Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

staceyd
LIF Adult

Member since 8/08

2052 total posts

Name:
stacey

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by beachgirl

But why am i reading the directions to him? Why not make it simple enough that he sits independently and does his homework and shows it to me afterwards. Why am I hovering over him reading the directions? When my daughter was in kindergarten her homework was geared towards her and not me so she did it and I checked it and corrected it if necessary.

They are 5!!! it should be geared towards a 5 year old and not the 5 year old AND the parent.



Speaking as a teacher, I think you're kidding yourself if you expect no parent involvement when it comes to HW. Especially at this age. You should be sitting down with your kindergartener as they do their HW to help reinforce concepts, explain directions, and assist them as needed.

Even back in the day when I was in kindergarten, in 1980!!!.........my parents sat down with me to do HW.

Sometimes HW requires directions that can't be explained at a 5 yr old level and it really has nothing to do with Common Core. It's just expected that a parent will help guide and facilitate their child's learning.

ETA - I taught Kindergarten and between Everyday Math, Fundations, and other HW sheets it was necessary for a parent to read and go through directions with the child. Also, I've NEVER heard of any Kindergarten child being expected to read independently at the start of school on an A/B level.



I agree.

I don't expect DS to even have the motivation yet to begin his homework without me at least providing a jump start.




I'll be completely honest too... I teach older kids and their parents are still a part of the homework process... What 5 year old is going to take their time doing their homework and learning from it without parent involvement? And what would homework look like without directions? How would anyone know what to do?

Posted 9/18/14 7:30 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

We spent more time on homework in K then any other grade. We had to walk/teach DS through it all. And don't get me wrong, it was frustrating for us and DS at times. And it was extremely time consuming. But it was our job to help him and reinforce the concepts being taught in school. He's in third grade now and mostly does jus homework on his own, then we correct it and go over any mistakes.
My little one will start K next year and I'm definitely not looking forward to starting this all over again.

Posted 9/19/14 8:30 AM
 

Ian&EmmesMommy23
My family is complete!

Member since 11/08

12970 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by staceyd

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by beachgirl

But why am i reading the directions to him? Why not make it simple enough that he sits independently and does his homework and shows it to me afterwards. Why am I hovering over him reading the directions? When my daughter was in kindergarten her homework was geared towards her and not me so she did it and I checked it and corrected it if necessary.

They are 5!!! it should be geared towards a 5 year old and not the 5 year old AND the parent.



Speaking as a teacher, I think you're kidding yourself if you expect no parent involvement when it comes to HW. Especially at this age. You should be sitting down with your kindergartener as they do their HW to help reinforce concepts, explain directions, and assist them as needed.

Even back in the day when I was in kindergarten, in 1980!!!.........my parents sat down with me to do HW.

Sometimes HW requires directions that can't be explained at a 5 yr old level and it really has nothing to do with Common Core. It's just expected that a parent will help guide and facilitate their child's learning.

ETA - I taught Kindergarten and between Everyday Math, Fundations, and other HW sheets it was necessary for a parent to read and go through directions with the child. Also, I've NEVER heard of any Kindergarten child being expected to read independently at the start of school on an A/B level.



I agree.

I don't expect DS to even have the motivation yet to begin his homework without me at least providing a jump start.




I'll be completely honest too... I teach older kids and their parents are still a part of the homework process... What 5 year old is going to take their time doing their homework and learning from it without parent involvement? And what would homework look like without directions? How would anyone know what to do?



my son's a weirdo. once i read him the directions he tells me to go sit on the couch and play on my phone while he finishes his homework alone. im starting to think he sees me on my phone too much. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 9/19/14 9:35 AM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by beachgirl

I think some of you are missing my point. I dont see the LOGIC in giving homework to five year olds that requires them to read directions in order to do it. What is wrong with an illustration - i.e the number 2 beside a box where they need to draw two circles and then they trace the number 2? This would seem appropriate to me for a 5 year old. Instead his homework is laid out as number one - 1 with a box to draw one circle then number two - 2 with a box to draw two circles etc etc and this goes on until number five - 5. This would be what you would assume is the way to do the homework BUT at the very bottom of the sheet is a small heading titled DIRECTIONS and in there it says in box 1 draw five circles, in box two draw three circles etc etc.

I am not a lazy parent. I sit down with my kids and check their homework. However when my 5 year old sat down and was doing his homework unaided I didn't feel the need to flap my wings around him and when he handed it to me to check I did not notice the DIRECTIONS as I was not expecting directions for a FIVE year old to read.

Now that I know and understand I will be reading directions on his homework. It was just jarring to me and made no logical sense.

Of course this all depends on how much time I have left from helping my 3rd grader complete her common core homework when 2 + 2 is still 4 but she will have to go around the world to arrive at 4 Chat Icon



I get what you are saying. I actually don't believe that kindergarteners should have homework at all especially this early in the year. The only homework they should have is reading every night - whether that be independent reading or co reading. Their brains sure don't need more dittos from EngageNY or Pearson.

Posted 9/19/14 10:41 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by beachgirl

I think some of you are missing my point. I dont see the LOGIC in giving homework to five year olds that requires them to read directions in order to do it. What is wrong with an illustration - i.e the number 2 beside a box where they need to draw two circles and then they trace the number 2? This would seem appropriate to me for a 5 year old. Instead his homework is laid out as number one - 1 with a box to draw one circle then number two - 2 with a box to draw two circles etc etc and this goes on until number five - 5. This would be what you would assume is the way to do the homework BUT at the very bottom of the sheet is a small heading titled DIRECTIONS and in there it says in box 1 draw five circles, in box two draw three circles etc etc.

I am not a lazy parent. I sit down with my kids and check their homework. However when my 5 year old sat down and was doing his homework unaided I didn't feel the need to flap my wings around him and when he handed it to me to check I did not notice the DIRECTIONS as I was not expecting directions for a FIVE year old to read.

Now that I know and understand I will be reading directions on his homework. It was just jarring to me and made no logical sense.

Of course this all depends on how much time I have left from helping my 3rd grader complete her common core homework when 2 + 2 is still 4 but she will have to go around the world to arrive at 4 Chat Icon



I get what you are saying. I actually don't believe that kindergarteners should have homework at all especially this early in the year. The only homework they should have is reading every night - whether that be independent reading or co reading. Their brains sure don't need more dittos from EngageNY or Pearson.



HW is meant to reinforce the concepts they learn in school AND to teach them responsibility and accountability.

Teachers assign HW from the get-go because it's part of getting them in the routine of being a student in school. It's no different then the other routines they learn and become responsible for like packing up, emptying their folders, standing quietly in line. etc.

Posted 9/19/14 11:01 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

We live in NC(Wake County) and I believe they have decided to start phasing out Commom Core. Right now, we are still following it. However, I feel my kids are learning totally appropriately. They use Letterland Characters and do not have homework.

Posted 9/19/14 11:06 AM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by beachgirl

I think some of you are missing my point. I dont see the LOGIC in giving homework to five year olds that requires them to read directions in order to do it. What is wrong with an illustration - i.e the number 2 beside a box where they need to draw two circles and then they trace the number 2? This would seem appropriate to me for a 5 year old. Instead his homework is laid out as number one - 1 with a box to draw one circle then number two - 2 with a box to draw two circles etc etc and this goes on until number five - 5. This would be what you would assume is the way to do the homework BUT at the very bottom of the sheet is a small heading titled DIRECTIONS and in there it says in box 1 draw five circles, in box two draw three circles etc etc.

I am not a lazy parent. I sit down with my kids and check their homework. However when my 5 year old sat down and was doing his homework unaided I didn't feel the need to flap my wings around him and when he handed it to me to check I did not notice the DIRECTIONS as I was not expecting directions for a FIVE year old to read.

Now that I know and understand I will be reading directions on his homework. It was just jarring to me and made no logical sense.

Of course this all depends on how much time I have left from helping my 3rd grader complete her common core homework when 2 + 2 is still 4 but she will have to go around the world to arrive at 4 Chat Icon



I get what you are saying. I actually don't believe that kindergarteners should have homework at all especially this early in the year. The only homework they should have is reading every night - whether that be independent reading or co reading. Their brains sure don't need more dittos from EngageNY or Pearson.



HW is meant to reinforce the concepts they learn in school AND to teach them responsibility and accountability.

Teachers assign HW from the get-go because it's part of getting them in the routine of being a student in school. It's no different then the other routines they learn and become responsible for like packing up, emptying their folders, standing quietly in line. etc.



I know what homework is and the purpose. I just don't believe 4 & 5 year olds get any benefit from it. I also don't believe homework is reinforcing much at that age.

There has been much research about the benefit of homework vs no homework. There is little research that can provide a strong correlation between homework in kindergarten and academic achievement in the future.

Posted 9/19/14 11:09 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by beachgirl

I think some of you are missing my point. I dont see the LOGIC in giving homework to five year olds that requires them to read directions in order to do it. What is wrong with an illustration - i.e the number 2 beside a box where they need to draw two circles and then they trace the number 2? This would seem appropriate to me for a 5 year old. Instead his homework is laid out as number one - 1 with a box to draw one circle then number two - 2 with a box to draw two circles etc etc and this goes on until number five - 5. This would be what you would assume is the way to do the homework BUT at the very bottom of the sheet is a small heading titled DIRECTIONS and in there it says in box 1 draw five circles, in box two draw three circles etc etc.

I am not a lazy parent. I sit down with my kids and check their homework. However when my 5 year old sat down and was doing his homework unaided I didn't feel the need to flap my wings around him and when he handed it to me to check I did not notice the DIRECTIONS as I was not expecting directions for a FIVE year old to read.

Now that I know and understand I will be reading directions on his homework. It was just jarring to me and made no logical sense.

Of course this all depends on how much time I have left from helping my 3rd grader complete her common core homework when 2 + 2 is still 4 but she will have to go around the world to arrive at 4 Chat Icon



I get what you are saying. I actually don't believe that kindergarteners should have homework at all especially this early in the year. The only homework they should have is reading every night - whether that be independent reading or co reading. Their brains sure don't need more dittos from EngageNY or Pearson.



HW is meant to reinforce the concepts they learn in school AND to teach them responsibility and accountability.

Teachers assign HW from the get-go because it's part of getting them in the routine of being a student in school. It's no different then the other routines they learn and become responsible for like packing up, emptying their folders, standing quietly in line. etc.



I know what homework is and the purpose. I just don't believe 4 & 5 year olds get any benefit from it. I also don't believe homework is reinforcing much at that age.

There has been much research about the benefit of homework vs no homework. There is little research that can provide a strong correlation between homework in kindergarten and academic achievement in the future.




As an elementary school teacher, I disagree with you. 100%.



Posted 9/19/14 11:18 AM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by beachgirl

I think some of you are missing my point. I dont see the LOGIC in giving homework to five year olds that requires them to read directions in order to do it. What is wrong with an illustration - i.e the number 2 beside a box where they need to draw two circles and then they trace the number 2? This would seem appropriate to me for a 5 year old. Instead his homework is laid out as number one - 1 with a box to draw one circle then number two - 2 with a box to draw two circles etc etc and this goes on until number five - 5. This would be what you would assume is the way to do the homework BUT at the very bottom of the sheet is a small heading titled DIRECTIONS and in there it says in box 1 draw five circles, in box two draw three circles etc etc.

I am not a lazy parent. I sit down with my kids and check their homework. However when my 5 year old sat down and was doing his homework unaided I didn't feel the need to flap my wings around him and when he handed it to me to check I did not notice the DIRECTIONS as I was not expecting directions for a FIVE year old to read.

Now that I know and understand I will be reading directions on his homework. It was just jarring to me and made no logical sense.

Of course this all depends on how much time I have left from helping my 3rd grader complete her common core homework when 2 + 2 is still 4 but she will have to go around the world to arrive at 4 Chat Icon



I get what you are saying. I actually don't believe that kindergarteners should have homework at all especially this early in the year. The only homework they should have is reading every night - whether that be independent reading or co reading. Their brains sure don't need more dittos from EngageNY or Pearson.



HW is meant to reinforce the concepts they learn in school AND to teach them responsibility and accountability.

Teachers assign HW from the get-go because it's part of getting them in the routine of being a student in school. It's no different then the other routines they learn and become responsible for like packing up, emptying their folders, standing quietly in line. etc.



I know what homework is and the purpose. I just don't believe 4 & 5 year olds get any benefit from it. I also don't believe homework is reinforcing much at that age.

There has been much research about the benefit of homework vs no homework. There is little research that can provide a strong correlation between homework in kindergarten and academic achievement in the future.




As an elementary school teacher, I disagree with you. 100%.






As a parent I also strongly disagree with that statement as well. My son excelled and did very well on his test and assessments a big part of it was the hwk and reinforcement at home.

Message edited 2014-09-19 11:24:30.497000.

Posted 9/19/14 11:24 AM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Each to their own but this is a brief example of why I don't believe there is much benefit to homework in kindergarten....Link

I wanted to add...I am not opposed to homework as a general idea...I don't believe it provides much benefit in kindergarten.

Message edited 2014-09-19 11:35:49.477000.

Posted 9/19/14 11:33 AM
 

Sash
Peace

Member since 6/08

10314 total posts

Name:
fka LIW Smara

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by CookiePuss

Each to their own but this is a brief example of why I don't believe there is much benefit to homework in kindergarten....Link

I wanted to add...I am not opposed to homework as a general idea...I don't believe it provides much benefit in kindergarten.



I haven't reviewed the link but may be it also depends on the type of hwk given.

For example one of my DS's hwk was to write the alphabet 3x a week. This helped him with writing immensely. Sight word review helped him with reading and word recognition.

Posted 9/19/14 12:22 PM
 

Adri
Joy!

Member since 5/05

3116 total posts

Name:
A

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

I think HW helps a lot, and more when they are little, to build good habits. For me, it is more than learning, it is to create the discipline of sitting down for a period of time. DS started doing HW out of the school when he was 4, and he didn't have HW on K at school, but continued doing his HW outside (kumon). When he got to 1st grade, it was amazing the difference with those kids that didn't do HW before. It was a real struggle for parents to get their kids to do it, and it wasn't because of the level, but because they weren't used to it. Saying that I always sat with him at the beginning to explain directions and to refocus him - that was the hardest.

Posted 9/19/14 12:45 PM
 

2BadSoSad
LIF Adult

Member since 8/12

6791 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by CookiePuss

Each to their own but this is a brief example of why I don't believe there is much benefit to homework in kindergarten....Link

I wanted to add...I am not opposed to homework as a general idea...I don't believe it provides much benefit in kindergarten.



I didnt get that from that link at all.

Posted 9/19/14 12:50 PM
 

My2Girlz11
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

785 total posts

Name:
Corrie

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by beachgirl

I think some of you are missing my point. I dont see the LOGIC in giving homework to five year olds that requires them to read directions in order to do it. What is wrong with an illustration - i.e the number 2 beside a box where they need to draw two circles and then they trace the number 2? This would seem appropriate to me for a 5 year old. Instead his homework is laid out as number one - 1 with a box to draw one circle then number two - 2 with a box to draw two circles etc etc and this goes on until number five - 5. This would be what you would assume is the way to do the homework BUT at the very bottom of the sheet is a small heading titled DIRECTIONS and in there it says in box 1 draw five circles, in box two draw three circles etc etc.

I am not a lazy parent. I sit down with my kids and check their homework. However when my 5 year old sat down and was doing his homework unaided I didn't feel the need to flap my wings around him and when he handed it to me to check I did not notice the DIRECTIONS as I was not expecting directions for a FIVE year old to read.

Now that I know and understand I will be reading directions on his homework. It was just jarring to me and made no logical sense.

Of course this all depends on how much time I have left from helping my 3rd grader complete her common core homework when 2 + 2 is still 4 but she will have to go around the world to arrive at 4 Chat Icon



I get what you are saying. I actually don't believe that kindergarteners should have homework at all especially this early in the year. The only homework they should have is reading every night - whether that be independent reading or co reading. Their brains sure don't need more dittos from EngageNY or Pearson.



HW is meant to reinforce the concepts they learn in school AND to teach them responsibility and accountability.

Teachers assign HW from the get-go because it's part of getting them in the routine of being a student in school. It's no different then the other routines they learn and become responsible for like packing up, emptying their folders, standing quietly in line. etc.



I know what homework is and the purpose. I just don't believe 4 & 5 year olds get any benefit from it. I also don't believe homework is reinforcing much at that age.

There has been much research about the benefit of homework vs no homework. There is little research that can provide a strong correlation between homework in kindergarten and academic achievement in the future.




Have you read the research that states that parental involvement is one of the top factors in student success?

Posted 9/19/14 3:46 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by My2Girlz11

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by beachgirl

I think some of you are missing my point. I dont see the LOGIC in giving homework to five year olds that requires them to read directions in order to do it. What is wrong with an illustration - i.e the number 2 beside a box where they need to draw two circles and then they trace the number 2? This would seem appropriate to me for a 5 year old. Instead his homework is laid out as number one - 1 with a box to draw one circle then number two - 2 with a box to draw two circles etc etc and this goes on until number five - 5. This would be what you would assume is the way to do the homework BUT at the very bottom of the sheet is a small heading titled DIRECTIONS and in there it says in box 1 draw five circles, in box two draw three circles etc etc.

I am not a lazy parent. I sit down with my kids and check their homework. However when my 5 year old sat down and was doing his homework unaided I didn't feel the need to flap my wings around him and when he handed it to me to check I did not notice the DIRECTIONS as I was not expecting directions for a FIVE year old to read.

Now that I know and understand I will be reading directions on his homework. It was just jarring to me and made no logical sense.

Of course this all depends on how much time I have left from helping my 3rd grader complete her common core homework when 2 + 2 is still 4 but she will have to go around the world to arrive at 4 Chat Icon



I get what you are saying. I actually don't believe that kindergarteners should have homework at all especially this early in the year. The only homework they should have is reading every night - whether that be independent reading or co reading. Their brains sure don't need more dittos from EngageNY or Pearson.



HW is meant to reinforce the concepts they learn in school AND to teach them responsibility and accountability.

Teachers assign HW from the get-go because it's part of getting them in the routine of being a student in school. It's no different then the other routines they learn and become responsible for like packing up, emptying their folders, standing quietly in line. etc.



I know what homework is and the purpose. I just don't believe 4 & 5 year olds get any benefit from it. I also don't believe homework is reinforcing much at that age.

There has been much research about the benefit of homework vs no homework. There is little research that can provide a strong correlation between homework in kindergarten and academic achievement in the future.




Have you read the research that states that parental involvement is one of the top factors in student success?



Yes I have.

Posted 9/19/14 3:52 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by 2BadSoSad

Posted by CookiePuss

Each to their own but this is a brief example of why I don't believe there is much benefit to homework in kindergarten....Link

I wanted to add...I am not opposed to homework as a general idea...I don't believe it provides much benefit in kindergarten.



I didnt get that from that link at all.



I didn't post the link as a one sided look against homework but more as a point of reference that there are cons as wells as pros in different circumstances.

My view on homework from a parental perspective...my kindergartener starts the day at 9 am and isn't off the bus until after 4:15. During that school day, there is not much time for my child to be a child...run, play, be social with friends, be physically active...so when my child gets off the bus at 4:15...I don't want too much of those precious few hours I have to let them play, decompress from school, dinner, bath and reading ..to be taken up by homework. If my child is in bed at 8 pm...that's only 3 hours and 45 minutes and I don't think 1/2 - 45 minutes of that times should be spent on dittos or number bonds at this age.

Message edited 2014-09-19 15:57:09.147000.

Posted 9/19/14 3:56 PM
 

Daisy32
Mommy

Member since 2/08

8081 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by My2Girlz11

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by beachgirl

I think some of you are missing my point. I dont see the LOGIC in giving homework to five year olds that requires them to read directions in order to do it. What is wrong with an illustration - i.e the number 2 beside a box where they need to draw two circles and then they trace the number 2? This would seem appropriate to me for a 5 year old. Instead his homework is laid out as number one - 1 with a box to draw one circle then number two - 2 with a box to draw two circles etc etc and this goes on until number five - 5. This would be what you would assume is the way to do the homework BUT at the very bottom of the sheet is a small heading titled DIRECTIONS and in there it says in box 1 draw five circles, in box two draw three circles etc etc.

I am not a lazy parent. I sit down with my kids and check their homework. However when my 5 year old sat down and was doing his homework unaided I didn't feel the need to flap my wings around him and when he handed it to me to check I did not notice the DIRECTIONS as I was not expecting directions for a FIVE year old to read.

Now that I know and understand I will be reading directions on his homework. It was just jarring to me and made no logical sense.

Of course this all depends on how much time I have left from helping my 3rd grader complete her common core homework when 2 + 2 is still 4 but she will have to go around the world to arrive at 4 Chat Icon



I get what you are saying. I actually don't believe that kindergarteners should have homework at all especially this early in the year. The only homework they should have is reading every night - whether that be independent reading or co reading. Their brains sure don't need more dittos from EngageNY or Pearson.



HW is meant to reinforce the concepts they learn in school AND to teach them responsibility and accountability.

Teachers assign HW from the get-go because it's part of getting them in the routine of being a student in school. It's no different then the other routines they learn and become responsible for like packing up, emptying their folders, standing quietly in line. etc.



I know what homework is and the purpose. I just don't believe 4 & 5 year olds get any benefit from it. I also don't believe homework is reinforcing much at that age.

There has been much research about the benefit of homework vs no homework. There is little research that can provide a strong correlation between homework in kindergarten and academic achievement in the future.




Have you read the research that states that parental involvement is one of the top factors in student success?


Sorry but that is really a low blow....so unneccesary and plain old mean. She doesnt agree with HW in grade K - so you assume she is not involved as a parent.

Posted 9/19/14 3:57 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by Daisy32

Posted by My2Girlz11

Posted by CookiePuss



Have you read the research that states that parental involvement is one of the top factors in student success?


Sorry but that is really a low blow....so unneccesary and plain old mean. She doesnt agree with HW in grade K - so you assume she is not involved as a parent.



I didn't take it as a low blow. Homework doesn't dictate my involvement with my children and the academics. If teachers are giving homework for the sake of getting parents involved who otherwise would not be...it's just making life worse for that child. A parent is involved because they are...not because a teacher assigns homework.

ETA: But thank you for posting Daisy

Message edited 2014-09-19 16:01:28.710000.

Posted 9/19/14 4:00 PM
 

My2Girlz11
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

785 total posts

Name:
Corrie

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by Daisy32

Posted by My2Girlz11

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by beachgirl

I think some of you are missing my point. I dont see the LOGIC in giving homework to five year olds that requires them to read directions in order to do it. What is wrong with an illustration - i.e the number 2 beside a box where they need to draw two circles and then they trace the number 2? This would seem appropriate to me for a 5 year old. Instead his homework is laid out as number one - 1 with a box to draw one circle then number two - 2 with a box to draw two circles etc etc and this goes on until number five - 5. This would be what you would assume is the way to do the homework BUT at the very bottom of the sheet is a small heading titled DIRECTIONS and in there it says in box 1 draw five circles, in box two draw three circles etc etc.

I am not a lazy parent. I sit down with my kids and check their homework. However when my 5 year old sat down and was doing his homework unaided I didn't feel the need to flap my wings around him and when he handed it to me to check I did not notice the DIRECTIONS as I was not expecting directions for a FIVE year old to read.

Now that I know and understand I will be reading directions on his homework. It was just jarring to me and made no logical sense.

Of course this all depends on how much time I have left from helping my 3rd grader complete her common core homework when 2 + 2 is still 4 but she will have to go around the world to arrive at 4 Chat Icon



I get what you are saying. I actually don't believe that kindergarteners should have homework at all especially this early in the year. The only homework they should have is reading every night - whether that be independent reading or co reading. Their brains sure don't need more dittos from EngageNY or Pearson.



HW is meant to reinforce the concepts they learn in school AND to teach them responsibility and accountability.

Teachers assign HW from the get-go because it's part of getting them in the routine of being a student in school. It's no different then the other routines they learn and become responsible for like packing up, emptying their folders, standing quietly in line. etc.



I know what homework is and the purpose. I just don't believe 4 & 5 year olds get any benefit from it. I also don't believe homework is reinforcing much at that age.

There has been much research about the benefit of homework vs no homework. There is little research that can provide a strong correlation between homework in kindergarten and academic achievement in the future.




Have you read the research that states that parental involvement is one of the top factors in student success?


Sorry but that is really a low blow....so unneccesary and plain old mean. She doesnt agree with HW in grade K - so you assume she is not involved as a parent.



No I am stating that when parents are involved with their child's homework that the child is more successful in the classroom. I never mentioned anything about her. I was stating it as that is a reason to have homework. To help their child with skills that were taught and to have them involved in the child's learning process that is a continuation from school.

You totally took that the wrong way

I also think that the link that was posted before does validate that point. That homework is effective when parents are involved in the home.

Message edited 2014-09-19 16:29:13.690000.

Posted 9/19/14 4:27 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by My2Girlz11

Posted by Daisy32

Posted by My2Girlz11

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by beachgirl

I think some of you are missing my point. I dont see the LOGIC in giving homework to five year olds that requires them to read directions in order to do it. What is wrong with an illustration - i.e the number 2 beside a box where they need to draw two circles and then they trace the number 2? This would seem appropriate to me for a 5 year old. Instead his homework is laid out as number one - 1 with a box to draw one circle then number two - 2 with a box to draw two circles etc etc and this goes on until number five - 5. This would be what you would assume is the way to do the homework BUT at the very bottom of the sheet is a small heading titled DIRECTIONS and in there it says in box 1 draw five circles, in box two draw three circles etc etc.

I am not a lazy parent. I sit down with my kids and check their homework. However when my 5 year old sat down and was doing his homework unaided I didn't feel the need to flap my wings around him and when he handed it to me to check I did not notice the DIRECTIONS as I was not expecting directions for a FIVE year old to read.

Now that I know and understand I will be reading directions on his homework. It was just jarring to me and made no logical sense.

Of course this all depends on how much time I have left from helping my 3rd grader complete her common core homework when 2 + 2 is still 4 but she will have to go around the world to arrive at 4 Chat Icon



I get what you are saying. I actually don't believe that kindergarteners should have homework at all especially this early in the year. The only homework they should have is reading every night - whether that be independent reading or co reading. Their brains sure don't need more dittos from EngageNY or Pearson.



HW is meant to reinforce the concepts they learn in school AND to teach them responsibility and accountability.

Teachers assign HW from the get-go because it's part of getting them in the routine of being a student in school. It's no different then the other routines they learn and become responsible for like packing up, emptying their folders, standing quietly in line. etc.



I know what homework is and the purpose. I just don't believe 4 & 5 year olds get any benefit from it. I also don't believe homework is reinforcing much at that age.

There has been much research about the benefit of homework vs no homework. There is little research that can provide a strong correlation between homework in kindergarten and academic achievement in the future.




Have you read the research that states that parental involvement is one of the top factors in student success?


Sorry but that is really a low blow....so unneccesary and plain old mean. She doesnt agree with HW in grade K - so you assume she is not involved as a parent.



No I am stating that when parents are involved with their child's homework that the child is more successful in the classroom. I never mentioned anything about her. I was stating it as that is a reason to have homework. To help their child with skills that were taught and to have them involved in the child's learning process that is a continuation from school.

You totally took that the wrong way

I also think that the link that was posted before does validate that point. That homework is effective when parents are involved in the home.



Parental involvement in school is not limited to homework and at some point, the type of parental involvement might be detrimental. And, at some point, I can't be involved in the homework process other then providing time, space and support because the child needs to learn it and my doing it or reading it won't help. But, that is another grade.

Parental involvement that helps a child be successful in school include communicating with the school, volunteering in the school, being part of the decision making at school, etc. And even the above is negligible because involvement is not a prediction of success. In kindergarten, I believe all of the above are vastly more important then doing Pearson math workbooks. I rather spend that 1/2 hour cuddled on the couch reading to my children or letting my kindergartener read to me.

Posted 9/19/14 4:39 PM
 

Bridex100
Two Under Two Mommy

Member since 3/08

10420 total posts

Name:
Momx100

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by CookiePuss

Each to their own but this is a brief example of why I don't believe there is much benefit to homework in kindergarten....Link

I wanted to add...I am not opposed to homework as a general idea...I don't believe it provides much benefit in kindergarten.



I enjoy doing HW with 5yo DS. We used to have a short study time after dinner during the summer and now that time is HW time. For us, it is about the routine.

For Mother's Day at preschool, the kids had to draw the activity they enjoyed doing most with their mom. DS drew a picture of DS studying with me and wrote, "I love studying with my mom." It was one of my happiest moments, definitely the best gift I received.

DS is very proud of his HW and enjoys taking it back to his teacher to show. I see no downside in 5-10 min of homework for a kindergartener.

Message edited 2014-09-19 17:47:37.463000.

Posted 9/19/14 5:27 PM
 

schmora15
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

2476 total posts

Name:

Re: Common Core - Kindergarten

Posted by CookiePuss

Posted by 2BadSoSad

Posted by CookiePuss

Each to their own but this is a brief example of why I don't believe there is much benefit to homework in kindergarten....Link

I wanted to add...I am not opposed to homework as a general idea...I don't believe it provides much benefit in kindergarten.



I didnt get that from that link at all.



I didn't post the link as a one sided look against homework but more as a point of reference that there are cons as wells as pros in different circumstances.

My view on homework from a parental perspective...my kindergartener starts the day at 9 am and isn't off the bus until after 4:15. During that school day, there is not much time for my child to be a child...run, play, be social with friends, be physically active...so when my child gets off the bus at 4:15...I don't want too much of those precious few hours I have to let them play, decompress from school, dinner, bath and reading ..to be taken up by homework. If my child is in bed at 8 pm...that's only 3 hours and 45 minutes and I don't think 1/2 - 45 minutes of that times should be spent on dittos or number bonds at this age.



I agree..I've found it works better for us to work on in the morning before school. DD gets a packet on Monday and it's not due back until the following Monday. She does it while I get her lunch and stuff ready so it doesn't cut into her down time in the afternoon. If it's a not so great morning we just skip it.

Posted 9/19/14 8:13 PM
 

sameinitials
insert creative comment here

Member since 2/12

1998 total posts

Name:

Common Core - Kindergarten

This is a bit of a tangent, I guess, but is it that uncommon for a 5 year old to be reading? I don't have kids so I don't know what is "normal," but I know that at 5 I was reading books, and my nephew turned 4 a couple months ago and is reading as well.

Posted 9/19/14 9:25 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
COME AND FIND OUT WHAT IS ATTACHED TO HIGH STAKES TESTING, DATA MINING, AND THE COMMON CORE CURRICULUM lc214 1/19/14 2 Parenting
COME AND FIND OUT WHAT IS ATTACHED TO HIGH STAKES TESTING, DATA MINING, AND THE COMMON CORE CURRICULUM lc214 1/19/14 2 Families Helping Families ™
XPOST - new group - Stop Common Core in NYS- Suffolk County Chapter! 2BadSoSad 10/28/13 0 Teachers
XPOST - New Group - Stop Common Core in NYS - Suffolk County Chapter!! 2BadSoSad 10/28/13 2 Parenting
Common Core Withdrawal bill filed in the NYS assembly!! 2BadSoSad 9/30/13 9 Parenting
If your child goes to private school, do they follow the common core standards? BargainMama 4/18/13 10 Parents of School-Aged Children