Re: Can you hold your child too much?
Posted 10/28/2009 2:50:17 PM by CrankyPants


Posted by MarisaK


Posted by CrankyPants


Posted by MarisaK


Posted by MrsProfessor


Posted by MarisaK

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......




I read in at least one parenting book (that was written by a pediatrician) that habits aren't formed for the first six months.



I'm not saying you're wrong - I've read the same thing a few times - I just don't buy it. I don't care what the author's credentials are - IMO it's not something that's cut and dry -
Like X antibiotic cures Y - KWIM?
How do you prove that theory ??
My son had 'habits' WELL before he turned 6 months old -



I get what you are saying-that's interesting. I guess then I would say even if you can spoil a newborn, I think it's okay because they need it in the early stages.



Chat Icon Which is why I think it's completely a matter of parenting style and comfort level .......*I* didn't feel that my son NEEDED to be with me constantly or need to be held constantly. A lot of people disagreed with me -

I always held him, talked to him, comforted him when he WAS fussing or upset - but I made a vey conscious effort to 'leave him alone' for periods of time when he was content to just chill and look around .......and I forced other people do it as well. (Needless to say, I got a lot of Chat Icon but that is what *I* felt was important for him)



I agree-it's all about your comfort level.

I also don't think there is anything wrong with letting sleeping babies lie-i.e. if he's content to just hang out then let him be.

I found myself wanting to pick up DD even when she was content just because I needed it-she was fine doing her own thing. I made an effort to let her be so she could get comfortable in her own skin-as long as she wasn't crying/fussing.
Print Post      Close Window