Bilingual Babies ...

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Bilingual Babies ...

Do they really develop language late, because of this?

DH speaks to the baby in one language, and I'm with him most of the day and I speak to him in English. I'm already so confused. Are we doing more harm than good?

Posted 7/10/10 10:02 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

There are a million studies out there all pointing to the huge advantage of introducing a second, even third, language from infancy.

IMO, you cannot go wrong with this. Babies are sponges & will absorb anything & everything they can. That's why they never want to sleep Chat Icon

As for "developing language" late, they are developing 2 languages at the same time. They take their time to process the languages but, you increase their knowlege.

Posted 7/10/10 10:17 AM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

DH speaks hebrew to our kids, while I speak english only. Did Alex demonstrate a small delay? yes. But once she caught up it was an absolute EXPLOSION - and now, she is WAY beyond her peers with her language and vocabulary skills.

All the research demonstrates that the earlier you expose your babies to other languages, the better it is for their development. So, yes, there will likely be a small delay, but in the longrun there's no developmental impact.

Posted 7/10/10 10:18 AM
 

pnbplus1
Family

Member since 5/09

5751 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

Absolutely not!!! You are giving your child a wonderful gift. I was raised in a bilingual home - actually I didn't learn English until I started Kindergarten (no Pre-K for me). I knew my numbers and letters but that's it. I am an Ivy League graduate and have a doctorate. We too are raising our child bilingually, we actually speak more Spanish to him than English bc we are afraid that he won't learn Spanish.

Sometimes learning 2 languages at once can cause a slight delay, but that's expected since you need to form connections for so many more words. But once language clicks, the child will be just fine. It's not a speech and language delay in a clinical sense, it just might take a tiny bit longer for baby to sort it all out.

Keep going and don't get discouraged. I am forever thankful that I am bilingual as it has afforded me so many opportunities, moreso than if I was a monolingual.

Oh and for future reference if your child ever starts saying they don't want to speak their second language, stay strong and keep going. When I was about 7 I told my parents that I didn't want to speak Spanish - I had a private tutor on saturdays so that I could read and write it too and I hated it - but my mom didn't listen and I still went. I am forever thankful she didn't let me get my way.

Posted 7/10/10 10:27 AM
 

babycakes18
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

1281 total posts

Name:
Dani

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

DD is almost seven months. I speak to her in Spanish when we are home alone. When DH and I are together we speak to her in english. My mother watches her while i work and speaks to her in spanish. My MIL only speaks to her in Greek.

Is she going to be confused as h ell? Probably! But I want her exposed to as many languages as possible. If it takes her a while to process it all...i'm not too worried about it. Spanish was my first language and I didn't learn english until pre-school.

I would like to get her a private tutor when she is older for her spanish.

i wouldn't worry about it!!!

Posted 7/10/10 10:36 AM
 

Chai77
Brighter days ahead

Member since 4/07

7364 total posts

Name:

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

I think kids who are exposed to more than one language at such a young age are more likely to have a delay in expressive language. I personally try to have my DS only exposed to English only because I do not want to confuse him at all as he is just starting to talk.

Posted 7/10/10 10:43 AM
 

CaMacho
Sisters :)

Member since 7/06

15112 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

I'm not worried about it at all!

MIL only speaks to DD in spanish (she watches her full time) and DH and I speak to her in english. She imitates a lot now and doesn't seem to have any trouble understanding either language so far (she's 11 months).

I'm excited that DD will be bilingual and will learn now b/c I know how hard it is to learn another language as an adult!

Posted 7/10/10 10:51 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

Posted by Chai77

I think kids who are exposed to more than one language at such a young age are more likely to have a delay in expressive language. I personally try to have my DS only exposed to English only because I do not want to confuse him at all as he is just starting to talk.



Can you FM anything you've read on this, or why you think this way? Personally I've always felt this way too. I was brought up bilingual and I always remember being confused in my first years at school. DH and his family kind of pressured me into it, but then all the psych research says its beneficial.

I just haven't really experienced it for myself, or maybe? I don't know I was always in advanced classes and scored high on everything early age. It just always remember being frustrated with language. I had no problem reading though I read in 3 languages by 1st grade. Maybe more on a social level its slowing kids down?

Any more thoughts on this?

Posted 7/10/10 11:07 AM
 

anonymoususer
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

3393 total posts

Name:

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

as a speech therapist, speaking multiple languages to your child you are only doing good

the 'delay' is because they are sorting out both languages; realizing that there are 2 words for each item and putting together who speaks what language

believe me, they will impress you when they do start talking

Posted 7/10/10 11:21 AM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

I am also a speech-language pathologist and we are teaching Loey both Spanish and English.

I am fully confident that he will have expressive and receptive language skills on par with his peers as he enters school.

Any "delays" he might have, IMO, are insignificant when compared with the long-term benefits.

Posted 7/10/10 11:25 AM
 

carissa1643
I LOVE my sons! :)

Member since 5/09

5283 total posts

Name:
Carissa

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

Posted by maybeamommy

I am also a speech-language pathologist and we are teaching Loey both Spanish and English.

I am fully confident that he will have expressive and receptive language skills on par with his peers as he enters school.

Any "delays" he might have, IMO, are insignificant when compared with the long-term benefits.



Oh this is good to know! I have to keep encouraging DH to speak Greek to the baby and maybe I can learn too! Chat Icon

Posted 7/10/10 11:41 AM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

here is something from a publication that I read. It's not an actual research article but there are plenty of references that you can look up to read more...

Bilingualism: Consequences for Language, Cognition, Development, and the Brain

and this is a "parent-friendly" link about learning two languages

Posted 7/10/10 11:47 AM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

Posted by maybeamommy

here is something from a publication that I read. It's not an actual research article but there are plenty of references that you can look up to read more...

Bilingualism: Consequences for Language, Cognition, Development, and the Brain

and this is a "parent-friendly" link about learning two languages



Thank you so much!

Posted 7/10/10 11:50 AM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

Posted by momytobein2010

Posted by maybeamommy

here is something from a publication that I read. It's not an actual research article but there are plenty of references that you can look up to read more...

Bilingualism: Consequences for Language, Cognition, Development, and the Brain

and this is a "parent-friendly" link about learning two languages



Thank you so much!



No problem.

I'm trying to look for some actual research articles where I can download the PDFs and send them to you, but since this is kind of an "old" topic, it's hard to find anything that's been published in the last five years that would be really extensive - KWIM?

Posted 7/10/10 11:54 AM
 

Momma2Be
Mommy of an angel

Member since 10/09

5911 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

I was raised bilingual as well, spoke only Greek at home and only started speaking English when I was first enrolled in nursery school. By the time I was in kindergarten, I was all caught up with my English-speaking peers. I always did well in reading and was in AP and honors English growing up so it did not negatively affect me in any way.

I am teaching DS Greek now as well. My mother is Korean and she didn't speak to me in Korean because she thought 3 languages would be too confusing and she thought that she would be able to teach it to us when we got a little bit older. Needless to say, my brother and I never learned to speak Korean because it's too difficult, and it has always been a regret of hers. I don't plan on making the same mistake with DS.

Posted 7/10/10 12:46 PM
 

Superkat
More a stranger than a friend

Member since 5/06

9730 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

My son has been learning Chinese and English. He didn't speak as much or as quickly as other boys his age but in the past few months, he has been learning like crazy! The long term benefits of being bi-lingual outweigh the language delay by far.

Posted 7/10/10 1:19 PM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

I spoke Hungarian before I spoke English, and then quickly learned Russian after that..my parents swear that I was a much faster learner of any language and at a much young age bc I was exposed to so many languages...

Posted 7/10/10 1:33 PM
 

WNA01
my 2 boys

Member since 10/08

4240 total posts

Name:

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

i went to kindergarten speaking predominately italian -i was familiar wtih some english but not enough to get me thru a conversation.
i honestly cant remember it being that difficult. by 1st grade i was speaking 2 languages and knew when to speak them - italian to family and siblings - english to teaches and friends.

i speak italian to ds all the time - even when dh is around (dh doesnt speak it but understands alot) dh speaks to him in english.

If hes delayed a bit thats ok bc in the end he will know 2 languages. im not concerned at all.

Posted 7/10/10 1:58 PM
 

munchkinfacemama
LOVE

Member since 11/07

15800 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

Posted by maybeamommy

I am also a speech-language pathologist and we are teaching Loey both Spanish and English.

I am fully confident that he will have expressive and receptive language skills on par with his peers as he enters school.

Any "delays" he might have, IMO, are insignificant when compared with the long-term benefits.



ITA with Hayley.

My ex's cousin was spoken to only in Spanish when she was a baby and when she learned english, her expressive and receptive language in both were incredible.

I wish we spoke a second language. I know some Yiddish and I try to speak to Sienna in Yiddish too, as do my parents. I would also like her to start Hebrew early. I think it is only a benefit later on!

Posted 7/10/10 2:09 PM
 

pnm1654
Mommy to 2 boys!

Member since 5/05

4565 total posts

Name:

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

We speak to our boys in 3 languages. Dh and I speak English, my family only in spanish and dh's family only in greek. My first son (he is 4.5) had no speech delay whatsoever and is conversational in english and spanish and somewhat in greek. Our 2nd son just turned two and while he did speak a bit after our first son, the ped said it was not a speech delay but the fact that our first son was just an early talker. Our 2nd son is not conversational yet in either of the 3 languages but understands everything in all 3 and has words from all 3.

Message edited 2010-07-10 19:02:44.940000.

Posted 7/10/10 2:48 PM
 

kms717
St Philomena Protect My Son

Member since 2/06

2747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

You are not doing any harm, it's great to expose your children to a second langauge early, but bilingual babies do tend to speak later.

Posted 7/10/10 3:11 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

Posted by Chai77

I think kids who are exposed to more than one language at such a young age are more likely to have a delay in expressive language. I personally try to have my DS only exposed to English only because I do not want to confuse him at all as he is just starting to talk.



Yes, they do have a *slight* delay, but it has absolutely no developmental impact, and the truth is, all the research demonstrates that it is actually more beneficial to them to learn other languages as infants.

Posted 7/10/10 3:15 PM
 

anonymoususer
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

3393 total posts

Name:

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

also, think back to middle school and high school-

the kids who already had 2 languages under their belts were able to learn spanish or french very easily compared to monolingual kids!


keep talking with as many languages as you know

baby will be more than fine!

Posted 7/10/10 4:57 PM
 

Chai77
Brighter days ahead

Member since 4/07

7364 total posts

Name:

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by Chai77

I think kids who are exposed to more than one language at such a young age are more likely to have a delay in expressive language. I personally try to have my DS only exposed to English only because I do not want to confuse him at all as he is just starting to talk.



Yes, they do have a *slight* delay, but it has absolutely no developmental impact, and the truth is, all the research demonstrates that it is actually more beneficial to them to learn other languages as infants.



I am a child psychologist and have worked with bilingual children on the preschool level. The delay can be more than slight for some children. Some children may have other learning or language issues (which I tend to believe they would have had anyway), but it can be complicated by the bilingual background (in terms of prognosis, language scores, ability to secure services for that child, etc). So, for some kids, I have seen a potential negative developmental impact.

The research I have read indicates that children with a bilingual background score higher on tests of cognitive flexibility, or code/set switching, which makes intuitive sense when considering the bilingual experience. That is the only potential positive outcome I am aware of in the literature.

Personally, I will not expose my DS to a language other than English. Even in a monolingual home, I feel that some parents are going out of their way to teach the infant or child a second or third language. I want my DS to get a firm footing in English before tackling a second language.

Posted 7/10/10 9:11 PM
 

wcs3504
my boys

Member since 2/06

2506 total posts

Name:
Wanda (formerly cw0904 on LIW)

Re: Bilingual Babies ...

I see nothing wrong with exposing children to more than one language. Me and my sister learned Spanish before English. We didn't learn English until we were in Kindergarten and we turned out just fine. Because of being fluent in Spanish and speaking French (my second major in college), I got the job that I have now.

Learning Spanish made it easier for me to learn French. I am also able to understand Italian and Portuguese because of it.

Not only is Xavier being taught Spanish (by me and my family) but I will start sign language in the next couple of weeks. The positives he may have in learning more than one language far out way the short term 'delay' that he may have.

Posted 7/10/10 10:35 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Bilingual babies -- does it lead to speech delay? bee 5/23/07 21 Parenting
I think we are all holding out for April/May babies CookiePuss 6/14/05 14 TTC
Dear God: out of the mouths of babies HarleyGirlFLA 6/12/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
People who keep on having babies with no college funds Janice 6/9/05 22 Families Helping Families ™
my 2 babies maybride2004 6/2/05 6 Pets
Babies and sunblock JennChris 6/1/05 12 Parenting