and no one did anything. Went on forever. I ended up befriending a "bodyguard" who no one messed with. She carried a knife (yes, elementary and junior high). |
|
Posted 4/23/13 9:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by 2BadSoSad We have a 3 strike rule: 1st time) Use your words to defend yourself 2nd time) Tell an adult/teacher 3rd time) Hit them back At some point, I feel like if you tried the right thing and it doesn't work you have to stand up for yourself. This. I want my kids to know that they have EVERY RIGHT to defend themselves if necessary. |
|
Posted 4/23/13 10:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: Do you teach your child to hit back? Posted by 2BadSoSad We have a 3 strike rule: 1st time) Use your words to defend yourself 2nd time) Tell an adult/teacher 3rd time) Hit them back At some point, I feel like if you tried the right thing and it doesn't work you have to stand up for yourself. I like this! |
|
Posted 4/23/13 10:12 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Had to share (sad story including a child being hit you are warned) | Xelindrya | 1/10/13 | 23 | Parenting |
| If Your Child Has Hit in School | Dulcinea | 2/15/12 | 5 | Parenting |
| Child hit by a car on my corner today *update* | fdnywife | 8/3/11 | 5 | Parenting |
| if your child hit/pushed another kid | nferrandi | 12/13/10 | 24 | Parenting |
| Child Hit & Killed by Campaign Vehicle | photoshopbabe | 1/6/09 | 15 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| When other children hit your child? | Michelle | 11/27/06 | 20 | Parenting |















