Christening gift insult?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

puppylove
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/05

561 total posts

Name:
Summer

Christening gift insult?

Please tell me if I am right to be upset about this:

We attended a Christening about 2 months ago for a family members DD. We presented the BABY with a hundred and fifty dollar check. Only to find out the money was used to pay for the the Christening party! We were shocked.

We had always been under the impression that money giving to a child for their chrisenting, 1st communion etc was for their parents to put away for them maybe for help with college.

If we had know that our gift was going towards paying for the party we would have not given a money gift. I feel that they took their child's gift. If they didn't have the money to pay for the party, then they should not have had one. As of right now their children WILL NOT get any more money gifts from us

I'm just wondering, am I wrong to be annoyed? Or is this what is people do? Please tell me if I'm wrong. Thanks! Chat Icon

Message edited 2007-01-14 15:35:56.133000.

Posted 1/14/07 3:24 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Christening gift insult?

eh, I think that they should have put it away for the baby but I would not get upset about it. Like you said, don't give them cash anymore or give savings bonds in the childs name

Posted 1/14/07 3:39 PM
 

apb17
My guys

Member since 5/06

2173 total posts

Name:
Alli

Re: Christening gift insult?

This is not the first time I have heard of parents doing this.Chat Icon I would be very angry as well especially b/c your gift was soooo generous. To be on the safe side I usually buy a svaings bond. This way you know the money will benefit the child adn not fund any party.

Posted 1/14/07 3:39 PM
 

puppylove
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/05

561 total posts

Name:
Summer

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by apb17

This is not the first time I have heard of parents doing this.Chat Icon I would be very angry as well especially b/c your gift was soooo generous. To be on the safe side I usually buy a svaings bond. This way you know the money will benefit the child adn not fund any party.



I have heard of a lot of parents doing this as well. And it always bothered me, but especially now! The savings bond idea is good...I will have to remember that for the future. Thanks for the idea.

Posted 1/14/07 3:45 PM
 

Stacey1403
Where it all began....

Member since 5/05

24065 total posts

Name:

Re: Christening gift insult?

I would stick with bonds from now onChat Icon

Posted 1/14/07 3:50 PM
 

CathyB

Member since 5/05

19403 total posts

Name:

Re: Christening gift insult?

It wouldn't bother me, it's a gift and up to the parent's discression how it's spent. We personally choose to put our children's gifts in saving accounts for them.

I can tell you that when I was young my dad was in the military and didn't make much money at all any monetary gifts my brother and I got had to go to paying the bills, groceries, etc. We usually got toys or clothes and money from our family members who knew what the situation was. But it certainly wasn't something most people knew and I bet a lot of people didn't realize that's where our money was going.

Posted 1/14/07 3:56 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Christening gift insult?

I guess I would be annoyed but probably wouldn't make a big deal about it. Just don't give cash from now on.
We're bad, we still don't have a separate account set up for DD but I have always kept track of how much of her money is sitting in our account. I would feel guilty if we actually started spending her money because my parents did that to me. Chat Icon

Posted 1/14/07 3:56 PM
 

Melbernai
I am a lucky Momma!

Member since 7/05

15652 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Christening gift insult?

I can understand how you would be upset because you gave the money thinking that it would be put away for the baby, but I have also heard of a lot of people using hte money to pay for the baby's party.

Personally my daughter has only recieved bonds, no cash as of yet, but we had very small parties with just immediate family member so she doesn't have much in bonds either. The one thing to remember though about bonds is that they don't reach their full value for 30 years now.

I do think though, that if it was between the child having no party at all, and the parents using some of the gift money to fund a reasonable party, not over the top, that it would be OK, since I can understand wanting to celebrate a special day even if you don't necessarily have the funds to do it.

Posted 1/14/07 4:11 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Christening gift insult?

We put our children's money in an account.

I woudn't be upset about it. I think it's unfortunate that the parents couldn't afford to throw the party & save the money for their child. I agree - stick with bonds for the future.

Posted 1/14/07 4:12 PM
 

SkyzTheLimit
Bring on summer!!!

Member since 3/06

2483 total posts

Name:
Jamie

Re: Christening gift insult?

I think any money that a child gets for there party should go towards them.. towards college of in to some kind of saving fund. That is ridiculous how people can be. Next time you go to something of theirs and give them a gift make it a savings bond. At least you know they can't do anything with that.

Posted 1/14/07 5:15 PM
 

preciouslove
I love my DS!!!

Member since 5/05

9340 total posts

Name:
Blank

Re: Christening gift insult?

Matty's christening money went into his bank account...

Posted 1/14/07 5:24 PM
 

puppylove
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/05

561 total posts

Name:
Summer

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by sarahsmommy

It wouldn't bother me, it's a gift and up to the parent's discression how it's spent. We personally choose to put our children's gifts in saving accounts for them.

I can tell you that when I was young my dad was in the military and didn't make much money at all any monetary gifts my brother and I got had to go to paying the bills, groceries, etc. We usually got toys or clothes and money from our family members who knew what the situation was. But it certainly wasn't something most people knew and I bet a lot of people didn't realize that's where our money was going.



I totally see your point. you are very right, in your case the money was very much needed to help the family. If this was their situation then I would be fine with how they spend the money. But it's not, they both work and live comfortably. I just think that if money is tight, then don't throw a party.

Posted 1/14/07 5:58 PM
 

Maathy317
Grammie's Little Man

Member since 2/06

3235 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Christening gift insult?

If you give a savings bond, make sure to list it only in the child's name with one of the parents as the beneficiary. Don't put any other name on the bond other than the child's, otherwise, it can be cashed in by the other person.

Posted 1/14/07 6:05 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Christening gift insult?

Well, maybe i am in the minority...BUT...i come from a large family. Everytime there was a christening in the past, the parents definitely used some of the gift money to pay for the party. I don't see anything wrong with it.

Not everyone in life is in situations where they have a ton of money...me included right now. My husband and i don't have much extra money as i am a SAHM, however we want to have a party for our son...nothing over the top, we are keeping it very simple BUT we may need to use some gift money for it. Actually family has already told us that they will give cash, that way it could help out.

We will pay for what we can and if we don't need gift $$ to help, it will go right in the bank...some families are fortunate to have all expenses covered and can save for their child right away, but others cannot. Doesn't mean they can't give their child a party..no matter how small or meager it is. Just my opinion, i know no one in my family or DH's would think twice.

Posted 1/14/07 6:45 PM
 

maybebaby
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

6870 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Christening gift insult?

I do think though, that if it was between the child having no party at all, and the parents using some of the gift money to fund a reasonable party, not over the top, that it would be OK, since I can understand wanting to celebrate a special day even if you don't necessarily have the funds to do it.

This is exactly what i feel, you summed it up well :)

Posted 1/14/07 6:47 PM
 

anon
where's winter?

Member since 11/05

2209 total posts

Name:

xxxxxxx

Message edited 2007-02-09 21:30:22.037000.

Posted 1/14/07 7:04 PM
 

pmpkn087
Life is good...

Member since 9/05

18504 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by stephanief

eh, I think that they should have put it away for the baby but I would not get upset about it. Like you said, don't give them cash anymore or give savings bonds in the childs name



I agree. I def think that the gifts should go for the baby, but everyone is different.

But then again I do not believe that wedding gifts should pay for the wedding reception either.

Posted 1/14/07 7:21 PM
 

puppylove
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/05

561 total posts

Name:
Summer

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by pmpkn087

Posted by stephanief

eh, I think that they should have put it away for the baby but I would not get upset about it. Like you said, don't give them cash anymore or give savings bonds in the childs name



I agree. I def think that the gifts should go for the baby, but everyone is different.

But then again I do not believe that wedding gifts should pay for the wedding reception either.


Posted by maybebaby

Well, maybe i am in the minority...BUT...i come from a large family. Everytime there was a christening in the past, the parents definitely used some of the gift money to pay for the party. I don't see anything wrong with it.

Not everyone in life is in situations where they have a ton of money...me included right now. My husband and i don't have much extra money as i am a SAHM, however we want to have a party for our son...nothing over the top, we are keeping it very simple BUT we may need to use some gift money for it. Actually family has already told us that they will give cash, that way it could help out.

We will pay for what we can and if we don't need gift $$ to help, it will go right in the bank...some families are fortunate to have all expenses covered and can save for their child right away, but others cannot. Doesn't mean they can't give their child a party..no matter how small or meager it is. Just my opinion, i know no one in my family or DH's would think twice.



I do understand what you are saying. Not everyone has enough money to pay for parties these days. So I guess in those cases using some of the $ to help out is one thing, but not all. I really think some of the money should have been put away for the childs future.

I feel the same way about wedding receptions also. I just feel that when planing a function you should be able to afford the event prior to recieving money gifts. I know that this would never happen but...what if no one gave the child a money gift? How would they have payed for the party then?

I knew before I posted that I would never mention it to them, because as much as I can say I know they are comfortable...I guess you can't ever really know what someone else financial situation is. And I really hope that I didn't offend anyone who did use the money for other things.

This was their first child and the first time I had dealt with this, so was I surprised. Thank you for giving me your diffirent opinions. I see both sides better now. I really don't want to not give money as a protest, cause I'm sure they'll have more children soon, so the savings bond idea is good, I really hadn't thought of that! Thanks ladies!

Posted 1/14/07 8:40 PM
 

Elizabeth
Mom of Three

Member since 9/05

7900 total posts

Name:
"MOMMY!!!"

Re: Christening gift insult?

It wouldnt bother me. Its not up to me once its out of my hands. Whats the difference between that and if they spent it a week later on something else? But maybe they were short and planned on replacing it for their child later on.

Posted 1/14/07 8:47 PM
 

greenybeans
:)

Member since 8/06

6435 total posts

Name:

Re: Christening gift insult?

Personally I believe that money given to the child should be put into an account for them.
As for savings bonds, parents can cash them in as well. It makes no difference if their name is on the bond or not.

Posted 1/14/07 9:17 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Christening gift insult?

It's possible that they have an account that they have automatic payroll deductions every week going just towards their kids. They may have needed the cash up front, and they'll more than make up for it during the year. I've given people money "for something", but it's all one big pool of money, technically. If they put the check into the child's account, that might mean the kid won't get the equivalent money from the parents that month.

I've learned not to judge what people do with their money. It's very generous what you gave, and it still indirectly goes towards the child. Paying off the party means less interest paid on credit cards, means more money in the family for the kids... everything balances in the end most of the time.

Posted 1/15/07 8:19 AM
 

LuvMy2Girls
@>---------

Member since 5/05

11165 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by GoldenRod

I've learned not to judge what people do with their money. It's very generous what you gave, and it still indirectly goes towards the child. Paying off the party means less interest paid on credit cards, means more money in the family for the kids... everything balances in the end most of the time.



I agree. Unfortunately, you really don't know exactly what happened with the money or gift, they might have taken a loan and replaced it.

This goes the same with any gift you give, what if you spend 150 bucks on a really cool toy or clothes and they returned them for something else, my point is, once you give a gift, monetary or an actual gift, it's out of your hands what happens after. It's like going to people's houses and looking for gifts you gave them and what they did with them, just wrong in my opinion.

I wouldn't give bonds, i personally hate those things, such a waste, I can invest my dd's money much better with more interest than those things earn. You can also cash them out for face value after a certain period of time and not wait for them to mature.

I am curious though, how did you find out they spent it on the party?

Posted 1/15/07 8:45 AM
 

pharmcat2000
Mom of 2 + 1

Member since 10/05

7395 total posts

Name:
Catherine

Re: Christening gift insult?

I don't think it's a big deal, and I wouldn't get upset about it. I too agree that if you give money to a child as a gift and it is used to pay for the party, then that is the parents' decision. It will be their responsibility to provide what the child needs in the future anyway, so if they use that money now to pay for the party and have to use "their" money later to pay for things like college then it all comes out even in the end. Many people have used wedding gifts to help pay for their wedding, and we all still give money for that. If the parents wanted to have a party for their child but needed some help paying for it, then it doesn't mean that the child was any less deserving of that party.

Like someone said above, you give a gift, and you have to let go of it.

And giving a bond doesn't ensure that the parents won't cash it. It can be cashed after a year unless you make it POD. I can tell you that I have many bonds for my DD and I hate them. I wanted to invest her money in something that would earn a better return than bonds but now I can't unless I go cash in those bonds. We put all of her money into an account for her but if she needed something for her and we decided to use her money for it then so be it.

p/s - we got a bond POD and I was so extremely insulted that I can't even explain it to you. I felt like I had been slapped in the face. It was almost as if the givers (BIL & SIL) were telling us that they didn't trust us to provide for DD so they were going to make sure that they did. Chat Icon

Posted 1/15/07 9:13 AM
 

puppylove
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/05

561 total posts

Name:
Summer

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by sweetness

Posted by GoldenRod

I've learned not to judge what people do with their money. It's very generous what you gave, and it still indirectly goes towards the child. Paying off the party means less interest paid on credit cards, means more money in the family for the kids... everything balances in the end most of the time.



I agree. Unfortunately, you really don't know exactly what happened with the money or gift, they might have taken a loan and replaced it.

This goes the same with any gift you give, what if you spend 150 bucks on a really cool toy or clothes and they returned them for something else, my point is, once you give a gift, monetary or an actual gift, it's out of your hands what happens after. It's like going to people's houses and looking for gifts you gave them and what they did with them, just wrong in my opinion.

I wouldn't give bonds, i personally hate those things, such a waste, I can invest my dd's money much better with more interest than those things earn. You can also cash them out for face value after a certain period of time and not wait for them to mature.

I am curious though, how did you find out they spent it on the party?




I see what you are saying. At a family get-together, we were talking and she mentioned how much money they had gotten for the Christening and that it was great, because they needed it to pay off the party. I was just surprised, but now I see a lot of people do this, and I can't judge where the money goes after it has left my hands. It is up to the parents and I have to resect what they decide to do.

Posted 1/15/07 12:06 PM
 

puppylove
LIF Adolescent

Member since 10/05

561 total posts

Name:
Summer

Re: Christening gift insult?

Posted by pharmcat2000

I don't think it's a big deal, and I wouldn't get upset about it. I too agree that if you give money to a child as a gift and it is used to pay for the party, then that is the parents' decision. It will be their responsibility to provide what the child needs in the future anyway, so if they use that money now to pay for the party and have to use "their" money later to pay for things like college then it all comes out even in the end. Many people have used wedding gifts to help pay for their wedding, and we all still give money for that. If the parents wanted to have a party for their child but needed some help paying for it, then it doesn't mean that the child was any less deserving of that party.

Like someone said above, you give a gift, and you have to let go of it.

And giving a bond doesn't ensure that the parents won't cash it. It can be cashed after a year unless you make it POD. I can tell you that I have many bonds for my DD and I hate them. I wanted to invest her money in something that would earn a better return than bonds but now I can't unless I go cash in those bonds. We put all of her money into an account for her but if she needed something for her and we decided to use her money for it then so be it.

p/s - we got a bond POD and I was so extremely insulted that I can't even explain it to you. I felt like I had been slapped in the face. It was almost as if the givers (BIL & SIL) were telling us that they didn't trust us to provide for DD so they were going to make sure that they did. Chat Icon



I could see how that would insult you and I really do see your point.

Posted 1/15/07 12:10 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Christening gift - who do I make check payable to? KAS 3/11/06 6 Parenting
Christening gift KAS 3/5/06 4 Parenting
Is this appropriate for a boy's Christening gift? MrsBumbleb 1/16/06 2 Parenting
Christening Gift for a Co-Workers daughter? Holly 12/10/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
Christening gift etiquette- Godmother Bri 12/5/05 16 Families Helping Families ™
Christening Gift raken40 10/7/05 7 Families Helping Families ™