Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted by nov04libride

I was just discussing this with a colleague today. She was taking her daughter who iis MR and will be old enough to vote next year to show her what to do. Her DD cannot read. She will not know about the issues or candidates. Her mother told her never to vote for anyone with a pro-life image next to their name. I can't help but think these individuals are not making their own decisions...and that's not what voting is about.



The reading part isnt really the problem...its the cognitive aspect. If the person could give me an answer as to why they are voting for Obama or McCain thats fine...If they dont know anything other then they are running for presidency...thats the problem..
There are actually alot of ways that accomodate people with disabilities and the ability to vote.

Posted 11/4/08 10:23 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by TeamBurns

MY brother is MR and is 20 years old. he expressed to my mother that he would like to vote this year, when she asked him who he wanted to vote for he didn't know anything about either candidate even their names. She explained to him that you don't just go in there and push buttons, it was important. She choose not to take him this time but told him that if next election he knew more about the candidates she would take him. I think it was a hard decision for her to make because while it is his right, he has no idea what he would be doing or who he would be choosing.

I think it was a good decision and will give him incentive to research and ask about the candidates next election



wow. your mom is impressive.

Posted by smdl

Legally (correct me if I am wrong) but if you considered unable to make decisions on your own (and that would be decided in a legal system) you are assigned a guardian who can make decisions for you. So unless they were considered legally mentally incompetent, they were allowed to vote.

But NOONE should tell anyone who to vote for.



and I agree with the sexy french woman



Me too and me too.

I am shocked that this thought never even entered my mind, given my field. I'll have to think about this.

But - I know there are many with significant issues who would not have any idea an election is going on. I can't imagine all the ethical rules being violated by having them used as a puppet....

Posted 11/4/08 10:26 PM
 

MrsBunnyBear
LIF Infant

Member since 9/08

143 total posts

Name:

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Hi,

I know this topic ended last week but its something I am passionate about and had to write.

I agree with a lot of what was said above. I am a social worker and work with people who have developmental disabilities. As long as someone can make a decision- any decision, they have the right to use their right to vote as long as they want to, are a registered voter and the court does not find them incapable of making a decision (very rare, because even a person with the most severe disability usually can choose a favorite activity or favorite lunch and these are choices). Even adults with Legal Guardianship (many people with a DD have) have the right to make a decision and are not found incapable by the court to make a decision. The Legal Guardianship is there for protection (mostly medical) but does not take their right to vote away.

People (all people) have the right to have someone in the booth with them to help them vote but they both have to go under oath at the polling site that the individual will not be influenced by the helper's opinion and the helper will not influence the individual's vote. The polling sites are usually a bit relaxed with this rule and just lets people go in together without question.

A responsible friend, staff or family member of a person with a DD would talk with the person weeks before about the issues to make sure they are educated enough to vote.

There is also an unofficial eligibility to vote checklist I have come across to help determine if someone does have the ability to vote responsibly. FM if you are interested.

To the original poster, you bring up a good point. "this particular group did not seem to know what was going on" Not all people with a DD can be characterized this way but it is likely that this group did appear this way because many people with a DD tend to have more receptive skills than expressive skills which means they understand more than it appears!

I am not sure why a poll person would be telling them who to vote for but I would think it would be a staff or family member and in that case I am hoping that she/he worked with the individuals beforehand on who they wanted to vote for because in these cases not knowing beforehand who the person wants to vote for could make for a very long day at the voting booth! What I mean is, its possible that they knew who these people wanted to vote for before they came and were not actually telling them who to vote for. Its okay that they were guided through the process but its has to be up to the voter 100% who they vote for.

Sorry this is long and late but its important and I just wanted to put it out there!

Posted 11/10/08 8:38 AM
 

ThePinkGoose
In Your Hands

Member since 8/08

4706 total posts

Name:
Nunya

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

I really hope that this does NOT get taken the wrong way, I do not mean it in a nasty way at all. I just wanted to say that there are a LOT of people that voted in this past election that have NO IDEA why they voted for their candidate. Just because someone is MR, does not mean that they cannot think or make a decision based on their beliefs. Maybe it is not the smartest or most thoughtful decision....but depending on the severity of the MR, you would be AMAZED at how thoughtful some of these amazing individuals are.

I don't think you should classify MR people in one group. MY BIL is MR and one of the smartest, sweetest people I know. On the contrary, an employee in the building that I work in stated to me last week that she voted for Obama because "she will have more rights as a black woman"................... WHAT???????!?!?!??! Chat Icon

At least my MR BIL had the common sense to realize that the reason he didn't want to vote for McCain is because he wanted the war in Iraq to be over. Still makes more sense than an Educated Employee where I work. Just something to think about.

Posted 11/10/08 9:32 AM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

It gets tricky though. Where do you draw the line? I think there are plenty of non developmentally disabled people who vote for reasons other than the issues--they like the way Cindy McCain dresses, or they have always voted Dem or Republican so they will do it again no matter who the candidate is. Guess I'm saying there are lots of people who vote knowing very little about the candidates and their positions.

Posted 11/10/08 10:24 AM
 

frosty
LIF Toddler

Member since 5/05

462 total posts

Name:

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

My SIL is developmentally disabled, and she takes voting VERY seriously. For every election, we get her a copy of Newday's election guide and she reads through every word of it. Then she writes down the names of all of the candidates that she wants to vote for, and takes that is list with her to the voting booth.

I took her to vote last week, and before she went to the booth, I reminded her what she needed to do (in terms of pulling the lever, etc.) She didn't need my help at all. Chat Icon Although, she was in the booth for a long time.

I admire her very much for ability to look at the candidate's stances on the issues and vote for the one that most closely aligns with her own. She is not a Democrat or Republican--she votes for who she thinks is the best candidate regardless of party affiliation. I wish more people would do that.

Posted 11/10/08 10:30 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
question about voting nferrandi 11/4/08 3 Parenting
grr about voting LSP2005 11/4/08 64 Families Helping Families ™
so I have to admit... (voting related) Cpt2007 11/4/08 42 Families Helping Families ™
Eyyyy, another voting question. photoshopbabe 11/4/08 4 Families Helping Families ™
LOVED the new e-voting!! Porrruss 11/4/08 12 Families Helping Families ™
I just witnessed the stupidest thing while voting.. Mimi25 11/4/08 10 Families Helping Families ™