deleted

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

deleted

thanks everyone! Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-11-24 11:54:33.263000.

Posted 11/24/10 10:22 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

I'm going to be honest here, and say that if you feel that strongly, I would tell your MIL that you think it's best that she doesn't mind DS.

As a working mom, it did take me a while to step back and think about what was best for DS--if my MIL takes him to the playground or aquarium and he has a great day, sure, I wish I was there, but the larger issue is that he was happy, and I know he was well taken care of. I do think some of your restrictions are unreasonable (not the driving long distances, but I can't imagine that happening too often anyway, and not going to fun places).

To me, when you have a relative minding DC, you do need to give them leeway and allow them flexibility. If you are putting your DC's life in their hands, then you need to assume that they will take it seriously and not do anything to endanger DC.

Message edited 2010-11-24 10:27:18.690000.

Posted 11/24/10 10:24 AM
 

BethanyLynn
Love these munchkins

Member since 10/09

6295 total posts

Name:
Bethany

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

I think # 3 and 4 are reasonable.
#1...you dont trust her driving? Whats the difference between 2 towns over and 5?
#2 however...I dont think you can tell her she cant take DS to fun places. That doesnt sound reasonable. I know as a first time mom that you want to do that but I dont think you can tell her that.

Message edited 2010-11-24 10:24:49.967000.

Posted 11/24/10 10:24 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

yes, to me, it sounds unreasonable.

but if that is what YOU want and are comforable with, that is what you do.

don't go by what other people think. Chat Icon

ETA: you should also be equally prepared for her "un"reasonable reaction!

Message edited 2010-11-24 10:25:25.197000.

Posted 11/24/10 10:24 AM
 

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by BethanyLynn

I think # 3 and 4 are reasonable.
#1...you dont trust her driving? Whats the difference between 2 towns over and 5?
#2 however...I dont think you can tell her she cant take DS to fun places. That doesnt sound reasonable. I know as a first time mom that you want to do that but I dont think you can tell her that.



i dont care if she takes him to fun places, but i would want to be there for his first time at say, adventureland, ya know??

eta: its not that i dont trust her driving... its just all new to me & freaks me out

Message edited 2010-11-24 10:27:36.850000.

Posted 11/24/10 10:26 AM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Okay totally playing devils advocate here....I can understand not wanting her to travel far. But as far as mommy and me groups why? (Not trying to be snarky). I mean your son is the one who will benefit from this and we had alot of grandmothers at the mommy and me classes I took Teddy too. It's a great way to help them socialize. I am just trying to understand? (please don't take it as me being nasty I am really not)Chat Icon

Posted 11/24/10 10:27 AM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by MeeshMosh

Posted by BethanyLynn

I think # 3 and 4 are reasonable.
#1...you dont trust her driving? Whats the difference between 2 towns over and 5?
#2 however...I dont think you can tell her she cant take DS to fun places. That doesnt sound reasonable. I know as a first time mom that you want to do that but I dont think you can tell her that.



i dont care if she takes him to fun places, but i would want to be there for his first time at say, adventureland, ya know??



But really, he will have no idea about adventureland for a year or more, so is that even worth bringing up now?

The difficult thing about this is he will have many firsts with her, and I think soon you'll need to figure out how to make peace with what he does and learns when you aren't there. It's a really tough thing.

Message edited 2010-11-24 10:29:23.180000.

Posted 11/24/10 10:28 AM
 

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by nov04libride

I'm going to be honest here, and say that if you feel that strongly, I would tell your MIL that you think it's best that she doesn't mind DS.

As a working mom, it did take me a while to step back and think about what was best for DS--if my MIL takes him to the playground or aquarium and he has a great day, sure, I wish I was there, but the larger issue is that he was happy, and I know he was well taken care of. I do think some of your restrictions are unreasonable (not the driving long distances, but I can't imagine that happening too often anyway, and not going to fun places).

To me, when you have a relative minding DC, you do need to give them leeway and allow them flexibility. If you are putting your DC's life in their hands, then you need to assume that they will take it seriously and not do anything to endanger DC.



thanks for your honest answer

i dont care if she does fun things with him... of course that would be great for ds... i just dont want to miss out on his first time at places ya know?? if she wants to take him a 2nd 3rd and 4th time fine

Posted 11/24/10 10:29 AM
 

CookieMomster
Golden

Member since 5/09

6414 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Oh and as for the aquarium and Adventure land, I would explain that maybe you guys can plan a trip together for the first time. And maybe buy a membership from there so she can take him on her own as well from there on after. HTH

Posted 11/24/10 10:30 AM
 

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by CookieMomster

Okay totally playing devils advocate here....I can understand not wanting her to travel far. But as far as mommy and me groups why? (Not trying to be snarky). I mean your son is the one who will benefit from this and we had alot of grandmothers at the mommy and me classes I took Teddy too. It's a great way to help them socialize. I am just trying to understand? (please don't take it as me being nasty I am really not)Chat Icon



bc i feel like a mommy & me group is something that i want to do with ds... something that is special for a mommy & a child

Posted 11/24/10 10:31 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by MeeshMosh

Posted by BethanyLynn

I think # 3 and 4 are reasonable.
#1...you dont trust her driving? Whats the difference between 2 towns over and 5?
#2 however...I dont think you can tell her she cant take DS to fun places. That doesnt sound reasonable. I know as a first time mom that you want to do that but I dont think you can tell her that.



i dont care if she takes him to fun places, but i would want to be there for his first time at say, adventureland, ya know??

eta: its not that i dont trust her driving... its just all new to me & freaks me out



does your MIL normally request these places?

do you have reason to believe that she would go to an amusement park (or whatever adventureland is) during a work day by herself???

don't get me wrong...i understand the anxiety. I just had a freak out myself b/c I was never told that someone was planning on driving my son someplace but didn't even ask me (but that person was NOT his every day caregiver) but you HAVE to make it enjoyable for everyone.

it is most unreasonable that you have your son sit at home all day waiting for you to do the fun stuff.

it is the worst part of being a working mom. but that is OUR choice. to work. your son still needs and deserves to do fun stuff during the day.

and honestly, be HAPPY that your MIL is there to do it with him!!!

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

ETA: I have a solution for you. everything YOU want to get first shot at, do it NOW. or plan it NOW. this way, you have no worries. Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-11-24 10:32:17.557000.

Posted 11/24/10 10:31 AM
 

Karma
LIF Infant

Member since 9/10

201 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Yes, it's unreasonable. You are only "punishing" your son by setting these ground rules and you will negatively affect your relationship with both your DH and your MIL.

Posted 11/24/10 10:32 AM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Honestly, I think they're a bit unreasonable. My mom watches DS two days a week and to be honest, while we have butted heads about certian things, I cant imagine telling her that she cant go to places and have fun with her grandson. I know the library has a lot of programs (that are mommy and me like) and actually encourage her to do that. Being stuck in the house with a toddler all day can be exhausting. So yes, she has a car seat and they go to home depot and BJs and the mall. they go to the park and other places. Will I be there for every "first?" No, but it when we do it together, he will be his FIRST time with MOMMY Chat Icon And while some would argue with me here, I dont think her calling me everytime she is going somewhere is necessary. I trust that she will see that no harm comes to him because he is her grandson and I trust her (otherwise I would not allow her to watch him in the first place).

Posted 11/24/10 10:33 AM
 

Salason
&hearts;

Member since 6/05

9878 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by Ophelia

yes, to me, it sounds unreasonable.

but if that is what YOU want and are comforable with, that is what you do.

don't go by what other people think. Chat Icon

ETA: you should also be equally prepared for her "un"reasonable reaction!



I agree with this Chat Icon

Posted 11/24/10 10:33 AM
 

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by MeeshMosh

Posted by BethanyLynn

I think # 3 and 4 are reasonable.
#1...you dont trust her driving? Whats the difference between 2 towns over and 5?
#2 however...I dont think you can tell her she cant take DS to fun places. That doesnt sound reasonable. I know as a first time mom that you want to do that but I dont think you can tell her that.



i dont care if she takes him to fun places, but i would want to be there for his first time at say, adventureland, ya know??

eta: its not that i dont trust her driving... its just all new to me & freaks me out



does your MIL normally request these places?

do you have reason to believe that she would go to an amusement park (or whatever adventureland is) during a work day by herself???

don't get me wrong...i understand the anxiety. I just had a freak out myself b/c I was never told that someone was planning on driving my son someplace but didn't even ask me (but that person was NOT his every day caregiver) but you HAVE to make it enjoyable for everyone.

it is most unreasonable that you have your son sit at home all day waiting for you to do the fun stuff.

it is the worst part of being a working mom. but that is OUR choice. to work. your son still needs and deserves to do fun stuff during the day.

and honestly, be HAPPY that your MIL is there to do it with him!!!

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

ETA: I have a solution for you. everything YOU want to get first shot at, do it NOW. or plan it NOW. this way, you have no worries. Chat Icon



yes -- when she was talking to dh about babysitting she mentioned those 2 places

Posted 11/24/10 10:35 AM
 

SecretTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

2284 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

1 and 3 are reasonable. 2 and 4 are really unreasonable.

Posted 11/24/10 10:36 AM
 

BethanyLynn
Love these munchkins

Member since 10/09

6295 total posts

Name:
Bethany

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

It is very scary for a working first time mom to imagine her child doing fun things without her, I know that.

But trust me, you have to try to be reasonable. She is not going to call you every time she wants to go somewhere. She is not going to be limited to certain towns.

Like PP said, if you are not there for the FIRSTS, remember that when you DO do it together, it will be the FIRST time with MOMMY!

Posted 11/24/10 10:37 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

I think you are being reasonable. But I have been called psychotic and have been told I have separation anxiety SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO keep that in mind. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/24/10 10:37 AM
 

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

ok maybe i didnt make myself clear, i dont care if she doest fun things with him... at all! of course i dont want her stuck in the house & i dont want DS stuck in the house either!

she had just mentioned the aquarium & adventureland to dh and i got sad thinking that i wouldnt be there for his first time there

Posted 11/24/10 10:38 AM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by MeeshMosh

yes -- when she was talking to dh about babysitting she mentioned those 2 places



ah.

so what if you maybe said she can take him there AFTER you do it.

I do understand wanting certain firsts. that is not unreasonable.

but your OP sounds like you are putting the smackdown on fun. and I think it will cause too many hard feelings.

pick and choose what is most important to you.

I am in the opposite situation. my MIL watches my son every day but has a bad knee so she can't get around as much as she used to. so, he's at home. all day. no classes. no nothing. Chat Icon

that bothers me more than ME missing a first. is HE not experiences it at all. Chat Icon

Posted 11/24/10 10:38 AM
 

Lauren82
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

4580 total posts

Name:
L

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

I will tell you how we worked it with my MIL and my mom, who babysit for my kids...they can go basically wherever they want with the girls, but if they are going somewhere out of the ordinary (like to Nassau County to pick up a turkey!, or to LGA to drop off my FIL: this could be a weekly occurrence since he is in the airline industry) we want a phone call so we have the option to come home. I am not comfortable with someone else driving my kids to LGA and will gladly come home sick from work for that. We did have some trouble accepting my MIL bringing my kids to do things that we really wanted to do with them first: aquarium, pumpkin picking...we talked to her and explained how we felt and she totally understood how we felt.
We tried to make it less of the "law" and more of how we just weren't comfortable with certain things and were willing to work with them to solve the issues in a way that was fair to everyone.

Posted 11/24/10 10:43 AM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by MeeshMosh

ok maybe i didnt make myself clear, i dont care if she doest fun things with him... at all! of course i dont want her stuck in the house & i dont want DS stuck in the house either!

she had just mentioned the aquarium & adventureland to dh and i got sad thinking that i wouldnt be there for his first time there




I think maybe she doesn't know what the first year of his life will be like. I can't imagine him enjoying either of those places for at least the first year, so I wouldn't worry about that now.

Posted 11/24/10 10:43 AM
 

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by Ophelia

ah.

so what if you maybe said she can take him there AFTER you do it.

I do understand wanting certain firsts. that is not unreasonable.

but your OP sounds like you are putting the smackdown on fun. and I think it will cause too many hard feelings.




yes that is what i meant in my OP... i jsut edited it -- so you dont think its unreasonable to ask her to wait till i can go too & then if she wants to take him again, tahts fine?

Posted 11/24/10 10:43 AM
 

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

To me, it does but we're very laid back. MIL watches DD full time and we didn't set one ground rule or tell her what to do or not to do when she's with her. She's responsible for DD during that time and we trust her 100%.

Now, I know she wouldn't drive somewhere an hour away with her without telling us but she does take her out to lunch, to the beach, park, mall, BIL's house if he's home, etc. I usually find out when I pick her up after work which is fine by me.

We also signed them up for a gym class once a week and she asked me the other day if she could do a swim class with DD. I think it's great that she wants to do that and YES it does make me sad that *I* won't be with her for that, but I just try to do fun things with her on the weekends to make up for it. I'd rather MIL take her to places and to classes so they get out of the house. It's good for both of them.

I know it's hard. Maybe you can just bring up that you'd like her to let you know if she's thinking about bringing your DS somewhere that week. Then you can talk about it.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/24/10 10:45 AM
 

Rycois
Blessed with 2blue/2pink

Member since 12/05

13341 total posts

Name:
J

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

I think you should test the waters before laying the law down or just feel her out. It sounds like she might just want access to a carseat so she can just an errand while she's with him, or go down to the park for a walk. For that type of thing, I wouldn't expect advance notice. "Excursions" are another thing and if you're going to limit them I would approach it very delicately and just say something like "you know I appreciate that you're watching DC and bringing him out and about but there are certain experiences I want to be there for first..."

Posted 11/24/10 10:47 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
My first MIL Issue- Beyond LIVID!! avamamma 1/7/07 8 Parenting
Another MIL issue iwed2005 6/20/06 4 Pregnancy
another MIL issue PrincessP 6/20/06 4 Pregnancy
How would you feel? (Long, MIL issue) CathyB 1/5/06 13 Parenting