Can you hold a child too much?

Forum Opinion Poll
Yes, let her cry it out if you know that she is only crying to be held. 4 4.82%
Yes, start to hold her less each time she is awake 13 15.66%
No, she is an infant and she needs her mother 61 73.49%
Either way she will grow out of it, don't change anything 5 6.02%
 

Vote in this poll

View poll

Can you hold your child too much?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

myasmommy
LIF Zygote

Member since 10/09

20 total posts

Name:
Sue

Can you hold your child too much?

I am curious to see how everyone feels about holding your child. Is there such thing as spoiling a newborn?
Here is a little background......
My DD was 5 weeks premature and ended up staying in NICU for 1 week. During that time, I would hold her the entire time I was with her (usually between 6 to 8 hours). Once she came home I continued to hold her all the time. Now she is 8 weeks old. She only wants to be held and cries when she is not in my arms. When she is asleep, she has to be on me. If I move her to the bassinet or swing she will wake up with in 1/2 hour of putting her down.
I have been told that she is an infant and she feel secure and she will grow out of it. I have also heard that she is getting too use to being held and will depend on me to fall asleep.
PLEASE HELP!!!!

Message edited 2009-10-28 14:13:18.820000.

Posted 10/28/09 2:11 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Angel321
...

Member since 4/08

15553 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold you child too much?

you cannot spoil a newborn. plain & simple.

think of it this way - she was in you for 9 months - that's 24/7 companionship. she was being rocked, hearing you talk, feeling you eat, move, etc...

the second she came out - she was already being held less - because you're not holding her 24/7.

Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 2:14 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

It's tough...they say you can't spoil your newborn but at the same time, I think you can start a habit.

Posted 10/28/09 2:16 PM
 

babybugsmum
THEIR UNBREAKABLE BOND

Member since 8/07

1962 total posts

Name:
gemma

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

not in my opinion love every minute of your bonding time together and when you need 2 hands put them in the Byorn and carry on Chat Icon

they grow up so very fast and then they dont want you to hold them Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 2:17 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

She is only 8 weeks- hold her as much as she needs and wants. I read somewhere that babies who are held a lot sleep better/longer. This was true of my DD. And as much as I held her, now she's 2.5 and hates to be cuddled. I miss those days. Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 2:18 PM
 

Michmouse
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1260 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

I do not think you can hold and cuddle your newborn too much- It is critical at this stage of development that your DD feel safe! I completely believe in the attachment parenting philosophy...wearing the baby is a great way to be attached and hands free.

I copied and pasted this explanation for you.Chat Icon

Attachment parenting, a phrase coined by pediatrician William Sears,[1] is a parenting philosophy based on the principles of the attachment theory in developmental psychology. According to attachment theory, the child forms a strong emotional bond with caregivers during childhood with lifelong consequences. Sensitive and emotionally available parenting helps the child to form a secure attachment style which fosters a child's socio-emotional development and well being. Less sensitive and emotionally available parenting or neglect of the child's needs may result in insecure forms of attachment style, which is a risk factor for many mental health problems. In extreme and rare conditions the child may not form an attachment at all and may suffer from reactive attachment disorder as defined in DSM-IV and ICD-10. Principles of attachment parenting aim to increase development of child's secure attachment and decrease insecure attachment.

Message edited 2009-10-28 14:23:15.010000.

Posted 10/28/09 2:22 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

I think you can ABSOLUTELY spoil a newborn. The baby is learning every single second of the day - I will never understand the idea that you can't get them accustomed to something before X months old .....-

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......

Call me a cold hearted b*tch - but at SOME point you're going to have to put that baby down, so would you rather do it after you got them 'used to' being held for 6 months ?? Personally I think it's better to do it while EVERYTHING is new to them -

Ultimately it's up to you and what you are comfortable with.

Everyone is going to have a different opinion and tell you what you 'should' or shouldn't do .......

Posted 10/28/09 2:24 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

I do not buy into attachment parenting, however I also don't think you can spoil a newborn and I would continue to hold her as much as she wants as long as it is not interfering with her safety (i.e. you falling asleep holding her would be interfering with her safety IMO).

I miss those days when DD would sleep on my chest for 2 hoursChat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 2:26 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by MarisaK

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......




I read in at least one parenting book (that was written by a pediatrician) that habits aren't formed for the first six months.

Posted 10/28/09 2:26 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

I don't believe you can spoil a newborn.

There does come a time when you should probably let the baby cry for a minute or a few minutes before you pick her up, but I don't think that time is within the first 3 months.

Posted 10/28/09 2:29 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by MrsProfessor

Posted by MarisaK

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......




I read in at least one parenting book (that was written by a pediatrician) that habits aren't formed for the first six months.



I'm not saying you're wrong - I've read the same thing a few times - I just don't buy it. I don't care what the author's credentials are - IMO it's not something that's cut and dry -
Like X antibiotic cures Y - KWIM?
How do you prove that theory ??
My son had 'habits' WELL before he turned 6 months old -

Posted 10/28/09 2:31 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by MrsProfessor

Posted by MarisaK

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......




I read in at least one parenting book (that was written by a pediatrician) that habits aren't formed for the first six months.



I'm not saying you're wrong - I've read the same thing a few times - I just don't buy it. I don't care what the author's credentials are - IMO it's not something that's cut and dry -
Like X antibiotic cures Y - KWIM?
How do you prove that theory ??
My son had 'habits' WELL before he turned 6 months old -



I get what you are saying-that's interesting. I guess then I would say even if you can spoil a newborn, I think it's okay because they need it in the early stages.

Posted 10/28/09 2:36 PM
 

MrsGmomof3
...

Member since 6/08

3290 total posts

Name:
Irrelevant

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

You absolutely CANNOT "spoil" a newborn.

Food spoils.... children cannot Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 2:37 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by MrsGmomof3

You absolutely CANNOT "spoil" a newborn.

Food spoils.... children cannot Chat Icon




Children certainly can-I agree not newborns but at some point children certainly can become spoiled.

Posted 10/28/09 2:38 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

s a twin Mom who went back to work at 7 weeks PP I can tell you my kids were not held all the time. They were NICU babies and for the first couple of weeks of their lives we did a lot of skin to skin holding, but we also go them used to their swings and bouncies. They can now play independently for an hour at a time. They sleep reasonably well-though that took me a long time because I'm a softyChat Icon Everyone tells me what happy babies I have so I guess we did something rightChat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 2:40 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by MrsProfessor

Posted by MarisaK

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......




I read in at least one parenting book (that was written by a pediatrician) that habits aren't formed for the first six months.



I'm not saying you're wrong - I've read the same thing a few times - I just don't buy it. I don't care what the author's credentials are - IMO it's not something that's cut and dry -
Like X antibiotic cures Y - KWIM?
How do you prove that theory ??
My son had 'habits' WELL before he turned 6 months old -



I get what you are saying-that's interesting. I guess then I would say even if you can spoil a newborn, I think it's okay because they need it in the early stages.



Chat Icon Which is why I think it's completely a matter of parenting style and comfort level .......*I* didn't feel that my son NEEDED to be with me constantly or need to be held constantly. A lot of people disagreed with me -

I always held him, talked to him, comforted him when he WAS fussing or upset - but I made a vey conscious effort to 'leave him alone' for periods of time when he was content to just chill and look around .......and I forced other people do it as well. (Needless to say, I got a lot of Chat Icon but that is what *I* felt was important for him)

Posted 10/28/09 2:42 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Hold her as much as she needs and as much as you like. You CANNOT spoil a newborn. They need to be held a lot to develop bonds, security, and feel soothed. Don't let anyone tell you different, and they will, but there is nothing wrong with holding your newborn/infant a lot in those early months. Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 2:45 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by MarisaK

I think you can ABSOLUTELY spoil a newborn. The baby is learning every single second of the day - I will never understand the idea that you can't get them accustomed to something before X months old .....-

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......

Call me a cold hearted b*tch - but at SOME point you're going to have to put that baby down, so would you rather do it after you got them 'used to' being held for 6 months ?? Personally I think it's better to do it while EVERYTHING is new to them -

Ultimately it's up to you and what you are comfortable with.

Everyone is going to have a different opinion and tell you what you 'should' or shouldn't do .......



You CANNOT in any way spoil a newborn. They NEED to be held A LOT. That's how they develop trust and security and bonds. To put a baby down because you don't feel like holding them is cruel and selfish IMO..........they don't have the tools to self soothe on their own and they need you to hold them and snuggle them and make them feel secure. I had to hold my DD A LOT in the those early months, more so when she wanted to fall asleep, but it's what she needed. NO bad habits were formed and she wasn't spoiled by my holding her a lot. Within a few months she learned to put herself to sleep and she was fine on her own but as a new baby in this world........she needed a lot of cuddling time like most new babies do. EVERY book, website, and doctor will tell you the same.

Message edited 2009-10-28 14:51:39.263000.

Posted 10/28/09 2:49 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by Hofstra26

Hold her as much as she needs and as much as you like. You CANNOT spoil a newborn. They need to be held a lot to develop bonds, security, and feel soothed. Don't let anyone tell you different, and they will, but there is nothing wrong with holding your newborn/infant a lot in those early months. Chat Icon



this is my opinion too. i wouldnt let a newborn cry it out--they arent old enough to make associations and only know their needs arent being met.

Posted 10/28/09 2:49 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by MrsProfessor

Posted by MarisaK

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......




I read in at least one parenting book (that was written by a pediatrician) that habits aren't formed for the first six months.



I'm not saying you're wrong - I've read the same thing a few times - I just don't buy it. I don't care what the author's credentials are - IMO it's not something that's cut and dry -
Like X antibiotic cures Y - KWIM?
How do you prove that theory ??
My son had 'habits' WELL before he turned 6 months old -



I get what you are saying-that's interesting. I guess then I would say even if you can spoil a newborn, I think it's okay because they need it in the early stages.



Chat Icon Which is why I think it's completely a matter of parenting style and comfort level .......*I* didn't feel that my son NEEDED to be with me constantly or need to be held constantly. A lot of people disagreed with me -

I always held him, talked to him, comforted him when he WAS fussing or upset - but I made a vey conscious effort to 'leave him alone' for periods of time when he was content to just chill and look around .......and I forced other people do it as well. (Needless to say, I got a lot of Chat Icon but that is what *I* felt was important for him)



I agree-it's all about your comfort level.

I also don't think there is anything wrong with letting sleeping babies lie-i.e. if he's content to just hang out then let him be.

I found myself wanting to pick up DD even when she was content just because I needed it-she was fine doing her own thing. I made an effort to let her be so she could get comfortable in her own skin-as long as she wasn't crying/fussing.

Posted 10/28/09 2:50 PM
 

KangaMom
...

Member since 1/06

4593 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Never... Hold and or Wear in a Sling and Enjoy Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 2:53 PM
 

MarisaK
HELLO Manolo !!

Member since 5/06

14562 total posts

Name:
Marisa

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by MarisaK

I think you can ABSOLUTELY spoil a newborn. The baby is learning every single second of the day - I will never understand the idea that you can't get them accustomed to something before X months old .....-

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......

Call me a cold hearted b*tch - but at SOME point you're going to have to put that baby down, so would you rather do it after you got them 'used to' being held for 6 months ?? Personally I think it's better to do it while EVERYTHING is new to them -

Ultimately it's up to you and what you are comfortable with.

Everyone is going to have a different opinion and tell you what you 'should' or shouldn't do .......



You CANNOT in any way spoil a newborn. They NEED to be help A LOT. That's how they develop trust and security and bonds. To put a baby down because you don't feel like holding them is cruel and selfish IMO..........they don't have the tools to self soothe on their own and they need you to hold them and snuggle them and make them feel secure. I had to hold my DD A LOT in the those early months, more so when she wanted to fall asleep, but it's what she needed. NO bad habits were formed and she wasn't spoiled by my holding her a lot. Within a few months she learned to put herself to sleep and she was fine on her own but as a new baby in this world........she needed a lot of cuddling time like most new babies do. EVERY book, website, and doctor will tell you the same.



Um, who said I put him down b/c I 'didn't feel like holding him' - WHO doesn't feel like holding a new baby ???
I put him down b/c I thought it was improtant for him to learn early that I couldn't hold him constantly -
I am not saying a newborn should be left to CIO - but I DON'T agree that a newborn MUST be held constantly -

And EVERY baby book website and Doctore will NOT tell you the same -

Posted 10/28/09 2:53 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by MrsProfessor

Posted by MarisaK

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......




I read in at least one parenting book (that was written by a pediatrician) that habits aren't formed for the first six months.



I'm not saying you're wrong - I've read the same thing a few times - I just don't buy it. I don't care what the author's credentials are - IMO it's not something that's cut and dry -
Like X antibiotic cures Y - KWIM?
How do you prove that theory ??
My son had 'habits' WELL before he turned 6 months old -



I get what you are saying-that's interesting. I guess then I would say even if you can spoil a newborn, I think it's okay because they need it in the early stages.



Chat Icon Which is why I think it's completely a matter of parenting style and comfort level .......*I* didn't feel that my son NEEDED to be with me constantly or need to be held constantly. A lot of people disagreed with me -

I always held him, talked to him, comforted him when he WAS fussing or upset - but I made a vey conscious effort to 'leave him alone' for periods of time when he was content to just chill and look around .......and I forced other people do it as well. (Needless to say, I got a lot of Chat Icon but that is what *I* felt was important for him)



I agree-it's all about your comfort level.

I also don't think there is anything wrong with letting sleeping babies lie-i.e. if he's content to just hang out then let him be.

I found myself wanting to pick up DD even when she was content just because I needed it-she was fine doing her own thing. I made an effort to let her be so she could get comfortable in her own skin-as long as she wasn't crying/fussing.



I think there is a difference if they are content or upset and fussing so I do agree with you on that point. My DD was able to chill by herself and play but to fall asleep and when she was fussy all she ever wanted was to be held and I think that's normal. I didn't hold her just to hold her, I left her alone if she was content and now at 13 months she's independent and plays on her own and has been for months. But again, I did hold her a lot and it's what she needed at that time in her life. Chat Icon

Posted 10/28/09 2:54 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by MarisaK

I think you can ABSOLUTELY spoil a newborn. The baby is learning every single second of the day - I will never understand the idea that you can't get them accustomed to something before X months old .....-

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......

Call me a cold hearted b*tch - but at SOME point you're going to have to put that baby down, so would you rather do it after you got them 'used to' being held for 6 months ?? Personally I think it's better to do it while EVERYTHING is new to them -

Ultimately it's up to you and what you are comfortable with.

Everyone is going to have a different opinion and tell you what you 'should' or shouldn't do .......



You CANNOT in any way spoil a newborn. They NEED to be help A LOT. That's how they develop trust and security and bonds. To put a baby down because you don't feel like holding them is cruel and selfish IMO..........they don't have the tools to self soothe on their own and they need you to hold them and snuggle them and make them feel secure. I had to hold my DD A LOT in the those early months, more so when she wanted to fall asleep, but it's what she needed. NO bad habits were formed and she wasn't spoiled by my holding her a lot. Within a few months she learned to put herself to sleep and she was fine on her own but as a new baby in this world........she needed a lot of cuddling time like most new babies do. EVERY book, website, and doctor will tell you the same.




I agree, but if you read some of her subsequent posts I think we are misunderstanding the poster.

She's not saying to let a fussing baby CIO nor is she saying that we shouldn't have lots of cuddle time with our DC.

She is saying when they are not fussing, we should make an effort to put the baby down and let them just be so that we don't develop a need to be held all the time.

Very different IMO and not off the mark.

Posted 10/28/09 2:54 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Can you hold your child too much?

Posted by MarisaK

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by MarisaK

I think you can ABSOLUTELY spoil a newborn. The baby is learning every single second of the day - I will never understand the idea that you can't get them accustomed to something before X months old .....-

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......

Call me a cold hearted b*tch - but at SOME point you're going to have to put that baby down, so would you rather do it after you got them 'used to' being held for 6 months ?? Personally I think it's better to do it while EVERYTHING is new to them -

Ultimately it's up to you and what you are comfortable with.

Everyone is going to have a different opinion and tell you what you 'should' or shouldn't do .......



You CANNOT in any way spoil a newborn. They NEED to be help A LOT. That's how they develop trust and security and bonds. To put a baby down because you don't feel like holding them is cruel and selfish IMO..........they don't have the tools to self soothe on their own and they need you to hold them and snuggle them and make them feel secure. I had to hold my DD A LOT in the those early months, more so when she wanted to fall asleep, but it's what she needed. NO bad habits were formed and she wasn't spoiled by my holding her a lot. Within a few months she learned to put herself to sleep and she was fine on her own but as a new baby in this world........she needed a lot of cuddling time like most new babies do. EVERY book, website, and doctor will tell you the same.



Um, who said I put him down b/c I 'didn't feel like holding him' - WHO doesn't feel like holding a new baby ???
I put him down b/c I thought it was improtant for him to learn early that I couldn't hold him constantly -
I am not saying a newborn should be left to CIO - but I DON'T agree that a newborn MUST be held constantly -

And EVERY baby book website and Doctore will NOT tell you the same -



If they are content of course it makes sense to leave them be.......if they are upset, having trouble falling asleep, fussy, crying etc. you should be holding them and in those instances you can't hold them too much. And yes......any book and ped. will tell you that. Newborns don't have the tools to self soothe. I should have been clearer in my post. Sorry. Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-10-28 14:56:30.633000.

Posted 10/28/09 2:55 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spinoff to my other post: Did anyone hold their child back? bicosi 1/9/08 4 Parenting
Link to Article from Child Magazine: 10 Best US Fertility Centers CathyB 7/9/05 0 TTC
Would you let your child... KaRiSsA 6/27/05 25 Families Helping Families ™
Cost of child care Woodsy 6/21/05 5 Parenting
Traveling with a small child justme1 5/23/05 3 Travel & Vacations
was your first child (pregnancy) (w/ POLL) neenie 5/19/05 30 Families Helping Families ™