Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

neenie

Member since 5/05

22351 total posts

Name:

Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

DH and i canNOT agree on a name. Not even close. How we agreed on DD#1's name is still amazing to me. We picked out a boy's name 5 years ago (before we even knew if we wanted kids), So i'm sure that means that we'll have 17 girls. Chat Icon

Anyway, i don't know that there's even a girls name that i love. But, DH has one that he LOVES. He wanted it for DD#1 and still loves it now. Seeing how much he loves it makes me WANT to love it... but i just don't. Chat Icon And its a nice name, i like it for other people (and apparently lots of other people love it too since it was one of the top names last year), but i just don't want it.

Just curious though, if anyone has compromised on their DC's name, for whatever the reason may be. Do you regret it? Do you love it now? Any other feelings on the topic?

Posted 7/26/10 3:42 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

I am a b!tch and always say that the woman who carries the baby gets to pull rank on the name

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/26/10 3:45 PM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

I chose DS's name so I'm not in your shoes, but DH's cousin is pregnant and her DH and their DS decided on a name and double teamed her Chat Icon She says she doesn't love the name at all, but since they both love it and it's not horrible, she's going with it. She's due any day now. She also said that since she chose their first DC's name, that she feels like she should let him choose the 2nd baby's name.

Posted 7/26/10 3:47 PM
 

Gatsbygirl
Please St. Therese....

Member since 10/07

8494 total posts

Name:

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

We went with DH's choice for DD because she was 9 days early and I was still up the air.

I 100% regret itChat Icon To the point I was all set to change it the other week, but I know I can't.

My advice is to go with your gut and DO NOT DISCUSS names with anyone, even your parents. The name should be what you want.

Posted 7/26/10 3:48 PM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

Originally if we were having a boy it would have been Thomas after DH's late father. Then he said he didnt want his son to be named after something so sad and have his own idenity. DH was stuck on Jack Thomas. Im like..Jack..no way. How about John and we'll call him Jack..NO GO. Just Jack.

I wanted Daniel, Eric, Dylan, Nicholas..one of those. DH and I compromised on Brandon Thomas. I was happy.

Then..we were at a housewarming party and DH has a distant cousin, 8 yrs old i think, named Brandon. Cute kid, but very prissy and spoiled. so then i had this image in my head of that and associated with a Brandon and that wasnt what I wanted my son to be.

So i gave in to Jack Thomas...i would joke that i would call him JT after my love for Justin Timberlake.

But u know what..the minute i saw DS, i knew he was a JACK. I dont know what it was, but it totally fits him.

So in the end, all worked out well.

Posted 7/26/10 3:48 PM
 

Deeluvsvinny
DONE

Member since 10/08

4952 total posts

Name:
Whatever

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

I compromised on DD's name. I LOVED a few names. =) Dh HATED all of them. Then we agreed on one..then I decided I didn't love it anymore. So we were back to square one..then Dh said he wanted to name her after his mom who is deceased..her name was joanne and we named dd Joanna..was it my first choice? No. Now that DD is here..I can't imagine that she'd have another name. We started using the name when I was preggo with each other just to make sure we really liked it.

I guess my situation is a bit different, bc I did it for respect, but I did compromise and I am glad I did.

Posted 7/26/10 3:49 PM
 

neenie

Member since 5/05

22351 total posts

Name:

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

Posted by Gatsbygirl
My advice is to go with your gut and DO NOT DISCUSS names with anyone, even your parents. The name should be what you want.




Oh yeah... i dont talk about it to anyone else (well, not names that i'm really considering, anyway lol). Especially my parents. But, i dont really talk to them in general, so this is no different Chat Icon


DH feels like i get more pull too, and is willing to consider some names that i like (though, the ones i like most, i know he hates lol). I just feel bad b/c i know he *LOVES* this name and it would make him so happy (he's a simple guy, really Chat Icon ) but i just dont feel any attachment to it.

Posted 7/26/10 3:51 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

There were names that I LOVED and names that JT LOVED but neither of us could sell each other on them, so we ended up having to find new names that we both could agree on. In the end, we narrowed it down to Chase or Nate and JT leaned towards Nate and I leaned toward Chase. Guess who won?Chat Icon So I say pick names you can both live with and take it from there.
It upset me because I didn't even really love the name Chase until I started calling him by that on a regular basis in my belly. The more I said it, the more I loved it and now I just absolutely adore his name.

Posted 7/26/10 3:51 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

I did.

I seriously regret it Chat Icon I feel I was pressured by the stupid society we live in, the ignorance of centuries of bad press, if you will, and general public opinion.

To this day I still wish I had stuck with my guns and named her Jezebel Rose.

Do I like? Sure afterall, it was my third choice. was my second choice. I love that I call her AJ of course. But part of me calls her AJ cause I always wanted her to be Jezzie. Chat Icon

Posted 7/26/10 3:51 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

Posted by Gatsbygirl


My advice is to go with your gut and DO NOT DISCUSS names with anyone, even your parents. The name should be what you want.




Totally AGREE WITH THIS 100%!

I wish we were given this advice the first time around!

To answer your question though, yes we compromised to some degree...My fave name for a girl was automatically a NO by DH

We picked Lily which he said he could deal with Chat Icon but of course now it doesn't matter, but this is the only time he really was stubborn about something

At the last minute, I pulled the I am carrying the baby I get more say argument...that sorta, not totally, worked...

The boys name we had an easier time with (we were
Chat Icon )

And I TOTALLY regret sharing my ideas w/my family

Posted 7/26/10 3:54 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

We were team Chat Icon with both children and only had a Chat Icon name for both.

With DS, after giving birth the nurse asked me what his name was-I blurted out his ame. DH looked at me like, "It is?" We were supposed to discuss it, but he was B to me.

With DD, I agreed to DH's request to not just blurt out a child's name again. Chat Icon He wanted the name M from before we were even married..

No regrets. Chat Icon

Message edited 2011-09-15 09:47:15.180000.

Posted 7/26/10 3:55 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

Compromise......if you want to call it that.

DS name is Edward, we call him Eddie. I HATED HATED HATED it, with a passion. However, it is DH name, his fathers name, his granfathers name, his great grandfathers name, and his great great grandfathers name. They were all the first son, of the first son.

So needless to say, when my DH (his dads first son) had a son (as his first), I couldnt be THAT girl and put an end to tradition. It was really important to DH. Id call it more than a compromise since I HATED the name.

With that said, DS is almost 3 and I couldnt see him called anything else and I have grown to LOVE LOVE LOVE it.

Posted 7/26/10 3:55 PM
 

Gatsbygirl
Please St. Therese....

Member since 10/07

8494 total posts

Name:

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

Posted by neenie

Posted by Gatsbygirl
My advice is to go with your gut and DO NOT DISCUSS names with anyone, even your parents. The name should be what you want.




Oh yeah... i dont talk about it to anyone else (well, not names that i'm really considering, anyway lol). Especially my parents. But, i dont really talk to them in general, so this is no different Chat Icon


DH feels like i get more pull too, and is willing to consider some names that i like (though, the ones i like most, i know he hates lol). I just feel bad b/c i know he *LOVES* this name and it would make him so happy (he's a simple guy, really Chat Icon ) but i just dont feel any attachment to it.



Worst thing I ever did was tell my parents my #1 name because they didn't like it and pressured me not to use utChat Icon

Posted 7/26/10 3:55 PM
 

Shorty
.

Member since 5/05

30390 total posts

Name:
really

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

no, i couldn't compromise. we kept looking through books, websites, and LIF for names that we both liked, then ranked them.

Posted 7/26/10 3:56 PM
 

carissa1643
I LOVE my sons! :)

Member since 5/09

5283 total posts

Name:
Carissa

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

I didnt compromise, I gave in! Chat Icon

Posted 7/26/10 3:56 PM
 

Wendy
Wheeee!

Member since 5/05

13736 total posts

Name:

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

Yes. Well, first had Ann been a boy, she would have been named George Chat Icon no matter what because it was DH's father's name Chat Icon (I was okay with the reason but not the name so much Chat Icon ).

Ann was Kathryn (DH's sister) Jeanne (DH's mother) for three seconds but we never resolved the Katie/Kathy argument, so she quickly became Ann Kathryn.


Just for the record, they are all deceased so again, I was okay with using any of the names because of that reason. I hadn't really come up wiht any names I loved.

Posted 7/26/10 4:00 PM
 

nicrae
He's here!

Member since 12/06

9289 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

I did. I did NOT want to name my son Anthony. I loved a million other names. DH liked nothing but Anthony and sometimes Tyler depending on the day.

My son is named Anthony John and we call him AJ. That was DH's compromise. Chat Icon I still am not thrilled with it but it is too late now.

Posted 7/26/10 4:01 PM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

With our first, I asked Rob if he wanted a 'junior' - and prayed he would say no because i didn't love the name Robert. He DID say no and we settled on Vincent for a boy and Caelan for a girl. When our son was born - I said.. "So.. Vincent then?" and he just gave me this LOOK. I sighed and said "You want to name him Robert, don't you?" He did and we did. I actually LOVE the name now and couldn't imagine another name for my kid.

With our second, we just could NOT decide on a name for a boy. I wanted Noah, he wanted Joseph. I actually started praying for a girl so we wouldn't have to argue about it if it was a boy. Well.. it was a boy! I immediately knew I was naming him Noah. In recovery Rob said "Well.. I was thinking that we could do Jason if you really want to.." It was a name I had thrown out weeks earlier. I knew it would be Noah - but had to figure out how to get his buy in so I told him I needed to think about it. When he came up later that day I put on my best "I'm so frail and tired after just having given birth" face and said "I've spent the whole afternoon with him.. and he's just Noah to me.." Of course he had no choice but to give the poor new mother whatever she wanted!Chat Icon But now.. he loves the name and couldn't imagine any other name that would suit him better!

Posted 7/26/10 4:03 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

Posted by eddiesmommy

Compromise......if you want to call it that.

DS name is Edward, we call him Eddie. I HATED HATED HATED it, with a passion. However, it is DH name, his fathers name, his granfathers name, his great grandfathers name, and his great great grandfathers name. They were all the first son, of the first son.

So needless to say, when my DH (his dads first son) had a son (as his first), I couldnt be THAT girl and put an end to tradition. It was really important to DH. Id call it more than a compromise since I HATED the name.

With that said, DS is almost 3 and I couldnt see him called anything else and I have grown to LOVE LOVE LOVE it.



i was that girl, but DH sort of agreed with me. DS would have been IV but DH hates his name, so why on earth would we give the name DH hates to our son? (lawrence)

we decided to name him after my father who passed (jack for john). Were DH's father and grandfather upset, yes but what are they going to do? They got over it and they understand the significance to DS' name Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/26/10 4:03 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

We compromised. Well I say compromise but it was really a variation of his choice.

What I regret is making a big to do about his first choice. If I knew that I was going to love the name because it was my child's name...that the name would become the child, I would have let him have his way.

Posted 7/26/10 4:09 PM
 

Elizabeth
Mom of Three

Member since 9/05

7900 total posts

Name:
"MOMMY!!!"

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

I didn't. My DH did bc he didn't want my DD's first name. I don't believe he regrets it now. He said it was bc he knew someone with the name and didn't like her growing up. But I think it's forgotten now as it's become my DD's indentity more than his past memories.

Posted 7/26/10 4:13 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

We were both on board w/ Sean Patrick for a boy .............and couldn't agree on anything for a girl.

Posted 7/26/10 4:14 PM
 

bayla
Love my two kiddos :)

Member since 8/06

7178 total posts

Name:

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

with my DS we both liked two names (one was my DH's name) so I gave him the choice of which would be the first and which would be the middle as they sounded nice together either way. He decided he wanted our son to have his own name, so that made the decision easy. With our DD, we always knew what her name was going to be. However, toward the end of the pregnancy I started to have 2nd thoughts b/c it is very popular. My DH loved it though and really wanted it, so we kept with it. Also, b/c it was the version that didnt end with a, it was in the 30's on the name list and not in the top 10 (didnt want a top 10 name). The name fits her perfectly, so I am glad we choose it

Posted 7/26/10 4:17 PM
 

Angel321
...

Member since 4/08

15553 total posts

Name:

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

there were always 2 girl names that we loved....but dave really liked the other better than the one we chose...but i was more for Emma than he was....then he did something he shouldn't have (silly, but it hurt my feelings) and i got to 'choose' the name....to make up for it...

now that em's personality is 'showing' more and more - he completely agrees that she's more of an Emma than the other name (though we're keeping that name in the 'reserves' if we have a second child and she's a girl)....the name Emma just 'suits' her to a T...

can you possibly compromise and use DH's fave name as a middle name???

Posted 7/26/10 4:21 PM
 

neenie

Member since 5/05

22351 total posts

Name:

Re: Did anyone compromise on their DC's name?

Posted by davenjess

can you possibly compromise and use DH's fave name as a middle name???




Oh, I'd definitely use it for a middle name, but he doesn't want that. Doesn't see the point in it (and i can agree/understand) b/c he wouldn't call her by her middle name anyway.

Posted 7/26/10 4:23 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I think we finally came to a compromise on the nursery! HomeIsWithU 2/28/09 8 Pregnancy
What were your not willing to compromise on when looking at houses? beautyq115 10/30/07 45 Home
What do you do when your boss asks you to compromise your integrity? BigB 5/16/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
Do you think this a fair compromise regarding the immigration issue? SweetestOfPeas 4/5/06 10 Families Helping Families ™