Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil?
Posted 8/27/2009 2:17:05 PM by Kara


Posted by Ophelia


I get all of this.

I guess it's just the general idea. most people don't know (or care) about anything you pointed out (doesn't make it any less relevant....it's just most people don't have a need to know this stuff, you know)

so someone like my husband...who is relatively smart Chat Icon and educated, can use what he sees as an everyday person to deduce that we as a people punish animal abusers more harshly than we do spousal abusers.

I guess that is my point. the general sentiment that is conveys...more than the legal/technical stuff that people "in the know" know, you know? Chat Icon Chat Icon

what you take from this is :Michael Vick abuses animals and is involved in dog fighting and does hard time.

Chris Brown beats, chokes, and threatens his girl friends life and will have to remove graffitti from the walls of Va. when he's not on tour, making movies, promoting an album, or otherwise living a fabu life.

and people got mad that Vick was allowed to play football once he was finished?????? up in arms about that, after he had SERVED.

Brown has his "service" revolve around HIS schedule.

it's a scary message, IMO, to put out there.



I'm just explaining my rationale for choosing the option "or are the two somehow different enough that they cannot be compared?" from your OP. Whether other people don't know that or don't care about that didn't factor into MY rationale for my choice.

And I still say may people take away more from this. The vast majority of my friends are non-lawyers and they all recognize from reading the news that Michael Vick was facing some very serious federal charges related to organized crime that are just not present in the Chris Brown case -- and it was THOSE charges that led to the deal he took and the sentence he received.

As for this being a scary message to put out there -- no one entity put this "message" out there. I'd also venture to say it's more of an interpretation of two unrelated events over a message, though. Our courts don't collude together and weight the facts of one person's case against the facts of a completely and totally unrelated case -- with good reason.

I agree with those who say that the penalties for domestic violence aren't harsh enough (and that the penalties for animal abuse aren't harsh enough either)... but Vick's case wasn't really all about the dogs as the media portrayed it.
Print Post      Close Window