Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

johnsae
Sip.

Member since 3/06

18677 total posts

Name:

Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Thought it would be an interesting topic to debate.

My Mom was in line behind a group of developmentally disabled voters today. She said this particular group did not seem to know what was going on and that the woman working at the booth was basically telling them who to vote for and pretty much guided them through the entire process.

What are your thoughts on this?

Posted 11/4/08 5:22 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

I don't think even I will touch this one Chat Icon

Posted 11/4/08 5:24 PM
 

MrsERod
Praying for Everyone.

Member since 5/05

26170 total posts

Name:
MrsERod™®

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

while i think they have every RIGHT to vote, i think it's pretty irresponsible of anyone, ESPECIALLY a poll worker to be TELLING them WHO to vote for. it might even be ILLEGAL.

Posted 11/4/08 5:26 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Ok.....is she sure? Because my sister was behind a blind voter with no one there to assist him (my Grandma was blind and I'd go with her, or my mom, she didn't trust my uncleChat Icon ) and HE was telling them who he wanted them to mark off, but they were repeating it as well.

Posted 11/4/08 5:28 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted by MrsERod

while i think they have every RIGHT to vote, i think it's pretty irresponsible of anyone, ESPECIALLY a poll worker to be TELLING them WHO to vote for. it might even be ILLEGAL.



I agree on all points.

Posted 11/4/08 5:28 PM
 

Reese1106
Family of 4! :o)

Member since 8/06

6655 total posts

Name:
Theresa

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

I think everyone should have the right to vote. However, I do think the person should also have the mental capacity to understand what they are doing. I don't mean they need the capacity to understand all of the intricate nuances of each candidates campaign. They should be able to understand the basics without someone else telling them what to do, especially a poll worker.

Message edited 2008-11-04 17:33:49.150000.

Posted 11/4/08 5:31 PM
 

Jessah
I love my dogs :)

Member since 2/08

1344 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

MY brother is MR and is 20 years old. he expressed to my mother that he would like to vote this year, when she asked him who he wanted to vote for he didn't know anything about either candidate even their names. She explained to him that you don't just go in there and push buttons, it was important. She choose not to take him this time but told him that if next election he knew more about the candidates she would take him. I think it was a hard decision for her to make because while it is his right, he has no idea what he would be doing or who he would be choosing.

I think it was a good decision and will give him incentive to research and ask about the candidates next election

Posted 11/4/08 5:35 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Legally (correct me if I am wrong) but if you considered unable to make decisions on your own (and that would be decided in a legal system) you are assigned a guardian who can make decisions for you. So unless they were considered legally mentally incompetent, they were allowed to vote.

But NOONE should tell anyone who to vote for.

Posted 11/4/08 5:36 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted by TeamBurns

MY brother is MR and is 20 years old. he expressed to my mother that he would like to vote this year, when she asked him who he wanted to vote for he didn't know anything about either candidate even their names. She explained to him that you don't just go in there and push buttons, it was important. She choose not to take him this time but told him that if next election he knew more about the candidates she would take him. I think it was a hard decision for her to make because while it is his right, he has no idea what he would be doing or who he would be choosing.

I think it was a good decision and will give him incentive to research and ask about the candidates next election



wow. your mom is impressive.

Posted by smdl

Legally (correct me if I am wrong) but if you considered unable to make decisions on your own (and that would be decided in a legal system) you are assigned a guardian who can make decisions for you. So unless they were considered legally mentally incompetent, they were allowed to vote.

But NOONE should tell anyone who to vote for.



and I agree with the sexy french woman

Posted 11/4/08 5:41 PM
 

VirginiaDeb
Don't eat me, hippo!

Member since 5/05

9252 total posts

Name:
Deb

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

DH brought his clients (all of whom are developmentally disabled). He took the time over the last few weeks to tell them about the issues.

Posted 11/4/08 5:46 PM
 

Jessah
I love my dogs :)

Member since 2/08

1344 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by TeamBurns

MY brother is MR and is 20 years old. he expressed to my mother that he would like to vote this year, when she asked him who he wanted to vote for he didn't know anything about either candidate even their names. She explained to him that you don't just go in there and push buttons, it was important. She choose not to take him this time but told him that if next election he knew more about the candidates she would take him. I think it was a hard decision for her to make because while it is his right, he has no idea what he would be doing or who he would be choosing.

I think it was a good decision and will give him incentive to research and ask about the candidates next election



wow. your mom is impressive.

Thank you

I really admire her! I at first told her she was mean, but I agree with her after hearing her reasoning

Posted 11/4/08 5:48 PM
 

LightUpOurLife
Totally in love

Member since 8/06

12785 total posts

Name:
Bonnie-Jean

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

I also wonder how many mail in votes are filled out by family members of people unable to vote.

Posted 11/4/08 6:04 PM
 

MrsPowers
So blessed!

Member since 11/06

10348 total posts

Name:
Ivelysse

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Everyone that is a legal resident of the United States has a right to vote. People that have developmental disabilities have the right to vote just as much as everyone else in this country. LIke everyone else, they should learn about the candidates. There are people who vote without having educated themselves about the candidates.

Posted 11/4/08 6:23 PM
 

Deedlebugs
Blessed

Member since 12/05

10281 total posts

Name:
Kiki

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted by TeamBurns

MY brother is MR and is 20 years old. he expressed to my mother that he would like to vote this year, when she asked him who he wanted to vote for he didn't know anything about either candidate even their names. She explained to him that you don't just go in there and push buttons, it was important. She choose not to take him this time but told him that if next election he knew more about the candidates she would take him. I think it was a hard decision for her to make because while it is his right, he has no idea what he would be doing or who he would be choosing.

I think it was a good decision and will give him incentive to research and ask about the candidates next election



You have an amazingly smart mother. Bravo!!

Posted 11/4/08 6:49 PM
 

Jessah
I love my dogs :)

Member since 2/08

1344 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted by Deedlebug126

Posted by TeamBurns

MY brother is MR and is 20 years old. he expressed to my mother that he would like to vote this year, when she asked him who he wanted to vote for he didn't know anything about either candidate even their names. She explained to him that you don't just go in there and push buttons, it was important. She choose not to take him this time but told him that if next election he knew more about the candidates she would take him. I think it was a hard decision for her to make because while it is his right, he has no idea what he would be doing or who he would be choosing.

I think it was a good decision and will give him incentive to research and ask about the candidates next election



You have an amazingly smart mother. Bravo!!



Thank you so much! I agree she is amazing. I don't think I could do it. It has been a hard 20 years always tying to make the best decisions for my brother, and as he gets older they get even harder.Chat Icon

Posted 11/4/08 6:59 PM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Unfortunately, I have to think - is the end result really that different from so many other voters who are perfectly able to make educated decisions, yet choose not to learn about the candidates and just vote for whoever?

Posted 11/4/08 7:03 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted by MrsPowers

Everyone that is a legal resident of the United States has a right to vote. People that have developmental disabilities have the right to vote just as much as everyone else in this country. LIke everyone else, they should learn about the candidates. There are people who vote without having educated themselves about the candidates.



Actually you have to be a US citizen to vote. NOT just a legal resident.

Posted 11/4/08 7:06 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

i believe that ALL voters SHOULD know enough about the candidates to make an informed decision about who they want to vote for - and while that is obviously more of a challenge for someone who is developmentally disabled, it is also true that a large number of people who are NOT developmentally disabled place their votes without knowing anything more than the candidates' name and race.

in a perfect world...

Posted 11/4/08 7:49 PM
 

Tabitha

Member since 2/07

2029 total posts

Name:

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted by TeamBurns

MY brother is MR and is 20 years old. he expressed to my mother that he would like to vote this year, when she asked him who he wanted to vote for he didn't know anything about either candidate even their names. She explained to him that you don't just go in there and push buttons, it was important. She choose not to take him this time but told him that if next election he knew more about the candidates she would take him. I think it was a hard decision for her to make because while it is his right, he has no idea what he would be doing or who he would be choosing.

I think it was a good decision and will give him incentive to research and ask about the candidates next election



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon that mustve been tough for you mom.. good for her!!

Posted 11/4/08 7:49 PM
 

MrsPowers
So blessed!

Member since 11/06

10348 total posts

Name:
Ivelysse

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted by smdl

Posted by MrsPowers

Everyone that is a legal resident of the United States has a right to vote. People that have developmental disabilities have the right to vote just as much as everyone else in this country. LIke everyone else, they should learn about the candidates. There are people who vote without having educated themselves about the candidates.



Actually you have to be a US citizen to vote. NOT just a legal resident.



Yes I am aware of this. I didn't phrase my response properly.

Posted 11/4/08 7:54 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted by JessInCA

Unfortunately, I have to think - is the end result really that different from so many other voters who are perfectly able to make educated decisions, yet choose not to learn about the candidates and just vote for whoever?



Exactly. What's the difference between someone who is not able to be educated about the candidates and someone who just isn't by their own doing? Not much different. Maybe except that the person who is MR might be more succeptible to voting based on someone else's influence.

Posted 11/4/08 8:21 PM
 

DeniseMarie
<3

Member since 8/07

10682 total posts

Name:

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Posted by Reese1106

I think everyone should have the right to vote. However, I do think the person should also have the mental capacity to understand what they are doing. I don't mean they need the capacity to understand all of the intricate nuances of each candidates campaign. They should be able to understand the basics without someone else telling them what to do, especially a poll worker.



i agree

Posted 11/4/08 8:22 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

Chat Icon

Posted 11/4/08 8:53 PM
 

PrincessP
Big sister!!!!!!!!!!

Member since 12/05

17450 total posts

Name:

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

This is an awesome topic...
I am a SWer for the Developmentally disabled and myself and the other SWer were debating this. I actually clearly agree with you. If they do not know what they are doing...I dont think they should vote. She kept saying "its their right". I had a African American student that has a moderate MR level (IQ 50-60) tell me he wanted to vote. I wondered if this came from him wanting to vote or some aids in the classroom telling him he needs to vote and who to vote for. Thats just wrong on SO many levels. He decided TODAY...yes...TODAY ...that he needed to vote. If he was as enthusiastic as he was today, then he would have asked for a register form well before now. It angers me to think others would rub off their opinions and tell them what to do.

Posted 11/4/08 9:00 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Developmentally disabled individuals voting....

I was just discussing this with a colleague today. She was taking her daughter who iis MR and will be old enough to vote next year to show her what to do. Her DD cannot read. She will not know about the issues or candidates. Her mother told her never to vote for anyone with a pro-life image next to their name. I can't help but think these individuals are not making their own decisions...and that's not what voting is about.

Posted 11/4/08 9:07 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
question about voting nferrandi 11/4/08 3 Parenting
grr about voting LSP2005 11/4/08 64 Families Helping Families ™
so I have to admit... (voting related) Cpt2007 11/4/08 42 Families Helping Families ™
Eyyyy, another voting question. photoshopbabe 11/4/08 4 Families Helping Families ™
LOVED the new e-voting!! Porrruss 11/4/08 12 Families Helping Families ™
I just witnessed the stupidest thing while voting.. Mimi25 11/4/08 10 Families Helping Families ™