deleted

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by MeeshMosh

Posted by Ophelia

ah.

so what if you maybe said she can take him there AFTER you do it.

I do understand wanting certain firsts. that is not unreasonable.

but your OP sounds like you are putting the smackdown on fun. and I think it will cause too many hard feelings.




yes that is what i meant in my OP... i jsut edited it -- so you dont think its unreasonable to ask her to wait till i can go too & then if she wants to take him again, tahts fine?



nope! not at all! Chat Icon

Posted 11/24/10 10:48 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Sunday
In love with a boy named Luca

Member since 6/09

1799 total posts

Name:
`

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Honestly? Except for the wanting to know where she is taking dc, I think you sound unreasonable and may even come off as ungrateful even though I know that's not where this is coming from.

MIL watches ds full time and I would be thrilled if she took him to fun places. SIL is around a bit more than I am and has taken ds to mommy and me. I think that's awesome and I love her for it. I hate how many hours I work and wish I could spend more time with ds but it's just the weekends for now and I jump at the opportunity for him to experience more.

As far as driving I know it can be scary but I know that my mil and sil are being just as careful as I am. I mean I think I'm a pretty good driver but tbh I don't think there is much of a difference ntwn them and me- it's not like they are speeding or drinking etc- we are all driving to the best of our ability.

Personally I do not ask mil to let me know when they drive- she takes him with her to some local dr.appts, grocery store, etc but she knows to tell me if they have some sort of big plan. I guess for me it is about trust-i trust her to make these decisions in my absence and there is a while lot of absence since I went back to work Chat Icon

Posted 11/24/10 10:52 AM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

I think your feelings are your feelings and nothing we can say will change that. Id feel the same way with firsts. I missed quite a few with Abby by virtue of her being in day care. I missed her first steps and her first words. I don't think it is unreasonable to feel that way. But I agree, you should do certain activities first and THEN have your MIL repeat them. If she wanted to take your little one to Disney World, that would be a huge "H E LL NO!!!!"

Posted 11/24/10 10:56 AM
 

MrsDrMatt
Live and RUN like a Ninja!

Member since 5/06

3104 total posts

Name:
MrsDrMatt

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Completely unreasonable.

sorry

Posted 11/24/10 10:57 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by MeeshMosh
1. i do not want her traveling far... only localy -- a few towns over is fine, but i dont want her going all over the island!

2. i dont want her taking ds to fun places like the aquarium or adventureland bc as a first time mom, i'd want to be there for ds's first time at fun places like that, KWIM? she can take him for his 2nd 3rd or 4th time, but id want to be there for his first time at fun places

3. i want her to call me to let me know where she plans on taking ds that day

4. i dont want her doing any mommy & me groups with ds







1. Sounds reasonable to me. I have a 2yr old and pretty much the same rules

2. I think this is part of #3 as well. I had the same kind of rule but instead I modified it to "Give me a heads up and I'll see if I can't take some time off early to go with you" Since she was so small she slept most of the time anyway and with feedings, changings etc, it really never worked out that this was an issue. But I am still willing to take a day off of work or an hour or two out early if she wants to take AJ to the Zoo. I get what you're saying but say it nicer. Chat Icon

3. Makes totally sense to me - Again at 2yrs old I'm still the same with AJ and my aunt. Even on just weekends. I explained it that I'm a paranoid freak and I'd just die if I found out there's a fire in her neighborhood only to find out they are at the mall. Or if there's some fire at a mall or random crime ..whatever and I didn't know they were there, etc. So for my blood pressure, please let me know where you are. Its called a courtsey call. Again worded the right way, this one seems understandable to me.

4. I don't care about Mommy & Me stuff. Its just a fancy name for child care with the parent/guardian there. Sure they learn new stuff but I never got into them. Its just paying money to someone else to entertain my child while I participate. If my aunt wanted to do this, then fine. I'd rather have the home moments of watching her learn to clap and tilt her head etc. So I don't think its "UNREASONABLE" I think its unimportant but that's my personal opinion.

Posted 11/24/10 11:03 AM
 

MrsRbk
<3 <3 <3 <3

Member since 1/06

19197 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

It's hard for me to say...

The issue with the driving, I myself have a VERY hard time with that. I just had an incidient last week where after my MIL told me they wanted to get a car seat for the baby so they could pick my DD and DS up for the weekend (we already had plans for them to go to IL's for the weekend, but WE were going to drive them... they live in Queens and we are in NJ). I told her no and gave her the following reasons:

1. Waste of $$ DS is a big baby and will not be in an infant seat for long.

and

2. I am NOT comfortable with others driving my kids. This is how I feel, and I can't help it. As their parent, that should have been respected instead of having my FIL show up that Friday to pick up the kids without anyone asking me if it was okay....yeah.... that happened and it was the first and LAST time I allowed it to happen.

So, for that, I can't fault you for how you feel.

I do feel though, if you are going to allow her to drive your DC, then asking she not do mommy and me type classes is totally unreasonable. I'm a SAHM now, and take my DD to places like Music Together, My Gym, etc.... and honestly, I'm one of the ONLY mommies there. The rest are usually nannies and grandparents. It's a great way for your DC to socialize instead of being cooped up at home all day.

My MIL watches my kids 2 days a week, well, now that I'm home, she's an extra pair of hands to help out. She herself is not comfortable driving the kids, but she will take them outside and out for walks just to get them out of the house.


I understand your anxiety, especially as a first time mom. But I think you do need to give a little.

Message edited 2010-11-24 11:06:58.777000.

Posted 11/24/10 11:06 AM
 

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

thank you for all your responses

i dont want to come off like im ungreatful for MIL offering to watch ds 2 days a week... if it didnt free up $400 a month (since he will be in day care 2 less days) i would have said thank you but no thanks & not bc i want to deprive ds of quality time with his grandmother (bc believe me, DH and i plan to still go out & have adult time without DS & she will be called a lot to watch him!) i just feel more comfortable with ds at the day care -- its through my job so i think thats why im so okay with it

anyways, i appreciate hearing opinions from the veteran moms lol -- thanks again Chat Icon

Posted 11/24/10 11:09 AM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

just wondering... would you feel the same way if it was your mom and not your MIL? or your DH and not your MIL?

it's inevitable that as a working mom, you're going to miss certain firsts... and it HURTS! i missed many firsts during those first 6 months and it STUNK, but when i got to see whatever it was for myself... it was JUST as amazing!

i understand how you feel... for example, my SIL took Loey to the beach for the first time and I wanted to do that... but you know what? the first time that I did take him... I got to see the wonder in his eyes, got to see him "taste" some sand... got to splash in the ocean with him... it was great! it didn't matter that it wasn't his first time. it was his first time WITH MOMMY and that makes it really special too.

i know you want to be there for the mommy and me classes, but you're going to be working and many classes are during the workday. my mom is going to be watching Loey some days when I start my new job and I've already looked up classes for them to go to. I feel like the baby needs to be stimulated and the caregiver needs some adult interaction too. staying at home all of the time with the baby can get old REAL fast! there's only so many toys you can play with... KWIM?

i understand the driving issue, but again... would you feel more comfortable if it was your mom vs. your MIL? if so, then i would really think about why you feel that way. for #1, 2 and 4... KWIM?

if it was me, I'd lessen the restrictions of #3... does she need to call you if she's going to the post office? the supermarket? the bank? etc.... KWIM? it could get a little crazy with phonecalls all day long. when DH watched Loey, I just expected them to do whatever during the day and I'd hear all about it when I got home... and sometimes even see pictures :)

Posted 11/24/10 11:23 AM
 

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by maybeamommy

just wondering... would you feel the same way if it was your mom and not your MIL? or your DH and not your MIL?




yes i would feel the same way if it was my mom wanting to drive ds

Posted 11/24/10 11:25 AM
 

mrskmurphy
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/09

688 total posts

Name:
Kate

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

hmm...i guess i'm in the minority, but i don't think it's unreasonable at all.

he's your child. she got to do all of those things with HER child, and now you get to make those decisions for yours!!!

i'm sure that you've taken DC to "fun" places before, so can't she just go to those places? i don't think at 2 days a week, she's going to need to be running all over to aquariums, zoos, etc.

maybe make it a point to get some of the "first timey" thigns out of the way on weekends, so that she has more to choose from with him during the week?

as for the driving, i totally agree. i feel uncomfortable with anyone else (aside from DH) driving logan. unless i'm in the car too, i have major anxiety about it.

you will figure it out - but do what YOU are comfortable with...who cares what everyone else thinks is reasonable? its' YOUR delicious baby :)

Posted 11/24/10 11:28 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by MeeshMosh

Posted by maybeamommy

just wondering... would you feel the same way if it was your mom and not your MIL? or your DH and not your MIL?




yes i would feel the same way if it was my mom wanting to drive ds



DH calls me whenever he takes AM somewhere while I am at work Chat Icon

Posted 11/24/10 11:30 AM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

I think you are not totally unreasonable and I feel the same way about doing "first time" stuff with DS without DH and I.

I dont see an issue with mommy and me. As much as I would be sad that I am not the one doing it with DS, if I was workling I wouldnt be able to and I think it is something really important for for a baby to go to those classes if they can.

I think it is reasonable to ask her to not go far, but you cant expect her to not go out with DC. As a SAHM right now I get cabin fever and need to get out.

I think you just have to tell her nicely about your concerns. Hopefully she will not get insulted.

Posted 11/24/10 11:30 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by CookieMomster

Okay totally playing devils advocate here....I can understand not wanting her to travel far. But as far as mommy and me groups why? (Not trying to be snarky). I mean your son is the one who will benefit from this and we had alot of grandmothers at the mommy and me classes I took Teddy too. It's a great way to help them socialize. I am just trying to understand? (please don't take it as me being nasty I am really not)Chat Icon



I agree with this.

Believe me I do understand not wanting to miss the firsts (DH & my ILs went to Disney with 4 yo DS - without me & it did crush me).

I also think that MIL has grand plans for taking him all over but may be out of touch with watching an infant. I don't know anyone who took an infant to Adventureland. I think she's imagining him as a toddler going. By the time you cross that bridge, he may be in pre-school & not being watched anymore.

I do think you should simply spell out the rule of "I need to know where you are going with him before you go" & if she's planning a place you wanted to be a "first", address it then.

Posted 11/24/10 11:31 AM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by Tilde

Posted by MeeshMosh

Posted by maybeamommy

just wondering... would you feel the same way if it was your mom and not your MIL? or your DH and not your MIL?




yes i would feel the same way if it was my mom wanting to drive ds



DH calls me whenever he takes AM somewhere while I am at work Chat Icon



Oh I totally get that and wasn't trying to knock it at all... just sometimes we get a little crazy over one person doing things, KWIM?

Like I would have hated for my BIL to do something with Loey, but wouldn't have cared if it was DH... KWIM? If that was the case, then I'd think maybe she needs to lighten up a bit. But if it's that way with EVERYONE and not just MIL (like for the driving situation) then I can understand that and don't think it's that unreasonable... I hope that makes some sort of sense!

DH watched Loey for 6 months and I never expected a call if they were going out.... but that's just us and there's nothing wrong with wanting a call to hear what your little girlie is doing! DH would text me pictures through the day anyway Chat Icon

Posted 11/24/10 11:32 AM
 

littlebeanz
LIF Adult

Member since 7/10

1667 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Honestly I think if you dont trust her then dont have her babysit. I trust my il's and allow them to do whatever they want because I do trust them.

Why do you not want them to take her anywhere fun????

Posted 11/24/10 11:33 AM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by littlebeanz

Honestly I think if you dont trust her then dont have her babysit. I trust my il's and allow them to do whatever they want because I do trust them.

Why do you not want them to take her anywhere fun????



My thoughts exactly

Posted 11/24/10 11:33 AM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by littlebeanz

Honestly I think if you dont trust her then dont have her babysit. I trust my il's and allow them to do whatever they want because I do trust them.

Why do you not want them to take her anywhere fun????



She never said she doesn't trust her. She just doesn't feel comfortable having other people drive her child - which many of us can understand.

She also just wants to do the "firsts" with her LO and not miss out. I'm sure she feels she's missing out on enough being a FTWM

Posted 11/24/10 11:34 AM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

I do think it's unreasonable. My only problem with my nanny is that she doesn't take my kids out enough. I wish, for their sake, they were able to get out more. I would love it for my parents or the nanny to take my kids to an acquarium, a playground or someplace fun. (though i do agree for any major places, i want to be there for the first time) would i be sad that I am missing it? Aboslutely. No doubt. but that's my hurt for being a f/t working mom. i dont want my kids to miss out and be stuck home all day because i have to work. If you trust your MIL driving, and have given her a thorough lesson in safe car seat use, I would be happy that she is taking your DC out. I would also be absolutely thrilled if my parents took DDs to "mommy" and me classes. i actually dont find that I "bond" with my kids at those classes. They have a lot of fun, but it's not a bonding experience. we have many many other ways we bond and interact more together. i actually dont like when we have a class we have to be at during the weekend, so i would love love love it if they got to do those things during the week and i could plan other fun activities for the weekends. as for knowing what they are doing that day--yes, i would want to know where my kid is.

Posted 11/24/10 11:38 AM
 

Deeluvsvinny
DONE

Member since 10/08

4952 total posts

Name:
Whatever

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

I think it's a bit unreasonable. I mean, DD goes to a sitter, who is like family to us. I got her a car seat and she takes DD around, she always tells where she's going that day, so I know. I would actualy LOVE for her to take DD to fun kiddie places..I don't want to deprive DD just bc I have to work all day. I can understand saying.. We want to take DC to the aquarium first. But, you cna't be the first take him everywhere.
I'm actually LOOKING for a mommy & me group for DD & the sitter, I think DD would love that, and the weekends get hectic and it takes away from our itme.

I know it's hard as a first time mom, and going back to work, but honestly, he'll be with his grandma, I think that's fabulous! You're going to have let go a little and realize that you will miss some "firsts". I have a deal with my sitter, it didn't happen at all until mommy sees it! So, even though she really crawled full fledged at the sitter's house, it didn't happen until later that night, when I saw it Chat Icon \

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/24/10 11:42 AM
 

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by maybeamommy

Posted by littlebeanz

Honestly I think if you dont trust her then dont have her babysit. I trust my il's and allow them to do whatever they want because I do trust them.

Why do you not want them to take her anywhere fun????



She never said she doesn't trust her. She just doesn't feel comfortable having other people drive her child - which many of us can understand.

She also just wants to do the "firsts" with her LO and not miss out. I'm sure she feels she's missing out on enough being a FTWM



exactly! i trust my MIL -- but someone else driving my child just freaks me out!

Posted 11/24/10 11:51 AM
 

adeline27
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

3121 total posts

Name:
Angela

Re: does this sound unreasonable?? (MIL issue)

Posted by MeeshMosh

1. i do not want her traveling far... only localy -- a few towns over is fine, but i dont want her going all over the island!

2. i dont want her taking ds to fun places like the aquarium or adventureland bc as a first time mom, i'd want to be there for ds's first time at fun places like that, KWIM? she can take him for his 2nd 3rd or 4th time, but id want to be there for his first time at fun places

3. i want her to call me to let me know where she plans on taking ds that day

4. i dont want her doing any mommy & me groups with ds



First off I understand where you are coming from 100%. With my first child I was very protective and nervous. It is very fortunate that you have a MIL you can trust and wants to be involved in your baby's life. She's grandma Chat Icon and only wants the best for your DC. I personally think the carseat is a great idea. Trips to the mall, grocery store, park...I would just simply say to her please let me know where you'll be going for the day if you plan to go out and leave it at that. For you to say anything else will look to her like you don't trust her. One town over, 5 towns over that's just something she doesn't need to know. If she tells you a place you don't like or are uncomortable with just tell her right then and there. If she mentions a place you wanted to go to with DC for the first time let her know that. # 3 absolutely totally reasonable and this is where you will come in to say oh that's fun but I'll be taking him soon there etc.. #4 aren't these things usually once or 2x a week? Why not sign up on the days you can go with DC and that's said and done. I don't see it being a big deal if she wanted to take him to a free library class during her stay with him. I would encourage that actually. Life is short be grateful your DC has a grandma that wants to do a lot with them including being with him two days a week! You don't want to sound like you don't trust MIL you just want to sound like you want to be informed on everything. I don't see anything unreasonable with that. I'm sure it will all go well and you'll see when you have more childrent you will be screaming TAKE THEM ALL!!!

Message edited 2010-11-24 11:57:57.823000.

Posted 11/24/10 11:54 AM
 

MeeshMosh
last month on leave!

Member since 6/08

4551 total posts

Name:

Re: deleted

Posted by Deeluvsvinny

I think it's a bit unreasonable. I mean, DD goes to a sitter, who is like family to us. I got her a car seat and she takes DD around, she always tells where she's going that day, so I know. I would actualy LOVE for her to take DD to fun kiddie places..I don't want to deprive DD just bc I have to work all day. I can understand saying.. We want to take DC to the aquarium first. But, you cna't be the first take him everywhere.
I'm actually LOOKING for a mommy & me group for DD & the sitter, I think DD would love that, and the weekends get hectic and it takes away from our itme.

I know it's hard as a first time mom, and going back to work, but honestly, he'll be with his grandma, I think that's fabulous! You're going to have let go a little and realize that you will miss some "firsts". I have a deal with my sitter, it didn't happen at all until mommy sees it! So, even though she really crawled full fledged at the sitter's house, it didn't happen until later that night, when I saw it Chat Icon \

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



thanks for your response!! Chat Icon

i think that maybe eventually i'll get to the point where i can say hey take my child see ya in 8 hours... but im no where near there yet & feel like i need to have a talk with MIL about what makes me feel comfortable for NOW, KWIM?

Posted 11/24/10 11:57 AM
 

adeline27
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

3121 total posts

Name:
Angela

Re: deleted

Posted by MeeshMosh

i think that maybe eventually i'll get to the point where i can say hey take my child see ya in 8 hours... but im no where near there yet & feel like i need to have a talk with MIL about what makes me feel comfortable for NOW, KWIM?



Chat Icon I know and I was trying to give an answer in half the mindset I was in with my first and how I feel now. I was REALLY protective. I was the type that would constantly stare at whoever was holding my first new baby at parties or wherever. Never liked passing him around at the christening party. LOL I was bad!

Posted 11/24/10 12:01 PM
 

cds58019
The loves of my life :)

Member since 6/08

4276 total posts

Name:
Candice

Re: deleted

I dont see how people can tell you that your feelings and what you're comfortable with are unreasonable. He's your child, so your rules. Honestly at least you're compromising with letting her drive him at all. B/c I dont think I would even allow that! Everyone's different. Do what will make you feel comfortable. Chat Icon

Posted 11/24/10 12:38 PM
 

cds58019
The loves of my life :)

Member since 6/08

4276 total posts

Name:
Candice

Re: deleted

Posted by littlebeanz

Honestly I think if you dont trust her then dont have her babysit. I trust my il's and allow them to do whatever they want because I do trust them.

Why do you not want them to take her anywhere fun????



I dont think its that she cant take him anywhere fun, just that some of the bigger events she would like to experience for the first time with him. After that Im sure she'd let her take him again herself.

Posted 11/24/10 12:41 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
My first MIL Issue- Beyond LIVID!! avamamma 1/7/07 8 Parenting
Another MIL issue iwed2005 6/20/06 4 Pregnancy
another MIL issue PrincessP 6/20/06 4 Pregnancy
How would you feel? (Long, MIL issue) CathyB 1/5/06 13 Parenting