Re: Can you hold your child too much?
Posted 10/28/2009 2:54:23 PM by CrankyPants


Posted by Hofstra26


Posted by MarisaK

I think you can ABSOLUTELY spoil a newborn. The baby is learning every single second of the day - I will never understand the idea that you can't get them accustomed to something before X months old .....-

I think the attitude of holding them vs. NOT holding them is more of a comforting/nurturing thing rather than a scientific thing - Some people feel that it's cruel to leave them 'alone' since they've been so close to you (inside you) for so long .......

Call me a cold hearted b*tch - but at SOME point you're going to have to put that baby down, so would you rather do it after you got them 'used to' being held for 6 months ?? Personally I think it's better to do it while EVERYTHING is new to them -

Ultimately it's up to you and what you are comfortable with.

Everyone is going to have a different opinion and tell you what you 'should' or shouldn't do .......



You CANNOT in any way spoil a newborn. They NEED to be help A LOT. That's how they develop trust and security and bonds. To put a baby down because you don't feel like holding them is cruel and selfish IMO..........they don't have the tools to self soothe on their own and they need you to hold them and snuggle them and make them feel secure. I had to hold my DD A LOT in the those early months, more so when she wanted to fall asleep, but it's what she needed. NO bad habits were formed and she wasn't spoiled by my holding her a lot. Within a few months she learned to put herself to sleep and she was fine on her own but as a new baby in this world........she needed a lot of cuddling time like most new babies do. EVERY book, website, and doctor will tell you the same.




I agree, but if you read some of her subsequent posts I think we are misunderstanding the poster.

She's not saying to let a fussing baby CIO nor is she saying that we shouldn't have lots of cuddle time with our DC.

She is saying when they are not fussing, we should make an effort to put the baby down and let them just be so that we don't develop a need to be held all the time.

Very different IMO and not off the mark.
Print Post      Close Window