Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Common Core - Kindergarten

What Logical mind thought it wise to give a 5 year old home work sheets with directions?? I would love to know the logic behind this. Instead of giving a 5 year old (who does not know how to read)an illustration or something they can understand or relate to.. they decided to print directions and ask the five year old to read the directions before starting his homework.

Defies logic.

Now I know why common core has people up in arms.Chat Icon

Posted 9/17/14 6:31 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

That's crazy.

DS is also in K and hasn't had homework yet.

We had open house last night and his teacher said it will start in October.

She also said that our district was one of the first that was actually properly trained on the CC.

It sounded like many others haven't even gotten that far yet.

Good luck!

Posted 9/17/14 6:59 PM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

This is a whole new world honestly most 5 year olds seem to be reading these days!! Pre-k is like k these days!!

Posted 9/17/14 7:33 PM
 

My2Girlz11
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

785 total posts

Name:
Corrie

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Maybe they expected the parent to read the directions with the student? I know that I sat with both my daughters last year and did everything with them. Even this year I read it over with them. I also would have them circle sight words in any directions that were given.

Posted 9/17/14 7:36 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by My2Girlz11

Maybe they expected the parent to read the directions with the student? I know that I sat with both my daughters last year and did everything with them. Even this year I read it over with them. I also would have them circle sight words in any directions that were given.



I just re-read and this could be the case.

My son's teacher said they are doing the "workbooks" in school and then she is going to prepare a packet of homework (enough for each night) for the parent to help the child with.

The packet is then returned to school the following week.

WE received the packet with the sight words last night.

Posted 9/17/14 7:39 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

You read the directions to them - they are not expecting a Kindergartener in September to be reading independently.

Posted 9/17/14 7:47 PM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Im confused, couldnt you just read the directions to your child? I think that is what you are supposed to do. That is what I always did. Im not sure I see the issue with encouraging them and getting them to practice reading and being exposed to writing and words?

Posted 9/17/14 7:58 PM
 

schmora15
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

2476 total posts

Name:

Common Core - Kindergarten

I don't think they expect a 5 year old to read the instructions. When I go over HW with DD I point to the words as I read them so she can begin to recognize them. Sometimes there are little pictures too.

Posted 9/17/14 8:07 PM
 

Dani922
Here's to new beginnings

Member since 10/07

7260 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

I just had to read the directions on my son's K math hw 3 times because they use their common core lingo & I had no idea what he was meant to do.

My daughter is in 4th so this isnt my first intro to common core & I'm not a fan Chat Icon

Posted 9/17/14 8:19 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

But why am i reading the directions to him? Why not make it simple enough that he sits independently and does his homework and shows it to me afterwards. Why am I hovering over him reading the directions? When my daughter was in kindergarten her homework was geared towards her and not me so she did it and I checked it and corrected it if necessary.

They are 5!!! it should be geared towards a 5 year old and not the 5 year old AND the parent.

Message edited 2014-09-17 20:31:50.633000.

Posted 9/17/14 8:31 PM
 

MichLiz213
Life is Good!

Member since 7/07

7979 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by lipglossjunky73

You read the directions to them - they are not expecting a Kindergartener in September to be reading independently.



That's exactly what they're expecting them to do.

Our K teachers have had professional development where new Kindergarteners are expected to be able to come in and read a book in September. The person running the PD is using the Teachers College approach. Our district is diverse as far as socio-economic status and we have a very large population of ESL. Our district has had this habit of just throwing things at us without the training to go with it. So our K teachers are extremely frustrated and the person doing the PD is out of touch with reality (she made a comment about the writing of one of my top students once and I nearly hit the roof, so I'm not a fan).

Posted 9/17/14 8:33 PM
 

schmora15
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

2476 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by MichLiz213

Posted by lipglossjunky73

You read the directions to them - they are not expecting a Kindergartener in September to be reading independently.



That's exactly what they're expecting them to do.

Our K teachers have had professional development where new Kindergarteners are expected to be able to come in and read a book in September. The person running the PD is using the Teachers College approach. Our district is diverse as far as socio-economic status and we have a very large population of ESL. Our district has had this habit of just throwing things at us without the training to go with it. So our K teachers are extremely frustrated and the person doing the PD is out of touch with reality (she made a comment about the writing of one of my top students once and I nearly hit the roof, so I'm not a fan).



Our district is very diverse as well, both with socioeconomic status and race. I really find it hard to believe that they are expected to come in reading a book. My daughters words for the week are "I" and "can." Are you sure they aren't exaggerating?

Posted 9/17/14 8:40 PM
 

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by beachgirl

But why am i reading the directions to him? Why not make it simple enough that he sits independently and does his homework and shows it to me afterwards. Why am I hovering over him reading the directions? When my daughter was in kindergarten her homework was geared towards her and not me so she did it and I checked it and corrected it if necessary.

They are 5!!! it should be geared towards a 5 year old and not the 5 year old AND the parent.



I totally understand and agree with what you are saying. While in theory hw should be done independently and a review of what the student learned that day in my experience that is not the case.

Posted 9/17/14 8:48 PM
 

MichLiz213
Life is Good!

Member since 7/07

7979 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by schmora15

Posted by MichLiz213

Posted by lipglossjunky73

You read the directions to them - they are not expecting a Kindergartener in September to be reading independently.



That's exactly what they're expecting them to do.

Our K teachers have had professional development where new Kindergarteners are expected to be able to come in and read a book in September. The person running the PD is using the Teachers College approach. Our district is diverse as far as socio-economic status and we have a very large population of ESL. Our district has had this habit of just throwing things at us without the training to go with it. So our K teachers are extremely frustrated and the person doing the PD is out of touch with reality (she made a comment about the writing of one of my top students once and I nearly hit the roof, so I'm not a fan).



Our district is very diverse as well, both with socioeconomic status and race. I really find it hard to believe that they are expected to come in reading a book. My daughters words for the week are "I" and "can." Are you sure they aren't exaggerating?



No exaggeration. But this is what the curriculum and their professional development expects. What the expectations are and what the reality is are two different things.

Posted 9/17/14 8:59 PM
 

Teachergal
We made a snowman!

Member since 1/08

3239 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by MichLiz213

Posted by lipglossjunky73

You read the directions to them - they are not expecting a Kindergartener in September to be reading independently.



That's exactly what they're expecting them to do.

Our K teachers have had professional development where new Kindergarteners are expected to be able to come in and read a book in September. The person running the PD is using the Teachers College approach. Our district is diverse as far as socio-economic status and we have a very large population of ESL. Our district has had this habit of just throwing things at us without the training to go with it. So our K teachers are extremely frustrated and the person doing the PD is out of touch with reality (she made a comment about the writing of one of my top students once and I nearly hit the roof, so I'm not a fan).




Not sure why the PD person would tell you that, but TC does not believe they should be reading in September. Here's their chart:

In September, kids can be expected to read:
Emergent Story Books
Shared Reading

In November, kids can be expected to read:
Emergent Story Books
Shared Reading
A/B (with book intro)

In January, kids can be expected to read:
B/C (with book intro)

In March:
1 (below grade level)=Early Emergent
2 (approaching grade level)=A/B (with book intro)
3 (grade level)=C (with book intro)
4 (above)=D/E

June
1 (below grade level)=B or below
2 (approaching grade level)=C (with book intro)
3 (grade level)=D/E
4 (above)=F or above

Posted 9/17/14 8:59 PM
 

MichLiz213
Life is Good!

Member since 7/07

7979 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by Teachergal

Posted by MichLiz213

Posted by lipglossjunky73

You read the directions to them - they are not expecting a Kindergartener in September to be reading independently.



That's exactly what they're expecting them to do.

Our K teachers have had professional development where new Kindergarteners are expected to be able to come in and read a book in September. The person running the PD is using the Teachers College approach. Our district is diverse as far as socio-economic status and we have a very large population of ESL. Our district has had this habit of just throwing things at us without the training to go with it. So our K teachers are extremely frustrated and the person doing the PD is out of touch with reality (she made a comment about the writing of one of my top students once and I nearly hit the roof, so I'm not a fan).




Not sure why the PD person would tell you that, but TC does not believe they should be reading in September. Here's their chart:

In September, kids can be expected to read:
Emergent Story Books
Shared Reading

In November, kids can be expected to read:
Emergent Story Books
Shared Reading
A/B (with book intro)

In January, kids can be expected to read:
B/C (with book intro)

In March:
1 (below grade level)=Early Emergent
2 (approaching grade level)=A/B (with book intro)
3 (grade level)=C (with book intro)
4 (above)=D/E

June
1 (below grade level)=B or below
2 (approaching grade level)=C (with book intro)
3 (grade level)=D/E
4 (above)=F or above



The person they hired has a background in very high achieving schools. So we're using the TC model (which is new to us, which is fine), but this is what she is telling them is the expectation in order to implement it effectively (which is stressing everyone out because it's unrealistic).

Message edited 2014-09-17 21:04:34.893000.

Posted 9/17/14 9:03 PM
 

schmora15
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

2476 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by MichLiz213

Posted by Teachergal

Posted by MichLiz213

Posted by lipglossjunky73

You read the directions to them - they are not expecting a Kindergartener in September to be reading independently.



That's exactly what they're expecting them to do.

Our K teachers have had professional development where new Kindergarteners are expected to be able to come in and read a book in September. The person running the PD is using the Teachers College approach. Our district is diverse as far as socio-economic status and we have a very large population of ESL. Our district has had this habit of just throwing things at us without the training to go with it. So our K teachers are extremely frustrated and the person doing the PD is out of touch with reality (she made a comment about the writing of one of my top students once and I nearly hit the roof, so I'm not a fan).




Not sure why the PD person would tell you that, but TC does not believe they should be reading in September. Here's their chart:

In September, kids can be expected to read:
Emergent Story Books
Shared Reading

In November, kids can be expected to read:
Emergent Story Books
Shared Reading
A/B (with book intro)

In January, kids can be expected to read:
B/C (with book intro)

In March:
1 (below grade level)=Early Emergent
2 (approaching grade level)=A/B (with book intro)
3 (grade level)=C (with book intro)
4 (above)=D/E

June
1 (below grade level)=B or below
2 (approaching grade level)=C (with book intro)
3 (grade level)=D/E
4 (above)=F or above



The person they hired has a background in very high achieving schools. So we're using the TC model (which is new to us, which is fine), but this is what she is telling them is the expectation in order to implement it effectively (which is stressing everyone out because it's unrealistic).



Are you a Kindergarten teacher? Or is this what your child's teacher is telling you? I'm really just curious. Do you happen to have an example of a book they are expected to read?

My DD is expected to be able to tell me about stories that have been read to her and discuss them but not to actually read them.


Posted 9/17/14 9:27 PM
 

MichLiz213
Life is Good!

Member since 7/07

7979 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by schmora15

Posted by MichLiz213

Posted by Teachergal

Posted by MichLiz213

Posted by lipglossjunky73

You read the directions to them - they are not expecting a Kindergartener in September to be reading independently.



That's exactly what they're expecting them to do.

Our K teachers have had professional development where new Kindergarteners are expected to be able to come in and read a book in September. The person running the PD is using the Teachers College approach. Our district is diverse as far as socio-economic status and we have a very large population of ESL. Our district has had this habit of just throwing things at us without the training to go with it. So our K teachers are extremely frustrated and the person doing the PD is out of touch with reality (she made a comment about the writing of one of my top students once and I nearly hit the roof, so I'm not a fan).




Not sure why the PD person would tell you that, but TC does not believe they should be reading in September. Here's their chart:

In September, kids can be expected to read:
Emergent Story Books
Shared Reading

In November, kids can be expected to read:
Emergent Story Books
Shared Reading
A/B (with book intro)

In January, kids can be expected to read:
B/C (with book intro)

In March:
1 (below grade level)=Early Emergent
2 (approaching grade level)=A/B (with book intro)
3 (grade level)=C (with book intro)
4 (above)=D/E

June
1 (below grade level)=B or below
2 (approaching grade level)=C (with book intro)
3 (grade level)=D/E
4 (above)=F or above



The person they hired has a background in very high achieving schools. So we're using the TC model (which is new to us, which is fine), but this is what she is telling them is the expectation in order to implement it effectively (which is stressing everyone out because it's unrealistic).



Are you a Kindergarten teacher? Or is this what your child's teacher is telling you? I'm really just curious. Do you happen to have an example of a book they are expected to read?

My DD is expected to be able to tell me about stories that have been read to her and discuss them but not to actually read them.





I'm a perm sub (I've taught K, 1st, and last year I taught 3rd as a long term leave). I've been in the same building for 6 years, so in the beginning of the year I spend a lot of time in Kindergarten. I was helping one of the teachers get all her anchor charts together, and she told me what changes are being implemented and what the PD person told them. They're not expecting them to read War and Peace or anything, but they were told they should all be able to take a level A or B and read it independently. Which is a very high expectation for our district.

We were handed all the Engage NY modules at the beginning of last year without any training, so our district has a tendency of setting the bar high without providing the right training.

Posted 9/17/14 9:42 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by beachgirl

But why am i reading the directions to him? Why not make it simple enough that he sits independently and does his homework and shows it to me afterwards. Why am I hovering over him reading the directions? When my daughter was in kindergarten her homework was geared towards her and not me so she did it and I checked it and corrected it if necessary.

They are 5!!! it should be geared towards a 5 year old and not the 5 year old AND the parent.



Speaking as a teacher, I think you're kidding yourself if you expect no parent involvement when it comes to HW. Especially at this age. You should be sitting down with your kindergartener as they do their HW to help reinforce concepts, explain directions, and assist them as needed.

Even back in the day when I was in kindergarten, in 1980!!!.........my parents sat down with me to do HW.

Sometimes HW requires directions that can't be explained at a 5 yr old level and it really has nothing to do with Common Core. It's just expected that a parent will help guide and facilitate their child's learning.

ETA - I taught Kindergarten and between Everyday Math, Fundations, and other HW sheets it was necessary for a parent to read and go through directions with the child. Also, I've NEVER heard of any Kindergarten child being expected to read independently at the start of school on an A/B level.

Message edited 2014-09-17 21:57:03.380000.

Posted 9/17/14 9:52 PM
 

bunnyluck
LIF Adult

Member since 1/14

3196 total posts

Name:

Common Core - Kindergarten

Just wondering...What happens if the parents can't read? I mean this in all seriousness too... For instance those who are ESL, illiterate, blind, etc. I ask because I recently heard a shocking statistic about CC and parents who are illiterate.

Posted 9/17/14 10:32 PM
 

InShock
life is good

Member since 10/06

9258 total posts

Name:

Common Core - Kindergarten

You are supposed to read the directions to your child. There is nothing Common Core about that.

Posted 9/17/14 10:59 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by beachgirl

But why am i reading the directions to him? Why not make it simple enough that he sits independently and does his homework and shows it to me afterwards. Why am I hovering over him reading the directions? When my daughter was in kindergarten her homework was geared towards her and not me so she did it and I checked it and corrected it if necessary.

They are 5!!! it should be geared towards a 5 year old and not the 5 year old AND the parent.



Speaking as a teacher, I think you're kidding yourself if you expect no parent involvement when it comes to HW. Especially at this age. You should be sitting down with your kindergartener as they do their HW to help reinforce concepts, explain directions, and assist them as needed.

Even back in the day when I was in kindergarten, in 1980!!!.........my parents sat down with me to do HW.

Sometimes HW requires directions that can't be explained at a 5 yr old level and it really has nothing to do with Common Core. It's just expected that a parent will help guide and facilitate their child's learning.

ETA - I taught Kindergarten and between Everyday Math, Fundations, and other HW sheets it was necessary for a parent to read and go through directions with the child. Also, I've NEVER heard of any Kindergarten child being expected to read independently at the start of school on an A/B level.



I agree.

I don't expect DS to even have the motivation yet to begin his homework without me at least providing a jump start.

Posted 9/18/14 5:16 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by bunnyluck

Just wondering...What happens if the parents can't read? I mean this in all seriousness too... For instance those who are ESL, illiterate, blind, etc. I ask because I recently heard a shocking statistic about CC and parents who are illiterate.



They were talking about this the other night at open house.

I think those students who are high risk are flagged so extra support can be provided.

I'm not sure how this works in all districts though, especially with budget cuts.

I have several friends who English is not their first language who are very passionate about this because they are highly educated women, but from what they say, schools often flag kids as special needs when in reality it's the language barrier.....

I know they also mentioned involving the social worker and psychologist....I also bet supports could be found outside of school-based resources.

Posted 9/18/14 5:20 AM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22152 total posts

Name:

Common Core - Kindergarten

First of all, I would expect, as a teacher, some sort of guidance from an adult regarding homework, kindergarten and beyond, CC or not. I'm NOT saying parents should hover or do the work, but be there, clarify, explain if needed. I don't know of any K student who can do it on his or her own unless the teacher fully explained it and the child is able to read directions. I think the authors also expect that a parent will be involved in the homework process. But they should gear it towards independent work for the child and give more visual examples.

With that said, CC is really upping the game and a bit too much, imo. It's one thing to raise the bar of expectations. It's another thing to expect kids to understand concepts and read 2 years above what USED to be expected. Basically, every child has skipped a grade or 2 with material. Math concepts taught previously in 6th are now taught in 3rd. Books read at the end of 2nd are now read at the start of 1st. The problem is that they have these expectations and yet, so many children are blank slates coming into school.

I appreciate having a national set of standards, not each state making it up. And to be honest, if you look AT the standards themselves, SOME aren't bad. They are straightforward. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.L.K.1.A
Print many upper- and lowercase letters. That's reasonable.
Other standards, however, are iffy, such as in K, CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.L.K.4.B
Use the most frequently occurring inflections and affixes (e.g., -ed, -s, re-, un-, pre-, -ful, -less) as a clue to the meaning of an unknown word. Umm...you expect K to understand prefixes and suffixes? They need to learn PHONICS first! I also think how they are implemented, how the publishing companies work them, how the publishing companies think they should be TAUGHT...part of the problem.

But the reality is that many children don't have the support needed at home to make this happen successfully. Children come into school not knowing English, not knowing what letters are, not knowing their own friggin name, but are expected to leave K at a level D...wth??? The expectations are super high. I truly believe it will divide the classes even further. And trust me, I'm all for aiming high. If you raise your standards, they will rise to the challenge. But realistically. You're expecting ALL children to climb Everest when some can't even walk.

Message edited 2014-09-18 06:05:47.210000.

Posted 9/18/14 5:57 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by Hofstra26

Speaking as a teacher, I think you're kidding yourself if you expect no parent involvement when it comes to HW. Especially at this age. You should be sitting down with your kindergartener as they do their HW to help reinforce concepts, explain directions, and assist them as needed.




My DD was in K two years ago and mostly had handwriting homework. Very basic but I still had to sit with her. You can't expect a kid getting HW for the first time to just sit down by themselves and do it. We didn't really get there with DD till the end of first grade, when she wanted to sit at her desk alone and work.

I'd be more concerned with how long a task takes. I am a big proponent of the 10 minutes per grade theory- I don't know how K would be measured but they should be able to finish in 5-10 minutes.

Posted 9/18/14 7:20 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
COME AND FIND OUT WHAT IS ATTACHED TO HIGH STAKES TESTING, DATA MINING, AND THE COMMON CORE CURRICULUM lc214 1/19/14 2 Parenting
COME AND FIND OUT WHAT IS ATTACHED TO HIGH STAKES TESTING, DATA MINING, AND THE COMMON CORE CURRICULUM lc214 1/19/14 2 Families Helping Families ™
XPOST - new group - Stop Common Core in NYS- Suffolk County Chapter! 2BadSoSad 10/28/13 0 Teachers
XPOST - New Group - Stop Common Core in NYS - Suffolk County Chapter!! 2BadSoSad 10/28/13 2 Parenting
Common Core Withdrawal bill filed in the NYS assembly!! 2BadSoSad 9/30/13 9 Parenting
If your child goes to private school, do they follow the common core standards? BargainMama 4/18/13 10 Parents of School-Aged Children