Being Sued

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

MK2010
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/10

401 total posts

Name:

Being Sued

My DH was in an accident two years ago. Basically both cars were at a red light and he went to make a left turn and the other car was going straight. The police came and my DH and the other driver both refused an ambulance and that is in the police report. There was minimal damage on the car. The airbags did not go off. The other driver was very belligerant and is suing us. He was 75 at the time of the accident and is now 77. He is claiming nerve damage, deterioration, athritis and loss of enjoyment of life. I am so scared that this guy is going to take away my daughter's college fund, our savings and home. We had a pretty crappy insurance policy back then (since we moved to a house, had a baby, etc. - we have a much better policy including an umbrella - but it doesn't cover the time period of the accident). I figured we didn't need huge coverage back then because we didn't really have anything. Stupid!!

Anyone have any experience with this either from the legal perspective or personally? I am going crazy with worry.





Message edited 2014-07-22 12:59:52.527000.

Posted 7/22/14 12:58 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Being Sued

Your carrier should be handling this.

Posted 7/22/14 1:02 PM
 

MK2010
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/10

401 total posts

Name:

Re: Being Sued

They are - we have a lawyer from the insurance company. I am worried about damages over the insurance limit. There was supposed to be a deposition this morning - but it got pushed out three weeks now. Not sure if I should hire my own lawyer - I'm worried that because we have such a small policy, the insurance company doesn't view this as a huge problem - because they don't have so much to pay out.

Posted 7/22/14 1:10 PM
 

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

Being Sued

Almost all cases like this will settle (eventually) for the insurance limit - even if it's low (and also depending on your ins. company). Unless there are extremely severe injuries (doesn't sound like it) or some egregious behavior on your DH's part (like drunk driving), the cost of going after your personal assets, for injuries that are not very serious, is not worth it. At this point there is no need for you to have the expense of hiring your own attorney. I know this is stressful for you, but try not to stress over it - this is a very routine case for your attorney.

Posted 7/22/14 1:40 PM
 

MK2010
LIF Toddler

Member since 7/10

401 total posts

Name:

Re: Being Sued

Posted by chilltocam

Almost all cases like this will settle (eventually) for the insurance limit - even if it's low (and also depending on your ins. company). Unless there are extremely severe injuries (doesn't sound like it) or some egregious behavior on your DH's part (like drunk driving), the cost of going after your personal assets, for injuries that are not very serious, is not worth it. At this point there is no need for you to have the expense of hiring your own attorney. I know this is stressful for you, but try not to stress over it - this is a very routine case for your attorney.



Thank you very much! I really appreciate the insight. The whole situation has been drawn out for so long now with no real answers. The lawsuit (which the insurance company said was boilerplate) - states my husband was recklessly driving. He pulled up to make a left turn after being stopped at a red light - so how he could possibly have been speeding when the entire intersection is only about 25 feet wide - seems ridiculous to me - but personal injury claims are scary. It seems like they have no limit.




Posted 7/22/14 1:48 PM
 

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

Re: Being Sued

Posted by MK2010

Posted by chilltocam

Almost all cases like this will settle (eventually) for the insurance limit - even if it's low (and also depending on your ins. company). Unless there are extremely severe injuries (doesn't sound like it) or some egregious behavior on your DH's part (like drunk driving), the cost of going after your personal assets, for injuries that are not very serious, is not worth it. At this point there is no need for you to have the expense of hiring your own attorney. I know this is stressful for you, but try not to stress over it - this is a very routine case for your attorney.



Thank you very much! I really appreciate the insight. The whole situation has been drawn out for so long now with no real answers. The lawsuit (which the insurance company said was boilerplate) - states my husband was recklessly driving. He pulled up to make a left turn after being stopped at a red light - so how he could possibly have been speeding when the entire intersection is only about 25 feet wide - seems ridiculous to me - but personal injury claims are scary. It seems like they have no limit.







Sounds like it is boilerplate - very little that is actually specific to the facts of the case. And unfortunately these things can get dragged out over several years. although there is no limit to what they can ask for, there are laws in place stating that they have to prove a "serious injury" - which has a definition and will be explained to a jury if the case ever gets that far.

Posted 7/22/14 1:54 PM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Being Sued

Sounds like "litigation Lottery" to me.

I hate these assholes who come in years later looking for a payday. Look some people re TRULY injured and deserve to be compensated.

I bet 1 million dollars the other guy is being represented by *insert smarmy lawyer we see on tv* here.

Weitz?
Celino and Barnes?

Posted 7/22/14 1:58 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Being Sued

Posted by MK2010

My DH was in an accident two years ago. Basically both cars were at a red light and he went to make a left turn and the other car was going straight. The police came and my DH and the other driver both refused an ambulance and that is in the police report. There was minimal damage on the car. The airbags did not go off. The other driver was very belligerant and is suing us. He was 75 at the time of the accident and is now 77. He is claiming nerve damage, deterioration, athritis and loss of enjoyment of life. I am so scared that this guy is going to take away my daughter's college fund, our savings and home. We had a pretty crappy insurance policy back then (since we moved to a house, had a baby, etc. - we have a much better policy including an umbrella - but it doesn't cover the time period of the accident). I figured we didn't need huge coverage back then because we didn't really have anything. Stupid!!

Anyone have any experience with this either from the legal perspective or personally? I am going crazy with worry.






I guess the outcome would also depend on who was at fault. I'm curious, was your DH in a left turn only lane and went straight instead?

Either way like a PP said would likely settle for insurance amount.


Message edited 2014-07-22 14:05:49.483000.

Posted 7/22/14 2:05 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Being Sued

I had this happen right after I got my license as a teen.

I think the guys kids were looking for a payout.

My parents consulted with an attorney and it was eventually handled through the insurance company.

It was an old guy in a beat up car from the 70s.

There are so many people out there thinking theyre going to make a quick buck this way, it's really a disgrace.

Posted 7/22/14 2:06 PM
 

EclecticEsq10810
Bored Esq.

Member since 10/10

2156 total posts

Name:
L.

Re: Being Sued

I handle insurance defense cases (auto/no-fault) and this case sounds pretty routine - it sounds like the guy who hit your DH doesn't have serious injuries.

The fact that he refused medical treatment at the accident scene and also minimal medical damages subsequent to MVA (motor veh accident) means it will be VERY difficult for his lawyer to present a compelling case before a jury. As the above posters have correctly noted, the case will be settled for a nuisance sum. You could get a lawyer but since your insurance company is already handling it, I dont think you need to worry to much unless the plaintiff is alleging medical damages that exceed the PIP limits under the policy (which in NY State is $ 50K).

If you really want to see if his case holds much water, reach out to your carrier and ask them to furnish you with a document called the Bill of Particulars. This will detail exactly what injuries he alleges he incurred as a result of the accident. If you don't see anything considered a serious injury (a serious injury means a fracture, broken bones, dismemberment, etc) then he really has a weak 'soft tissue injury' case which will settle and you will not be liable out of pocket.
Best of luck!

Posted 7/22/14 2:08 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Being Sued

I used to work in personal injury and I've been sued as a result of a car accident. I know it's scary, but believe me, this is no big deal. You don't need to hire your own lawyer, you don't need to worry about your child's college fund, your house, none of it. The insurance company will handle it. It really doesn't matter what the summons and complaint says. At the end of the day, the compensation a person receives is on par with their damages. What you listed there isn't going to result in a million dollar settlement. Not by a long shot. He's 77 years old - God bless him - but how is he going to prove that arthritis and loss of enjoyment of life aren't the result of being 77 years old?? If he was 30 years younger and losing income and not able to support his family due to the accident, it would be a different scenario.

Depositions get postponed A LOT. I mean for years even. It's likely this case will never even go to trial. My accident happened in 2001 and to my knowledge has never settled and certainly won't ever go to trial. Try not to worry too much. Chat Icon

Posted 7/22/14 2:15 PM
 

JoanneAndJustin
LIF Adult

Member since 2/09

1801 total posts

Name:
Joanne

Being Sued

I also work in no fault. Everyone else already gave you great advice. Do not stress this.

Posted 7/22/14 4:02 PM
 

bunnyluck
LIF Adult

Member since 1/14

3196 total posts

Name:

Being Sued

My friend was hit by an underage, drunk driver while crossing the street and needed extensive physical therapy and still suffers from back pain. She received $7,000 from the drivers insurance company. She had medical insurance and no debilitating injuries so no lawyer wanted to go to court over it....

This guy is almost 80 and is complaining of nerve damage and arthritis! (two years later nonetheless) Please find me one 77 year old without either of those????

What a scammer! I wish I was on that jury (not that I think it will make it to court). I would give him a big fat goose egg.

Message edited 2014-07-22 16:10:27.997000.

Posted 7/22/14 4:10 PM
 

JoanneAndJustin
LIF Adult

Member since 2/09

1801 total posts

Name:
Joanne

Being Sued

Double post

Message edited 2014-07-22 18:28:22.393000.

Posted 7/22/14 5:00 PM
 

evrythng4areason
And then there were 4

Member since 1/10

5224 total posts

Name:
Kayla

Being Sued

I agree with previous posters. My dad was riding his motor cycle, and was literally dragged by his foot under a car bc someone made a left turn-he ended up with not much at all-certainly not the value of a house or college fund

Posted 7/22/14 5:17 PM
 

lilqtny
-Crossfit & pitbull addict

Member since 7/06

2830 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Being Sued

I got hit by a car while riding g my bike. I almost does. I broke my entire body. I still did not get a penny over what the I s covered. I doubt this will touch all your funds. But to be safe can you put some in a safety deposit box.

Posted 7/22/14 5:35 PM
 

Maddie180
LIF Adult

Member since 2/07

1992 total posts

Name:

Being Sued

My dad was sued for a million dollars for an accident I was in. It took ten years, but we finally settled out of court for $90000 the night before the trial. It was a very stressful time even though I knew only 3% (it used to be this???) of cases go to trial, but I was beyond upset and stressed. Good luck!!!

Posted 7/22/14 6:05 PM
 

LisaW
Time for me to FLY!

Member since 5/05

13199 total posts

Name:
Did I ever tell you that I hate people?

Re: Being Sued

These things settle for policy limits the majority of the time. Don't even worry about it.

Posted 7/22/14 7:21 PM
 

LisaW
Time for me to FLY!

Member since 5/05

13199 total posts

Name:
Did I ever tell you that I hate people?

Re: Being Sued

BTW, is he really claiming the accident gave him arthritis? LMAO

Posted 7/22/14 7:24 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Being Sued

Posted by lilqtny

I got hit by a car while riding g my bike. I almost does. I broke my entire body. I still did not get a penny over what the I s covered. I doubt this will touch all your funds. But to be safe can you put some in a safety deposit box.



What's sad is that people who generally deserve compensation rarely see it.

I've been working with people with brain injury for years and they rarely see anything when they sue.

Maybe a little amount of money that goes into a trust to cover the most basic of expenses.

And that's after lawyers are involved and paid, and the case goes on for years, causing unnecessary stress and upset.

Quacks like the OP mentioned should pay out for all the aggravation THEY cause for wasting everyone's time and causing stress.

Posted 7/22/14 7:41 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Being Sued

My family was sued over my sister's car accident years ago. The guy (who ran the red light!) had an anxiety attack at the scene so I called an ambulance.

He claimed loss of activities & loss of consortium. I'm pretty sure his long lunch with the chick in his car is what led to that with his wife. He was checked out at the scene & was completely fine but HE WAS THE GUY AT FAULT. He still made some cash when percentage was assigned.

Like everyone said, don't stress about this.

Posted 7/22/14 9:08 PM
 

Straightarrow
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

3534 total posts

Name:

Re: Being Sued

Posted by Paramount

Sounds like "litigation Lottery" to me.

I hate these assholes who come in years later looking for a payday. Look some people re TRULY injured and deserve to be compensated.

I bet 1 million dollars the other guy is being represented by *insert smarmy lawyer we see on tv* here.

Weitz?
Celino and Barnes?



This is really uncalled for.

I've worked in litigation for 12 years. Yes, people sue for bs injuries but that is what insurance coverage is for. And you can blame the carriers just as much because they pay out as well.

To the op, it'll be fine. You have an attorney and they will handle it. And I'm 110% sure your policy limits will cover itChat Icon

Posted 7/22/14 10:27 PM
 

Straightarrow
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

3534 total posts

Name:

Re: Being Sued

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

What's sad is that people who generally deserve compensation rarely see it.

I've been working with people with brain injury for years and they rarely see anything when they sue.

Maybe a little amount of money that goes into a trust to cover the most basic of expenses.

And that's after lawyers are involved and paid, and the case goes on for years, causing unnecessary stress and upset.

Quacks like the OP mentioned should pay out for all the aggravation THEY cause for wasting everyone's time and causing stress.



This is all really untrue. There are cases where you have a 'great' injury but there is terrible liability so the claimant doesn't get a massive amount of money (vice versa as well)

And if they have a TBI why shouldn't the money be put in an annuity? The injured should get $200k to just piss away?

Lastly why shouldn't the lawyers get paid? Every plaintiff signs the SAME retainer and all attorneys get the SAME fee. You think it's easy work? Trials cost $50k PLUS (doctors charge 10k to testify so let's hate them).

I'm sorry. I just hate when people get on the anti lawsuit bandwagon. But would sue if it were them...I'm sure of it

Posted 7/22/14 10:39 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Being Sued

Posted by Straightarrow

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

What's sad is that people who generally deserve compensation rarely see it.

I've been working with people with brain injury for years and they rarely see anything when they sue.

Maybe a little amount of money that goes into a trust to cover the most basic of expenses.

And that's after lawyers are involved and paid, and the case goes on for years, causing unnecessary stress and upset.

Quacks like the OP mentioned should pay out for all the aggravation THEY cause for wasting everyone's time and causing stress.



This is all really untrue. There are cases where you have a 'great' injury but there is terrible liability so the claimant doesn't get a massive amount of money (vice versa as well)

And if they have a TBI why shouldn't the money be put in an annuity? The injured should get $200k to just piss away?

Lastly why shouldn't the lawyers get paid? Every plaintiff signs the SAME retainer and all attorneys get the SAME fee. You think it's easy work? Trials cost $50k PLUS (doctors charge 10k to testify so let's hate them).

I'm sorry. I just hate when people get on the anti lawsuit bandwagon. But would sue if it were them...I'm sure of it



I agree. The anti-lawsuit bandwagon can be so extreme and the people who complain are sometimes the first people to line up when they think they've been wronged. In this case we really don't have enough information to say whether the injuries were frivolous because we only have a vague description. The fact that the description is vague could mean something, though. The delay in filing the case doesn't mean a lot to me. Maybe there were settlement talks long before he filed the case. He may have been trying to avoid litigation but then he had to file to protect his rights.

I don't blame the OP for being concerned about this, though, as these are legitimate questions but I really don't think there is anything to worry about.

Message edited 2014-07-23 03:02:39.623000.

Posted 7/22/14 11:26 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Being Sued

Posted by Straightarrow

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

What's sad is that people who generally deserve compensation rarely see it.

I've been working with people with brain injury for years and they rarely see anything when they sue.

Maybe a little amount of money that goes into a trust to cover the most basic of expenses.

And that's after lawyers are involved and paid, and the case goes on for years, causing unnecessary stress and upset.

Quacks like the OP mentioned should pay out for all the aggravation THEY cause for wasting everyone's time and causing stress.



This is all really untrue. There are cases where you have a 'great' injury but there is terrible liability so the claimant doesn't get a massive amount of money (vice versa as well)

And if they have a TBI why shouldn't the money be put in an annuity? The injured should get $200k to just piss away?

Lastly why shouldn't the lawyers get paid? Every plaintiff signs the SAME retainer and all attorneys get the SAME fee. You think it's easy work? Trials cost $50k PLUS (doctors charge 10k to testify so let's hate them).

I'm sorry. I just hate when people get on the anti lawsuit bandwagon. But would sue if it were them...I'm sure of it



Wow. I never said those things you are assuming, so do not put words in my mouth and misinterpret my post. Of course they shouldn't be just handed the money to piss away, as you so nicely put it......but what my point is they are not getting the extent of what they suffered, especially when the accident wasn't their fault.

I also never said anything negative about attorneys.....my point again is they are not making out as much as one would assume after all the fees and such are paid.

I think you need to apologize for mincing my words.

Oh, and btw, everyone I know who has gotten some money has told me they could give a rats ass about it....they just want their life back to how it was. But, as I actually said, this money is to help with their needs since they can't work and have to depend on "the system".

I also love how you're suddenly psychic, ASSuming to know how others would handle a situation.

Not everyone is sue-happy.

Message edited 2014-07-23 05:40:02.933000.

Posted 7/23/14 5:20 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Ex-NFL star Brian Holloway may be sued by parents of teens who allegedly trashed his upstate NY home MrsA714 9/20/13 39 Families Helping Families ™
BRISTOL PALIN Sued By Bar Heckler aka oh the days when it was safe to yell at someone "your mom is a whore" nrthshgrl 6/13/12 2 Celebrities & Entertainment
Perez Hilton Sued For $7.5 Million MrsQ 12/1/06 2 Celebrities & Entertainment
X-post- Seaford School District Sued justthe4ofus 8/13/06 0 Families Helping Families ™
SEAFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT SUED justthe4ofus 8/13/06 3 Parenting
Has anyone ever sued a doctor before MrsBumbleb 7/13/06 4 Families Helping Families ™