Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? Posted by Ophelia I get all of this. I guess it's just the general idea. most people don't know (or care) about anything you pointed out (doesn't make it any less relevant....it's just most people don't have a need to know this stuff, you know) so someone like my husband...who is relatively smart and educated, can use what he sees as an everyday person to deduce that we as a people punish animal abusers more harshly than we do spousal abusers.I guess that is my point. the general sentiment that is conveys...more than the legal/technical stuff that people "in the know" know, you know? what you take from this is :Michael Vick abuses animals and is involved in dog fighting and does hard time. Chris Brown beats, chokes, and threatens his girl friends life and will have to remove graffitti from the walls of Va. when he's not on tour, making movies, promoting an album, or otherwise living a fabu life. and people got mad that Vick was allowed to play football once he was finished?????? up in arms about that, after he had SERVED. Brown has his "service" revolve around HIS schedule. it's a scary message, IMO, to put out there. I'm just explaining my rationale for choosing the option "or are the two somehow different enough that they cannot be compared?" from your OP. Whether other people don't know that or don't care about that didn't factor into MY rationale for my choice. And I still say may people take away more from this. The vast majority of my friends are non-lawyers and they all recognize from reading the news that Michael Vick was facing some very serious federal charges related to organized crime that are just not present in the Chris Brown case -- and it was THOSE charges that led to the deal he took and the sentence he received. As for this being a scary message to put out there -- no one entity put this "message" out there. I'd also venture to say it's more of an interpretation of two unrelated events over a message, though. Our courts don't collude together and weight the facts of one person's case against the facts of a completely and totally unrelated case -- with good reason. I agree with those who say that the penalties for domestic violence aren't harsh enough (and that the penalties for animal abuse aren't harsh enough either)... but Vick's case wasn't really all about the dogs as the media portrayed it. Message edited 2009-08-27 14:18:00.420000. |
|
Posted 8/27/09 2:17 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? This topic is misleading. The Brown Vs Vick really got me excited. |
|
Posted 8/27/09 2:20 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? Posted by Kara As for this being a scary message to put out there -- no one entity put this "message" out there. I'd also venture to say it's more of an interpretation of two unrelated events over a message, though. Our courts don't collude together and weight the facts of one person's case against the facts of a completely and totally unrelated case -- with good reason. this is not what I meant to imply in any way, shape or form. I just wanted to put that out there. I am not thinking about it as a "legal" person but as a layperson. you are exactly right. its the interpretation by the general public that I think is scary. perhaps that would have been better to say than "message". our courts sometimes can't even work together...let alone collude
|
Posted 8/27/09 2:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? Posted by MeNBobs Hopefully the backlash against Brown will be so big that he won't have any work to work around. I will never buy anything that will help further his career, never watch a show or movie he is in and if I hear his song on a radio station they will get an email from me. If enough people do this the only time we will ever have to see his face again is on a show on VH-1 in 2045 called "Whatever happened to...." I hear you and agree with you! But don't you know, he's a changed man! Show Chris some love! I just don't get that song- why was it even written? |
|
Posted 8/27/09 2:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? I don't think you can compare the two. |
|
Posted 8/27/09 3:09 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? Michael Vick did not just run a dog fighting ring, and abuse animals. Message edited 2009-08-27 15:17:48.353000. |
|
Posted 8/27/09 3:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? I see the point you're trying to make here, but as some previous posters mentioned I really think it's hard to compare the two. Personally speaking, I think they are both horrible people and they both committed heinous crimes. |
|
Posted 8/27/09 3:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? I think the law made an example of Michael Vick which is why he was sentenced to as much jail time as he was. If you look into it, his cohorts didn't even receive as stiff of sentences. |
|
Posted 8/27/09 4:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? I think in general that animal abusers are usually given a slap on the wrist so I am THRILLED that Vick got the punishment he did |
|
Posted 8/27/09 6:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? Posted by eroxgirl Interesting question. I think Chris Brown is worse. Not to get the animal lovers up in arms, but people - human beings - should always come first, which makes Chris Brown's crime the bigger offense. By the same token, how can we blame Michael Vick for his cruelty to animals when the Chris Browns of the world treat people the way they do? If you can't treat the woman you love with basic decency how in the he l l can you expect someone to treat an animal properly. i have to agree with this. as much as i am an animal lover, i think what Chris Brown did was worse. |
|
Posted 8/27/09 8:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? Very interesting. |
|
Posted 8/27/09 9:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? Posted by MrsList Posted by glinda-goodwitch While an animal can cause more damage with its teeth, I still feel like animals are more defenseless than humans. You can repeatedly abuse an animal and they have no recourse. At least a person can choose to go to the police, file charges, and leave on their own will (unless kept hostage, which is not the case with most domestic abuse). BOTH forms of abuse are horrible and I'm sure it is so hard for a woman to leave this type of situation. But in most causes she has the ability to leave and fight back. An animal doesn't. Very well said and exactly what I was thinking. ITA |
|
Posted 8/27/09 11:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? Posted by glinda-goodwitch While an animal can cause more damage with its teeth, I still feel like animals are more defenseless than humans. You can repeatedly abuse an animal and they have no recourse. At least a person can choose to go to the police, file charges, and leave on their own will (unless kept hostage, which is not the case with most domestic abuse). BOTH forms of abuse are horrible and I'm sure it is so hard for a woman to leave this type of situation. But in most causes she has the ability to leave and fight back. An animal doesn't. I agree 100% Beth |
|
Posted 8/28/09 9:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? They are both horrible people. I agree that Chris Brown should have gotten a harsher sentence. However, I think he didn't because it was a first time offense and he plead guilty. |
|
Posted 8/28/09 10:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil? Posted by MAC222 Michael Vick did not just run a dog fighting ring, and abuse animals. He murdered them. He drowned them, shot them with guns at point blank range, hung them with nooses from trees, electrocuted them and buried the bodies. It is so far beyond just being called violent, it is psychotic. There were over 64 dogs recovered, and something like 15-20 bodies found. I don't know why I look at the Chris Brown situation so differently...Rihanna stayed with him after he did it, and that didn't help me feel differently...either way, NEITHER sentence is fair, and celebs get away with way more than your average joe...but that's life... Thank you, I kept reading that he abused them and wondered when someone would bring up that they murdered the underperformers and losers of the fights too. Consider that one pit bull, Ginger, a female, showed up at DogTown, a no-kill shelter. When they examined her, they found she had no teeth. None, at all. They tested her for disease. You know why she didn't have teeth? Because after she was done in the ring, she was such a good fighter that they decided to breed her. But what happens when a championship fighting dog gets mounted by another? She's gonna kill them, probably, right? So they REMOVED ALL OF HER TEETH. SURGICALLY. Which means some kind of veterinary professional was in on all of this. Then they strapped her to a RAPE RACK and ran a parade of other champion male dogs to increase their chances. These kinds of things went on constantly, for years and years. His friends were involved, professionals, they painted their buildings black and blacked out the windows so helicopters couldn't see the fights going on at night. This was so much more than a case of abuse. Dogs don't have a voice, so we have to speak for them. They need advocates. Battered persons do too, but they can explain, they can defend, they can act. I am glad Vick got as stiff a penalty as he did, and even more glad that so much light has been shed on these situations. And even happier that very few of the dogs left at his compound were euthanized. A very very smart law official gave them a chance to be rehabilitated. A majority of them are now placed in their forever homes, away from the horror of their previous lives. As far as Chris Brown goes, he's a disgusting excuse for a human being also. I don't think he got enough for what he did, and it shouldn't matter how willing or unwilling the victim was in the proceedings. The punishment should not only encompass what he DID but ensure that even if he's not regretful of his actions, he will be regretful of future punishments if he should try it again. I don't think he's learned his lesson, there haven't been many real repercussions. I think it's a travesty and sending a terrible message. |
|
Posted 8/28/09 11:37 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chris Brown Wasn't Allow To Participate In Michael Jackson Tribute During 2009 BET Awards | GossipQueen | 6/29/09 | 13 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| Chris Brown Goes Clubbing After Court Hearing | GossipQueen | 8/27/09 | 2 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| Chad Michael Murray and his fiancee Kenzie Dalton | GossipQueen | 8/27/09 | 6 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| Great lipstick colors for fair skin and brown hair? | Calla | 8/27/09 | 5 | Fashion & Beauty! |
| Chris Brown and Rihanna | GossipQueen | 5/8/08 | 4 | Celebrities & Entertainment |
| Rihanna & Chris Brown | GossipQueen | 3/3/08 | 1 | Celebrities & Entertainment |



and educated, can use what he sees as an everyday person to deduce that we as a people punish animal abusers more harshly than we do spousal abusers.







? That doesn't seem just either. 





