Christening gift insult?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Christening gift insult?

Ideally, yes, it would be great if they saved the money for their child, but I don't really understand why it's your business what they do with that money?Chat Icon Even more than that, I don't even know how you would know what they did with it.

Posted 1/15/07 12:11 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Anniegrl
I'm two!

Member since 5/05

4320 total posts

Name:
Ann

Re: Christening gift insult?

I'll admit, I've been tempted to use money given to Jackson for other things, but my guilt got the better of me. All money sent for him goes into his savings account.

So yes, if I were you, I'd be annoyed.

ETA - if the money was used towards something important, then I wouldn't mind. But to pay for a party???? Chat Icon

Message edited 2007-01-15 12:14:54.683000.

Posted 1/15/07 12:12 PM
 

puppylove
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/05

561 total posts

Name:
Summer

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by prncssrachel

Ideally, yes, it would be great if they saved the money for their child, but I don't really understand why it's your business what they do with that money?Chat Icon Even more than that, I don't even know how you would know what they did with it.



I was mad because I didn't give them money to pay for the caterer and balloons. We gave them money for their child's future. It's hard to save money these days, and so we figured that with all the money you receive for the Christening, 1st Communion and other money giving celebrations throughout the years it builds up and will give the child a nice bank account one day.

We found out because it is my DH cousins 1st child, we talk a lot and at a family get-together she mentioned how great it was to get all that money, because they needed to pay off the party.

I see everyones point, it really should not be my concern what happens to the money after we give it away. It just struck me as odd at the time, but I am open minded to the answers that everyone gave me. Thank you.

Posted 1/15/07 12:22 PM
 

puppylove
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/05

561 total posts

Name:
Summer

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by Anniegrl

I'll admit, I've been tempted to use money given to Jackson for other things, but my guilt got the better of me. All money sent for him goes into his savings account.

So yes, if I were you, I'd be annoyed.

ETA - if the money was used towards something important, then I wouldn't mind. But to pay for a party???? Chat Icon



Thank you. That is what I was getting at. I'm not saying the parents should save the money until the child is 40 and then give it to them, but something a little more useful and important than a party.

Posted 1/15/07 12:23 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Christening gift insult?

You know why your post irked me. It's hard enough being a new parent as it is, then you add to it the fact that everyone is judging you, and it becomes quite annoying. You are posting on a parenting board where not everyone is in the same financial situation, and you don't know how many people here have done the same thing. I'm sorry that you're disappointed with how your gift was handled, and I'm happy that you are open minded to what other people are saying, but if you'd like to judge people on what they do, just be aware that it could always be you in that situation someday.
That being said, I have used just about all the money that has been given to my daughter as a gift because I cannot afford her prescription formula that my insurance does not cover. So, if I did have a christening for her, I can tell you that money would go straight to formula as well. So, if you want to know why I take this so personally, that would be the reason.

Posted 1/15/07 12:34 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Christening gift insult?

I actually feel badly for the parents.

Im sure they didnt anticipate on using the babys gift money and Im sure it didnt make them feel great to have to do it.

Im also sure they didnt use every single monetary gift to pay for it .

I wouldnt be mad. Really when your giving a gift to a baby, your giving it to the parents and dont get to control where it goes.

Posted 1/15/07 12:56 PM
 

SoinLove
Making big changes

Member since 5/05

16541 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by anon

Posted by sarahsmommy

It wouldn't bother me, it's a gift and up to the parent's discression how it's spent. We personally choose to put our children's gifts in saving accounts for them.

same here



I agree

Posted 1/15/07 12:57 PM
 

hazeleyes33
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

13060 total posts

Name:
Ginger

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by puppylove

Posted by prncssrachel

Ideally, yes, it would be great if they saved the money for their child, but I don't really understand why it's your business what they do with that money?Chat Icon Even more than that, I don't even know how you would know what they did with it.



I was mad because I didn't give them money to pay for the caterer and balloons. We gave them money for their child's future. It's hard to save money these days, and so we figured that with all the money you receive for the Christening, 1st Communion and other money giving celebrations throughout the years it builds up and will give the child a nice bank account one day.

We found out because it is my DH cousins 1st child, we talk a lot and at a family get-together she mentioned how great it was to get all that money, because they needed to pay off the party.

I see everyones point, it really should not be my concern what happens to the money after we give it away. It just struck me as odd at the time, but I am open minded to the answers that everyone gave me. Thank you.



I'm sorry, but I have to agree with you. That money is not intended to pay for a party that the PARENTS want, not even the child. I understand parents want to be like everyone else and do everything for their kids but there is a time when they have to sit back and realize that they just can not afford it. I personally have never, and never would take money my children were given as gifts. Big things like christenings and communions (we never had big parties so they never got much) are put right into their bank accounts. Birthdays, Easter, Christmas, etc. money is given to them to spend on toys, etc.
We had a small party at home for my dd for her communion. We still owe the credit card which I put towards each week because I would NEVER take the money she got from family and friends to pay for it.
I am not judging anybody by how much money they have but sometimes you have to think of your priorites. If your child needs clothes or food, do NOT have a party that you can not afford. Do something small that you will be able to save for or pay back in the coming months.

Posted 1/15/07 7:49 PM
 

puppylove
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/05

561 total posts

Name:
Summer

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by prncssrachel

You know why your post irked me. It's hard enough being a new parent as it is, then you add to it the fact that everyone is judging you, and it becomes quite annoying. You are posting on a parenting board where not everyone is in the same financial situation, and you don't know how many people here have done the same thing. I'm sorry that you're disappointed with how your gift was handled, and I'm happy that you are open minded to what other people are saying, but if you'd like to judge people on what they do, just be aware that it could always be you in that situation someday.
That being said, I have used just about all the money that has been given to my daughter as a gift because I cannot afford her prescription formula that my insurance does not cover. So, if I did have a christening for her, I can tell you that money would go straight to formula as well. So, if you want to know why I take this so personally, that would be the reason.



I would like to apologize to you and any other parent that I offended. It was not my intent to make you feel bad about what you do as a parent. However, we are hardly millionaires either, so please don't assume that because I don't have children to spend money on we are not struggling. Putting aside $150 was not easy for us, but we wanted to help with the child's future. This being said, I would imagine that when we have children every bit of money that comes to our children will either be spent on important and needed items or put away for their future. I was initially insulted by the way our money was used, but opened minded enough to want to know if I was wrong to think so. I came on here to see what other people had to say. I am sorry that I offended you, again I truly did not mean to hurt you.

As I responded to another post who brought up the fact that often even when the parents want to put the money given to a child away, often it cannot be saved due to certain family situations.

If parents need the gift money to pay for prescription drugs/formula, food, clothing, the roof over their head or just to make Christmas beautiful for the child, that is completely different situation. No where in my posts did I say anything bad about people who used the money for needed things. A party is not a need. And in those cases I welcome the family to use the money to better their lives and the lives of their children.

My point is this, if money is tight for the family, then when they receive gift money aren't there more important things than spending the money on a party? Who is to say that with things as expensive as they are, that things will be different for the family in 18 years? So, wouldn't it be great to skip the party, and then tell your kids when they grow up, it’s not much but here is your "found" money that you can put towards college or a used car? Or even just put the money away for future family emergencies such as food and clothing.

If your concern is for your child then wasting the money on a party is not right. My $150 would have gone farther at Walmart or Target or a supermarket buying cloths and food than it did for the party, balloons and party favor.

I am saying that I presented the parents with a check for their child to either PRODUCTIVELY help the child presently or in the future. The child won't remember that there was no Christening party, or that the party was just a small get together at your house. They will however remember not having food or some money for college in the future.

By using the gift money for your daughters prescription formula, you are looking out for what is undoubtedly in her best interests. I am not condemning those who use the money for the best, only those who think a party is more important. Again I truly and whole heartdly apologize to you.

Posted 1/16/07 12:43 AM
 

puppylove
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/05

561 total posts

Name:
Summer

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by hazeleyes33

Posted by puppylove

Posted by prncssrachel

Ideally, yes, it would be great if they saved the money for their child, but I don't really understand why it's your business what they do with that money?Chat Icon Even more than that, I don't even know how you would know what they did with it.



I was mad because I didn't give them money to pay for the caterer and balloons. We gave them money for their child's future. It's hard to save money these days, and so we figured that with all the money you receive for the Christening, 1st Communion and other money giving celebrations throughout the years it builds up and will give the child a nice bank account one day.

We found out because it is my DH cousins 1st child, we talk a lot and at a family get-together she mentioned how great it was to get all that money, because they needed to pay off the party.

I see everyones point, it really should not be my concern what happens to the money after we give it away. It just struck me as odd at the time, but I am open minded to the answers that everyone gave me. Thank you.



I'm sorry, but I have to agree with you. That money is not intended to pay for a party that the PARENTS want, not even the child. I understand parents want to be like everyone else and do everything for their kids but there is a time when they have to sit back and realize that they just can not afford it. I personally have never, and never would take money my children were given as gifts. Big things like christenings and communions (we never had big parties so they never got much) are put right into their bank accounts. Birthdays, Easter, Christmas, etc. money is given to them to spend on toys, etc.
We had a small party at home for my dd for her communion. We still owe the credit card which I put towards each week because I would NEVER take the money she got from family and friends to pay for it.
I am not judging anybody by how much money they have but sometimes you have to think of your priorites. If your child needs clothes or food, do NOT have a party that you can not afford. Do something small that you will be able to save for or pay back in the coming months.



Thank you. You said exactly what I am trying to say.

Posted 1/16/07 12:48 AM
 

Sweets13
Bella Bambini

Member since 5/05

9300 total posts

Name:

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by puppylove


If parents need the gift money to pay for prescription drugs/formula, food, clothing, the roof over their head or just to make Christmas beautiful for the child, that is completely different situation. No where in my posts did I say anything bad about people who used the money for needed things. A party is not a need. And in those cases I welcome the family to use the money to better their lives and the lives of their children.





Exactly.....using DC's money for the above and using the money to pay for the childs party are totally different.............

It is obvious that you didnt write this post to offend anyone.


:hug

Message edited 2007-01-16 06:38:12.370000.

Posted 1/16/07 6:37 AM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by puppylove

Posted by prncssrachel

You know why your post irked me. It's hard enough being a new parent as it is, then you add to it the fact that everyone is judging you, and it becomes quite annoying. You are posting on a parenting board where not everyone is in the same financial situation, and you don't know how many people here have done the same thing. I'm sorry that you're disappointed with how your gift was handled, and I'm happy that you are open minded to what other people are saying, but if you'd like to judge people on what they do, just be aware that it could always be you in that situation someday.
That being said, I have used just about all the money that has been given to my daughter as a gift because I cannot afford her prescription formula that my insurance does not cover. So, if I did have a christening for her, I can tell you that money would go straight to formula as well. So, if you want to know why I take this so personally, that would be the reason.



I would like to apologize to you and any other parent that I offended. It was not my intent to make you feel bad about what you do as a parent. However, we are hardly millionaires either, so please don't assume that because I don't have children to spend money on we are not struggling. Putting aside $150 was not easy for us, but we wanted to help with the child's future. This being said, I would imagine that when we have children every bit of money that comes to our children will either be spent on important and needed items or put away for their future. I was initially insulted by the way our money was used, but opened minded enough to want to know if I was wrong to think so. I came on here to see what other people had to say. I am sorry that I offended you, again I truly did not mean to hurt you.

As I responded to another post who brought up the fact that often even when the parents want to put the money given to a child away, often it cannot be saved due to certain family situations.

If parents need the gift money to pay for prescription drugs/formula, food, clothing, the roof over their head or just to make Christmas beautiful for the child, that is completely different situation. No where in my posts did I say anything bad about people who used the money for needed things. A party is not a need. And in those cases I welcome the family to use the money to better their lives and the lives of their children.

My point is this, if money is tight for the family, then when they receive gift money aren't there more important things than spending the money on a party? Who is to say that with things as expensive as they are, that things will be different for the family in 18 years? So, wouldn't it be great to skip the party, and then tell your kids when they grow up, it’s not much but here is your "found" money that you can put towards college or a used car? Or even just put the money away for future family emergencies such as food and clothing.

If your concern is for your child then wasting the money on a party is not right. My $150 would have gone farther at Walmart or Target or a supermarket buying cloths and food than it did for the party, balloons and party favor.

I am saying that I presented the parents with a check for their child to either PRODUCTIVELY help the child presently or in the future. The child won't remember that there was no Christening party, or that the party was just a small get together at your house. They will however remember not having food or some money for college in the future.

By using the gift money for your daughters prescription formula, you are looking out for what is undoubtedly in her best interests. I am not condemning those who use the money for the best, only those who think a party is more important. Again I truly and whole heartdly apologize to you.





While I appreciate the apology, and I truly don't think you meant to offend anyone, I think you're missing the point. The judging alone is what is the problem. Maybe it's very important to people to have a party for their child's christening. It's not your place to judge whether or not that's an expense worth spending on. And I never said that you must have money because you don't have children. I would never assume that. I just think that we all do what we feel is right as parents, and it's not our place to judge. While I agree that if I didn't have the money for a party, I wouldn't be having one, I can also understand why it's important to people, as well. Is it as important as food or clothing or shelter? Probably not, but who am I to say that it's not important at all? That's my point. Just that maybe we should spend less time judging other people. Again, I don't think that you meant to offend anyone. I think this is a subject we will have to agree to disagree on.

Posted 1/16/07 6:45 AM
 

CaseyGirl
Mommy to 3 Boys :)

Member since 5/05

19978 total posts

Name:
Jen - counting my blessings...

Re: Christening gift insult?

I agree, it should go towards the baby's college fund or something but once the $ leaves your hands I guess they can do whatever they want with it...

eta: i always give savings bonds..

Message edited 2007-01-16 07:12:45.327000.

Posted 1/16/07 7:12 AM
 

IrishTracy
Believe!!

Member since 5/05

15167 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by hazeleyes33

I'm sorry, but I have to agree with you. That money is not intended to pay for a party that the PARENTS want, not even the child. I understand parents want to be like everyone else and do everything for their kids but there is a time when they have to sit back and realize that they just can not afford it. I personally have never, and never would take money my children were given as gifts. Big things like christenings and communions (we never had big parties so they never got much) are put right into their bank accounts. Birthdays, Easter, Christmas, etc. money is given to them to spend on toys, etc.
We had a small party at home for my dd for her communion. We still owe the credit card which I put towards each week because I would NEVER take the money she got from family and friends to pay for it.
I am not judging anybody by how much money they have but sometimes you have to think of your priorites. If your child needs clothes or food, do NOT have a party that you can not afford. Do something small that you will be able to save for or pay back in the coming months.



I agree. If I can't afford the party I'm not having it. I would never take money intended for my children. They all have bank accounts & that is where all the money they ever get goes.

Posted 1/16/07 8:05 AM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by prncssrachel

Ideally, yes, it would be great if they saved the money for their child, but I don't really understand why it's your business what they do with that money?Chat Icon Even more than that, I don't even know how you would know what they did with it.



I totally agree.

Posted 1/16/07 8:43 AM
 

nylisa
My Children

Member since 5/05

7905 total posts

Name:
MaMa

Re: Christening gift insult?

Let me tell you, we had a small party for DS's christening at our house and all the money he received we had to pay bills with because at that time I was not getting paid from my job. So all his money went to bills but we have written down how much he has gotten since he was born and we will be paying him back and opening an account for him.

Posted 1/16/07 11:06 AM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Christening gift insult?

I wouldn't be insulted at all. Would you be insulted if they used the money to pay for diapers? Food? Toys? Clothes? Is it they used it for the party that bothers you? Chat Icon

You gave a monetary gift, you have to let it go. I could understand being upset if the parents went out and bought an Ipod or clothes for themselves with it, but they spent it on a party for the baby, so I don't see the big deal.

Posted 1/16/07 11:27 AM
 

LisaI
Momma's Little Beans

Member since 1/06

3923 total posts

Name:

Re: Christening gift insult?

x

Message edited 2007-01-16 12:03:20.093000.

Posted 1/16/07 12:00 PM
 

hazeleyes33
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

13060 total posts

Name:
Ginger

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by Shelly

I wouldn't be insulted at all. Would you be insulted if they used the money to pay for diapers? Food? Toys? Clothes? Is it they used it for the party that bothers you? Chat Icon

You gave a monetary gift, you have to let it go. I could understand being upset if the parents went out and bought an Ipod or clothes for themselves with it, but they spent it on a party for the baby, so I don't see the big deal.



I think the point she is trying to make is that the money you give is normally intended for the child and their future. It is not to pay for a huge party that the parents could not afford anyway.
Everyone IS different but I could NEVER touch my kids money for anything that was not for them. That is why we never had big parties for them as we could not afford it. Their money is their money.

Posted 1/16/07 12:30 PM
 

Bklyngrl
luvmyfamily

Member since 9/06

5307 total posts

Name:

Re: Christening gift insult?

I can understand celebrating a happy occasion with family and close friends but I think some people go too far with the guest list. If you can't afford to host a party, have something with immediate family & friends only. Its a christening - the baby doesn't want the party. that's my opinion.

Posted 1/26/07 3:34 PM
 

Suzan
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/06

754 total posts

Name:

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by CathyB

It wouldn't bother me, it's a gift and up to the parent's discression how it's spent. We personally choose to put our children's gifts in saving accounts for them.



This is how I feel.

Posted 1/26/07 5:47 PM
 

lvdolphins
My Loves!

Member since 5/05

46292 total posts

Name:

Re: Christening gift insult?

I think I'd be a little annoyed. When we had to parties like that (when we were younger), my parents always put the $ in our bank accounts.

Posted 1/26/07 6:29 PM
 

4monkeys
boys will be boys =)

Member since 9/05

7205 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: Christening gift insult?

I think Id be a little annoyed also. My parents put all our money into bank accounts. and that's what we've done for the boys.
If we cant afford a party at a restaurant, we wont have a party at a restaurant.

MAybe they plan to "pay back" the child.
I think I mentioned this story in another post. A coworker once was inviting everyone to a 30th bday she was throwing for herself Chat Icon at a nice restaurant. so in chatting with her, she said "how do I tell everyone to ONLY BRING CASH, that's in the Russian tradition to do that, NO GIFTS, and also, I NEED the envelopes to pay for the party that nite, $35 each minimum" Chat Icon Chat Icon
I nearly fell over. It was in bad enough taste that she threw her own party...

needless to say, not one person went after this went around. She was trying to figure out a way to word this on the invite! and she was a BIG spender, obviously spending way over her head..
sorry, this story just reminded me of that.

I think at first this christening thing would bother me, but when it comes down to it, everyone does what they need to do.

Message edited 2007-01-26 20:34:25.383000.

Posted 1/26/07 8:33 PM
 

cloddy
Holiday 2011 photo

Member since 8/05

8088 total posts

Name:
Kristen

Re: Christening gift insult?

I think that this is the chance you take when you give cash or a check. You have no idea what it's going to be used for. And unless it's made out to the child how would you even indicate that it's your wish that it be used for their future or their college? I think it would be nice if they saved it for their child, but I don't think as the gift giver you have any control. If it bothers you then I think you have to give it as a bond in the future b/c that's the only way you might be able to discourage them from using it right away. As previous posters said, each family is different and if they needed the money, then it's their perogative to use it. It's interesting to me b/c we had a party at the house while I felt like almost everyone else was having them at restauarants b/c we couldn't afford it and then it turned out that DD got tons of money as gifts which I never expected and I said after the fact to DH I guess we really could've had it at a restaurant considering, but I would never have done that since we didn't have the money for it, but that's just me. To each his own, you know?

Posted 1/26/07 9:08 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Christening gift insult?

I agree with some of the other posters, once you give a gift, it is out of your hands. If it bothered me that much, I wouldn't give cash next time.

I also think this is a little like a chicken and the egg argument. If they had a small party, they wouldn't have received too many cash gifts, so the child wouldn't have received most of the cash gifts anyway. Since they did have the party, they might have overextended themselves financially to pay for it. To me, it's important to celebrate these life events and the gift is secondary.

Posted 1/26/07 9:57 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Christening gift - who do I make check payable to? KAS 3/11/06 6 Parenting
Christening gift KAS 3/5/06 4 Parenting
Is this appropriate for a boy's Christening gift? MrsBumbleb 1/16/06 2 Parenting
Christening Gift for a Co-Workers daughter? Holly 12/10/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
Christening gift etiquette- Godmother Bri 12/5/05 16 Families Helping Families ™
Christening Gift raken40 10/7/05 7 Families Helping Families ™