|
Re: Circumcision
Posted 11/1/2011 1:34:45 PM by Grill Once again, the LIF ladies LOVE the drama, LOVE to misinterpret and LOVE to draw unnecessary conclusions in hopes of stirring up drama. I did NOT say that circumcision was comparable to rape or sodomy. I said that children don't remeber being raped, but that doesnt mean it doesn't affect them. I was discounting the "Won't Remember" argument that is constantly used to do harsh things to your children (ie. prolonged CIO, circumcision, physical punishment, etc.). The fact that he may not remember is NOT a good enough reason in my book to strap him down in four point restraints and rip off the most sensitive part of his genitalia. Whether the reason is so that he will look like his Dad or look like the other guys in the locker room, or be able to clean it easier, or religious....I don't care. I think the procedure is abusive. I am absolutely entitled to my opinion. I am also entitled to advocate strongly for unborn males in hopes of saving them from their parents poor decisions. Yes, they'll get over it. Yes, they'll be fine emotionally. Yes, their when he and his dad compare penises with each other they will look the same. I don't need to justify my own actions. I've done the research and I feel that circumcision is synonomous with genital mutilation, which is illegal if performed on females. I do think this practice should be outlawed. And I do think that religious customs and family traditions need to be challenged from time to time in order for the population to continue to evolve morally, spiritually and biologically. I've seen several videos of hospital circs and I've attended many Bris ceremonies (which are much more peaceful...even though the mom hides in the back room and cries). But IMO, which the OP asked for, circumcision is wrong. I don't think it makes anyone a bad parent. We are all doing the best we can out of love. But I do think it is sad when a mother, who has seen what a circumcision procedure REALLY looks like and seen physiological markers of the after effects, will still willingly send her new baby off to be cut. It's a process that deserves to be intensely scrutinized by all new parents. It is not enough to say 'we are doing it, because that's what we do'. If you think I'm disgusting, go watch the videos and then go apologize to your son. The procedure is disgusting. And I don't care who I offend. I was asked for my opinion and I provided it. I know it's a strong one...but there's a brand new human being at stake here...with real feelings, emotions, security needs and pain thresholds. I feel sad for him...I don't feel judgmental towards you. I get it. I get why people do it. I just think that as a whole, our society needs to challenge this from a medical, cultural, religious and emotional points of view. |